Male Vs Female Nursing Leadership Essay

2263 words - 9 pages

Introduction
This study will be exploring the reason male nurses are apparently dominant in the leadership role than the female nurses. Leadership is an integrate part in every human organization as an important subject; it has continued to generate an immense amount of research, although the aspect of male nurse dominance in leadership role appears to be unexplored, the prevailing circumstances shows that healthcare organizations prefer the male nurse in administrative roles than the female nurses. The question that calls for answers are ;when it comes to leadership in the nursing profession, do female nurses differ significantly from male nurses, are there gender issues (such as strengths and weaknesses) when it comes to successful leadership in nursing? Who makes a better nurse leader male or female? Why do healthcare organizations prefer male nurse in administrative roles than the female nurses? Regardless of the style of leadership, the vital point is for the leader to be able to lead and the followers are able to follow in line with established rules, cultures and set goals. Daniel Levi argued that it is better to apply different leadership styles in different situation rather than an optimal leadership style; he opined that leaders are more important in some situation than orders (Daniel Levi, 2014). Often times leadership is automatically assigned with gender sensitivity mostly in favor of the male counterpart, even when the female may be as qualified or even more skillful than the man. Despite the fact that in some societies women's status has improved remarkably in the 20th century, however, in many societies women continue to lack access to power and leadership compared with men (Carli & Hagely, 2001).The ability of a leader to manage human and material resources effectively is a vital rallying point which contributes towards the success of any leader. This should be the main criteria in determining the effectiveness of a leader regardless of the gender, sexual orientation, tribe, tongue, religion, culture, social class or any other applicable variable. It is worthy of note that the issue of women and leadership style has continued to generate a lot of attention and thought provoking literatures, this issue is even more in the nursing profession where apparently male nurses being the minority group seems to be dominant in leadership role. According to Eagly,(2007) in the United States, women’s leadership skills have been recognized increasingly. She added that regardless that women exhibit leadership styles associated with effective performance more than men, more people prefer male than female bosses
Related Literature
The history of nursing profession with Florence Nightingale pioneering automatically placed the female as leader. Regardless of the much impact made by Florence Nightingale towards the development and furtherance of nursing as a profession, the need for effective nurse leadership remains vital to the overall...

Find Another Essay On Male vs Female Nursing Leadership

The Development of Nursing Along American History

2000 words - 8 pages as the “Superintendent of Female Nurses of the Army”. While Dorthea or Dix as she was known had no formal training she cultivated vast organizational skills while working on behalf of patients in prisons and asylums. In July 1962 Dix set reglations on women applicants for nursing positions in the military. She said that women “applicants must be older than 35, plain-looking, dressed in plain colors (preferably brown, gray, or black) with no

Nursing: Why Not Men? Essay

1513 words - 6 pages male nurses were recruited then less female nurses would’ve been called to military duty. A male nurse is considered a “valuable man” (Craig). Men currently are looked down on in the nursing profession due to many different beliefs. While it’s true in some, if not a very rare few, these beliefs are what make the nursing profession for men uncomforting and discouraging. It is believed many male nurses are gay and because of this lack the

Why Are There So Few Men In Nursing?

1325 words - 5 pages Among twenty leading female-dominated professions, registered nurses (RN’s) are the second most occupation that employed women in 2006¬. Similar to many traditionally female professions, the percentage of male in nursing is small. In fact, male nurses only comprised eight percent of RN’s in 2008. Although much effort has been made to recruit more men into nursing, many contributing factors have driven them away from this profession. Those

Leadership Prejudices of Men and Women in the Workplace

1840 words - 7 pages compared to male. Female employees will reach the glass ceiling, an intangible barrier that restricts women from reaching the top executive positions of an organization. Some male employees who work in a dominantly-female positions, such as nursing or teaching, will go through glass encounter, a force that allows them to achieve levels of leadership (Ferrante, 2011, p. 316). For those workers who wish to join the 43% of women in executive

Ethics and Professionalism in Nursing

586 words - 3 pages principles of Florence Nightingale, the founder of Modern Nursing. Florence Nightingale was born in 1820 in Florence Italy. She was not only a nurse but exercised leadership skills that set the standard for the world of nursing. She dedicated her life to the sick and the delicate task of caring for wounded soldiers. Ms. Nightingale established an organized unit of over 38 female nurses to serve and care for wounded soldiers during the

Images of nursing- how the images of nursing have changed over time. How these images impact on the position of nurses within society. Includes interviews with 5 participants.

1418 words - 6 pages readings on the subject, seem to indicate that gender norms; particularly in relation to the nurse as a female entity, have had a significant impact on common images. Perpetuated by the media, these images both reflect and reinforce the social status of nursing through out history.I interviewed two female and three male students, all of whom were nineteen years of age. To maintain the private identity of the respondents the interviews were conducted

Social Justice: The Role of Higher Education, Criminality and Race

3095 words - 12 pages social and legal status of African Americans during the 1900’s. Men also encountered barriers in the field due to the remaining stigma that nursing was a female only occupation. Fortunately, racial and gender segregation in the nursing field finally diminished in the mid 20th century (UPA School of Nursing 6). Economic disputes affected all nurses as they often faced irregular income and employment (UPA School of Nursing 6). The demand for

The Effect of Classical Music on Exam Scores

1972 words - 8 pages participants as shown in table 3. Significance can be measured from the difference between male and female participants, but there were only seven male participants vs. 50 female participants. Such a large disparity between these two groups does not allow for any reliable statistical inference to be made, but does offer potential for a different study comparing males vs. females who listen to music while taking tests. Results The test scores from the

The Glass Ceiling and the Lack of Female Executive Leadership

2355 words - 9 pages making efficient executive decisions and provide proper strategic guidance to their companies. Although it would be highly inappropriate to define female leadership style as inferior to the male one, there are certain differences in perception of career and professional duties between the two genders, and it has to be kept into account. While it does not of course signify the inability of female professionals to provide efficient professional

Male Versus Female Communication Styles

899 words - 4 pages , bricklaying, and taxi driving had a "male organized" brain. But men and women in female-typical jobs such as nursing, tended to have a female organized brain. These and several others tests have buttressed the theory that one's choice of occupation is often coordinated with the degree of feminine or masculine of one's brain1The gender plays an important role when we look at the communication in terms of science. Science argues that male and female

Organzational Leadership

1694 words - 7 pages disposition-short, tall, neat, sloppy, young, old, male, and female” (Bennis, 2009, p. 33). Unlike Johnson (2011), Bennis (2009) proposes additional components to leadership. First, there must be a vision. A leader has to have a well-defined direction and purpose. They must understand not only the direction they will take, but also the steps to achieve the stated objectives. The vision must be articulated to those that follow. According to

Similar Essays

Male Versus Female: Leadership Stype Essay

2225 words - 9 pages by distinguished corporations. Needless to say, woman can also exhibit this method of leadership although it is more common for women to display transformational leadership. Transformational leadership is more commonly associated with female leaders. This style of leadership is more interactive than transactional leadership: “Transformational leadership is leadership that occurs when the leader stimulates the interest among colleagues and

Creon Vs. Antigone Or Male Vs. Female?

1035 words - 4 pages , pride is strongly evident in Creon making him an even better example of the male stereotype. He refuses to compromise or humble himself before others especially women. For example, he says: "...never let some woman triumph over us. Better to fall from power, if fall we must, at the hands of a man--never be rated inferior to a woman, never" (759-763). He stubbornly refuses others the right to express opinions different from his own. Creon abuses

Gender Roles Essay

799 words - 3 pages male and female behavior, derived from our culture’s traditions. Adherence to these roles demonstrates fulfillment of social expectations but not necessarily personal preference. Throughout the nursing profession it is well know that nursing have been predominately a female role, 12 years ago when this writer started nursing school, there were only 2 male in that program, all the other students were female, by the completion of that nursing

An Occupation Of Equal Just Won’t Do

1716 words - 7 pages Nursing is predominantly a female occupation in a male dominated culture. This fact is one the fundamental problems that women face in most occupations, not only in the nursing profession. Nursing does however; provide an opportunity to examine the extent and causes of gender-based inequalities in the labor market. Women live under a structure of power known as patriarchy, a social organization, in which a male has supreme authority. Every