Math Approaches: Traditional Or Reform Essay

1301 words - 6 pages

Math Approaches: Traditional or Reform
Presently there is an argument regarding whether it is better to teach mathematics in a reform or traditional approach. Understandably, educators want to teach children in the best way that will benefit students as a child and a learner. Different people can argue that their approach is more effective than traditional methods, and likewise for the reform approach. However, research reveals that there are certain advantages and disadvantages to each teaching approach.
Traditional Approach
Traditionally math has been taught in a teacher-centered environment. With this traditional approach students give all their attention to the teacher, and work problems using a given method. The National Mathematics Advisory Panel defined this approach as “instruction in which primarily the teacher is communicating the mathematics to the students directly” (National Mathematics Advisory Panel, 2008). In this approach the teacher explains the idea that the class will be working on, and then shows the students how to answer the problem. The goal is getting to the answer, and the students rely on the teacher to determine if their answers are correct or not (Van de Walle, 2007).
Advantages to the Traditional Approach
Research shows that there are advantages to using the traditional approach in the math classroom. Direct teaching is considered one of the most powerful teaching methods because of its systematic and grounded principles (Markusic, 2012). One advantage of a traditional teacher-centered classroom is that the teacher is directing the learning, and students have no problem determining what is important in a lesson (Markusic, 2012). This is also an advantage for the teacher because the teacher does not have to worry about a student missing an important topic.
Disadvantages to the Traditional Approach
Research also shows that there are disadvantages to using the traditional teacher-centered approach in the classroom. “Children emerge from these experiences with a view that mathematics is a series of arbitrary rules, handed down by the teacher, who in turn got them from a very smart source” (Van de Walle, 2007). As a result of this approach, students often are unable to take what they have been taught and transfer it to problems that are slightly different from those they have been working in class (Kohn, 1999). Students may easily add numbers when they are stacked on top of each other, but may struggle when they are lined up horizontally. Children become good at learning rules in order to ensure good grades, but are unable to actually do the mathematics. This traditional system seems to reward students for learning the rules, but does not give students the opportunity to actually do the mathematics (Van de Walle, 2007).
In a traditional teacher-directed classroom students work alone, and do not learn to collaborate with other students in the classroom. Because of this, students may lack the social...

Find Another Essay On Math Approaches: Traditional or Reform

Charter Schools in Washington DC: A Reasonable Solution?

2471 words - 10 pages from regulations regarding curriculum and design. Some charter schools offer unique teaching environment, for instance, “a school conduct science class in the field or offer specialization in arts education” that traditional public schools do not offer (Chen). Charter schools’ innovative environment has led some school communities to seek more freedom to enhance students’ knowledge and experiences by creating new approaches of teaching. In D.C

Math Facts Essay

1871 words - 7 pages Yermish, 2011). Typically, these facts are memorized at grade levels deemed appropriate to a student’s readiness – usually second or third grade for addition and subtraction and fourth grade for multiplication and division. If a child can say the answer to a math fact problem within a couple of seconds, this is considered mastery of the fact (Marques, 2010). Automaticity – the point at which something is automatic- is the goal when referring to math

Building Critical Thinking Skills with Math

1068 words - 4 pages to learn algebra. She was a non-traditional student and as such, she was just beginning an introduction to algebra at the age of thirty-two. The article describes the student declaring that she had never had any event in her life in which it was needed to have an understanding of algebra in all her years in which a person would normally have learned algebra in a traditional school up to her own age. She basically called math teachers, or anyone

Employing Games in Education

2245 words - 9 pages have to work through problems and understand the reasoning behind the math skills. In the article,the authors also mention that in the traditional classroom, teaching methods and past negative experience also cause this anxiety. One has to agree with this statement focusing on the attitude of Bowman (1982), that kids often make comments like ‘Math has no real life usage’ or ‘Math is boring’. The basic challenge lies in the fact that what

No Child Left Behind Assessment

1364 words - 5 pages If a standardized test was a contestant on Dancing With the Stars or American Idol, would it be voted off? Depends on whether the judges were politicians, professors, psychologists or parents. The stakes are high; ideology and money are at stake, and accountability is on the line. Using standardized tests as quantitative measurement tools have important implications for American education, “quality of assessment is one of the key features of

Year Round Education: A Worthwhile Transformation

2226 words - 9 pages academic ability stemming from a lapse in learning in which students forget information. Furthermore, studies show that math and spelling skills in particular require practice or they are susceptible to being forgotten (Cooper). Because of the learning loss teachers are required to spend ample time at the beginning of the school year reviewing the previous year’s material. In fact, it is estimated that the first 4-6 weeks of a school year are dedicated

Multicultural Education

1777 words - 7 pages multicultural educator recognizes that traditional forms of assessment are no more free from charges of arbitrariness that the curriculum itself" (p.23). We must reform the way we assess students' learning abilities.         There are three basic types of multicultural education programs according to articles written by Sleeter and Grant (1993) One or all can be offered. The first is content-orientated or programs focusing on information. In this

Technology is Taking Over and Replacing Humans

1362 words - 5 pages machines, but by placing all its faith within these devices our math and writing skills have decreased making life spiral into chaos if the technology malfunctions. Since the invention of the abacus humanity has always craved and crated new items and technological machines to help in its theory, practice, and understanding of math. These advancements in technology made calculators one of the great inventions in helping ordinary people solve

migratory reform

1101 words - 5 pages solve this socio-economic problem implicit in the failure of the current migratory law. . Nonetheless, the migratory reform has detractors who claims that a reform in the migratory laws (which dignifies the illegal aliens) will provoke that this intruders take the jobs of the Americans; they also appeal at the cost of the immigrants once they become legal citizens, for they will become eligible to receive government benefits like Medicare or

Gender Bias in Math and Engineering, What is being done?

806 words - 3 pages become a source of controversy and frustration. As a future teacher, I feel it is important for me to recognize the problems , and to the best of my abilities, ensure that students have a non-biased classroom.Up to the high school years, girls and boys score equally in overall achievement. However, by the end of high school, the majority of girls take fewer math courses than boys, preferring English or history. Around the seventh and eight grade

Learning-Style Responsive Approaches for Teaching Typically Performing and At-Risk Adolescents

1678 words - 7 pages /error prone approaches or time-consuming mental math. The program improves the automaticity and accuracy of recall of simple math facts, rules and/or procedures. When students are not able to do this, they tend to have major roadblocks to higher-order thinking. When they are able to free up their working memory by automatically recalling those facts they have the cognitive resources available to take on higher-order tasks. In the short term

Similar Essays

Math Strategies For Special Education Students

1328 words - 5 pages mathematical ideas, try alternative paths, and be willing to persevere, (NCTM, 2000; Bottge et al. 2007). The NCTM agreed that reform was needed areas such as basic skills instruction and instruction in problem solving (Bottge et al. 2007). Bottge, Kwon, LaRoque, Rueda, & Serlin (2007) looked at the use of Enhanced Anchored Instruction (EAI) to help boost problem solving skills of students with disabilities in the area of math. EAI immerses

School Reform In America Essay

1260 words - 6 pages risen in math and reading since the NCLBA was passed. The Center on Educational Policy released a report clearly indicating scores have risen and ultimately a step in a positive direction. In 2009, President Barack Obama announced another educational program, Race to the Top. “Race to the Top marks a historic movement in American education.” This initiative provides additional funding for states that focus on educational reform. The individual

The Teachings Of Mathematics Education In America

987 words - 4 pages America’s problems with math are not new news; they predate both the No Child Left Behind Act and the reform-math movement. To us, the story here is less about test scores and more about the nation’s attitudes toward math. Simply put, America is math-phobic—to an extent that profoundly influences our country’s policies, teaching practices, and, ultimately, the performance of our students.” (ERIC) The National Council of Teachers of

Public Education Essay

1469 words - 6 pages , traditional public schools are still failing to provide students with a quality education. This is disheartening as we learn that the United States lags behind in math and science compared to our international counterparts. It is safe to say that educational reform has spent billions of dollars over the years in an honest effort to reform education in American; however, most reform decisions have produced little changes. Among the many radical education