Is The Nature Of Crime In Our Society Accurately Presented By The Media? Discuss

1656 words - 7 pages

Untitled

Is the nature of crime in our society accurately presented by the media? Discuss.

Introduction

A considerable amount of literature consistently argues that the way crime is portrayed in the media significantly differs from what official records and research tell us, that is to say, that the media is said to misrepresent the crime problem. Five main arguments are presented demonstrating that the media distorts the crime problem. First, the media tend to report on crimes that are considered `newsworthy.' Second, it is argued that the media's role is that of an agenda-setter. Third, media reporting on crime is supportive of law enforcement agencies but is negative towards courts. Fourth, the media reports on crime that escalates public anxiety to such an extent that it can lead to moral panic about particular crimes. Fifth, stereotypes of both victims and offenders dominate media representations of crime. It is believed that the media is the public's primary source of knowledge about crime and it has exploited this by inaccurately presenting the nature of crime to our society.

Discussion

The first argument supporting that the media distorts the crime problem is that the reporting of crime is selective and the types of crimes reported in the media are those deemed `newsworthy.' Media compete in a marketplace to attract as large an audience as possible as they are profit orientated organisations. Consequently, crimes are selectively reported and are generally reported in ways that conform to news values of the immediate, the novel, the dramatic, and so on, which reinforce already established images of threat from crime. The assumption that the volume of crime is high and rising is one of the main arguments advanced by society. In Australia, studies have shown that a substantial proportion of the population incorrectly believe that crime rates are increasing when, in fact, they are stable or declining (Indermaur D & Roberts L, 2005). The discrepancy between the crime rate and the public's perceived crime rate has been commonly attributed to the expansive media coverage of crime, especially violent and more sensationalised crime (Duffy B, 2008). The media is the primary source of indirect knowledge of the crime problem and by selectively presenting crime to society in a dramatised and sensationalized manner; it has lead to the myth that the volume of crime is high and rising.

The second line of reasoning is that some contend that the media's construction of crime is more than just selective, it is that of an agenda-setter (Surette R, 1996). As an agenda-setter, the media defines the problem of crime in a way that sets parameters of discussion and debate. The impact of agenda-setting is that only some types of crime are brought to the public's attention and in the same way, only some kinds of criminal justice responses are presented as solutions to control crime. Research has found that the media reports the nature of...

Find Another Essay On Is the nature of crime in our society accurately presented by the media? Discuss

How the Media Influences Our Society

1347 words - 5 pages confesses that he has fantasized about killing someone since the eighth grade (Shahid 1). With one violent television show alone tied to two recent murders, it is safe to say that the media has impacted on the amount of violence in our society. It not only affects adults, but also teens and kids. Someone could argue that both Andrew Conley and Mark Twitchell are psychologically disturbed, but they each personally stated that they were inspired by the

Nature vs. Nurture: Virtues in our Society

1155 words - 5 pages musical training building moral character, he often sung his wisdoms, he once said; “Let a man be stimulated by poetry, established by the rules of propriety, perfected by music.” Taoism is an Eastern philosophy is “harmony with nature.” The main goal of this philosophy is to get outside ourselves and have “intimate connection with our inborn nature” (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). The origins of character education were incorporated in

Global and Local Issues Underlying the Corporations and the Media in our Society

1582 words - 6 pages while only 49 are countries. The advantage of having a corporation over being an individual investing in trade voyages etc, was that an individual's debts could be inherited by descendants. Corporations had therefore the potential, from the onset, to become very powerful. There is much recognized and unrecognized corporate influence in our lives. Indeed, much of western culture and increasingly, around the world, consumerism is expanding. Like for

This Essay, Bad Advertising, Is About The Effect The Media Has On Children In Our Society Today. It Specifically Focuses On Television Watching

889 words - 4 pages Extensive viewing of violent programs on television can lead to aggression in children. Children watch an average of three to four hours a televison a day. Television is a powerful influence in shaping behavior and developing value systems. It may lead to a gradual acceptance of violence, imitation of violence, and the identification of violence within themselves.The more a child views a violent television program the more they will become

"The Human Rights act for ever changes the nature of British society, marking a major turning point in British Constitutional history." Discuss

2358 words - 9 pages having in principle no different status from that of any other statute' and whose effects, can not be considered so 'far-reaching.' This essay will seek to identify the effects that the Act will have on both our constitution and our lives as British citizens.Ostensibly, the Human Rights Act 1998 purports to confer upon British citizens 'rights'. It would seem appropriate therefore, if first, we explore exactly what is meant by the word 'rights

Human Nature and society presented through Huckleberry Finn

888 words - 4 pages Human Nature and Society presented through Huckleberry Finn Mark Twain opposed many of the ideologies of his time. Through his novel Huckleberry Finn, he explored human nature and the society. He made apparent his dislike for them. The book focus’s on the general treatment of black people during this time. Specifically, the author criticizes morality, slavery and racism. The characters encountered in Huckleberry Finn do not have very high

Kurt Vonnegut's "Harrison Bergeron" -- A story symbolic of the oppression inherent in society, and the depths to which it pervades our lives through the media, politics, and popular culture

1494 words - 6 pages many times after, I have come to realize that there are more parallels between the story and our contemporary society than I had ever thought to consider; today, in 2004, American society is figuratively employing the same controls and constraints used literally in Vonnegut's imaginary 2038.The last fifty years or so of American history have seen significant changes in media image, methods of creative expression, and levels of government control

To What Extent Do Current Crime Statistics Reflect Criminal and Deviant Behaviour in Our British Society

1680 words - 7 pages . Hagan uses the term Consensus Crimes, as there is an overall consensus in society that these crimes are the most heinous. Hagan entitles the second category as Conflict Crime; these include crimes such as prostitution, drug abuse, or illegal abortions. Hagan believes that crimes in this category are treated less seriously by society, but are still crimes nonetheless (Sociology, 2014). Deviance is behaviour that violates the norms of society

To What Extent Do Current Crime Statistics Reflect Criminal and Deviant Behaviour in Our British Society

864 words - 4 pages . Hagan uses the term Consensus Crimes, as there is an overall consensus in society that these are the worse kind. Hagan entitles the second category as Conflict Crime, these include crimes such as prostitution, drug abuse or illegal abortions. Hagan believes that crimes in this category are treated less seriously by society, but are still crimes nonetheless (Sociology, 2014). Deviance is behaviour that violates the norms of society, such

This research paper is on advertising and alcohol. There are facts about how media and advertising portrays alcohol in our society today

1308 words - 5 pages the usage of alcohol by adolescents?Ultimately, underage drinking is a serious problem in American society today. Campaigns against tobacco and drug use have proved effective. For example, in December 2000, The Brown University Child and Adolescent Abuse Letter stated that tobacco use among younger adolescents has been steadily decreasing. Reasons for this can be attributed towards ?comprehensive, sustainable, and accountable tobacco-control

Does Media have too much control over our society today?

902 words - 4 pages exposed. They are starting to take it too far. Nothing is a secret anymore for anybody, and people do not realize that anything they put on the internet or television cannot be taken back. With thousands of channels on television, there are so many biased opinions which are being talked about every day. Media has a major role in human’s lives today. Throughout the day, people are surrounded by the media in some form, whether they realize it or

Similar Essays

The Hillside Stranglers By Darcy O'brien. Crime Is The Biggest Problem Facing Our Society Today

1580 words - 6 pages Crime in its many facets, is the biggest problem facing our society. Today society's outrage to crime is misplaced. However a serial killer's act may contribute to society's outrage, and the outrage should be directed towards the prevention of crime. Crime has actually become acceptable to many. As a result, we are becoming immune to crime.People disagree on crime prevention. Some argue that the death penalty is a deterrent - a way of making

Crime In Our Society Essay

832 words - 3 pages The task of fighting crime is becoming more complex, and therefore more challenging. Criminals are becoming more organised and sophisticated, operating with little regard for national boundaries.What is Crime?Crime has so many faces, and is perpetrated by people at so many different levels of our society that you may ask yourself what exactly it is.The answer is simple; crime is any activity in conflict with a just law - laws made to protect the

The Interconnected Nature Of Media, Culture And Society

1912 words - 8 pages taking new proportions, the media is becoming marginally out of control. The period in which we live is frequently differentiated by reference to the prevalence of the media in our society, such as words like ‘information’ and ‘communication’ are used conversely to describe the age in which we live.(Williams, K. 2001). Approaches which appear to historical context are essential to the continuous assessment and evaluation of the media’s role in

Discuss The Relationship Between Crime And The Mass Media By Looking At Relevant Literature And Examples

2383 words - 10 pages , 2013). This could be due to the advancements in technology e.g. CCTV and even policing. However, half of these offences were theft related. As technology advances, theft increases. Social class is an important factor in today’s society and no one wants to be seen as being ‘poor’. As unemployment rates have increased over the years, people find it easier to turn to crime rather than to get a job. The media tend to stereotype those who are