Matters Of Psychological Difference In Religious Analysis: Psychological Assessments In Weber And Durkheim

1324 words - 5 pages

Elizabeth Jennings 3/10/10 Matters of Psychological Differences in Religious Analysis
Psychological considerations have proved invaluable to religious analysis. Because religion is both an internal and an external institution, it is difficult to exclude the attributes which are primarily mental. Both Durkheim and Weber use psychological interpretations, but their approach drastically differs. Durkheim resolutely claimed to avoid psychological assessments but used this type of inference to resolve the relationship between man and religion. Weber, however, openly utilized p p sychological evaluations, in respect to actual data, in order to show the ultimate implications of religious values.Despite his attempts to refrain from the subjective and vague tendencies of psychological interpretation, Durkheim's key arguments depend on purely psychological analysis. Rather than excluding general personal experiences, he considers the effect on the psyche that physical events h ave. Religion, he contends, is created by the conflict these physical facts have with basic emotions. When faced with challenges, "the modes of action they advised or prescribed to man could only rarely been effective: illnesses are not cured through purifying rituals, nor do crops grow because of chants and sacrifices… If religious faith was not born to ensure man's harmony with the material world, the errors it made him commit in his struggles with the world would have had little effect because it was nourished from another source. If people became believers for reasons other than this, they must have continued to believe even when these reasons were contradicted by facts. Faith must have been quite strong then not only to withstand these contradictions, but to deny them and prevent the believer from taking them to heart. In effect, such faith made them inoffensive to religion. When religious feeling is intense, it does not accept that religion could be guilty and easily suggests explanations that preserve its innocence. If the rite does not produce the expected results, the failure is imputed either to some fault in execution, or to the invention of a rival divinity. But for this to happen, religious ideas cannot arise from a feeling that is troubled by the disappointments of experience" (Durkheim 2001: 72-73). Durkheim bases his analysis of the relationship between internal reactions, such as faith, emotions, and rites, on psychological reasoning that these mental states contain the potential to alter religion. He believes that physical events can inspire certain mental states which can change the whole of religion.In discussing the manner in which sacred elements inspired religion, Durkheim uses the example of man's interaction with nature. He takes two views and infers as to the state of mind each had when confronted with the same situations, juxtaposes modern Western man's experience with nature to that of a primitive. "He cannot have contact with nature without...

Find Another Essay On Matters of Psychological Difference in Religious Analysis: Psychological Assessments in Weber and Durkheim

Issues in Psychological Psychology Essay

900 words - 4 pages PSY 475 Psychological Tests and Measurements University of Phoenix MaterialIssues in Psychological Testing WorksheetUsing the text for this course, the University Library, the Internet, and/or other resources answer the following questions. Your response to each question should be at least 200 words in length.What are at least two ethical issues associated with psychological testing? What impact do these issues have on the field of

Issues In Psychological Profiling Essay

1319 words - 5 pages is to develop a behavioral composite that combines both sociological and psychological assessment of the would-be offender. The type of person who could have committed the crime can often be identified on the premise that accurate analysis and interpretation of the crime scene can point to a reasonable suspect (Egger, 1999). Psychological profiling may have found its origin in fiction rather than fact with Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s fictional

Psychological and Sociological Factors in Smoking Addiction

2457 words - 10 pages Psychological and Sociological Factors in Smoking Addiction Understanding the habit of smoking tobacco The essay will discuss how smoking tobacco became a habit among people; what are the factors that affect the thinking of individuals in experimenting tobacco smoking; and what makes them think of quitting smoking. It will address both psychological and sociological ideas and will attempt to apply each idea in order to understand people’s

Voyage and Psychological Development in Homer's Odyssey

3328 words - 13 pages The Voyage and Psychological Development in Homer's Odyssey       Homer's Odyssey arguably stands out head and shoulders above any other piece of epic literature produced by Western civilization for nearly three millennia. Most remarkable is the extent to which the Western hero archetype is to this day still a result of the molding that occurred upon the character of Odysseus so long ago. In imagining a police lineup of the most profoundly

Psychological Criticism of Characters in Othello

2172 words - 9 pages jealousy drives him to murder. Also questionable, are Iago’s reasons for wanting to destroy Othello. Analysis will discover the characters unique motivations for their actions. Othello is the tragic hero of the play, whose tragic flaw is jealousy. In the beginning, Othello seems to display only superior qualities. He has a good reputation and people respect him as a good lieutenant and a man of noble character. Othello assumes the best about

Psychological Analysis

1351 words - 6 pages Does one really know the definition of psychological instability? Perhaps it has an existence at the mental institutional treatment sanitarium here in southern California. The patient of evaluation, Holden Caulfield, a seventeen year old Caucasian male, weighs approximately 120lbs with a skinny, lanky stature and is 6 feet and 2.5 inches tall. Caulfield has crew-cut hair that is graying on the right side. The patient was an occasional drinker

Holden, Charlie, and Devon: An Analysis of the Psychological Disorders in Three Characters INCLUDES OUTLINE AND WORKS CITED PAGE!

2154 words - 9 pages OUTLINEHolden, Charlie, and Devon:An Analysis of the Psychological Disorders in Three CharactersTo truly understand the characters (as well as their thoughts and actions) in The Catcher in the Rye, The Perks of Being a Wallflower, and Not as Crazy as I Seem, it is necessary to understand the psychological disorders that they deal with, such as manic-depressive disorder, obsessive--compulsive disorder, Post-traumatic Stress disorder, and others.A

Psychological Analysis of The Matrix

2671 words - 11 pages throughout The Matrix trilogy. Perception is defined as the psychological phenomenon whereby information is selected, organized, and interpreted to form a mental representation of the world, Myers (2006). Perception occurs separately for everyone and although reality is difficult to define, in the film, perception is very clearly separated from the idea of reality. In reality, all members of The Matrix are suspended in pods, caught in an altered

Psychological Analysis of Coriolanus’s Downfall

1889 words - 8 pages a command over him, controlling his actions and inhibiting his growth. It is almost ironic that she becomes the hero after spending her life wanting this for her son. It is his downfall or failure to achieve this honor that makes Volumnia become the hero. “Hypermasculinity is a psychological term for the exaggeration of male stereotypical behavior, such as an emphasis on strength, aggression, body hair, odor, and virility.” As seen in Act 1

A Psychological Analysis of "Of Mice and Men"

1451 words - 6 pages The psychological approach views literature through the lens of psychology. There are multiple approaches to the psychological aspect of literature but the two most recognized are the Freudian and Jungian approach. The best approach to use when critically analyzing the novel Of Mice and Men, written by John Steinbeck, is the Jungian approach. Because the novel’s main theme is a struggle with the idea of “self”, using this approach allows the

Psychological Estrangement in Shakespeare’s Hamlet

1563 words - 6 pages of friendship, his bondage to his religious and normative principles, and his bond to his professional colleagues. Many different forms of estrangement occurring simultaneously risk his psychological sense of identity. The realization that he faces such enormous pressures shapes his seemingly bizarre behavior in the play, and makes him struggle against the awesome weight of his obligation to destroy Claudius. All of this, of course, is in addition to his basic fear of being executed if he attempts to kill Claudius.

Similar Essays

Psychological, Philosophical And Religious Elements Of Heart Of Darkness

900 words - 4 pages Psychological, Philosophical and Religious Elements of Heart of Darkness      Heart of Darkness is a kind of little world unto itself.  The reader of Conrad’s Heart of Darkness should take the time to consider this work from a psychological point of view. There are, after all, an awful lot of heads and skulls in the book, and Conrad goes out of his way to suggest that in some sense Marlow's journey is like a dream or a return to our

Max, Durkheim And Weber Essay

1753 words - 7 pages Comparison of Marx, Durkheim and Weber Sociology can easily be described as a untidy subject. As the "˜science of society and social relations' its boundaries are wide and difficult to draw. Marx, Durkheim and Weber are the major classical sociological thinkers and are often regarded as the "˜trinity' of major classical sociologists. They provide theories and arguments in order to create an understanding of our society. In comparing

Durkheim, Weber And Marx Essay

1228 words - 5 pages integrated their founding theories to further create and develop more modern theories. Durkheim, Marx and Weber were first to explore the economy and society and their relationship in the early 19th and 20th centuries. Marx argues that the economy is at the center of society, providing the base to a social superstructure. It is this economic base that determines the other social institutions, such as religion and politics. Durkheim, on the other

Psychological Analysis Of Rashoman

1306 words - 5 pages PSYCHOLOGICAL ANALYSIS OF RASHOMAN English 161, Chris Evans Submitted by Joe Rousseau Rashomon, by Ryunosaki Akutaguya provides great insight into the psychological discord that the Japanese culture was undergoing in the early part of the twentieth century. Japan was in the throes of a societal transformation, from a traditional, religious-based society, to a newly adopted weternized culture. Japan was rapidly assimilating industrial and