This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Masculinity And Race Essay

2561 words - 10 pages

Masculinity and Race


Historically, masculinity in the United States has been constructed as being White Protestant Anglo-Saxon, furthermore heterosexual and in charge of all matters, and this definition sets standards against which other men are measured an evaluated. Michael Kimmel provides a good definition:

[…], Young, married, white, urban heterosexual, Protestant father of college education, fully employed, of good complexion, weight and height and a recent record in sports(271).

This definition refers to a so-called „hegemonic masculinity“ because it describes a man of power, in power and with power(272).
Racially and ethnically other men have always been equated with characteristics that symbolically effeminate and disempower them. Those other men are African Americans and Asian Americans as well as Latinos and Native Americans, which are not my concern in this essay. I want to argue that race and masculinity cannot be regarded as distinct matters but are closely linked and intertwined with each other because the hegemonic masculinity by definition is only valid for Caucasians and also constructed by them. Ethnically and racially other men can never fully become masculine by that definition, they have to content themselves with the role of a marginal other. To emphasize the importance and historical significance I like to quote Dollimore:

„No consideration of cultural and/or racial difference should ever neglect the sheer negativity, evil and inferiority with which „the other“ of such differences has been associated throughout history“ (Dollimore 18) .

These Others have the opportunity approach masculinity, in terms of the definition provided by Kimmel, when they assimilate to white hegemonic structures, mannerisms and habits, but they have to depend on those same hegemonic structures to grant them this reward, for the dubious price of neglecting their own heritage and culture, at least that is what I think.
Others can always help the Caucasian hero to reach his goal and safe „the world“ because they might possess a specific and peculiar skill that helps to achieve the aspired goal and this capability furthermore marks their otherness. But they can never possess the whole package like the white hero does.
Historically, African Americans have been made hypermasculine as well as they have been emasculated. They were portrayed as either the overwhelmingly strong, sexual aggressive invader or the harmless boy not to be feared.
Asian American have been depicted as malicious, sneaky and evil minded others that always threaten to rape innocent white maidens. They are thought of as not being able to speak...

Find Another Essay On Masculinity and Race

Masculinity and hegemonic masculinity - second year of university - essay

2780 words - 12 pages Masculinity and Hegemonic Masculinity Over the course of this paper, the main focus will be targeted towards analysing the concept of masculinity, how it has developed and evolved over time and what impact it has had on the dynamics of society. The analysis will consist of exemplifying different aspects of masculinity and discussing them, with exemplification and analogies being formed in order to have a better understanding of them. Masculinity

Lad Flicks: A Hybrid of Buddie Movies, Romantic Comedies and Chick Flicks

2521 words - 11 pages , ‘lad flicks’ are multiply ambivalent texts as they on one side portray features of sexism, racism and homophobia yet they also highlight gender, race and homosocial relations (Feminism at the Movies 46). Gender relations in the ‘lad flicks’ discussed above do portray masculinity as a troubled, anxious cultural category as they hide behind a humorous façade through their unglamorous jobs, male bonding, homophobic comments and insults, and the

American Masculinity: Defined By War

1884 words - 8 pages group of individuals, leaving the majority of the American public emotionally and personally distant from war, mainstream American masculinity still draws heavily upon the characteristically male experience of going to war. In modern American society, masculinity is still defined and expressed through analogy with the behavior and experiences of men at war; however, such a simplistic masculinity cannot account for the depth of human experience

Messerschmidt’s Theory of Hegemonic Masculinity

2570 words - 10 pages for male crime. Hegemonic masculinity deals with the culturally normative ideas of who a male is and how he should behave. It is a social process. However, the method of displaying one's maleness can vary with each situation, culture, race, and class. If legitimate opportunities are not available in order for one to prove his maleness, then force may be used and opportunities created through criminal activity. From the time we are born, we are

Messerschmidt’s Theory of Hegemonic Masculinity

2570 words - 10 pages for male crime. Hegemonic masculinity deals with the culturally normative ideas of who a male is and how he should behave. It is a social process. However, the method of displaying one's maleness can vary with each situation, culture, race, and class. If legitimate opportunities are not available in order for one to prove his maleness, then force may be used and opportunities created through criminal activity. From the time we are born, we are

The Social Construction of Gender

856 words - 3 pages Different culture and different periods of history construct gender differently. Due to the social construction of gender, gender always ranks women below men of the same race and class. The rich details of the historical and field studies have given the notion that violence is always related to masculinities. Men is always referred as the subject of the action “violence against female” when speaking of the phrase “violence toward women”. Men

AIDS: Danger to Everyone

1264 words - 5 pages and homosexual men, women, and children of every race and age through sexual activities, blood transfusion, or genetic inheritance (Altman 1). Therefore, it does not specifically target a particular race/class/age/gender/orientation as people would assume—even superheroes can contract the disease. Superman always has his powers and muscles but in this case, he is stripped of both aspects. He needs an oxygen mask to breathe and his body is as skinny

Understanding Gender Identity and Sexuality

1341 words - 5 pages sister, friend, and neighbor. One’s gender identity refers to his or her perception of self as a male or female, as well as being masculine or feminine. Because masculinity and femininity are fluid, rather than static, they are dependent on the perspective of the beholder. A person’s perspective is often influenced by their surroundings as well as values with which they were raised, both of which are never identical between two people. Race

The Legalization of Abortion and Crime

2409 words - 10 pages , Minority groups cause more crimes due to their affiliation with other things not pertaining to school and education and finally African Americans are notorious for causing crimes in their subordinate groups. Crimes come up from the need to be masculine and show the masculinity. Crimes are all different due to age, race, ethnicity, and have a strong inclination to attract the male population to assert their dominance. III) In correspondence of

The Continuation Of Patriarchy In Our Culture

1538 words - 6 pages allows men to form bonds with one another often through the objectification of women. This connection with other men is important, and there is a risk of losing masculinity if a man should choose not to participate in homosocial behavior. Even Schwyzer, a pro-feminist thinker, has found himself going along with the banter of his peers out of fear of exclusion. When relationships begin to be formed around ideas that drive patriarchy it becomes

Mad Men & The Representation of "US"

2321 words - 10 pages series expresses every concerning aspect of media’s representation of “US”, our history, our ideals and beliefs. What is perhaps most interesting about this award-winning show is how it always generates a dialogue about the state of our current cultural identity, saying so much about the nature of gender roles, sexuality, race and more. It is a reminder that whilst we are being entertained, we are also having our identities critiqued and expressed

Similar Essays

Compare And Contrast The Representation Of Masculinity Of John Wayne’s Rio Bravo (1959) And Die Hard (1988)

2209 words - 9 pages beside the bar and appears to be dominating those around him. Contradicting Wexman’s (1993:94) interpretation between stature and race, height connotes a gendered privilege that is specifically attributed to masculinity. This relationship between stature, authority and power is a cultural expectation of masculinity. To be powerful is to be able to exert physical superiority over those around you. In Die Hard (1988), McClanes stature is not a

Gender Studies Essay

1692 words - 7 pages Gender is socially constructed and emphasized on different factors such as media, family, peers, schools, religions and the list keeps going. There is race, class and sexuality that interact with gender. People always emphasize two types of gender, which is masculinity and femininity. Usually is based on the person sex. Society will not accept anyone whose sex is male and gender is feminine. Sex is what is in between the legs and gender is

Comparative Anaylsis Of Hegemonic Masculinity Essay

1652 words - 7 pages that men need to be educated in order to succeed and exert power and dominance over women. For men to be educated, they are able to attain good paying jobs to support their families. Although both articles discuss the importance of educating men, Tragos largely focuses on hegemonic masculinity in the context of exclusively white men. The article targets white men and women which insinuates that people of different race are to be minorized. In

Hegemonic Masculinity Practices Essay

1493 words - 6 pages As mentioned before in historically specific masculinities, hegemonic masculinity is not a universal phenomenon. Hegemonic masculinity practices are not only dominate towards women - domination practices also involve ‘other’ masculinities. Hegemonic masculinity is thus “the hegemony over women and hegemony over subordinate masculinities”, according to Demetriou (2009,341). Not all men and their practices, fall within the hegemonic masculine