This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Max Shulman’s “Love Is A Fallacy”

800 words - 3 pages

1MillerKate MillerMs. SoyENGL 1302: Composition II17 November 2013Journal Three: Max Shulman's "Love is a Fallacy""Love is a Fallacy" is a fun short story where the author teaches basic principles of fallacies in an entertaining way. There are three main characters, the narrator, Petey Burch and Polly Espy. The three main characters study in the same university, also the narrator and Petey Burch are roommates and Petey and Polly share the love relationship. The narrator is a self-called cool, logic, keen, calculating, perspicacious, acute and astute student, while Petey tends to be much more interested in craze, especially in the clothing. One day, Petey Burch resigned to exchange the narrator's raccoon coat with his girlfriend Polly. Satisfying the needs of both of them, the deal had been made. For a few days, and by some small tests, the narrator found that Polly was really an unintelligent girl. To make her logic and intelligent according to his standards, the narrator began to teach her logic. When the narrator realized that Polly has really become logical, the narrator decided to propose to her. Unexpectedly, Polly used all the logic fallacies that he taught her to refute his offer. When it comes to the reason why she refused him, she said with a logical reason, "Petey has got a raccoon coat" (Shulman 391). In this story, the narrator seems to be the final winner while he is just the victim. The interesting ending tells us some information, that love is not just a fallacy.The narrator of this story classifies himself as better than the others. At the beginning of the story, he describes himself, "Cool am I and logical. Keen, calculating, perspicacious, acute and astute - I was all of these. My brain was as powerful as dynamo, as precise as a chemist's scale, as penetrating as a scalpel. And -think of it! -I was only eighteen" (Shulman 383). He uses many commentary words to praise himself as an intelligent and smart person. However, the images of the other two characters are described in a totally different direction. He describes Petey Burch as a "faddist and nothing upstairs/same age, same background, but dumb as an ox" (Shulman 383). He also describes the character Polly as quite unintelligent girl. Therefore, the narrator seems to think of Polly only in the way of being a woman of beauty and nothing more. He did not...

Find Another Essay On Max Shulman’s “Love is a Fallacy”

Is Romeo and Juliet a Love Story?

1718 words - 7 pages Is Romeo and Juliet a Love Story? Immature love says: 'I love you because I need you.' Mature love says 'I need you because I love you.' Erich Fromm. Romeo and Juliet is based on immature love, and is not a true love story. Love is a great source of passion throughout the world. Though love is considered a good emotion, it can also be one of the biggest flaws a person can have. When one is in love, they will basically do anything to be with

Love is a temporary form of insanity

947 words - 4 pages Love is a temporary form of insanity In the novel The Kite Runner and the play Antigone Love can be a destructive force such as betrayal, which occurs when one betrays a loved one. An example in Antigone would be when Antigone broke Creon’s law to go bury her beloved brother this questions us to think will people do wrong to help and be with their loved ones and is love a destructive force. In the Dictionary Love is a strong feeling of

love is a catalyst for change

662 words - 3 pages Love is a catalyst for change, love of self and love of country bring about change to end injustice so everyone can be treated the same, and people can enjoy the same rights and privileges of others regardless of their racial and economic background This issue is transparent in Dr. Martin Luther King's 1963 masterpiece "Letter from Birmingham Jail" and the author's use of language clearly surfaces the connection between this most precious human

Love is Blind: A True Life Experience

1031 words - 4 pages Everybody has heard the saying "love is blind." Although very few of us have taken the time to apply it to our own relationships, it holds truth, for better or for worse. I spent one of my first serious relationships turning a blind eye to the faults of my significant other. He would blow me off, and I would make excuses for him. He would treat me with disrespect, and I would ignore it. He would play mind games with me, and I would grow to be

A fallacy about why there are locks on doors if the store is open 24hrs a day, 7 days a week, 365 days a year

603 words - 2 pages A fallacy about why there are locks on doors if the store is open 24hrs a day, 7 days a week, 365 days a year. -At 1:30 in the morning you are driving down Walton Road when you pass the7-11. You decide to stop in and treat yourself to a nice big slurpee. As you pull inthe parking lot you notice that the sign says, 'We're open 24 hr's, 7 days a week, 365days a year.' However, when you reach the door you notice that they have locks onthe doors and

Is Love A Key Element When Choosing A Marriage Partner?

2402 words - 10 pages A famous quote by John Lennon saying that “love is the answer and only you know that for sure” was not entirely truthful the fact not realised was that, for the many people in today’s contemporary “dating” grouping, truly knowing what the answer actually is in regards to dating is often easier said than done. Therefore, the answer certainly is not love. According to the Merriam-Webster Dictionary (1974), love is defined as a “strong affection

Romeo and Juliet is Not a Love Story

1194 words - 5 pages plays is titled The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet. In this tragedy, the concept that is discussed and portrayed through the characters is love, as they are recognized as being “in love”. The general umbrella of love encompasses various kinds of love such as romantic love, the love of a parent for a child, love of one’s country, and several others. What is common to all love is this: Your own well-being is tied up with that of someone (or something

Is Romeo and Juliet a True Love Story?

873 words - 4 pages Everybody has heard of the famous play Romeo and Juliet by William Shakespeare but, hardly anyone knows that it was not a love story. For years there has been a debate whether or not Romeo and Juliet is actually a love story. Romeo and Juliet is not considered a true love story, according to many sources because it does not follow the guidelines of a true love story, Romeo and Juliet are too young to know what love is and cultural traditions

Love is Evil: A Midsummer Night’s Dream by Williams Shakespeare

1142 words - 5 pages “There is no evil angel but Love.” While that specific quote is from one of William Shakespeare’s plays A Midsummer Night’s Dream, love has been the evil mastermind behind several, if not all, of Shakespeare’s infamous tragedies. Take Hamlet for example; the tragedy of Hamlet would not be a tragedy if it were not for anguished love. Feeling, seeing, hearing, and ultimately experiencing love can have multiple effects on a person, or many

Is there such a thing as true love?

928 words - 4 pages job. After publishing his books, Fitzgerald acquired a great deal of wealth and fame, then he was allowed to marry Zelda. Wealth is the key to a happy life along with love, however, love alone cannot provide happiness in marriage. Despite having loved Gatsby, Daisy has ended their relationship because Gatsby cannot provide her luxurious gifts, like the pearls that Tom bought her. After five years, Gatsby and Daisy have met and he has been changing

Romantic Love is a Poor Basis for Marriage

712 words - 3 pages Romantic love is a poor basis for marriage because love is simply a result of a stimulated limbic system, a stable relationship cannot rely solely upon affection, financial stability is more important than an emotion that can fade, a couple must have similar goals in life, and finally because a couple must share similar cultural and moral backgrounds. Marrying because of romantic love is ill-fated because love is merely an emotion, and emotions

Similar Essays

Influences Of Love: A Comparison Of William Shakespeare And Max Martin

1585 words - 7 pages and breathing creature. Songs and poems have been written about love for hundreds and thousands of years. Love has been around since the beginning of time, whether someone believes in the Big Bang or Adam and Eve. Without love, there wouldn’t be a world like it is known today. But with love, comes pain with it. Both William Shakespeare and Max Martin know and knew this. Both ingenious poets wrote love songs of pain and suffering as well as

Love Is A Powerful Thing Essay

782 words - 4 pages The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet was one of shakespeare's most well known plays. The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet is a play about two star-crossed lovers that are fated to hate each other because of their families. Romeo who was a Montague and Juliet who was a Capulet, clearly they were not meant to be together, but they were so madly in love that they were determined to be together and were not going to let anything stop them. It obviously

Love Is A Bumpy Road! Essay

2312 words - 10 pages Whoever said that true love is a smooth road traveled, has never experienced true love in their life! When you truly love someone, you learn to accept all of their ways of being and every obstacle they experience in life, you make a choice to live and experience with them as well. There was a time in my life where my husband had a huge bridge to cross. I had to make a decision for myself as to how much I loved this man, and if this situation was

A World Where Love Is A Skill

711 words - 3 pages Love has a diverse definition for each and every one of us which makes us restless in pursuing its true significance. We chase after love and hope to find reciprocation within the relationship. Some find themselves with the right one while others ended up getting hurt. Relationships can be easily acquired but who knows, it is also easy to change through time. Elbi Pie is an imperfect world, but its people who truly love find rest in those they