This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Marx And Durkheim’s Views Contributed To Our Understanding Of Crime And Deviance?

981 words - 4 pages

Introduction to the Sociology and Psychology of Crime

Section A (Sociology of Crime)
How have Marx and Durkheim’s Views Contributed to our Understanding of Crime and Deviance?

Karl Marx’s Marxist theory and Emile Durkheim’s functionalist theory were both significant in their own ways and therefore made a large contribution to our perception and understanding of how crime and deviance occurs and is dealt with in society.

The Marxist theory on crime was focused on the concept that the huge shift towards a capitalist society was the root cause and driving force behind the formation of social divisions and subsequent increase in crime and conflict. Willem Bonger expanded on the Marxist theory by explaining that the capitalist shifts lead the law to focus on the proletariat divisions as the deviant members of society, they were believed to be the one to commit a crime, rather than be a victim of crime due to the social class they placed in. The bourgeoisie on the other hand; the powerful and wealthy, were almost totally overlooked by the law, it’s almost as if they were immune to the effects of the law and its enforcement because of their societal status. The emphasis on the way the law treated, or rather didn’t treat the higher classes has led to the understanding that wealth is an enormous factor in terms of how vulnerable and individual is to the effects of the law and assumptions of individuals deviant behaviour based on their social class.
It has also been suggested by Frank Pearce that use of ‘elite-favouring’ in capitalist societies has resulted in the intensification of lower class criminality. The lower class have been subsequently ‘branded’ as the people who deviate from ideal behaviour and cause the crime in society. A capitalist society being led to believe such labels and characteristics of the proletariat and the bourgeoisie social divisions has developed the widespread assumption and understanding that criminals are assessed on where they stand in their social status and class rather than their actual behaviour and criminal actions.

Durkheim’s theory of functionalism suggests crime and deviance is the norm and provides its own functions that are vital to society. He believed that the presence of deviance in society allows moral borders and boundaries to be structured around social assumptions of deviant behaviours and what’s considered right and wrong. The subsequent responses to these types of behaviours promote social unity and encourage social change.
David Downes and Paul Rock proposed that crime should be viewed and a necessary factor that is a ‘healthy social phenomenon’ in societies. This shows that Durkheim sparked the recognition that crime should be viewed as a ‘healthy’ normality at sensible levels, rather than is being viewed as a solely negative factor that brings society down. Crime and deviance is supposedly is key to regularity in society, it provides a huge amount of public understanding and social acceptance to...

Find Another Essay On Marx and Durkheim’s Views Contributed to our Understanding of Crime and Deviance?

Outline and assess the importance of victim surveys for sociological understanding of crime and deviance

604 words - 2 pages abuse, sexual harassment and disputes between neighbours.Victim surveys are of continual importance to sociological research as the help to uncover the 'dark figure,' that is the vast number of unreported andunrecorded crimes. Such surveys give an understanding of the nature and extent of crime in the contemporary UK.

How has the discovery of Iceman contributed to our understanding of Neolithic Italy/Austria?

2225 words - 9 pages the transitional age when stone tools began to give way to metal and when agriculture was supplanting hunting and gathering. The body, his equipment and clothing have all contributed to the knowledge and understanding of the Iceman and the period of time from where he came.The body looks like a skeleton wrapped tightly in hairless skin. It gleams with a glaze of ice that is left undefrosted to protect it. Its mouth is frozen in an expression that

Marx and Durkheim’s View on the Benefits and Dangers of Modern Capitalism

2203 words - 9 pages exploitation for their means of survival, as a result of lacking in the ownership of capital and money. Discussion of Durkheim’s View on the Benefits and Dangers of Modern Capitalism Marx views the division of labour as a tragedy as it leads to class distinctions and alienation. On the other hand, Durkheim views the division of labour as nothing to worry about, as people need a role in society and must be specialized, as long as it is necessary, and

Crime and Deviance

1491 words - 6 pages This paper explains the different sociological perspectives of deviance and in the essay I had compare each perspective to the movies that we watched in class dealing with crime.The movies that were mentioned in this essay were-"Menace II Society""News from a Personal War" documentary"The Secret History of Street Gangs" documentary"Good Fellas"and "City of God".There were also some references on the book "1984" by George Orwell.There are many

Assess Marxist Theories of Crime and Deviance

626 words - 3 pages , as they make healthy workers to earn them profit. Neo-marxism or critical criminology is a newer philosophy, having arisen from marxist theories and social action theories. A Fully Social Theory of Deviance was a book written by criminologists Taylor, Walton and Young that combines traditional marxism with Neo-marxism. Karl Marx claims that crime is inevitable in capitalists society, as capitalism is a criminogenic system. In a capitalist

How Canada has contributed to the understanding of health and disease

1004 words - 5 pages I believe that Canada has contributed a lot to the understanding of health and disease over the years. A few examples I have been able to come up with would be the discovery of Insulin by Frederick Banting and Charles Best in 1921, and Dr. Penfield’s discovery on treating epilepsy using a method called the Montreal Procedure in 1934. George Klein invented the electric wheelchair in 1952, and in. Doctors

The usefulness of functionalist theories to explain crime and deviance - sociology - essay

1327 words - 6 pages Evaluate the usefulness of Functionalist theories to our understanding of crime and deviance (40 marks) A functionalist analysis of crime and deviance begins with society as a whole. It looks for the source of deviance in the nature of society rather than in the individual. Durkheim argued that crime is an inevitable and normal aspect of social life. Crime is present in all types of society; indeed, the crime rate is higher in the more advanced

Sociology:Outline and assess Structuralist theories of crime and deviance

589 words - 2 pages All Structuralist theories of crime and deviance seem to suggest that crime is socially constructed rather than focused on the individual.Albert Cohen, combining Structuralist and sub cultural theories drew on Merton's idea of strain but criticized Merton's ideas of crime being an individual response and believed that he ignored non-utilitarian crimes such as vandalism and joy-riding. Cohen was particularly interested in deviance which was not

Money is the Root of All Evil- Monetary Issues Leads to Crime and Deviance

1003 words - 4 pages to each of their members, was $24,000.” These people seem to be satisfied with their income. Then you come to those that make less than this or those people who make much more. The individuals who make less always want more, as a result, in some cases their behavior leads to crime. If these people had more they could buy something a little nicer than they already have. Now those who have more money than the average person always seem to want

As an IB student, how has your learning of literature and science contributed to your understanding of individuals and societies?

908 words - 4 pages Shriniel tankaria Tankaria 1Shubhda missTOK6th January 2014As an IB student, how has your learning of literature and science contributed to your understanding of individuals and societies?IB is completely a new experience for me. It has helped me to develop many qualities and has completely changed my personality and my way of thinking towards things. My experience in IB is amazing because it has helped me to know myself much better than what I

Compare and contrast the views of Durkhiem and Karl Marx

1240 words - 5 pages " the main ideaswill be discussed and Durkheim's perspectives will be discussed.Secondly, Marx views about religion will be discussed, looking at his main views and ideasabout religion, science will also be discussed relating to Durkheim's perspectives.Thirdly, The views of Durkheim and Marx will be compared and contrasted.And Finally, This essay will argue which theorists perspectives do I think are most relevantto contemporary times and why I

Similar Essays

Cultural Criminology: A New Perspective To Understanding Crime And Deviance

2602 words - 10 pages Cultural criminology is a relatively new perspective and approach to understanding crime and deviance. Cultural criminology first began to develop in the 1990s and rapidly progressed in to a new field of criminology that is both influential and informative. The core concept of cultural criminology is built upon by using traditional approaches from different disciplines such as sociological studies, cultural studies, symbolic interactionism and

Labelling Theories' Contribution To The Sociological Understanding Of Crime And Deviance

1575 words - 6 pages Labelling Theories' Contribution to the Sociological Understanding of Crime and Deviance Becker is the main sociologist studying labelling theory on deviance, he argues that 'social groups create deviance by making the rules whose infraction constitutes deviance.' Meaning acts only become deviant when observers perceive it and define it as deviant. An example of this would be the act of nudity, it is accepted in the

Outline Any Two Theoretical Approaches To Identity And Explain How Each Has Contributed To Our Understanding Of This Concept

1120 words - 4 pages From the Psychosocial and Social Identity Theory (SIT) perspectives there different approaches to what makes identity uniquely individual to humans and different from other animals. Each has contributed to our understanding of identity in different ways. Using observational and research methods psychological theorists' show that humans do not have a fixed identity but that identity is complex and diverse, changing throughout a person's life

Why/How Is ‘Power’ Central To Our Understanding Of Deviance?’

410 words - 2 pages ethnic minority is more likely to be defined as criminal (Wolfgramm, 2000).That power is central to our understanding of deviance can be witnessed in society everyday. The recent issue concerning AFL team president Joseph Gutnick threatening to resign should a Jewish player play on a Sunday "“ going against Orthodox Jew Gutnick's beliefs "“ is an example of the way power can shape what is considered deviant behaviour. Had an Orthodox Jew of lesser status complained it is unlikely that this small occurrence would have escalated into what is now a public issue.