Manipulation Of Time In "Cloud Nine" And "Top Girls"

2369 words - 9 pages

The manipulation of time is important in the Cloud Nine and Top Girls, two plays by Caryl Churchill. In one, she manipulates the passage of time to create a connection between the oppression of women and the oppression of those living in the British colonies. In the other, she puts the present first and the past last, suggesting that the past is more important than Britain would like to admit. Like Patrick Wright, she is questioning the idea of a national identity or heritage that wants to continue class and racial discrimination but give it a different name. The history for Churchill is very important in developing the future not only for her characters, but for Britain in general. Churchill questions the need for one history, but instead pushes forward Wright’s idea of a “heterogeneous society” where each individual can define their own history. Churchill shows the ugliness of colonial Africa, of racism, of classism, of sexism, and of homophobia while also showing that these characters that represent the “other” have histories that are just important to Britain as those who are the so-called “custodians”.

Caryl Churchill brings the past and the present together in Cloud 9 with an Act One focused on the colonial past and the second act focused on how the modern family is just as dysfunctional. In the first act, Churchill focuses on colonial Africa and the way race and gender were approached. With the character of Clive we get the Britain which is unable to see diversity and believes they are helping the colonies by being a father in the way that Clive treats Joshua. However, by having Joshua pointing a gun at Clive in the end we see Churchill’s introduction of the opposing view and how the colonies actually viewed Britain. Churchill also uses Victorian Africa to show the parallels of how one kind of oppression was replaced with another. In this view we see the ugliness that the ‘national past’ would like to forget.

Wright says “with the rationalization and bureaucratization of everyday life the past – especially in its imperialist dimension – becomes a theatre in which adventures of personal action can be played out” (22). This is exactly what Churchill creates with her Victorian family in Africa. Clive says in the beginning” This is my family. Though far from home / We serve the Queen wherever we may roam / I am a father to the natives here, / And father to my family so dear.”(Churchill 3). Clive is the head of the family pushing his ideals on his family and the natives while his wife stands by (played by a man) trying to be how the men want her to be. This is the family structure that Wright believes is traditional and Churchill sees the romantic version of Imperial Britain was neither romantic nor innocent so she adds the violence and sex of the modern world to remind the reader of the ugliness of the past. But also the family unit is used to show how although the modern world may have worked past issues of racism and...

Find Another Essay On Manipulation of Time in "Cloud Nine" and "Top Girls"

Feminism in "Top Girls" and "The Handmaid's Tale"

1594 words - 6 pages large. Churchill once wrote: ‘Playwrights don’t give answers, they ask questions’, [6] and I think she is proving it in Top Girls: she brings up many tough questions over the course of the play, including what success is and if women’s progress in the workplace has been a good or bad thing. Margaret Atwood is a Canadian feminist writer, who wrote The Handmaid’s Tale in times of the defeat of the Equal Rights Amendment, the rise of the religious

Truth in Distance: Caryl Churchill’s Use of Representative Discord in Cloud Nine

1654 words - 7 pages as pertinent to Churchill’s plays, but are sometimes a bit more obscure. In Cloud Nine, her contemporary and future influences are easy to spot: her participation in workshops on sexual politics at the Joint Stock Theatre Group (directly inspiring Cloud Nine) in 1978-1979, the questions that the play leaves hanging about the future of gender, racial, and sexual roles, and the uncertain results of a life repressed by neo-Victorian conservatism

A Doll's House and Top Girls that contributes to or highlights each heroine's realization of theses issues.Compare and Contrast.

1692 words - 7 pages Caryl Churchill "Top girls" I will focus on the items mentioned above. Caryl successfully shows another version of a "new woman". In contrast to Nora's role, Marlene is a successful, career-minded managing director in an employment agency. Unlike Nora, she chooses what she wants in life. In "Top Girls" I want the stage lightings to be lit more brightly for Joyce and Marlene. The idea is to show that it is about time that both sisters talk about how

Jeanette Winterson's Written on the Body and Caryl Churchill's Cloud Nine

3320 words - 13 pages distinct differences between the genders through the presence of love and gender stereotypes, the dominant idea of nature, and the struggle between male and female characters with specific reference to sexual relationships and marriage. Gender stereotypes seem characteristic in both Written on the Body and Cloud Nine. Clearly the women are expected to be submissive, while the men are to be assertive. The first time we see the idea of these

Essay on the Manipulation of Polonius and Ophelia in Hamlet

1009 words - 4 pages himself. Polonius tries to control the way Hamlet is seen around the court so as to rise in stature himself. Through his manipulation of Ophelia, Polonius becomes a character not as much concerned with familial ties as one whose concern rests within the world of court intrigue and position.   Taken separately, these two characters have different agendas concerning the Prince. Polonius' preoccupation with power exists at the same time as

Write an essay comparing and contrasting the two play Top Girls and A Doll's House

1534 words - 6 pages Self -expression is about being able to voice out what you think, feel and mean in any form of activity. However, women that existed in the early centuries often have to follow the constrictive protocols prescribed by their patriarchal societies, thus depriving them many opportunities of self expression. This essay explores the different unique ways in which the female characters in Top Girls and A Doll's House challenge these protocols and how

An Occurence at Owl Creek Bridge: A Manipulation of Time

742 words - 3 pages An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge Essay An Occurrence At Owl Creek Bridge: Present-Past-Present Ambrose Bierce’s An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge, which is a short story released in 1890, gained much popularity over the years. It is most famous for it’s manipulation of time. Though the events in the book only take seconds, the story is over eight pages long. Time seems to slow for the man in the noose and at the same time speed

It's Time for Girls and Boys to Plays Sports Together

1146 words - 5 pages It's Time for Girls and Boys to Plays Sports Together On the athletic field, in the gym, or on the ice, there have always been standards for the athletes to follow. These standards range from what type of athletic equipment is not only necessary but appropriate, to who can play when, where, and how. This last standard is the one that is being challenged the most; can men play not only on women’s teams, but can they also participate in

Motivation and Manipulation in Julius Caesar

1839 words - 7 pages In Julius Caesar, Shakespeare illuminates the themes of human motivation and manipulation. He examines the relationship between actions and motivations, cause and effect, and word and deed, using the symbols of hands and hearts. Throughout the play, the characters Brutus and Marc Antony express their different understandings of this relationship rhetorically. In his 1953 film interpretation, Joseph L. Mankiewicz demonstrates these characters

Manipulation of Truth in Oliver Stone's JFK

1271 words - 5 pages Manipulation of Truth in Oliver Stone's JFK            Oliver Stone is a master of manipulation. Being an expert in the art of directing, Stone is able to make an audience believe whatever he wishes. In the 1991 film JFK, Oliver Stone manipulates facts in order to convey a fictional conspiracy involving the assassination of John F. Kennedy. The Zapruder film and the magic bullet theory are two

Manipulation of desires in The Iliad.

835 words - 3 pages Agamemnon, by trying to fulfill his agenda, chooses the right gifts to bribe Achilles, he fails to acknowledge one important factor; Achilles also has an agenda. Gifts may work in achieving someone's sometimes, but if the victim of manipulation is determined to stay on his path, the gifts are worthless.Works ConsultedHomer, The Iliad. Chapman, George. Hertfordshire. Wordsworth Classics, 2003.Roles of Men, Women, and Children in Greece. "http://oncampus.richmond.edu/academics/as/education/projects/webunits/greecerome/Greeceroles1.html" Spring, 1998.

Similar Essays

Reading Between The Lines: Use Of Space And Body Language In Caryl Churchill's 'top Girls'

1798 words - 7 pages instead of being words that the actress must speak, they are instructions from the playwright dictating the need for certain non-verbal signals to be made. These may be as basic and unobtrusive as indicating which characters are on stage at any one time or as intrusive as dictating what a character is wearing, what they are doing and exactly what tone of voice they are speaking in. Churchill's stage directions in `Top Girls' leave plenty of scope for

How Does Caryl Churchill Present Women In Acts 2 And 3 Of Top Girls?

2137 words - 9 pages through the examination of sister hood to highlight how Margaret Thatcher and Marlene in Top Girls were both being rejected as 'sisters' because of the career paths and beliefs they chose. Although both women could be seen as having achieved success from a bourgeois feminist perspective, they engage in 'intra' gender oppression of their working-class counter-parts, which is ultimately what Churchill was portraying through the character is her play, with the idea of 'us' and 'them' and the opposition she suggested about Britain's class structure at the time.

Top Girls In The Predicament Essay

3370 words - 13 pages ¡°Top Girls¡± in the Predicament From the perspective of society, despite certain conditions it had established for women to move up to the top of their social careers through both the official efforts and the endeavors of women themselves, those British ¡°top girls¡± under the influence of Thatcherism in the late 1970s and early 1980s continued to live in a predicament resulting from the traditional gender bias, which was further enhanced by

Restaurant Scene In Top Girls Essay

1493 words - 6 pages Restaurant Scene in Top Girls The restaurant scene in Top Girls (TG) revolves around Marlene celebrating her promotion at work, it is purely female gendered, having no male actors present throughout the whole play. The significance of the five guests she has chosen to celebrate with promotes the hard work and sacrifices she has made in order to get where she is. This scene uses women of the past, to highlight struggles of women through