This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Male Friendship As Viewed By Aristotle, Cicero, Montaigne, And Emerson

1328 words - 5 pages

All four writers, Aristotle, Cicero, Montaigne, and Emerson discuss the importance of male friendship, and all four characters make statements about the superiority of friendship above other associations. However, the tone, the interpretation of friendship, and manner of rhetoric is influenced by the translation of the individual writer’s culture.
Aristotle uses a rather categorical approach to friendship. By making strict delineations and then using examples, he establishes a rather strict definition of friendship that is created along lines of social class. He argues, among other things, that friendship must be between similarly virtuous men of equal standing. In addition, the purest form of friendship, and the one that Aristotle considers the only genuine friendship, involves that of two men and that is free from outside reciprocation.
The writer who most directly addresses Aristotle’s assessment on friendship is Cicero in his Laelius: on Friendship. Quite bitingly, he begins with Laelius remarking that he does not claim to be like the Greeks “who claim the ability to deal with any subject you care to set before them, without the slightest preparation.” In fact, the whole presentation is in contrast with the didactic manner that Aristotle uses. Laelius, throughout the work, claims his lack of expertise in the subject, which is in stark contrast of Aristotle who assumed knowledge in the subject.
So while Cicero intentionally diverges from the style of Aristotle, he nevertheless adopts many of Aristotle’s maxims. Like Aristotle, Cicero argues that one must “place friendship above every other human concern” and that “friendship is only possible between good men” who are similar and equal to each other. Furthermore, in claiming that there was no finer man than the recently deceased Scipio, Cicero tacitly concurs with another one of Aristotle’s beliefs that one can only have one true friend. Although he elaborates on the importance of virtue in friendship – that good men do not need friendship but are edified by it through their friendship with other good men, and it is a lack of will that places bad men in the greater need for friendship, particularly with good men – it is nevertheless an elaboration, or at least a concurrence, of Aristotle’s ideas.
However, where Cicero disagrees from Aristotle, and quite significantly, is his interpretation of the benefits that a friendship entails. While Aristotle was quite stringent on the assertion that outside benefits diluted the purity of a friendship, Cicero was more willing to accept these as valuable, at least in secondary nature to friendship itself. However, Cicero makes the caveat that while “giving and receiving” is a valuable feature of friendship, it is “merely one feature and consequence of friendship.” In addition, he asserts that the primary basis of friendship must still be founded upon without “any calculation of profit.” Part of this, I believe, stems from the realpolitik of Roman...

Find Another Essay On Male Friendship as Viewed by Aristotle, Cicero, Montaigne, and Emerson

Contemporary Value of Religion as Viewed by Kearlee Gregory

1641 words - 7 pages . Similar to Buddhism, the ideal religion should help people uplift themselves as well as others, by accompanying their differing base beliefs and encouraging the pursuit of knowledge, which is what we humans do naturally. The religion should not bring people to believe that their religion is the one and only truth in the universe, but instead encourage acceptance of differing beliefs and cultures, allowing them to thrive alongside one another

Greek and LatinClassics by Cicero, Vergil, Horace, Plato and Livy

1090 words - 4 pages -knowledge, individualism, and studying lessons from the past; appealing to the authorities of the Greek and Latin classics by Cicero, Vergil, Horace, Plato and Livy. Petrarch and Pico’s thinking can be constituted as a marked departure from medieval attitudes and beliefs, due to the origins of humanist resources being classical and biblical rather stemmed from medieval philosophers and theologians. Petrarch, considered the “father of humanism

Oedipus the King and Things Fall Apart - Tragedies as Defined by Aristotle

2216 words - 9 pages Oedipus and Things Fall Aparttragedies as defined by Aristotle Almost 2500 years ago Aristotle defined a tragic plot as one containing six essential elements. The first is a hero (sympatheia) who is noble by birth or has risen to a place of power. The hero should also be of good character. Aristotle stated in The Poetics, “This is the sort of man who is not pre-eminently virtuous and just, and yet it is through no badness or villainy of

In defense of the Indians by Las Casas and On the Cannibals by Montaigne

1707 words - 7 pages witness this first-hand. So indeed the facts and arguments that Las Casas makes within In Defense of the Indians are all true because he witnessed everything first-hand. Although there may be a discrepancy regarding the number of Native deaths due to diseases versus those caused by the Europeans, his treatises is full of true statements. Seigneur De Montaigne was known as a great renaissance thinker who was born into a wealthy merchant family

Democracy Outlined by Plato and Aristotle

1114 words - 4 pages for the basis of modern political thinking, although many in modern society UK would be sceptical to call it a democracy. Plato and Aristotle in The Republic and The Politics respectively were critical of the Athenian democracy, by examining the culture and ideology present the limitations and possible downfalls of a democratic way of life. Within this essay I will outline these limitations and evaluate their validity. Plato defines Athens as a

Purity and Civility in The Praise of Folly by Desiderius Erasmus and Of Cannibals by Michel de Montaigne

1521 words - 6 pages stage;a virtuous man may be a wretched being or a king may be a beggar in fact. Just like this case,in “Of Cannibals”,Michel de Montaigne implies ironically by the statement: “All this is not too bad-but what’s the use?They don’t wear breeches.” That although costumes or breeches,which are taken as a token for civility,may turn out to be just the opposite.They are veils under which true identities and intentions

Gender Roles in Shakespearan Society and Modern Society As Viewed in Movies

1371 words - 5 pages clear and concise actions throughout the film. In “The Lady with the Little Dog,” Chekhov’s character, Dmitri Gurov, an initial male chauvinist married man, has lust for many females, but changes to heart-felt love when he encounters Anna Sergeyovna. She counteracts Dmitri view of women as the “lower race” by using shy and constrained appearances to aid her throughout their meetings. Chekhov describes Anna as “touching, had a breath of purity of a

"Nature and Self-Reliance" by Ralph Waldo Emerson

567 words - 2 pages nature, people learn not only what is practical but also what is good; for Emerson nature and the soul are perfectly complementary. Emerson also states that it is good to learn from the books as long as the reader keeps his creativity and way of thinking and that by practical experience we learn quickly and well. Emerson tries to makes us realize that by our own virtues and by calling on our own internal means we can find the answers to many

How Society Viewed Love and Marriage in Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen

1747 words - 7 pages exacerbated by the fact that their courtship was very short, unorthodox and kept a secret. Marriage of their type shows the results of not following society’s rules. Society viewed this as dishonesty and because of this their reputation would be severely tarnished. “That the loss of virtue in a female is irretrievable… and that she cannot be too much guarded in her behaviour towards the understanding of the other sex”. Lydia’s damaged reputation

A comparative essay on the idea of a perfect person as viewed by the major eastern religions

2483 words - 10 pages humility and conquering emotions with wisdom. By controlling the ego, one's wisdom can shine forth. A controlled ego allows for other qualities of a perfect human to be attainable, namely wisdom and understanding, as represented by the elephant's large head, as well as kindness and compassion toward all, represented by the human heart. In addition, the large elephant ears denote a great capacity to listen to others (Grimes, 1995). The perfect human is

How were Wales and the Welsh viewed by outsiders during this period?

1784 words - 7 pages defensive to a house,Against the envy of less happier lands,This blessed plot, this earth, this realm, this England. . . .William Shakespeare wrote favourably of the Welsh unlike many of his other fellow writers; this could therefore show his personal view and attitude for Wales. People and Wales were viewed by other writers as strange and needed to be disciplined and to be civilised. In the book Malcontent, one of the characters called Passarello

Similar Essays

Aristotle And Friendship, Philosophical Ethics Essay

609 words - 2 pages an example here. Friendship between the young is grounded on pleasure because the lives of the young are regulated by their feelings, and their main interest is in their own pleasure and the opportunity of the moment. They are quick to create and destroy friendships because their affection changes as fast as the things that please them do. Aristotle felt that this sort of pleasure changes rapidly. The young also have a tendency to fall in love

Human Nature As Viewed By Thomas Hobbes And David Hume

2046 words - 8 pages Human Nature as Viewed by Thomas Hobbes and David Hume Thomas Hobbes in Chapter 13 of Leviathan, and David Hume in Section 3 of An Enquiry Concerning the Princples of Morals, give views of human nature. Hobbes’ view captures survivalism as significant in our nature but cannot account for altruism. We cover Hobbes’ theory with a theory of Varied Levels of Survivalism, explaining a larger body of behavior with the foundation Hobbes gives

Marriage As Viewed By Greeks, Christians And Hebrews

1252 words - 5 pages demands respect and punishes man when he does not get it. The story of Noah is an example of this where man suffers for his disrespect towards God. Man pays very dearly for neglecting his duty to his Maker. Biblical texts as well as Greek mythology have evidence of men or women sent to certain people as messengers, leaders or healers by God and the gods respectively .This shows a lot concern for their creatures on the part of these beings

Justice As Defined By Augustine And Aristotle

1918 words - 8 pages Justice as Defined by Augustine and Aristotle “Justice removed, then, what are kingdoms but great bands of robbers?” (Augustine, The City of God against the Pagans, p. 147[1]). Augustine makes quite a claim here. The presence or absence of “justice,” he implies, can make or break a great kingdom. What is this justice that Augustine speaks of? Is it the philosopher kings that define Plato’s “just city[2],” or perhaps Aristotle’s