Mary Montagu's Rebuttal Of Jonathan Switf's Misogynistic Poetry

1629 words - 7 pages

Women Always Get the Last Word:
Mary Montagu’s Rebuttal of Jonathan Swift’s Misogynistic Poetry

Unsatisfied with conventional romantic poetry that overly idolized women, renowned satirist Jonathan Swift exaggerates the vanity of women in his poem “The Lady’s Dressing Room.” Swift consequently insults all women by portraying the female character of his poem as a vain and superficial figure who attempts to hide her more crude activities (such as defecating). Offended by the misogynistic tone of Swift’s poem, Lady Mary Montegu responds with her own poem “The Reasons that Induced Dr. Swift to Write a Poem Called the Lady’s Dressing Room,” which attacks Swift personally; she alleges that Swift’s attempt to embarrass Celia by exposing her messy room stems from his own embarrassment about failing to perform sexually during an engagement with a prostitute. Montegu’s structure parodies Swift’s, and she strategically inverts his form in places to reveal the sexist undertone of Swift’s poem. She thereby discredits his misconstrued perception of women. Through an analysis of these two poets contrasting portrayals of women, one can draw conclusions about the implications of gender in 18th century culture: women were not complacent in their constricted role in society, but instead were acutely aware of the power they possessed.
The most fundamental difference between the two poems is the target of their criticism; while Swift criticizes the false personas of women in general, Montagu specifically criticizes Swift (and his friend Pope) on a personal level. From the first line of his poem, “Five hours, (and who can do it less in?) by haughty Celia spent in Dressing,” Swift makes it clear that his criticism of Celia is directed towards women in general (Swift 1). This jab at women stems from the stereotype that women take copious amounts of time to dress themselves, making a humorous appeal to men looking for a justification to elevate themselves above women. Conversely, rather than making generalizations about men as a gender, Montagu focuses on one man in particular: Swift himself. For example, Montegu jests that neither Swift’s “bawdy, politics nor satire could move this dull hard-hearted creature,” implying that neither Swift’s clever strategies nor his crude humor can help him achieve his rhetorical goals (Montegu 12). This quotation also chides Swift for thinking that women are too dull to understand his work. Although some may see this as Montegu failing to make legitimate, logical points to defend the claims made against women in Swift’s poem, her complete dismissal of Swift’s demeaning exaggerations about the female body makes Swift’s argument less effective. In her counter-argumentative poem, Montegu refuses to directly address the claims made in Swift’s poem about feminine hygiene until the very end of her poem, and, in so doing avoids adopting an overly defensive tone that might discredit her argument. Lastly, the fact that Montagu’s poem...

Find Another Essay On Mary Montagu's Rebuttal of Jonathan Switf's Misogynistic Poetry

The Difference Roles Among Male And Female Poets

1768 words - 7 pages than men, who were able o have their own stable careers. In addition, men from upper class families such as Sidney and Herbert were educated in Latin and Greek. However, there was a certain amount of poetry written by women. Poets such as, Mary Sidney, who edited her late brother Philip’s work, and also translated poetry from Latin into English. The other female poet is Aemilia Lanyer was under the guidance of the countess of Cumberland

John Milton's Representation of Early Modern Literature: Misogynistic?

2660 words - 11 pages studying and researching not only the work of Milton, but of his contemporaries including Aphra Behn, Mary Wroth, Aemilia Lanyer and Edmund Spenser. John Milton was a highly educated man, a political campaigner and a deeply revered thinker. His poetry and prose have been critiqued and studied by most, if not all those who show interest in the canon of literature. He was a libertine and revolutionary, who embarked on works of epic proportion and

Quamaine Coleman Mary Shelley Rough Draft

622 words - 3 pages Thesis: Although Mary Shelley had a tragic childhood, she was able to overcome her personal tradies in order to become a well-known writer and poet. Introduction: Mary Shelley was a well-known poetry. She began to write at the age of sixteen when she married her first husband Percy Shelley. Mary Shelley had a tragic childhood growing up losing the only mother figure that she knew of name, Lousia the nanny. This convinced Mary to start writing

Techniques Used in the Writing of Metaphysical Poetry

614 words - 2 pages understand. It can give the reader a sense of comparison to their own lives if they are able to relate to what is going on in the story they are reading. With sex, reality, and intellect and metaphors may come a better understanding of the poem or story. Metaphysical poetry helped to pave the way for brilliant satirical poetry from such authors as, Jonathan Swift and John Gay.

10 Dimensions for Dracula by Bram Stoker The aesthetic and psychological views on Dracula

1029 words - 4 pages climbing down the steep walls of his castle in a strange bat-like manner. We also learn of the many strange things that Jonathan records, like absence of mirrors or the presence of blood in many places. So Jonathan basically observes a few of the main habits and actions of a vampire.After this the novel introduces Mary (Jonathan?s wife) and Lucy Westenra (Mina?s close friend). We follow what happens as Mina and Lucy exchange many letters of great

Apology for Poetry

1885 words - 8 pages An “Apology for Poetry” is a compelling essay refuting the attack on poetry by Puritan and fundamentalist Stephen Gosson. This complex article written by Sir Phillip Sidney represents the decisive rebuttal defending poetry. His strong emotive passages defend the uncongenial comments of poetry from Gosson. Although, his justification for the rebuttal is alluded to Gosson’s durable attacks on poetry; it is known Gosson’s remarks prompt Sidney’s

The Implications of Calvinism

1255 words - 5 pages to be lived in the difficult knowledge of a goal beyond unites the poetic and religious quest” (98). On the other hand, author Judit Konyi argues in her essay “The Pseudo-Silence of Emily Dickinson” that Dickinson’s religious language referenced her calling as a poet and Dickinson considered herself a messenger of God (96). Could these ideas be the key to unlock the inscrutability of Dickinson’s poetry? Although I agree with both of these

Misogyny in the Poem "Ode on the Death of a Favourite Cat, Drowned in a Tub of Gold Fishes" by Thomas Gray

1718 words - 7 pages Female writing during the 18th century became a popular method of expressing feminine mentality on issues that were previously considered forbidden. Writers such as Aphra Behn, Mary Leapor and Lady Mary Wortley Montagu published their works alongside many respected male poets such as Jonathan Swift and Thomas Gray. Women were gaining a sense of independence and emancipation from the traditional patriarchal rule, and this was occurring at an

Literature Representations of Women

651 words - 3 pages ; in sorrow thou shalt bring forth children; and thy desire shall be to thy husband, and he shall rule over thee." (Genesis, 59) Thus, the first misogynistic act came to pass.The tradition that began in Genesis continued for many years. In 431 BCE, Euripides wrote what is arguably the most misogynistic text of all time, Medea. In the play Medea, of Colchis meets and falls in love with Jason a Corinthian man. When her family disapproves of their

Hardship in Ireland in A Modest Proposal by Jonathan Swift

1071 words - 5 pages In Jonathan Swift’s “A Modest Proposal” written in 1729, he writes of the hardships faced by the lower class and proposes a solution to help it out. Living in Ireland, Swift witnessed many hardships suffered among the poor, such as stealing and begging. However, not too far away, the British royalty was living a lavish lifestyle, and by doing so, it was sucking the life out of the poor. Jonathan Swift saw this enormous unbalance of wealth and

The Contributions of Mary Shelley, George Eliot and Emily Bronte

2613 words - 10 pages Justice. Mary Wollstonecraft died from complications a short time after Mary's birth. With such familial influence, Mary grew up encouraged to study and pursue intellectual exertions, and quickly developed a wide variety of knowledge in education, history, literature, mythology, poetry, politics and science.In 1814, when Mary was just 17, her infamous reputation greatly increased when she ran away with Percy Bysshe Shelley. Shelley was already married

Similar Essays

The Realm Of Sisterhood In Mary Leapor’s Poetry

3097 words - 12 pages The Realm of Sisterhood in Mary Leapor’s Poetry For a woman writer to be read by her peers in eighteenth century England was somewhat unusual. For this woman to procure some kind of living from her writing was even more remarkable. But for such a woman to claim both these accomplishments, with writings attacking the very state of women no less, was extraordinary. Yet Mary Leapor was this woman. Not only did she herself defy

How Is The Concept Of Belonging Represented In Peter Skrzynecki's Poetry? Feliks Skrzynecki, 10 Mary Street And St Patrick's College

1877 words - 8 pages Belonging to one's self is essential in order to belong to humanity. It is a sense that can only be achieved through embracing one's own identity, despite popular believe that we must change ourselves and adopt the traits of mainstream society in order to belong. As illustrated in Peter Skrzynecki's Immigrant Chronicle poetry, having a strong sense of self-knowledge & understanding - and a deep connection to one's own culture, beliefs and

Representations Of Female Sexual Desire And Faithfulness

990 words - 4 pages William Wycherly's The Country Wife and Lady Mary Wortley Montagu's “Epistle from Mrs. Yonge to Her Husband” both open a discourse on female sexual desire and fidelity, representing similar ideas. Both works consider the constraints of honour and societal expectations upon women, and the double standard for fidelity between husbands and wives. Ultimately the works present a final statement through consequences for women affected by the issues

A Comparison Of Persuasive Techniques In 'to His Coy Mistress' And 'an Answer To A Love Letter'

2224 words - 9 pages accepted as a Scholar of Trinity College and took his B.A. degree. Within a few days, his mother had died and after his father died also within 2 years, he left Cambridge. It was in this period, after he started travelling in Europe, that he wrote 'To His Coy Mistress'. Lady Mary Wortley Montagu was born in 1689, the eldest daughter of the Duke of Kingston. Her family were wealthy, but not concerned with Lady Mary's