This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Mandatory Vaccination In Children – An Ethical Dilemma

2280 words - 10 pages

Vaccination was first introduced globally for small pox and later on extended to other communicable diseases which are now known as vaccine preventable disease. Vaccination is beneficial both for individuals and community. This bring us to the ethical dilemma - Vaccination of a healthy child with the intention of protecting both the individual child and the community at the same time exposing the child to the theoretical risk of exposure to disease products whether live, attenuated or killed. There was a time when people never questioned the government or their physicians. Now because of more public awareness and accessibility to medical information, they are questioning the safety aspects of vaccines.
Most of the time parents take decision for a minor, even in the worst scenarios their decisions are always for the best interest of the child. Parental autonomy should always be respected unless the child is at greatest risk for not getting the vaccine.
Is it justifiable to scare the public by the statement by not vaccinating yourself or your child it poses a threat for the community? Who has the right to take a decision for a child – parent or physician or the legislation? Whose interest is to protect a community by vaccination – the government, the legislation, the pharmaceutical companies, researchers, physician or the individual?
The Case
Mrs. A with her new born is at a pediatric clinic. She is been advised to vaccinate her baby for a disease X,Y, and Z. Mrs A has a discussion with Dr.D regarding the benefits of vaccines, possible side effects and why her baby needs to be vaccinated. She understands the benefits and the risks, but decides not to immunize her baby because she believes that her baby is not at risk of contracting the diseases. Dr.D explains further to her that the risks pertaining to immunization are minimal and it would only be beneficial for her and the baby. Mrs. A sticks to her decision. Who is right and who is wrong here? Does the parent hold a right to refuse immunization for her baby?
Mandatory Vaccination
In the 1800s, compulsory vaccination against small pox was introduced into Europe and some states in the USA which contributed to the success and subsequent eradication of small pox2. In 1971, small pox legislation was annulled in UK2. Childhood vaccination is no longer compulsory in UK since 20042. In USA the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) has recommended an immunization schedule which is a non mandatory one. Most states in USA has adopted this policy and require the children to be vaccinated in order to attend day care centers and public schools in which case vaccination becomes mandatory.2 Exemptions are allowed for medical reasons whereas it is limited for religious and philosophical reasons in 20 US states3.
Risks and Benefits of Vaccination
Vaccines are one of most successful and cost effective public health preventive tool in current century for preventing communicable diseases. According to...

Find Another Essay On Mandatory vaccination in Children – an ethical dilemma

Ethical Dilemma In Business Essay

1665 words - 7 pages Ethical Dilemma In Business Ethical wrongdoing is a problem in the real world wherein the rules can be bent to manipulate financial standing. In some organizations such as Lehman Brothers, we will take a look at how they were able to alter real information that was damaging to the company in such a way to make it look more secure. Before these things can happen the upper management must discontinue listening to their employees and even punish

Euthanasia, an Analysis of an Ethical Dilemma

1083 words - 4 pages Voluntary euthanasia is defined as the act of killing someone painlessly, especially to relieve suffering from an incurable illness, with their consent (Collins English Dictionary, 2013). The morality and legal aspect of voluntary euthanasia has been a debate for many years. Voluntary euthanasia is a significant ethical dilemma that impacts nursing practice and other professionals in the healthcare field. With the utilization of ethical

An Ethical Dilemma within the Army

1619 words - 6 pages that your children are good enough to go to combat but not good enough to remain in our ranks in garrison. How would you feel if this were your child? As operations begin to draw down in Iraq, you could make the case that this is an ethical dilemma of the past. We will not need as many troops in the future. This may be true, but consider for a moment the following. MSNBC.com posted an Associated Press article in 2005 that highlights some

Physician Assisted Suicide: An Ethical Dilemma

1939 words - 8 pages they began using the Mercitron, because as a doctor he didn’t want them to experience pain. (Jackson). The use of this machine brought about an ethical dilemma. Is it ethical for terminally ill patients to end their own lives with the assistance of their doctor? Many patients when faced with this decision do not wish to go through the suffering or loss of abilities for doing every day activities. They want to die before they become incapacitated

Mandatory Vaccination in the United States: A Past and Present Examination of Jacobson v Massachusetts

1350 words - 6 pages towards legislating human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccination. HPV has been linked to several types of cancers of the reproductive organs, and an effective vaccination exists that can protect individuals from disease. Therefore it seems desirable to mandate vaccination in children before they engage in sexual activity, exposing themselves to the viruses. By impeding transmission of the virus, future morbidity and mortality can be lessened both in the

Mill and Kant's Efforts to Solve an Ethical Dilemma

1373 words - 6 pages It is natural for human beings to subscribe to particular moral ideologies and to apply them to their day-to-day lives since we all live in societies that have norms and values. For many centuries, philosophers have tried to formulate frameworks upon which these moral principles can be based and measured. This paper tries to apply the moral theories of John Stuart Mill and Immanuel Kant is solving an ethical dilemma. John Stuart Mill opens his

The Case of Conjoined Twins- an Ethical Dilemma

3253 words - 13 pages parents of the twins, they feel that Jodie and Mary have an equal right to life. By taking into account the ‘best interests’ of both their children, rather than basing it on just one of them. Therefore in the ‘Best Interests Principle’, this involves applying the best possible act for the individual. However because the case is complicated, as it involves two individuals, the parents base their decision on the ‘best interest

Developing an Ethical Framework and Applying It to an Ethical Dilemma

2319 words - 9 pages Introduction It is the purpose of this paper to explain the process by which I have come to develop my own ethical framework and apply this framework to an ethical dilemma. I have discovered through my research that an ethical framework is a collection of guidelines, usually in question format, that function together to support and reinforce the ethical decision-making process. Ethical frameworks can be designed and applied in both personal

Ethical Dilemma of partner disclosure in HIV/AIDS

698 words - 3 pages patient refuses to disclose their status to their primary partner, it becomes an ethical dilemma. In a lecture during our second block this year called “Ethical and legal problems in HIV/AIDS” by Yolande Guidozzi, we discussed this dilemma. It was concluded that it is often a choice the healthcare worker has to undertake, given the circumstances. The Health Professional Counsel South Africa (HPCSA) also advises that own discretion is used. This made

Ethical Decision Making in an Organization

1062 words - 4 pages What makes a good leader? It depends. Most organizations look for individuals that have something to offer when they look at credentials or a great interview but looks can be deceiving does a good manager necessarily mean that a good leader I do not think so. An ethical dilemma is when an incident that makes you to ask yourself how do I handle this situation based on your beliefs and deciding how to choose between right and wrong

Scandal In Corporate America: An Ethical, Not A Legal, Problem

957 words - 4 pages problems. On the other hand, Jeffrey L. Seglin argues that the problems in American businesses are a combination of ethical and legal problems. The ideas of ethical problems in corporate America are illustrated differently in both Frohnen and Clarke’s essay and Seglin’s essay. In Bruce Frohnen and Leo Clarke’s essay, "Scandal in Corporate America: An Ethical, Not a Legal, Problem" they discuss their views of American businesses and the

Similar Essays

Mandatory Vaccination In The United States

911 words - 4 pages against smallpox, an ethical dilemma arose. What is the ethical question: Should the US government be allowed to federally mandate a vaccine? Currently in the United States, the federal government does not mandate any vaccines. Instead, the decision to require vaccines is left up to the individual states’ discretion (1). All fifty states do require certain vaccines for children entering the public school system, but each state individually decided

Banking: An Ethical Dilemma? Essay

2628 words - 11 pages Topic: Banking; an ethical dilemma? Name: Kan Shen ID number: u1368086 Module: Introduction to financial services Module code: BFE0012 Tutor: Shabbir Dastgir and David Pearson Date: 11 March, 2014 Word count: 2300 Introduction With the massive development of modern society, people’s income statement has become better and better. The bank has played the important role in many different kinds of areas such as loan contracts

An Ethical Dilemma Essay

1526 words - 7 pages guilty. Bowen’s ethical dilemma was this: Was it ethical to leave the Sadhu after doing his part to assist him, or should he have done more? This particular case also sheds light on Individual Ethics contrasted with Group Ethics. Bowen comes to the realization that he “walked by an ethical dilemma without appropriate action”. How can one identify an ethical dilemma upon encountering a situation such as this? An Ethical Dilemma is a complicated

Abortion: An Ethical Dilemma Essay

1960 words - 8 pages born I sanctified you and appointed you as my spokesman to the world." Here God clearly states that He knew Jeremiah, the unborn, before he was conceived and had a purpose for him. A prominent question in this ethical dilemma is "Is this life preconceived?" And if it is, "Do we have the autonomy to terminate this potential being?"A pro-choice stance supports the women's complete autonomy in her healthcare. They believe that life does not begin