The Use Of Force, A Story Of Guilt

811 words - 3 pages

The Use of Force, A Story of Guilt

"The Use of Force" by William Carlos Williams is a window into one doctor's guilt over the negligent loss of a child patient. This story focuses on the disillusionment caused by his self-pity and guilt. The doctor's guilt triggers a fanciful illusion of "The Use of Force" that gives him giddy delight in his envisioned torture of the young, beautiful girl. His disgust for her uneducated, immigrant parents and their poor, humble surroundings only heighten this image. But his justification of these imagined actions empowers him all the more. He perceives himself above these less than human creatures, as a master lords over his good for nothing dog. In his self-empowered greatness he comes face to face with the greatest flaw any doctor can have, lack of humanity and compassion for those lesser then himself.

During the first 20 paragraphs, Williams is simply recalling the events as they had taken place. Never revealing the death of the child. We are led to believe that the child never dies, but Williams gives us clues into her death when he states in paragraph 31, "I have seen at least two children lying dead in bed of neglect." His guilt of how he handled the situation plunges his imagination down a dark, immoral path. The pivotal point between reality and his vivid imagination becomes clear when he states, "I explained the danger but said that I would not insist on the throat examination so long as they (her parents) would take the responsibility." This is where his imagination takes over. Instantly, his adoration and love for the young girl turns to utter loathing. He goes on to describe her as a "savage brat."

In his dream state, Williams feels such urgency to diagnose the girl, and save her from herself. With fire in his blood he states, "The damned little brat must be protected against her own idiocy" The guilt he feels in reality heightens this urgency to save her. His descriptions of the girl also add to the tone of this illusion when he describes her motions as "catlike" and instinctive as she "clawed instinctively for my (Williams) eyes"

Williams describes his distaste for the immigrant family. "I ground my teeth in disgust"...

Find Another Essay On The Use of Force, A Story of Guilt

Presidential Use of Force Essay

1615 words - 6 pages Presidential Use of Force When the framers of the Constitution constructed the executive branch of government, they envisioned a president with certain limited powers. Having delegated to the president a specific type of authority, the framers would probably be surprised to see that they had actually created a rather dynamic officer. The presidency is continually changing over time. That is, the power of the president has been both

Criminal Liability and the Use of Force

1628 words - 7 pages Criminal Liability and the Use of Force In today’s world it is of utmost importance that law enforcement understands how to determine culpability with regards to criminal activity as definitions surrounding what constitutes a particular crime can be confusing. Just as important is the ability to know when to use force, what constitutes use of force, and how that force can and cannot be applied. In determining culpability one must remember that

Police Discretion and the Use of Force

2202 words - 9 pages Discretion is defined as the authority to make a decision between two or more choices (Pollock, 2010). More specifically, it is defined as “the capacity to identify and to document criminal and noncriminal events” (Boivin & Cordeau, 2011). Every police officer has a great deal of discretion concerning when to use their authority, power, persuasion, or force. Depending on how an officer sees their duty to society will determine an

International Insecurity and the Use of Force

1335 words - 5 pages International Insecurity and the Use of Force The Media, the People, and Public Opinion There are numerous interest groups who are against the data collection processes of the National Security Agency. While reviewing articles, Reitman wrote, “ Today, a bipartisan coalition of 86 civil liberties organizations and internet companies – including Electronic Frontier Foundation, reddit, Mozilla, Freedom Works and the American Civil liberties

Police Brutality and the Use of Force

2828 words - 11 pages . Authority and power are basic concepts of political order, and the police use force as a way to control forms of behavior which are detrimental to society (Elliott & Pollock, 2013). The application of force is often considered ethically neutral it can, under a variety of circumstances, constitute an abuse of authority. The International Association of Chiefs of Police (IACP) defines the use of force as “that amount of effort required by

Use Of Force (ambrose Bierce)

737 words - 3 pages Use of Force Ambrose Bierce, a social critic known for his sarcasm and wit, once described the police as "an armed force for protection and participation." In this pithy statement, Bierce identifies three critical elements of the police role. First, by describing the police as "armed," their ability to coerce recalcitrant persons to comply with the law is emphasized. Because police carry weapons, it follows that the force

Is Excessive Use of Force a Systemic Problem?

642 words - 3 pages situation. Sometimes this force takes the form of hand to hand combat with a suspect who resists being arrested (Dantzker, 2003). The police do have strict guidelines to follow when using force. Force should be used in only the minimum amount needed to achieve a legitimate purpose. Most police officers use these five stages through which the use of force can progress: (a) verbal persuasion, (b) unarmed physical force, (c) force using non lethal weapons

The Social Dynamics of the Police Use of Force

1477 words - 6 pages When it comes to the criminal justice system, legal rulings only provide a systematic method of dealing with the problem of crime and, especially, the problem surrounding the police use of force. In Graham vs. Conner, for example, the courts established the four-factor test to evaluate police use of excessive force but left other, underlying social and moral dilemmas untouched. Furthermore, the influence money has in negotiating punishment via


1267 words - 5 pages heretofore been sleeping with. At this point, it seems as if Josef is finally ready to face the reality of his trial and get it over with. He soon lapses into a depressive obsession, however, after determining to draw up a petition of everything he's ever done to prove that he must be innocent. In this part of the story, Josef begins on the right path by trying to face his guilt himself, and he even sets about starting to interrogate himself

The Efficacy of Article 2 (4): Use of Military Force

3262 words - 13 pages action on a wide range of issues through the General Assembly, the Security Council, the Economic and Social Council and other bodies and committees. Article 2(4) is a section of the UN Charter that specifically states that: all member states shall refrain from the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of any state or in any manner inconsistent with the purposes of the United Nations. Section two is a

The Use of Force, by William Carlos Williams

1391 words - 6 pages The Use of Force is a short story by William Carlos Williams that is very powerful and leaves the readers with an ethical dilemma. The following social issues can be debated on it: Can physical for good purpose be justified?, What compels the use of force isn’t simply altruism, difference of two separating two different tasks, a dark side persists in every individual, parents concern for their children, use of force as sympathy care for a

Similar Essays

The Use Of Force Essay

939 words - 4 pages Depression through his short story “The Use of Force”. William Carlos Williams during his lifetime (1883-1963) prospered not only in the medical field as a doctor for over 40 years, but also became a well known author and poet. He is known for his unique way of writing and for his strong imagist, anti-romanticist way of thinking. His writing style was “uncluttered” and had “functional phrasing”. Although he was of foreign decent, he took great pride in

Police Use Of Force Essay

1078 words - 4 pages In certain situations, the police may have to act quickly on their instincts. Sometimes, a situation is unpredictable and a decision needs to be made in a split second. The quick decision may to be to take a person down physically with the officer’s own hands, or to use deadly force, unfortunately. Anything can happen and the officer needs to be ready for every scenario. The different levels of force can be anywhere from just a police officer

Police Use Of Force Essay

1574 words - 6 pages force necessary to control a situation, arrest the person, or protect themselves or others from harm (p.1). When a situation begins to spiral out of control for the police officers, the next level should be used in order to gain control. Once the situation is resolved, police officers should make sure the injured receive medical treatment and notify family of any injured individuals (p.1). Levels of force that officers use depend upon the

Use Of Force Continuum Essay

825 words - 4 pages A '''use of force continuum''' is a standard that affords law enforcement officials & security officers (police, probation, or corrections) with guidelines as to how much use of force may be used against a repelling subject in a given situation. In certain ways it is similar to the military’s escalation of force. The reason of these models is to clarify, both for officers and citizens, the complex subject of use of force by law officers. They