This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Mandatory Prenatal Hiv Testing Essay

1179 words - 5 pages

Mandatory Prenatal HIV Testing

This particular journal researches prenatal HIV testing as it relates
to vertical transmission.
Randomized controlled studies involving HIV- positive pregnant women at various stages of pregnancy were monitored and evaluated in an effort to find conclusive reasoning for prenatal testing. Women of different income levels, educational and ethnic backgrounds were involved in these studies.
The AIDS Clinical Trials Group Study 076 as well as following
randomized controlled trials were used in order to test whether prenatal testing was an effective means of preventing the vertical transmission of the HIV virus. Quick and relatively simple tests were performed in order to first determine whether pregnant mothers were HIV- positive. If the mother then tested seropositive, antiretroviral therapy was begun in an effort to reduce the perinatal transmission of the virus. Randomized trials performed in developing countries also tested whether early detection followed by antiretroviral therapy greatly reduced viral transmission.
The ACTG 076 showed that in cases involving prenatal HIV testing,
where the virus was discovered in the earlier stages of pregnancy, that treatment could lower the chance of transmission from 25 % to 8 %. Furthermore, since these findings were released along with the recommendation that prenatal testing be mandatory for all pregnant women the cases of perinatally transmitted AIDS reported in the United States have been cut in half.

AIDS Clinical Trials Group Study 076 produced evidence that
mandatory prenatal testing would be effective, but it is plausible that the study itself could have been more effective.
The studies performed were statistically sound and lead to seemingly
significant results. Randomized and controlled studies were performed subsequently in an effort to ensure useful results. Statistically, these methods of research produce findings that are typically more accurate than the other various approaches to research.
Likewise, the HIV test itself is basically a simple and for the most part accurate means of determining whether a pregnant mother is HIV- positive. The tests were administered to mothers that had already tested positive in order to further ensure the accuracy of the study. In this way, it appears that much time and effort was put forth in order to find conclusive reasoning either proving or disproving the theory that prenatal HIV testing should be mandatory.
On the other hand, in order to develop policies that would make prenatal screening mandatory there are two sides to consider; pregnant women who are HIV- positive and pregnant women who do not carry the virus. In this way, the study lacks in including women who must be tested for seemingly no reason. It fails to mention if any undue hardships must be placed upon women who are HIV- negative.
Because HIV can be a treatable disease the findings from this study are as
most would...

Find Another Essay On Mandatory Prenatal HIV Testing

HIV Babies Essay

1128 words - 5 pages . Activists fear that conservative legislators and policy makers will use the clinical data to justify mandatory testing and treatment for pregnant women.During the latter part of February, the United States Public Health Services published guidelines for HIV pregnant women in the Federal Register. Which coincidentally was published on the same day as the National Conference in Washington, DC for 'HIV infection in women: Setting a New Agenda.' The

AIDS and Ethical Treatment of Infected Patients

4033 words - 16 pages exposure to emergency response workers or health care workers occurs, although permission generally must be sought. In addition, some states permit the testing of prisoners and persons accused of sex crimes. Connecticut and New York also require mandatory HIV testing of newborns, which indirectly reveals maternal HIV status.Mother-to-child transmission of HIV has been a priority area for earlier detection because transmission is significantly reduced

Mandatory AIDS Testing

528 words - 2 pages in a high-risk group of contracting HIV, the disease believed to cause AIDS, are still stigmatized by the media and other professionals as being diseased and abnormal. The key word now is prevention. Among many proposed policies to help prevent AIDS infection, one of the most controversial is mandatory AIDS testing. And today, I am going to talk about the Mandatory AIDS testing program, the ability to control the spread of aids with Mandatory

The Pros and Cons of Prenatal Screening

1335 words - 5 pages innovations in the medical field had developed a method to detect the abnormality before delivery and prevent this future tragedy to happen. This method is known as prenatal screening. There are several advantages and disadvantages of prenatal screening. Prenatal screening is a test to detect diseases or conditions in a fetus or embryo before birth. It is available to all pregnant women. Prenatal screening may include blood testing, ultrasound

Case Analysis: HIV/AIDS

1700 words - 7 pages ) informed consent for testing for HIV status, (2) mandatory testing of patients for HIV, (3) confidentiality of patients infected with HIV, (4) the duty to treat individuals infected with HIV, and (5) issues concerning health care workers infected with HIV. Once a client has been diagnosed with HIV and is ready for treatment ethical dilemmas encountered by social workers in providing services to HIV-affected

discrimination against HIV positives

892 words - 4 pages attempts to fight the HIV epidemic as a whole. Discrimination can also discourage individuals reluctant to access HIV testing, treatment, and care. Among the HIV discriminants is at the health care settings where people go for treatments and care. Discrimination in the health care setting is one of the top discriminants in the world. People can experience discrimination such as being refused medicine or access to facilities, receiving HIV testing

Teratogens

1000 words - 4 pages of babies being born with HIV we need to educated about HIV and AIDS, make AIDS tests mandatory for every pregnant woman and easy available for every woman who intends to become pregnant.David G. Meyers (2004), Exploring Psychologyhttp://www.marchofdimes.com/professionals/681_1170.asphttp://www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/fas/http://www.thalidomide.ca/en/index.htmlhttp://www.aegis.com/factshts/network/simple/thalid.htmlhttp://www.fda.gov/cder/news/thalidomide.htmhttp://www.avert.org/http://www.marchofdimes.com/professionals/681_1223.asp

HIV-AIDS Testing in Pregnant Women

608 words - 2 pages individuals involved in the birth process, including the doctors and nurses, the child, and the mother. With the way that this disease is spreading today, if HIV-AIDS testing was made mandatory for women who have become pregnant it would help greatly to deter the overall spread of this deadly virus.

HIV-AIDS Testing in Pregnant Women

608 words - 2 pages individuals involved in the birth process, including the doctors and nurses, the child, and the mother. With the way that this disease is spreading today, if HIV-AIDS testing was made mandatory for women who have become pregnant it would help greatly to deter the overall spread of this deadly virus.

Mandatory AIDS testing

1980 words - 8 pages itself, and also all of the stigmas that are attached to AIDS. Therefore, not only will mandatory AIDS testing not prevent HIV infection, it will indirectly increase HIV infection because of the adverse effect it will have on voluntary testers.One of the major flaws of mandatory AIDS testing is that 'it provides people with a false sense of security.'(Greig, p68) When one goes for AIDS testing or more accurately an HIV antibody test which is also

The Stigma of HIV/AIDS

3345 words - 14 pages status to sexual partners”, as well their family, friends and health care providers (Rao et al, 2006, p. 266). In other words, self- stigma causes individuals with HIV/AIDS not to disclose their status of health due to the fear of being rejected by society. “Stigma also results in those who think that they may be infected to forgo testing, thus contributing to the spread of the disease” (Davidson, 2010, p.87) .This stigma is the key issue as to

Similar Essays

Opinion: Hiv Testing Should Be Mandatory

572 words - 2 pages In 1995 nearly fifty thousand individuals died of HIV/AIDS in the United States alone. Increased public awareness and the production of various medications have given this number a very notable decline, yet still over seventeen thousand people died last year - and the numerous benefits of mandatory HIV testing amount much too important to ignore.Type in "HIV every day" in Google and you will see is a CBS Report, "1000 Kids Get HIV Every Day." It

The Pros Of Mandatory Hiv Testing And Disclosure Of Hiv Status

2463 words - 10 pages The Pros of Mandatory HIV Testing and Disclosure of HIV Status The universal precautions of the Centers for Disease Control do not eradicate all risk to the patient or health care provider, says Baillie et al. (p. 129). While health care providers in all institutions have been educated in universal precautions, Beck, a registered nurse, cautions that some employees have failed to comply with the recommended procedures from the Centers of

Prevention Of Hiv Transmittance To Babies

1037 words - 4 pages protests by several activist groups. Activists fear that conservative legislators and policy makers will use the clinical data to justify mandatory testing and treatment for pregnant women. During the latter part of February, the United States Public Health Services published guidelines for HIV pregnant women in the Federal Register. Which coincidentally was published on the same day as the National Conference in Washington, DC for "HIV

Mother To Child Transmission Of Hiv

998 words - 4 pages population in US and that percentage has been growing since then. The mother-to-child transmission (MTC) occurred due to the lack of information provided by the U.S. health care agencies. This absence of early treatment options given to mothers who were HIV positive, led to many pregnant women to not seek prenatal care or get HIV testing during pregnancy. This lead expecting mother’s HIV status to be unknown. In addition, many pregnant mothers