Maquiladoras: Manufacturing Poverty In Mexico Essay

2788 words - 11 pages

The trend toward a more globalized market has become increasingly developed in the latter half of the 20th century. Emphasis on world trade has become a dominant figure in almost every Nation’s economy. Between 1970 and 2000 world trade has experienced an increase of almost 370 percent. Concurrently, world GDP increased by 150 percent. Trade is beneficial to Nations because it allows the creation of avenues that aid in efficient allocation of resources (Canas & Coronado). Countries can gain from trade when they specialize according to their comparative advantage. This is, when they create conditions where goods and services can be produced at a lower opportunity cost than in any other country. Along the same logic, countries can also make large profits by taking advantage of another countries comparative advantage.

A prime example of this is the relationship between Mexico and the United States. Mexico has a comparative advantage over a large majority of countries in the world in its abundance of cheap labor. Mexico also has fairly underdeveloped environmental protection and labor laws, which allows corporations more leeway in their operations. Additionally, Mexico provides incentives to foreign corporations including reduced tariffs, unrestricted leases and certain tax exemptions. As a result, corporations have less overhead costs and a greater potential for profits.

In this paper I will discuss this phenomenon in several different contexts. First, I will draw on the history of Mexican labor in the United States as it undoubtedly set the stage for future labor agreements between these two nations. Second, I will discuss the Maquiladora Program which encouraged United States corporations to relocate their plants and factories to Mexico through the lure of cheap labor and business friendly legislature. Lastly, I will discuss the negative effects of Maquiladoras ranging from the environment to the exploitation of Mexican workers.

Early Mexican Immigrant Labor

The first real need for migrant workers by US employers came during the expansion of cattle ranches in the Southwest and the increase in agricultural production in California during 1850 and 1880. During this time over 55,000 workers emigrated from Mexico to the United States seeking jobs as field hands ( A majority of workers were also employed in the completion of the railway that would eventually connect Mexico with the United States. In fact, it is estimated that during the height of construction between 1880 and 1890, as many as 60% of the working crews were Mexican ( Soon the Mexican workforce became well established in American industries including mining, the railroad and commercial agriculture. Up to this point the migration of workers into the Unites States was small and limited mainly to skilled miners, field hands, indentured servants and small manufacturers forced north by Indians raids or the Mexican Revolution...

Find Another Essay On Maquiladoras: Manufacturing Poverty in Mexico

Maquiladoras Essay

624 words - 2 pages Maquiladoras, foreign owned export assembly plants, have been both beneficial and problematic to men and mainly women working near the U.S.-Mexico border. The maquiladora program is a world wide economic issue affecting many people that must be addressed to the public.Mainly women make up the workforce in maquiladoras. Although the maquiladoras have been able to supply many women with jobs, the women, however, have faced many adversaries in the

Maquiladoras Essay

1986 words - 8 pages , companies from other countries such as Korea, Japan, and the United States (Fig.2) embark to build their assembly plants and flourish on the low labor rates. "Maquiladoras" are foreign owned manufacturing plants that rely on cheap Mexican labor.The unemployment rate was high in Mexico in the 1960's. To fix this issue, the plan was to draw in American corporations that would build their companies in Mexico. In order to ascertain new businesses in

The North American Free Trade Agreement

3714 words - 15 pages genuine and substantial growth. The day NAFTA went into effect, maquila employment along the U.S.-Mexico border stood at 546,433. As of April 1998, 983,272 Mexicans were employed in maquiladoras; the maquila sector is the top generator of employment in Mexico. While Mexican economic development has failed miserably, so too has standard of living for many Mexicans. Between 1984 and 1994, and through several currency devaluations, the Mexican poverty

The Role of Mexican-American Border Relations in the Political Process

3442 words - 14 pages a number of occasions that we haven’t lost sight of what we want to do, but it has proven hard” ( The future of this issue is very interesting seeing as though the United States is very cautious of foreigners due to their involvement in military action in other countries. Another border issue which both Mexico and the United States are not adequately addressing is the maquiladoras (sweatshops) and poverty in border towns. There are

NAFTA amid Globalization

2054 words - 9 pages $946.1 billion in 2008. At the same time, Canada-United States trade has nearly tripled and Mexico-United States trade has more than quadrupled” (NAFTANOW). For example, in the auto manufacturing industry alone, “90 percent of Canada’s total automotive imports come from the United States and Mexico” and 97 percent of car exports go to these two markets (Draper, page 196). By removing tariffs, this trading relationship has successfully out-competed

After the Peso Crisis, the Mexican Recovery with Maquilas

3340 words - 13 pages momentum in manufacturing in Mexico brought about by the revitalization of the Maquila is a push that the Mexican government hopes will put the on the road to full recovery. While the industry is still in the early phases of recovery, the effects are already being seen. In June the country's 2,900-plus Maquiladoras exported goods worth $7.72 billion. This number is 20% higher than a year ago and it sets a monthly record for the Maquiladora industry

Exploration of the Economic/Profitable Dimensions of Illegal Mexican Immigration for U.S. Economy

821 words - 3 pages better wage than can be found in centralized regions, however, the working and living conditions of these employees are on the most part abominable. Without the stability to form unions, the workers of the maquiladoras are at the mercy of the opportunistic factory owners who exploit their workers with 12 hour workdays, unsafe working conditions and lack of benefits. Although these workers are paid the minimum wage of Mexico, it is not enough to allow

The Problems with NAFTA Not Helping Economies

1503 words - 6 pages not the case in Mexico where NAFTA has slammed the middle class back into poverty. Another thing, which NAFTA affects, is the environment. NAFTA supporters promised that the agreement would lead to increased investment in environmental cleanup and less maquiladoras along the U.S.-Mexico border. However, many communities still lack access to both water and sewage systems. "Today, only 10 percent of Mexico's yearly output of 7 million tons of

Top Ten Reasons to Oppose the Free Trade Area of the Americas

1172 words - 5 pages jobs have disappeared as a result of NAFTA. When these laid off workers find new jobs, they earn 23 percent less on average than at their previous employment. In Mexico, manufacturing wages fell 21 percent from 1995 to 1999, and have only started to recover. The percentage of Mexicans living in poverty has also grown since NAFTA went into effect. The environment suffers: In the maquiladora zones along the US-Mexico border, the increased pollution

Equity and Sustainable Development

1037 words - 5 pages In part three of the book, Equity and Sustainable Development: Reflections from the U.S.- Mexico Border, poverty, vulnerability, and environmental management are discussed. Chapters use Tijuana to show how vulnerability and poor environmental management is widespread within poverty stricken cities. Connections between these factors show how one leads to another, making for sustainability problems in cities like Tijuana. Chapter six

The Future Of Currency

3241 words - 13 pages occurred in many corporations, "In Canada, as well as in the U.S., real wages are stagnating and the proportion of full-time workers living in poverty continues to grow." There should never be any workers, let alone full-time workers, living in poverty. In Canada as in any country, poverty should not exist among the working class. This is definitely not the case in Mexico where NAFTA has slammed the middle class back into poverty. Another

Similar Essays

Sweat Shops In Mexico Essay

1131 words - 5 pages implications of having these foreign factories in Mexico do not benefit the people in the long run. Maquiladoras ignore the well-being of workers proving that they should be banned. The working conditions in the Maquiladoras endanger workers. Women workers are denied access to social, maternity, and health benefits (Woman’s Labor). Woman are at a disadvantage if they get pregnant. There are no benefits for these workers to fall back on

The Struggle Of Women In Maquiladoras

2460 words - 10 pages ". Business Week, 09/21/98, p18D. "Manufacturing in Nearby Mexico". Collectron of Arizona, Inc. 1997. (20 Mar. 1999). Martinez, Hector. "Maquiladoras: Should U.S. Companies Run for the Border?" The Latin American Alliance. 1997. (26 Feb 99). "Sex Discrimination in Mexico's Maquiladora Sector". Human Rights Watch Publication. 1996. (3 Mar 1999).

Maquiladoras & Nafta Essay

2053 words - 8 pages side. The Maquiladora program also wanted to attract foreign manufacturing facilities, technology, and know-how by giving a permanent tax holiday to manufacturing companies that would set up "twin plants" on the Mexican side of the border. In the beginning of the program, all foreign-owned operations had to be located within a 20-kilometer strip along the US-Mexican border. Since 1972 they can be located anywhere in Mexico. In 1996

Nafta And Maquiladoras Essay

2310 words - 9 pages pressure by environmental and labor groups, the attachment of two side agreements concerning labor and the environment. Although still too early to tell, NAFTA appears to be amending some of the inherent problems which exist along the U.S.-Mexico border. Opposition to NAFTA must be placed in some historical context. During the 1980’s many American manufacturing jobs were being exported to Mexican maquiladoras. American labor groups originally