This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Marxist Criticism Essay

1343 words - 5 pages

Marxist Criticism


Marxist literary criticism is based upon the political and economic theories of the German philosopher Karl Marx. In works like The German Ideology and The Communist Manifesto, written with Frederick Engels , Marx proposes a model of history in which economic and political conditions determine social conditions. Marx and Engels were responding to social hardships stemming from the rise of capitalism. Appropriately, their theories are formulated specifically to analyze how society functions in a state of upheaval and constant change.

A materialist view of history

Using Hegel's theory of dialectic , which suggests that history progresses through the resolution of contradictions within a particular aspect of reality, Marx and Engels posit a materialist account of history that focuses upon the struggles and tensions within society. As society forms more complex modes of production, it becomes increasingly stratified; and the resulting tensions necessitate changes in society. For example, the introduction of heavy machinery into the feudal economic system fragmented existing social structures and necessitated a move towards capitalism.

The base and superstructure model

Within Marx's dialectical account of history is the idea that a given individual's social being is determined by larger political and economic forces. Marx writes that "it is not the consciousness of men that determines their being, but, on the contrary, their social being that determines consciousness." Simply stated, the social class into which a person is born determines her outlook and viewpoints.

Marx then expands this concept of determination into one of the central concepts of Marxism--that of base and superstructure. The base is the economic system on which the superstructure rests; cultural activities--such as philosophy or literature--belong in the superstructure. To Marxist critics, a society's economic base determines the interests and styles of its literature; it is this relationship between determining base and determined superstructure that is the main point of interest for Marxist critics.


Marx believes that because the superstructure is determined by the base, it inevitably supports the ideologies of the base. Ideologies are the changing ideas, values, and feelings through which individuals experience their societies. They present the dominant ideas and values as the beliefs of society as a whole, thus preventing individuals from seeing how society actually functions. Literature, as a cultural production, is a form of ideology, one that legitimizes the power of the ruling class. In the eighteenth century, for example, literature was used by the English upper classes both to express and transmit the dominant value systems to the lower classes.

Georg Lukacs and the Social Realists

There is a great deal of difference in opinion among Marxist literary critics concerning the relationship...

Find Another Essay On Marxist Criticism

A Tale Of Three Classes. A Marxist Criticism on 'The Importance of Being Earnest' by Oscar Wilde

1396 words - 6 pages little power only respect, but in the Victorian period the power was starting to diminish but it still existed. The characters in the play who were of noble birth did indeed know how to use that power.Well when one makes a Marxist criticism it can't be solely based on the story's view of the servants, but however one needs to also look at the way the nobility are viewed. In Oscar Wilde's play he seems to make almost a mockery of the nobility

The Wrapped Golf Ball: A Marxist Literary Criticism

1256 words - 5 pages The philosopher Karl Marx once said, “It is not the consciousness of men that determines their being, but, on the contrary, their social being that determines their consciousness” (Marx). Marx argues that social circumstances determine one’s value and belief. Therefore, in his short story “Winter Dreams”, F. Scott Fitzgerald supports this Marxist theory by exposing that the proletariat is oppressed by the bourgeoisie’s ideology that the goal of

The Importance of Distinction in Literary Theory and Criticism

1385 words - 6 pages Szeman). The boundaries between the two, criticism and theory, blur according to Groden et al, however the boundary between their approaches is much more distinguishable. New Criticism and Marxist theory are examples of two different approaches to literary criticism. Both approaches share the same objective, in that they look to better understand literature, but their paths diverge on how exactly they go about this. It is the disparity between the

The Marxist Interpretation of A Doll’s House by Henrik Ibsen

635 words - 3 pages “A principal tenet of Marxist criticism is that human consciousness is a product of social conditions and that human relationships are often subverted by and through economic considerations.”(Witham and Lutterbie) A Doll’s House, by Henrik Ibsen, can be interpreted and critiqued in many different ways. One of these ways is the Marxist approach. This way of thinking can basically be summed up by saying this: Money changes people’s thinking and

A Marxist Critical Approach to Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby

1726 words - 7 pages phenomena has indeed led to the characters downfall and alienation. The true evidence of isolation within the novel is apparent through the death of Gatsby. Throughout the novel, and despite Gatsby’s frequent hedonistic parties, Nick states in regards to his funeral that still, “nobody came”. The Marxist criticism within the anthology suggests that through the negligible treatment of commodification, we “become alienated from ourselves” and that is

How relevant is the Marxist critique of capitalism to the analysis of the modern international system?

2463 words - 10 pages this reason, it has been shaping, and continues to shape, societies on a global scale. Although it can be said that capitalism has prospered throughout the centuries and has turned into a strong economic practice, it hasn’t been exempt of criticism. Marxist school of thought sets forth the most challenging critiques capitalism has encountered. Marxist doctrine emerged in the 19th century with Karl Marx, along with Friedrich Engels (Encyclopædia

Marxist Ideology

1282 words - 5 pages tailored toward a total extrinsic analysis. Terry Eagleton, a Marxist critic, says the task of Marxist literary criticism "is to show the text as it cannot know itself, to manifest those conditions of its making (inscribed in its very letter) about which it is necessarily silent" (Marxist Literary Criticism: A Brief Guide). Ideology, as used in the “Marxist Literary Criticism: A Brief Guide” describes ideology as “the shared beliefs and values

Examine Functionalist and Marxist explanations of the family

662 words - 3 pages up as sociology. It is also clearly biased towards the supposedly 'typical' USA m/c family. Another criticism of the functionalist view is that assumptions are made about industrial society.The Marxist view rejects the functionalist view that society is based on value consensus and thus operates for the benefit of all. Instead the family is seen as part of the superstructure of society and it is just one of a number of institutions which serves

A Critical Look at Marxism in Literature

1131 words - 5 pages of the text. (240)Another problem with Marxism, in general, is that it was not originally a literary theory, but a sociological and philosophical explanation of society and direction for social movement. "Marxist literary theory and criticism is a twentieth-century phenomenon" (Bressler 211). Marx let little be known of the relationship between his ideas and literature. He spoke infrequently of language, "Language is as old as consciousness

Marxist Media Theory

4310 words - 17 pages Marxist Media TheoryDaniel Chandler"XIntroduction"XBase and superstructure"XMedia as means of production"XIdeology"XMedia as amplifiers"XThe constitution of the subject"XDifferences within Marxism"XThe Frankfurt School"XAlthusser"XGramsci and hegemony"XStuart Hall"XLimitations of Marxist analysis"XStrengths of Marxist analysis"XReferencesIntroductionIn Britain and Europe, neo-Marxist approaches were common amongst media theorists from the late

WPA in Guyana

922 words - 4 pages time, with its critical role in the non-aligned movement, its anti-apartheid stand, and increasing ties with socialist countries benefited from the that most of the allies of the opposition Marxist-Leninist PPP welcomed Guyana’s support as a state. While the PPP was caught in this quagmire the WPA managed to avoid some of the pitfalls of this conundrum that pitted democracy against socialism. It achieved this by its concentration on local

Similar Essays

Marxist Literary Theory And Criticism Essay

1718 words - 7 pages highly and appreciated 19th century literature except for Dostoyevsky and Goncharov. Ironically, as we will see later, those writers lead people by their great masterpieces to believe in Communism and their cause. (Cuddon 493)A prominent figure in Marxist literary criticism history is Georg Lukacs. He is the first major Marxist critic. He believes that literature is not supposed to alienate an already alienated audience, i.e. alienated by

To What Extent Is Marxist Criticism Helpful In Opening Up Potential Meanings In Catch 22?

1970 words - 8 pages the ideas came to me from the civilian situation in this country in the 1950s”. Marxist literary criticism claims writers are formed by their social contexts. Indeed, Heller’s social and political climate formed Catch 22, which Heller criticizes the complacent attitude towards profiteering at the expense of the individual. This is achieved through the voices of key characters, such as Yossarian, who dare to question the moral complacency of

Marxist Criticism Is Always Concerned With The Class Struggle In History

1496 words - 6 pages was no secret Orwell considered Russia, and consequently Communism, a counter-revolutionary force that would inevitably become corrupted by greed and power. Indeed, perhaps in order to go further in offering a Marxist reading of the text, it is necessary to pass judgement on the author and the epoch in which the book was written. In doing so, I hope to show just how progressive (or anti-progressive) the book is. From almost the very

Marxist Criticism In Black Boy Essay

870 words - 3 pages Faced with the segregation of white and blacks; rich and poor, communist and anti communists, the intellectuals and illiterate, the “haves” and the “have nots”, Richard Wright, a black boy from down south struggles to prove himself to not only his family and the rest of the world, but himself. Richard struggles with a black culture that tries to reshape him according to what it believes he should be which is less bookish, more obedient, and more