Marx And The Two Enlightenments Essay

3119 words - 12 pages

Marx and the Two Enlightenments

ABSTRACT: The claim to rationality is disputed by two rival enlightenments, which collided in the dispute between Plato, Socrates and the Sophists, and which Marx united critically. He criticizes the capitalist system immanently as restrictive of production, and its market as not a case of freedom or equality (justice). However, Marx is most concerned with ontological injustice, coerced alienation of the human into being a commodity. He retains Promethean Enlightenment values however: technology, creativity, democracy, which should be economic, participatory and international. Marx criticized Hegel’s rationalization, idealization, ‘transfiguration and glorification’ of private property and the market. But he retains key elements of the idealist notion of human nature: that human is a ‘universal, therefore free being.’ The proletariat, with no other class to exploit, is therefore the philosophical ‘universal class.’ Freedom is class emancipation, justice is common ownership. There is an unwarranted skepticism about the rationality of such values and ideals. Rawls for instance misrepresents them by putting them in the same category as wants or preferences. Ideals, values, and enlightenments can and should be rationally argued over, in dialogue.

The Sophistic and the Platonic Enlightenments

The claim to rationality is disputed by two rival enlightenments. They collided in the dispute between Plato’s Socrates and the Sophists. On the one side was a secular, Promethean, in principle a-moral enlightenment in the technology of means to the ends of individual survival, pleasure and power, with an instrumental view of politics. On the other was a religiously oriented enlightenment about the dialectical ascent to moral and spiritual dimensions of reality. The first returned in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. In my opinion Hegel’s idealist response failed to criticise or transcend it; that task was completed by Marx.

Marx’s thought could be seen as a critical appropriation of both the modern secular enlightenment, concerned with economic ‘Man’, and the dialectical enlightenment concerned with the spiritual element in the human being traditionally seen as shared with the divine, ‘Mind’. Subsequent Marxism has almost invariably defined itself as the final development of ‘the (unique) Enlightenment’. But Marx’s acknowledged debt to Aristotle, for instance, is becoming ever clearer. Habermas has defined as ‘an irreversible achievement of modernity’ the separation of morality, politics and economics. But Marx attacked that position in ‘On the Jewish Question’ as the very essence of what was wrong with bourgeois society. He defended Aristotle’s principle, that the human being is a zoon politikon by nature. He held a non-hedonist, non-agonistic concept of human nature as did Plato in opposition to the Sophists’ reductionism. He invoked old and new ideals together in the phrase ‘the nobility of man’ shining...

Find Another Essay On Marx and the Two Enlightenments

Karl Marx and the Communist Manifesto and Animal Farm

1667 words - 7 pages to government over to totalianism. In the novel Animal Farm, by George Orwell the character of Old Major and his ideology represents Karl Marx and his ideas in Russian history.To begin, Old Major compares to Karl Marx in a countless number of ways. Exclusively, at the end of Old Major's speech, where he professed, "Whatever goes upon two legs is an enemy. Whatever goes upon four legs is a friend" (Orwell 31). In that quote Old Major puts blame on

Compare and contrast the views of Durkhiem and Karl Marx.

1240 words - 5 pages " the main ideaswill be discussed and Durkheim's perspectives will be discussed.Secondly, Marx views about religion will be discussed, looking at his main views and ideasabout religion, science will also be discussed relating to Durkheim's perspectives.Thirdly, The views of Durkheim and Marx will be compared and contrasted.And Finally, This essay will argue which theorists perspectives do I think are most relevantto contemporary times and why I

The Ideas of Karl Marx and The Communist Manifesto

2025 words - 8 pages The Ideas of Karl Marx and The Communist Manifesto It has been shown by many historians, scientists, and psychologists that people are affected by the world around them. This is exactly what caused Karl Marx to write his Communist Manifesto. The living conditions of the working class-his proletariat, as well as that of the bourgeoisie (the upper class) must have had a profound effect on his views and ideals. In France the

The Communist Manifesto by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels

1012 words - 4 pages The Communist Manifesto by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels The Communist Manifesto, written by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, outlines how a society should be run under communism. The document provides truths to what is wrong with society; what causes these wrongs; how they can be fixed; and how this relates to humans and nature. Marx was a political philosopher of German ancestry. Marx and Engels split the document up into four sections

A summary of the idealogies and thoughts of Karl Marx

1984 words - 8 pages these shoes are impoverished children in Thailand, which have been exploited by savvy businessmen (Reiss, 94).During his lifetime, Marx also influenced the political structure of many European nations. In 1848, revolutions were starting in many European countries, in large part due to Marx and his The Communist Manifesto. To condense, Marx's main point was that in all historical epochs, society is generated from two constantly struggling groups

The Communist Manifesto by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels

1061 words - 4 pages The Communist Manifesto by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels      The Communist Manifesto was written by two world renowned philosophers, Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels. This book was produced in an era of great suffering and anguish of all workers in a socially distressed system. In a time when revolutions were spreading through Europe like wildfire, Marx organized his thoughts and views to produce the critical pamphlet “The Communist

The Comparison of Karl Marx and Matthew Arnold

640 words - 3 pages Through their writing, Karl Marx and Matthew Arnold show their opposing views on the importance of internal and external functions of culture. In the first chapter of Culture and Anarchy, 'Sweetness and Light', Arnold describes culture as being responsible for the progress of politics and society and as 'the best knowledge and thought of the time' (19). Matthew Arnold's culture is based on two main aspects, religion and education. Karl Marx

Why do Mazzini and Marx Support the idea of revolution?

757 words - 3 pages Why do Mazzini and Marx Support the idea of revolution?Mazzini and Marx support the idea of revolution because when a society is no longer deemed fit by the people it should be subject to reform. Mazzini supports revolution because he feels the people which make up the majority of society have a right to reform their social and political systems. Marx's ideals are very similar to Mazzini's however Marx's idea is that revolution should be

Marx, Keynes, Hayek and Friedman: The Power of Ideas

1877 words - 8 pages Economics, commerce, money theory, production, business cycles, government intervention, credit/debit and many other things were paved with a heavy foundation involving these four economists. Each had their very own opinions in light to each other, which only gave way to new findings about our economies in whole. Along with ideas came great contributions to nations as well. Karl Marx was sort of the founder of modern communism, by merging

Early and Later Writings of Karl Marx. Compares the classical works of Karl Marx and looks at some of his most well known theories. Includes works cited.

2110 words - 8 pages influence on these ideas. Marx felt that the conflict between social groups would create new stages of social development. By Marx's estimation there were two main social groups, the Bourgeoisie (or Capitalists) and the Proletariats (or workers). The Capitalists owned the means of production, and they were constantly exploiting the workers in that system. He envisioned the workers rising up to become a class for themselves and reform the current

Karl Marx - The Victory of the Proletariat and the Fall of the Bourgeoisie

913 words - 4 pages Karl Marx - The Victory of the Proletariat and the Fall of the Bourgeoisie In the Communist Manifesto, Karl Marx writes of the proletariat working class on the verge of revolution due to the overwhelming oppression perpetrated by the bourgeoisie. Marx lays out a sequence of steps, which demonstrate the coming of the revolution, a revolution caused consequentially by the actions of the bourgeoisie. As the bourgeoisie constantly form new

Similar Essays

Compare The Conception Of Freedom By Any Two Of The Following: Rousseau, Marx And Mills.

2760 words - 11 pages Compare the conception of freedom by any two of the following: Rousseau, Marx and Mills.Freedom in the most basic terms is a license to do what one wishes. Citizens can experiment with certain behaviour both good and bad, without becoming criminals. The idea of freedom has been one that has many interpretations to it. People view it in different ways. Therefore, the freedom in one state will be different to another. For example in states like

Karl Marx And The Communist Manifesto

1026 words - 4 pages , Preface to the German Edition of 1872, in Manifesto of the Communist Party, (New York: Pathfinder, 1987), 13. [iii] Paul Dorn, Two Months of Red Splendor: The Paris Commune and Marx’ Theory of Revolution, <http://userwww.sfsu.edu/~pdorn/Marx.html> (21 March 2002) [iv] Dorn [v] Dorn [vi] Paul Lewis, For Many, Marx’s Manifesto Remains Relevant, The New York Times (Sept. 21, 1997). [vii] Lewis [viii] Jessop [ix] Philip J. Kain, Marx and Modern Political Theory, (Maryland: Rowman and Littlefield Publishers, Inc., 1993), 360. [x] Kain, 360

Karl Marx And The Authorship Of Communism

3229 words - 13 pages It has been said that Karl Marx wrote his theories concerning socialism from a liberal starting point. This essay will discuss this possibility, in relation to socialism and if Marx's theories would in fact, create a conflict free world. There are two main areas within this question: firstly, the differences and similarities between socialism and liberalism, and how it is possible to write one from the starting point of the other, and secondly

Marx (The Communist Manifesto) And Rousseau

2152 words - 9 pages The political philosophy of Jean-Jacques Rousseau and Karl Marx examined the role that the state played and its relationship to its citizen’s participation and access to the political economy during different struggles and tumultuous times. Rousseau was a believer of the concept of social contract with limits established by the good will and community participation of citizens while government receives its powers given to it. Karl Marx