Marxist Locke Essay

2524 words - 10 pages

Marxist Locke

Karl Marx and John Locke both place a great deal of importance in both labour and property in discussing their political philosophies. At first glance, the two thinkers seem to possess completely different ideas on property, its importance, and the form of society which should grow from it. The disparity in their beliefs is evident, but they share a similar approach to labour and acceptable conditions while constructing philosophies which inherently attack each other. Locke’s suggestion that capitalism is a natural political progression can only be accomplished when the worker himself becomes a commodity to be traded, a transformation which Marx identifies as a major problem with capitalism. In looking at capitalism through a Marxist lens, we can see that Locke may find substantial problems with it.

At the outset of Locke’s fifth chapter in the Second Treatise of Government, he sets the stage for property acquisition. “God, who hath given the world to men in common, hath also given them reason to make use of it to the best advantage of life, and convenience” (Locke 18). Locke implies that God’s creation of the world ultimately serves men, for their property will come of it, and with it, the best advantages of life. As the fruits of the world ripen, men find themselves picking it off the trees and placing it under their command as part of their property. One cannot underestimate the importance of property for Locke. It is the single most important aspect of human relation. Disputes over property directly proceed to Locke’s state of war, an important term which I will return to later. In Locke’s mind, property plays a key role in the creation of civil society. “The only way whereby any one divests himself of his natural liberty, and puts on the bonds of civil society is by agreeing with other men to join and unite into a community for their comfortable, safe, and peaceable living one amongst another, in a secure enjoyment of their properties…” (Locke 52). I would say that while Locke discusses the necessity for the state to protect life, liberty, and the pursuit of property, the necessity for the state follows directly from property acquisition. According to Locke, the need for protection is spurred by the idea of property. The protection of one’s health and one’s freedoms directly relate to the property in his possession and the threat that other people may show him in desire for that property.
Labour itself also plays a large part in Locke’s analysis of property and thus, the analysis of the state. What constitutes property for Locke? “Whatsoever then he removes out of the state that nature hath provided, and left it in, he hath mixed his labour with, and joined to it something that is his own, and thereby makes it his property” (Locke 19). Locke places a great deal of emphasis on the importance of labour, and the fact that its addition to goods constitutes property. He goes so far as to say that in analyzing “what in...

Find Another Essay On Marxist Locke

Property Law assignment - Essay

1282 words - 6 pages does not suffice in a justification for the ownership of property. [3: Karl Widerquist, ‘Lockean Theories of Property: Justifications for Unilateral Appropriation’ (2010) 2 Georgetown University – Qatar, 3; John Locke, On Property’ Second Treatise of Government (1690), Chapter 5 ‘Of Property’.] [4: Ibid.] [5: Ibid.] [6: Nicholson 1998,153.] [7: Norman Fischer and Asher Milbauer, Marxist Ethics within Western Political Theory: A dialogue

The Justice of Private Property: Analysis of Locke, Smith and Marx

2044 words - 8 pages bodies. This ownership of our bodies includes our actions/works. This is similar with Marxist thought regarding the interrelationship between man, labor, and products we create. 1)"Whatsoever then he removes out of the state of nature… he hath mixed his labour with, and joined it with something that is his own, and thereby makes it his property." Assuming we do truly own our work/efforts, Locke believed that when we applied our work (ourselves) to

Holsti’s Conceptual Interpretations of International Systems

1533 words - 6 pages When exploring the relationships between nations, a number of conceptual models exist. Each model purports to explain and predict the interactions between international actors. Three of these schools of thought were initially enumerated in The Dividing Discipline: Hegemony and Diversity in International Theory. (K. J. Holsti, 1985) These schools were the “Classical Paradigm”, “Theory of Global Society”, and the “Neo-Marxist” conceptual models

1750-1900 Questions

849 words - 4 pages I. The Enlightenment features ideas of secularism, limited government and more sovereign power to the people or individual provinces. These ideas would impact the American Revolution, the Framers of the Constitution specifically were impacted by these ideas, many of whom were devout Christians who read John Locke and studied science and secular philosophy. The Framers would ask for independence because King George III was acting like a tyrant

The Syrian Civil War

1692 words - 7 pages that help the population of Syria as a whole and the country as a democracy as well, but were met with armed subjugation in return. The roots of liberalism thrive on principles of putting the people and their preferences before those of the government. John Locke (1632-1704) in his Second treatise on government focuses on a kind of government that concentrates on the well being and kindness of its people (Locke). He explains how for a

Is liberalism merely the ideological justification for capitalism - Humanities - Essay

1040 words - 5 pages Is liberalism merely the ideological justification for capitalism? In this essay I intend to outline the argument by which affirms liberalism to be an ideological justification for capitalism. Evident to this, it is clear that liberalism interconnects with the economic infrastructure of capitalism through the means of private ownership of property and largely the free market. Many key intellectuals such as, Locke and John Stuart Mill shed

North Korea and Chinese Relations: Impact of Lockeian Elements on US Foreign Policy

3244 words - 13 pages Impact of Lockeian Elements on US Foreign Policy; North Korean and Chinese Relations Due to Marxist-Leninist Policies and a Look at Korean Culture Resulting From Extreme Ideologies The realist worldview of North Korea characterizes North Korea as a coalesced form of belligerence that must be dealt with through American containment and deterrence. Because of the rising fear produced by North Korea’s growing nuclear power and radical

Superman; the mythic representation of cultural reality shifts in truth, justice and the American way

2196 words - 9 pages human freedom, dreams in a Freudian nature, and the complex relation of fantasy and reality which required introduction before in-depth research. Superman's representation of cultural ideology is that of 'the ideas of the ruling class are in every epoch the ruling ideas', the Marxist interpretation of material production and mental production (Karl Marx, 1932, pp. 7-8). Superman as title implies that he is "better" than just man; thus providing

A Comparison of the American and Russian Revolutions

1079 words - 4 pages war. Lenin emerged as the leader of the Bolsheviks, and in 1917 he went to Russia calling for "peace, land and bread." Lenin was a Marxist and wanted to train the working class to become a revolutionary force. On November 7, 1917, the Bolsheviks overthrew the provisional government in what is called the October Revolution. In 1918, the Bolsheviks renamed themselves the Communist Party. After the war with the Whites, the Communists renamed the

Subjugated Black People of Harlem and their advancement with Langston Hughes - Brac School - Assignment

2802 words - 12 pages them and white people. Numerous newspaper journalists, columnists attempt to focus a revolutionary tone against the racial imbalance which propels the American to formally stop racialism. [7: Spanning the 1920s to the mid-1930s, the Harlem Renaissance was a literary, artistic, and intellectual movement that kindled a new black cultural identity. Its essence was summed up by critic and teacher Alain Locke in 1926 when he declared that through art

Understanding the Notions of Communication and Culture

2578 words - 10 pages posits is not influenced by the media it consumes but rather the media is a direct portrayal of the cultural values a society endows. Unlike the liberal-democratic approach of viewing media as the representative institution impersonating reality, the Althusserian approach disprove by arguing that media as one of the Ideological State Apparatus (ISA) influencing human consciousness. Although the Althusserian approach is a structuralist Marxist

Similar Essays

Philosophers: Niccolo Machiavelli, John Locke And Karl Marx

1017 words - 5 pages while Marx focuses on economic sovereignty during the exploitation of workers during the Industrial Revolution. The differences in the principles of these men are transparent. Locke’s ideas heavily oppose Machiavellian rule because it hinders political sovereignty and progress that Locke ought to achieve in a representative democracy. Meanwhile, Marxist theory controverts the propositions of Locke’s ideal government as it promotes the exploitation

Politics Essay

1328 words - 5 pages “the kicking in of the rotten door” (John Kenneth Galbraith Quotes, n.d.). Locke on the Dissolution of the Government John Locke, one of the most reputable political scientists whose works are often cited for major ideas such as division of power into three branches and natural rights, did not object to the disbandment of the government that mistreats its people. In Locke’s view, this dissolution is usually “brought

Compare And Contrast The Philosophies Of John Locke, Thomas Hobbes, And Karl Marx

772 words - 3 pages influential feature of any Marxist theory. According to Locke, the natural reason allows us to establish civilized relations without force. The 'Rule of Reason' law has to govern the conduct of the ruler as well as the subjects. Taking the quantitative aspects of Marx's theory and mixing it with the qualitative characteristics of Locke's theory will yield in the maximum benefit for the civil society.Even with the same goal of improvement in

Initiative And Ideologies: Liberalism And Social Democracy As Applied To Modern Legislation

1259 words - 5 pages banning bonuses and mandating shareholder consent in major decisions. A recent proposition also suggested implementing an initiative that “would permit companies to award their best-paid worker no more than 12 times what the worst paid.” (Stamm) This measure invokes sentiments similar to those invoked by historic ideologies. The societal problems that Locke and Bernstein attempted to address with Liberalism and Social Democracy respectively manifest