This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Mansfield Park, The Novel, Or Mansfield Park The Film?

1834 words - 7 pages

There have been many adaptations of Jane Austen's books over the years; all six of her novels have been made into films or television dramas with varying degrees of success, from the classics of Persuasion, Pride & Prejudice and Sense & Sensibility, to the funny modern version of Emma in the form of Clueless. In this paper I want to show how director Patricia Rozema has made Austen's novel Mansfield Park much more modern, accessible, and, as some claim, radical, by skipping parts of the story that would make the film version drag, and importing events and dialogue that have significance into scenes, often created by Rozema, that are more appealing.
There is always controversy whether a Jane Austen masterpiece can be adequately conveyed through the medium of film. It has been said that ‘seeing a movie or television adaptation of any of Jane Austen's works is like hearing a symphony of Mozart played on a harmonica’ which suggests that the adaptations are cheapened by the filmmakers and sometimes wildly misinterpreted. Andrew Wright says that many adaptations of Austen's work are made to ‘entice the demi-literate or those of presumably short attention span.’ This is the criticism that faced director Patricia Rozema with her film version of Mansfield Park, which states the very start that the film is only loosely based on the film, but also draws inspiration from the early journals and letters of Jane Austen. There are two schools of thought on the adaptation of Jane Austen's novels, whether they are beneficial or not. It is clear that Rozema’s version of the film makes it more accessible to viewers. M. Casey Diana has experimented on Austen adaptations with her class group:
‘She divided her students into two groups; one read Sense and Sensibility first and then saw the Thompson/Lee film, the other saw the movie first and then read the book…the first group had a hard time comprehending (never mind responding on any deeply imaginative level to it), and both groups used the movie as a "gateway" into the book or an explanation afterwards.

The film version certainly gives us a more vivid view of the story, especially in scenes set in Fanny’s Portsmouth home, where we can see the squalor you end up in when you marry for love. The film is also more poignant on the issues of slavery and abuse of human rights. I am referring to the wailing Fanny hears coming from the slave ship, and the sketchbook that she finds with pictures of the slaves that her uncle has in Antigua. I will go into that in more detail later in this paper.
There is some debate whether the film should be called ‘Patricia Rozemas Mansfield Park’, as opposed to Jane Austen's, as Derek Elley points out in his review of the film. He claims Rozema:
‘reinterprets the central character, Fanny Price, as a cross between Austen herself and a tomboyish proto-feminist, throws in some magical realism and gratuitous lesbian frissons to spice up the pot, and too often steps out of its...

Find Another Essay On Mansfield Park, the novel, or Mansfield Park the film?

The Search for a Home in Jane Austen's Mansfield Park

2453 words - 10 pages        Jane Austen's Mansfield Park is a novel obsessed with home and family.  It begins a story of one family, three sisters, and quickly expands to a story of three families, the Bertrams, the Prices, and the Norrises.  Family upon family is added, each one growing, expanding, and moving until the novel is crowded with characters and estates.  An obsession with movement creates an overall feeling of displacement

Comparison of Mansfield Park a Essay

1519 words - 6 pages Comparison of Mansfield Park and Metropolitan Whit Stillman's attempt to capture Jane Austen's novel Mansfield Park on film in Metropolitan is a fair adaptation but it is unable to give the viewer the same insights. Stillman manages to have most of Mansfield Parks characters represented in some way or another, however the time needed to develop those characters is simply not there in a two hour movie. It is this development that makes Jane

Mansfield Park by Jane Austen

1455 words - 6 pages At the start of Mansfield Park Fanny arrives at Mansfield. Fanny stands out from those who live at Mansfield. She is much more humble and less arrogant than her relatives. Fanny is, all in all, a simple girl. As the story goes on, however, the reader gets a glimpse of exactly how Fanny has changed when she goes back to visit her family. Before encountering this look of Fanny's family and her life at Portsmouth, it is clear that her time at

Women's Education in Mansfield Park

2056 words - 8 pages Women's Education in Mansfield Park       In Mansfield Park, Jane Austen presents three different kinds of formal education for women. Two of these have the ultimate goal of marriage, while the third is, possibly, as close to a gentleman's education as a woman's could be. Although there is some overlapping of these three types, each one is, basically, embodied in one of the major female characters -- Maria

Fanny in Jane Austen's Mansfield Park

2151 words - 9 pages Price. Fanny is a Christian heroine who is submissive, physically delicate and all too collusive with the privileged world of Mansfield Park. Having Fanny as the heroine displaces the energy and vitality of Mary Crawford. However Fanny is the heroine of this novel and we have to discover if she is only the heroine due to the fact that all the other characters in the novel falter in some way. When Fanny comes to Mansfield she is an extremely

The Importance of Home and Family in Jane Austen's Mansfield Park

1686 words - 7 pages families that cause Fanny and the novel to turn out the way they do.  Yet the heroine finds herself in this situation only because of the influence of the Austen family on the characters in Mansfield Park.  Not only can parallels easily be drawn between lively, theatrical, handsome Henry Crawford and Henry Austen, reputedly Jane's favorite brother1, but the imprint of Jane's siblings also shows in Fanny herself.  Sent

British Social Class in Mansfield Park by Jane Austen

2055 words - 9 pages Mansfield Park is a complete socially oriented novel. In this novel Jane Austen closely describe the everyday life of rural middle class society, its gaieties and hardships, describing a distinct system of moral and social principles influencing people’s lives in that period, women status in the system and female life expectations. In the novel Austen shows the efforts of some trying to break the predetermined limitations in order to improve

Sexuality and Desire in Jane Austen's Mansfield Park

3355 words - 13 pages play seem to be a condemnation of sexuality and passion? Although we are aware of her unwavering desire for Edmund throughout the novel (most commonly expressed through modest blushes and an intense jealousy toward Mary), it would never occur to anyone reading Mansfield Park to suspect Fanny Price of possessing sexual desire or impure thoughts. Butler compares her feelings to Edmund to her emotions toward William, saying that they have a

Comparing Male Dominance in Pride and Prejudice, Mansfield Park, and Emma

3357 words - 13 pages preventing Frank from spending more time with his family in Highbury, and causes Frank's engagement to be a secret, which leads to arguments between him and Jane Fairfax that almost end the affair. Clearly, power held and exerted by women only causes trouble for themselves and those around them in all three novels. In comparison, the women who had little or no influence in the family structure were very virtuous. In Mansfield Park, Fanny is an

Satire of class distinction in the film 'Gosford Park' by Robert Altman (including techniques)

587 words - 2 pages One of the main issues being satirised in Gosford Park is the absurdity of class distinction in society. Altman satirises the idea of a social hierarchy, where people are separated into different classes based on their amount of wealth and aristocracy, forced to live different lives and be different people. He highlights the negative effects imposed on society, especially the upper class, as a result of class distinction, where one must do

The Stories of Katherine Mansfield

2074 words - 8 pages symbolism. Symbolism was considered the most important technique to Katherine Mansfield. It influenced her early writing while additionally, it helped her develop ideas. “The most important idea that she took from the Symbolist theory was the belief that in literature an abstract state of mind or feeling should be conveyed concrete rather than description.” (Hanson 26) Going further into the ideas of Katherine Mansfield, “A Dill Pickle,” is one of her

Similar Essays

The Silences In Mansfield Park Essay

1832 words - 7 pages ungrateful” (296) in her uncle’s eyes. The reader learns that even in silence one cannot hide from the hurt of the world. One cannot be mute on all horrible matters in life, such as bad proposals. Others in Mansfield Park have their own moments of silence or lack thereof. In the beginning of the novel we hear that the silence of Lady Bertram saddens young Fanny. This is the first silence the reader hears in the book. The silence of Lady Bertram

Mansfield Park Essay

1680 words - 7 pages categories of silence used intentional and unintentional silence. The category of silence that the letter fell in was intentional silence, being that her niece never said if she wished to marry the man or not. Austen stated that she could no longer hold her silence and told her niece that may not be the right person for her. The new source that was introduced was the movie Mansfield Park BBC version by Billie Park based off of the novel, Mansfield

Mansfield Park: Changes To The Female Protagonist In Film

1441 words - 6 pages Patricia Rozema's film Mansfield Park is vastly different to its 19th Century literary counterpart, societal values expressed through the behaviour, speech and moral judgement of characters change over time and Rozema's film takes character's and re-invents them to be applicable to contemporary societal values and be engaging for a modern audience. The most obvious example is the changes made to the female protagonist of shy, frail, well

Fanny Price: The Heroine Of Mansfield Park

1516 words - 6 pages Fanny Price: The Heroine of Mansfield Park Jane Austin's Mansfield Park is not widely accepted by critics. The novel's criticism is due to the heroine, Fanny Price. Since Fanny does not encompass the conventional characteristics of a heroine (charm, wit, and beauty), critics hold the opinion that she is passive, week, and boring. Ironically, Austin's goal was to demonstrate that superficial charm and wit are nice, but there are more