‘Mc Ewan Suggests That True Atonement For Ones Crimes Can Never Be Possible.’ St James Year 13 Essay

987 words - 4 pages

‘McEwan suggests that true atonement for ones crimes can never be possible.’ To what extent do you agree with this view? Remember to include in your answer relevant detailed exploration of McEwan’s methods
The novel itself serves as a palimpsest to the truth of Briony’s crime, which demonstrates the artificiality of Briony’s attempt of atonement. Ultimately due to the fact resolution and atonement are only depicted in the ‘novels’ with in the book which are written purely for an audience suggests that McEwan believes, similarly to the ‘hairline cracks’ of the vase- that repenting for ones crimes is impossible. So, instead of the notion that McEwan is suggesting that atonement in itself is impossible, he provokes the idea that, authors use literature to demonstrate their own art rather than pose questions on morality; this is shown by the fact that at the end of the book, Briony feels accomplished in the fact she ‘finally put her pen down,’ despite the fact none of her actual crimes have been repented for- this mirrors her childhood glee upon the acknowledgement of her ‘own handwriting’ covering loads of pieces of paper, when she first wrote the ‘Tales of Arabella’. It is the reuccurance of this play towards the end of Briony’s life that introduces the notion that by attempting this atonement Briony has instead found herself in a purgatory in which she is incapable of escaping her mistakes and her conceit as a writer.
When considering the notion that ‘true atonement for ones crimes can never be possible,’ one is also reminded of the other crimes McEwan depicts in the novel, namely those committed by Lord and Lady Marshal- the rapist and his silent victim. Lola in not speaking out perpetrates her crime so atonement is inherently impossible, this is because even the only victim to the crime who in capable of speaking out deliberately chooses not to. And by marrying the villain she demonstrates her knowledge of the ‘right side to butter her bread’- which explicitly establishes justice as impossible. Further more through the couple’s marriage in a Christian church, Lola and marshal are rendered ‘immune’ because sacraments of Christianity prevent: Lola being able to testify against her newly wed, and justice from being achieved. This reiterates the notion that atonement is impossible as McEwan suggests that victims to crimes are in fact capable of perpetrating the crimes committed by the villain, so therefore no efforts of atonement can restore the world.
The unjust nature of the world is emphasised in the contrast between Marshal and Briony’s fate. McEwan demonstrates implicit sympathy for Briony and the crime of deception she commits as a child, especially compared with the adult Paul Marshall who is the rapist and who is never punished- this is shown in the fact Briony has lived a copiously unfulfilling life forever held back by the remorse for her childhood crimes and on the brink of...

Find Another Essay On ‘McEwan suggests that true atonement for ones crimes can never be possible.’ - st james year 13 - essay

Discuss the changing business environmental factors that can have possible effects on the operation, use and development of HRIS

1358 words - 5 pages affordable and are designed and developed to have a user-friendly, GUI-based interface that is more Windows-like for ease of use as new technology often represents a major organizational change that can affect job activities and staff morale. With the advancement in processing speed and storage capacity, current computerized HRIS are more secure, and can easily be accessed by different departments of an organisation via Local Area Network (LAN

Can we say that the selection of the best and able and then educating them to become true leaders is better than popular vote to choose leaders?

1580 words - 7 pages made by popular vote, every person will have the freedom of expression. We know that election has many problems and disadvantages. As an example, nowadays, politicians spend an enormous amount of money on their election campaign in order to take a position of a leader. However, this money could be spent to achieve better ends; for example, it can be spent for education of children and opening factories thus creating more job places. Is it

Criminal Offenses and Possible Reasons for Crimes

2057 words - 9 pages time. This gave rise to the law and order discussion that is still prevalent and can be easily observed in many election canvassing. More and more politicians were making use of crime as a political matter that could draw votes plus there was the change from trying to comprehend criminals more willingly than held them responsible, in order to stress on pre-emptive measures in addition to efforts to eliminate crimes. Perchance, the chief

Can True Happiness be Achieved?

877 words - 4 pages most humans cannot be truly happy. In fact, the search for true happiness is a never ending struggle. Therefore, taking a look into why we can't find happiness, can perhaps be explained by the reasons of why we suffer. The human nature is a cycle, where there is birth, growth, and death, but in between all of that, there is more suffering than happiness. Take the following philosopher for example; Buddha, a rich prince that while shielded from all

Essay responding to topic Education and Myself. Impossible can be possible

920 words - 4 pages Impossible can be possibleMemory is a strange thing. When I’ve been there, looks like I have never paid attention to surroundings. I never thought all that even a trifle will stay in my memory and after four years I still remembered everything as it was just yesterday. That day I thought only about myself and about my final thesis those were mandatory in order to graduate. Everything was complicated. So I did not care about landscape or

This is a description essay that I will be submitting this evening. Any comments or suggestions will be appreciated. Please excuse me for omitting true names

670 words - 3 pages August day as the camera captured the sheer perfection of her, and knowing that no cherub could exude such radiance, I thought for sure my heart would burst at the seams with pride. Its no wonder people stopped me on the streets to tell me what a gorgeous child I had. Their kind words only confirmed what we already knew, but never tired of hearing through the years.Flipping through the worn album, I realize how quickly the time has gone since that day

Should Governments be Punished for the Crimes that were committed during wars?

1083 words - 5 pages imprisoned. Many countries hurt other countries and the best way to hurt a country severely is by killing the most important thing in it, which is their "People". Some countries were punished for the crimes that they have committed against humanity. So the question is "Should Governments Still be Punished for the Crimes that were committed during wars?" The first person that comes to our minds when we think of world war two would be Adolf Hitler

Tyranny can Never be Completely Removed

1709 words - 7 pages equality when one class decides to jump over the rest? ?The animals form themselves into two factions (for Snowball or Napoleon)? (65). The election for a leader with eligible candidates being two pigs is obviously not right in the sense that all animals are supposedly equal. Pigs will be favored whether it is Snowball or Napoleon who wins the ?election?. All animals can?t be equal when there is a leader who has supreme power over the rest. Parallel

The Bridge That Will Never Be

1154 words - 5 pages seated area that allowed someone to get out of the wind and still be able to see out. As an adult, I no longer have this glowing admiration for the ferry services in Surry. It never fails that when I am approaching the dock; the ferry is pulling away. Thereafter, it will be at least a thirty-minute wait for the next ferry to arrive. As well as, the actual ride across which could be an additional thirty minutes depending on which ferry pulls into the

Never Will Be That Redhead Barbie Doll

1132 words - 5 pages known for their beauty, a beauty that most of us women will never get to reach. Black Barbies have been created, but the only thing that changed was the skin tone as well as Hispanic Barbies. Cisneros could have created this to show that it doesn’t matter how hard Clemencia tries to be like Megan, she never could, just like a Barbie doll, us women can never look like those commercialized plastic toy beauties. Envy is not be the narrator’s main

Law national admissions test: Law essay - year 13 - Essay

605 words - 3 pages can afford to contribute at all. The debts that students incur after university is ridiculous and this issue must be resolved immediately. Students should make contributions to their degree since they now receive a higher level of education and are taught by exceptional professionals. The outstanding resources and teaching offered by many universities is expensive, the time and effort aimed at giving students the finest education is priceless

Similar Essays

Why Does Plato Argue That Divine Commands Can Never Be Genuinely Moral Commands? Do You Agree?

823 words - 3 pages From the Euthyphro dilemma, Plato argues that divine commands can never be genuinely moral. The divine commands are those belonging or coming from God. This argument stems from the idea that because God is omnipotent, omniscient that he will punish us when he detects any failures. Thus suggesting that the fear that motivates us to follow such divine commands is not a suitable motive to a certain moral action. Another argument that Plato presents

St. James Food Pantry: How Homeless Can Occur

1087 words - 4 pages serves the 60605 and 16 zip codes. As an African American female, being a part of society middle-low class, I was shock to see that it was other races especially Asians, coming into the facility for help. I was shock to see Asians coming into the facility because in the media African Americans are the ones depicted to need assistance not Asians. However, volunteering at St. James showed that all races need help, not one more than other. Walking

Various Groups In Which Industrial Activities Can Be Divided Dmi St John The Baptist University Second Year First Semester Assignment

1787 words - 8 pages light of principles, like that of light-houses guides, only those who know the way into port. He listed and described fourteen principles of management. The principles are as follows 1)Division of Work; where Fayol has advocated it to take the advantages of specialization. This principle can be applied at all levels of the organization for higher productivity. 2)Authority and Responsibility; which is the corollary of authority and arises from it

How Can Researchers Ensure That Their Research Reaches As Wide An Audience As Possible?

1877 words - 8 pages permit immediate open public access to peer review in a way that does not substantially threaten the viability of the journal’s article or published books; A new open-sharing culture must be cultivated, and in particular the idea that research work is not and has never been for financial gain, even though a system of financial and other kind of rewards (holidays, bureaucratic shortcuts and so on) can be a legitimate way to promote this behaviour aimed at reaching the widest possible audience.