This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Matthew Arnold Versus Aristotle's Poetics Essay

3851 words - 15 pages

The value of imitation: a vision of Aristotle's Poetics

Aristotle wrote his Poetics thousands of years before Matthew Arnold's birth. His reasons for composing it were different from Arnold's reasons for using it as an element of his own poetic criticism. We can safely say that Arnold was inclined to use the Poetics as an inspiration for his own poetry, and as a cultural weapon in the fight for artistic and social renewal. Aristotle, by contrast, was more concerned with discovering general truths, and with formalising truths already known intuitively within his own society.

I wish, in this article, to make some observations about the way in which some of the seminal ideas in the Poetics affected one key writer within the English literary tradition. Curiously enough the first thing to be said about Arnold's view of Aristotle is that it is more a Platonic than an Aristotelian view. In short Arnold was primarily, though not merely, an idealist. If, for the sake of clarity we could for the purpose of this analysis call Aristotle a realist, we might be better able to see the proper scope of this account. What we have then is the case of a man who was primarily a scientist and philosopher -- a realist in the best sense of the word, influencing a poet and visionary -- an idealist in the best sense of the word.

I have decided, despite many references in Arnold's work to Aristotelian ideas generally, to concentrate on one piece of work by Arnold; a piece of work where he more specifically refers to Aristotelian ideas of imitation. This is the 1853 Preface to The Poems of Matthew Arnold 1840-1866. I will therefore, where appropriate, compare and contrast this Preface to the Poetics. Such an approach gives us a chance to look at Aristotle in his own right, and also to gauge his influence, or otherwise, on Arnold.

I have also chosen the Arnold Preface because it is manageable in length, and because, as Stefan Collini says in his book Arnold "The 1853 Preface has a particular biographical interest ... as Arnold's first public engagement in those critical controversies that were to be the stimulus to his best work" (p. 48). Two points follow from this statement. Firstly it suggests that Arnold saw literature, philosophy and criticism, as of vital public importance, and secondly it says that the his engagement in public debate tended to have a positive effect on his creative work. This makes his approach similar to that of Aristotle who also saw theory as intimately linked to public practice. Aristotle's Poetics, and his writing in general, have a profoundly social and moral dimension. I would argue then that Arnold attempts to import a moral ideal into England from Greece, and argue even further that his greatest ambition was not just the restoration of national literature to England, but finally a great society. In the realm of ideas Arnold does manage to show the desireability, for England, of Aristotelian ideas and Greek ideas in general....

Find Another Essay On Matthew Arnold versus Aristotle's Poetics

Matthew Arnold as a Poet and Critic

1875 words - 8 pages Amal Mohaya AlRekabi Course : Poetry Matthew Arnold as a Poet and Critic The word "criticism" is derived from a Greek word that means "judgment". So, criticism is basically the exercise of judgment, and literary criticism is, therefore, the exercise of judgment on works of literature. From this, it is clear that the nature of literary criticism is to examine a work of literature, and its function is to identify its points of

the role of a critic in defining a piece of art

3336 words - 13 pages generations. Plato and Aristotle the duo stand as torchbearers for all the critics ever after. After Aristotle's death his philosophy continued to be taught at the "PERIPATETIC SCHOOL" by a long line of successors. Profound pieces of literary works have been judged on the basis of principles layed down by Aristotle's "POETICS".As stated earlier-the power to criticize can be acquired. As soon as a man becomes aware that it would suit his purpose to

Essay on Technical Qualities, Symbolism, and Imagery of Dover Beach

1644 words - 7 pages Technical Qualities, Symbolism, and Imagery of "Dover Beach" In "Dover Beach," Matthew Arnold creates a dramatic monologue of the Victorian Era that shows how perceptions can be misleading. Arnold conveys the theme of "Dover Beach" through three essential developments: the technical qualities of the poem itself, symbolism, and imagery. The theme of illusion versus reality in "Dover Beach" reflects the speaker's awareness of the

Victorian Literature

1297 words - 5 pages "To save our souls and heal the State", the words of George Gordon portrays how the English Literature is in danger. John Stuart Mill's critical essay "What is Poetry?" as well as "The Study of Poetry" by Matthew Arnold both depict in defense of poetry. Robert Browning's "Caliban upon Setebos" and Lord Alfred Tennyson's "In Memoriam A.H.H.", both face religious crises and "heal". All four of these authors clearly depict in their work and support

Dover Beach Theme Imagery and Sound

1448 words - 6 pages In "Dover Beach," Matthew Arnold creates a monologue that shows how perceptions can be misleading. The theme of illusion versus reality in "Dover Beach" reflects the speaker's awareness of the incompatibility between what is perceived and what truly is real. Arnold conveys the theme of "Dover Beach" through three essential developments. First, he uses visual imagery. Second, he uses sound (aural) imagery. Third, he uses rhythm and metric. These

Loyal Disobedience - A Social Tract of Euripides in Medea and Helen

1794 words - 7 pages good deed!" (Chorus 1730).  So even though Theonoe lied to her brother she is forgiven for the deed.  Loyalty to predecessors, and to the gods overrules loyalty to Theoklymenos.               These contradictions of the female characters help make the women more accessible.  According to Aristotle's De Poetics heroes and heroines should be perfect, they should have no faults, and they should be almost completely single-sided.  Euripides

Modernism in T.s. Eliots's the Wasteland

1152 words - 5 pages of unifying the disjointed speaker(s), all of which conflict with each other although they may be equally true. Thus faced with this paradox, the reader is privy to one of the modernist themes in the work: individuals are permanently estranged, each bearing a unique identity, yet they are able to connect with each other to create a kind of coherence, however temporary. Of course, Matthew Arnold wrote something very similar in To Marguerite

Common Man Tragedy in Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman

1849 words - 7 pages The idea of dramatic tragedy is a classical one, discussed in Aristotle's Poetics. Before it can be established as to whether Miller really has written a tragedy or not, the very concept of tragedy must be investigated. Aristotle asserted, 'Tragedy is a representation, an imitation, of an action.1? He went on to outline the common features tragic drama must have. Tragedy has six elements, which, in order of importance, are: plot, character

Analysis of "Dover Beach" by Matthew Arnold

1497 words - 6 pages "Dover beach" is a beautiful poem written by a famous poet, Matthew Arnold; from the romantic era. The poem is melancholic and pessimistic in nature and shows human misery through the ages. The diction changes as the poem progresses, from the beginning till the end, soft and loving to hard and rough, respectively. The images are centered around the ocean, this is to show the analogy that life can be both turbulent as well as placid. The time

Jazz and Three Novels

2089 words - 9 pages In an essay on Heinrich Heine in his Selected Prose Works written in 1860, Matthew Arnold penned: “Modern man finds himself with an immense system of institutions, established facts, accredited dogmas, customs, and rules which have come down to him from times not modern. Though his life must move forward, he has a sense that this system is not of his own creation, and that it by no means corresponds exactly to the wants of his actual life

High Culture

1838 words - 7 pages Frankfurt School where culture is constituted by class relations and social structure, whereas, the idealist approach concerns itself with literary criticisms of Matthew Arnold (Arnoldian), F.R. Leavis and Q.D. Leavis (Leavisite) where it discriminates between high culture and low culture. This essay seeks to examine how the concept of high culture is used and its alternative counterparts. Idealism, by Oxford’s definition, is ‘the practice of

Similar Essays

Kierston Lewis Essay

1135 words - 5 pages Matthew Arnold was known to be two different people when it came to his poetry versus his life; ‘poet and censor’. Matthew Arnold was not so much as determined to be successful. He only loved the art of poetry. Arnold never saw poetry as a profession. With no mother figure or siblings, only having his father to lean on, Matthew saw poetry only as a mere hobby. Little did he know there were greater things to come from his ‘mere hobby’. An

Definition Of Tragedy According To Aristotle's "Poetics"

792 words - 3 pages complete. T. R. Henn defines 'completeness' as totality which Matthew Arnold later called 'architectonice'. Aristotle himself, in different chapter of the Poetics, has saught to define 'completeness'. If the play begins abruptly, the reader or the audience may not understand what it is about. Let not the reader ask "What happens then?" The work of art should be rounded off. The Greek art, whether plastic or non-plastic, always insisted on symmetry

Oedipus Rex As A Great Tragedy

630 words - 3 pages piece of writing because it exemplifies these qualities described in Aristotle's Poetics.In Poetics, Aristotle described tragedy to be an imitation of events that is "serious and complete, and of a certain magnitude." The reader can clearly see these qualities in Oedipus Rex. The play is unquestionably serious, as it deals with the theme of plague, "hateful plague, he hounds the city," and incest, "my own mother's husband." It is also complete as

Arnold's Dover Beach And Wordsworth's Tintern Abbey

1872 words - 7 pages Wordsworth's project: what we learn here is that the lessons extricated from and delivered through poetic discourse shall ultimately be philosophical. Evaluating Wordsworth's poetics, Matthew Arnold, in his Preface to The Poems of Wordsworth (1879), says that "poetry is at bottom a criticism of life; that the greatness of a poet lies in his powerful and beautiful application of ideas to life, -- to the question: How to live?" (85). Arnold holds