Masculine Identity Essay

2383 words - 10 pages

Masculinity, similarly to other aspects of one’s identity, is being intensively discussed in contemporary society. It has undergone significant development in the last few decades which has been reflected in and accelerated by the media. This essay explores the reasons for this - it refers to historical development where appropriate and discusses the consequences of the fragmentation of male identitities.

The essay starts with a brief discussion of masculinity as a term. It will draw on theories and show how the understanding of the concept changed over time. It then moves to describing...
define terms masculinity, masculinities

If it has been believed that in the past, only one version of masculinity existed, it has theoretical background in the philosophical view of essentialism. Essentialist philosophers argued that every (material) thing has its own (abstract) essence. Essence represented the fixed, unchanging qualities of the object.

When this thinking is applied to the discussion about men, it helps us to understand where the ideas about a “natural” masculinity that is same for all men comes from. If “man” is the physical representation, “masculinity” is the essence that defines him. So for example, if “masculinity” is defined by the society as behaviour that is sexually and physically aggressive, dominant, confident and avoiding the show if emotions, men that do not conform to these qualities are arguably less manly.

John Beynon, Professor in the Cardiff School of Creative & Cultural Industries, argues that this still reflects in “commonsensical assumption that masculinity is a standardized container, fixed by biology, in which all “normal” men are placed, something natural that can be measured in terms of psychological traits and physical attributes” (Beynon 2002, p. 2).

From the late 20th century, this thinking has been increasingly criticised and finally identified as not valid. it was replaced by anti-essentialist ideas that argue that there is no essence to all men and that their identities as men are constructed during their lives and shaped by the society they live in via social interaction. This theory if social constructionism opened up new possibilities for exploring masculinity and its many variations. This was reflected in the shift from the term “masculinity” to the plural form “masculinities”.

Beynon also explores the topic further: “Masculinities is composed of many masculinities... Masculinity is alway interpolated by cultural, historical and geographical location and in our time... the conception of a uniform masculinity and even sexuality is no longer held to be fixed or innate” (Beynon 2002, p. 1).

Before we move on to describing the changes that happened in the society, it is important to outline the role of media in shaping one’s (masculine) identity. They shape how we think about masculinities on a number of levels.

Television, radio, print, advertising, online and other media influence the...

Find Another Essay On Masculine Identity

Fight Club Essay

1437 words - 6 pages , Palahniuk presents how men in modern society have lost their masculine identity and the extreme actions they go to in order to obtain it again. Belittled by their absent fathers, broken homes, and a feminine-centered society, the men in Fight Club present an incisive notion of the lives of modern men. With no outlet for expression the modern man is, in all aspects of his life, physically emasculated and emotionally castrated. Palahniuk

Emmett’s Experience in Vietnam in the Novel In Country

1259 words - 6 pages is the one who cooks for them; and finally, most obviously, Emmett cross-dresses. He associates the War with the masculine, evidenced in his comment that a cardboard tank at the dance looks like “an elephant’s peter.” According to Mark Graybill’s essay “Reconstructing/deconstructing genre and gender: postmodern identity in Bobbie Ann Mason’s In Country and Josephine Humphreys’s Rich in Love,” his search to find the masculine is represented by his

Research on The Relationship of the Male Identity from a Social Construct

1032 words - 5 pages crisis of insomnia which is a symptom of a larger agency which is his crisis of a Masculine identity. According to Springer (2014), his pleasure of masochism is supported by him being alive in the fight club very well by extension, supports his identity. (You aren't alive anywhere like you're alive in Fight Club, Springer: 2014). From a post-structuralism perspective, Identity is comprehended as a process. It is never ultimately attained. So

How Are We To Assess Gender In Relation To The Formation Of Identity?

1580 words - 6 pages social roles that define our gender, i.e. how masculine or feminine we are. Since society creates our concept of masculine and feminine stereotypes society will also judge humans who use their gender as a part of their identity. For example a woman who is very feminine will be seen to be healthy and well adjusted by the society that defines the stereotype. She will by the same token though, be treated the way society decides it will treat


1171 words - 5 pages overflowing macho testosterone, it's no wonder that the sole female character is an enigma shrouded in cigarette smoke and filled with sexual tension. Fight Club, the movie as well as the novel, explores the concept of recovering masculine identity through destruction of self. The sole essential female character is Marla Singer. Marla’s presence is felt throughout the movie. Both the film and novel explores Marla’s role through the physical

National Identity in Australia as presented by television broadcast television

1848 words - 7 pages masculine discourses. It is important to consider these discourses in this debate about Australian culture, identity and television because television is the major communicative device for disseminating such cultural representations, representations that constitute cultural identity. Television has provided a proliferating resource for both the deconstruction and the construction of cultural identities. That is, television has become a leading

Masculinity in "Fight Club"

2320 words - 9 pages Others often use masculinity, most often associated with strength, confidence and self-sufficiency to define a man’s identity. The narrator perceives Tyler Durden as a fearless young man who is independent and living life by his own rules. So is Tyler Durden masculine because of his no nonsense attitude or are his law breaking antics and unusual lifestyle seen as a failure because he is a man with neither family, money nor a well respected job

The Tall Tale Male: Literary Versions of American Manhood

1718 words - 7 pages “Leather Stockings” series, “The Last of The Mohicans,” uses the American frontier an aesthetic articulation of male Identity. (“Masculine Heroes” American Passages Voices and Visions) In an excerpt from Cooper’s classic, “From Volume I Chapter III”, (Cooper. 485-491) the reader is introduced to the recurring character Natty Bumppo – referred to as Hawkeye-- and his friend Chingachgook. Both men can be seen as representations of the American

Freud, S. on the Theory of Sexuality from his article 'The Transformations of Puberty in Three Essay on the Theory of Sexuality and other works'

1535 words - 6 pages -identity and interactions. His Third Essay discusses the transformations of puberty in both males and females. Part four of this essay focuses on the differentiation between male and female sexuality. Freud states in this part that 'as far as the autoerotic and masturbatory manifestations of sexuality are concerned the sexuality of little girls is of a wholly masculine character' . This paper will attempt to identify the assumptions that lead Freud

Gender Expression

1776 words - 8 pages ” or “girl’s soccer”. This is unusual as women’s sports are considered the “variation” and not the “norm” (Crawford, 2006, p.61). Masculinity in sports can be a key part in gender identity and men in traditionally “feminine” sports must develop strategies in order to construct a masculine identity as seen a study by Caroline Chimot and Catherine Louveau (2010). The study addresses “how young men in a “feminine” sport- rhythmic gymnastics

The Men of the Open Spaces - Focuses on the the Australian bush culture

882 words - 4 pages identity."The Men of the Open Spaces", focuses on a very traditional concept of nationhood, constructing a version of the Australian reality. The author constructs Australia as a predominantly white masculine society, while women and ethnic cultures are excluded. The text also looks into the traditional concepts of nationhood and constructs Australian's as very egalitarian and anti-authoritarian society where everyone's equal. This also has a

Similar Essays

Development Of A Masculine Identity Essay

1692 words - 7 pages Development of a Masculine Identity For many years now there have been studies conducted on feminism and it is developed through youth. But in the past two decade there has been more research focusing on the development of a masculine identity through throughout childhood and adolescence. There are many factors that effect the development of a masculine identity, but due to my childhood experiences I am especially interested in the

An Analytical View Of Gender From Glee By Donald Le Blanc

1048 words - 5 pages male the gender, it also portrays how a homosexual male can maintain his masculine identity. Just like Kurt, the character called Blaine is also a homosexual male. Blaine retains his masculine appearance unlike Kurt, and functions as the masculine counterpart to the Kurt. Being a homosexual male challenges the traditional masculine concept, so the show uses Blaine as a way to illustrate how a homosexual’s actual sexual activity can differ from

Things Fall Apart Essay

648 words - 3 pages shows how serious the masculine versus feminine issue is. Therefore, the author portrays a masculine versus feminine theme throughout the novel. This theme shows how gender roles can dominate a person’s character and society. It seems as though the author the readers to acknowledge a connection and a difference between a male identity and a female identity based on particular roles that they portray. The connection shows different perspectives

The Masculine Figure On Early American Literature

1191 words - 5 pages everywhere." (Hammett, 87)Sam Spade chooses to remain faithful to his job although it could cost him everything; therefore he is showing his firm moral standings through his faithfulness to his job, because he is standing up for what he believes in. Spade always chooses to be faithful to his job--because this means being faithful to his own identity, his masculine self. (Bazelon, 194)Through his firm social and moral standings Sam Spade best