This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Mandatory Vaccination In The United States

911 words - 4 pages

The ethics of federal mandatory vaccination in the United States can be determined through the following case-study.
Description of case study: In 2003, President George W. Bush put forward a plan to vaccinate 450,000 public health-care workers (including military personnel, health care workers, and first-responders) against smallpox in case of a bioterrorist attack on the United States. The plan was ultimately unsuccessful because only 4,213 of the desired 450,000 actually opted to get the vaccine. Inoculation is optional for the targeted personnel (except for those in the military), so with no initial financial protection plan in place, most of the workers decided to stay unvaccinated. ...view middle of the document...

Over the course of almost 200 years, Jenner’s vaccine became the most-successful preventative healthcare solution to date, finally eradicating smallpox in 1980 (5). Smallpox is the only virus that has ever been eradicated. So in 2003, when U.S. President George W. Bush proposed a plan to vaccinate citizens against smallpox, an ethical dilemma arose.
What is the ethical question: Should the US government be allowed to federally mandate a vaccine?
Currently in the United States, the federal government does not mandate any vaccines. Instead, the decision to require vaccines is left up to the individual states’ discretion (1). All fifty states do require certain vaccines for children entering the public school system, but each state individually decided to mandate inoculation based on the idea of “herd immunity” (2).
Define terms: “herd immunity” is the result of wide-spread vaccination or natural-immunity to a certain strain of an illness or disease. This occurs when even those who go unvaccinated can reap the benefits of immunization indirectly by never facing exposure to an illness in the first place because of the lack of transmission.
Other relevant facts:
Medical: [explain how new smallpox vaccine works]
Mechanism of action:
What are the relevant ethical considerations?
Respect for persons: not treating someone as a mere means to a goal or end
In the United States Declaration of Independence, it is stated that “All men are created equal.” Therefore, regardless of the Catholic stance on this issue, it can be agreed upon by U.S. citizens that it is imperative that whatever the decision, the outcome must respect all people involved. Those involved include military personnel, health care workers, and first-responders, their families,...

Find Another Essay On Mandatory Vaccination in the United States

Abortion in the United States Essay

3719 words - 15 pages that these restrictions were constitutional, and that while some women would have to drive 150 miles to have the procedure, it did not present an undue burdens (Tomlinson). Abortion in Texas Since Roe v. Wade, it is estimated that there have been more than 40 million abortions performed in the United States. Even after the Supreme Court ruling, Texas still has some of the

TANF in the United States Essay

3808 words - 15 pages In the 19th century and the beginning of the 20th century, social welfare in the United States tended to be operated mostly by private and religious organizations. The original concepts of social welfare were based upon protestant ethics along with liberal values. It was believed that only people of "weak character" could become poverty stricken. At this time, the American ideal was to be a "self made man", meaning that a person was able to

Abortion in the United States

1937 words - 8 pages , 84,610 women obtained abortions in Texas, producing a rate of 16.5 abortions per 1,000 women of reproductive age. Some of these women were from other states, and some Texas residents had abortions in other states, so this rate may not reflect the abortion rate of state residents. The rate decreased 4% since 2005, when it was 17.3 abortions per 1,000 women 15-44. Abortions in Texas represent 7% of all abortions in the United States.”(Jones, Zolna

Obesity in the United States

1408 words - 6 pages instead a tractor or a machine to get accomplish a job. Unlike our predecessors over a century ago, when physical labor was at 30 percent, now it is less than 1 percent. Many schools are not facilitating OBESITY IN THE UNITED STATES 3 this issue, either. Physical Education or PE classes used to be mandatory, now so many schools are making cuts to

The United States in Decline

2366 words - 9 pages One of the most vigorous debates focuses on the current status of the United States hegemony and whether or not it is in decline. This begs the question, if the United States is indeed declining in status, will it still be an influential player or not? I argue that the United States is losing its prominent position as the hegemonic leader of the world, but will still remain an influential player in global politics in the following decades to

Hispanics In The United States

1253 words - 6 pages Hispanic population is steadily rising in the United States. As the second largest ethnic group in the United States, Hispanic Americans account for 14.4 % of the total United States or almost 47 million nationally. While some Hispanic Americans are improving socially and economically, others are slowly declining. They also struggle with social, political, and linguistic acceptance. There are concerns over rights and regulations of Hispanic

Homelessness in the United States

1474 words - 6 pages According to the National Student Campaign Against Hunger and Homelessness, “approximately 3.5 million people are homeless each year, while 36.3 million live in households without enough food.” This statistic only reflects the United States, and to many people, it just doesn’t make sense. For instance Alfredzine Black of the YWCA in Marion, Indiana says, “I don’t understand why we have so much poverty in the richest country in the world

Immigration in the United States

1104 words - 4 pages The United States has often been referred to as a global “melting pot” due to its assimilation of diverse cultures, nationalities, and ethnicities. In today’s society, this metaphor may be an understatement. Between 1990 and 2010, the number of foreign born United States residents nearly doubled from 20 million to 40 million, increasing the U.S. population from almost 250 million to 350 million people. With U.S. born children and grandchildren

Divorce in the United States

1250 words - 5 pages only 6 weeks -- and file for divorce on grounds ofmental cruelty.Popular attitudes toward divorce changed as the United Statesbecame more urbanized and less religious. The increasingacceptance of divorce was reflected in court interpretations ofexisting laws and in new legislation enacted by the states. Twotendencies merged, making possible the establishment of new andeasier grounds for divorce. The focus of state divorce, whichpreviously concerned

Poverty in the United States

1004 words - 5 pages It certainly seems peculiar how so much disparity exists among the haves and have-nots in the country that leads the free world. The high level of poverty in the United States coupled with the disparaging rates of income are at times hard to comprehend. How can a country of such great wealth and power also be a country of vast poverty? Poverty will always be evident in the United States to some extent. However, minimizing poverty and income

Immigration in the United States

1983 words - 8 pages Immigration is what has made America what it is today. An immigrant is a person who comes to a country to take up permanent residence. Everyone in the United States of America is an immigrant either moving here themselves or being directly related to someone who did. All of us came from different parts of the world even as far back as the Native Americans when they emigrated from Asia to the United States. Immigration is needed to grow America

Similar Essays

Mandatory Vaccination In The United States: A Past And Present Examination Of Jacobson V Massachusetts

1350 words - 6 pages constitutional, and consequently, Mr. Jacobson was in violation of the law and required to pay the original $5 fine. Ultimately the U.S. Supreme Court agreed to hear the case and address the question, “[is the state’s] statute, so construed, therefore, inconsistent with the liberty which the Constitution of the United States secures to every person against deprivation by the state” (3). In other words, the Court examined the notion of a state’s

Should The United States Have Mandatory Military Conscription?

1385 words - 6 pages Absolutely, positively, emphatically, unequivocally, without a doubt, NO! Not now, not ever! Well, maybe for one reason, in the event of an existential threat to our nation. Now that I have stated my opinion I will back this up with information from several studies providing evidence for continuing the worlds greatest all volunteer (entry) military force. For the vast majority of our nation’s history, the United States has had an all volunteer

Hpv Vaccination: The Mandatory Urgency Essay

915 words - 4 pages The HPV vaccination presented by Gerasil in 2006 has caused a controversy in the realms of science, religion, and philosophy. With nearly 6 million new cases of HVP every year, the vaccination itself has not been the issue, however it is the compulsory use of the vaccination that has been proposed in most states and implemented in a few that has caused a scene. James Colgrove of the New England Journal of Medicine presents the varying

Mandatory Vaccination In Children – An Ethical Dilemma

2280 words - 10 pages to her that the risks pertaining to immunization are minimal and it would only be beneficial for her and the baby. Mrs. A sticks to her decision. Who is right and who is wrong here? Does the parent hold a right to refuse immunization for her baby? Mandatory Vaccination In the 1800s, compulsory vaccination against small pox was introduced into Europe and some states in the USA which contributed to the success and subsequent eradication of small