Meaning, Understanding, And The Politics Of Interpretation

2599 words - 10 pages

Meaning, Understanding, and the Politics of Interpretation

ABSTRACT: In his essay "The Politics of Interpretation: Spinoza's Modernist Turn," Berel Lang attributes to Spinoza the view that interpretation presupposes or implies a political framework-in effect, that interpretation is itself a politics. The thrust of Spinoza's argument is against "interpretation from authority," i.e., against the view that the meaning of a text can be determined by an external authority. Understanding cannot be coerced, according to Spinoza. In my paper I attempt to make the relationship between reader and text even more direct and "free" than it is in Spinoza. I argue that any approach (such as Derrida's) which posits an interpretation between reader and text places constraints on the notion of a democracy of free readers. I argue that in a truly literate democracy readers have the right to claim that they have understood or grasped their texts without having any kind of intermediary placed between themselves and their texts, regardless of whether this intermediary takes the form of an external authority (in Spinoza's sense) or an interpretation (in Derrida's sense). In the course of the paper I draw upon Michael Dummett's philosophy of language in order to critique the "humpty-dymptyism" of the interpretationist school. I place myself firmly on the side of Alice in Through the Looking Glass, and spend some time discussing the significance of the difficulties which she experiences with the nonsense poem, "Jabberwocky."

Most philosophers of language who have referred to the confrontation between Alice and Humpty Dumpty in Chapter Six of Lewis Carroll's book, Through the Looking-Glass, have used that famous scenario to illustrate certain contrasting approaches to a philosophy of language. In general, most philosophers who cite the famous scenario tend to take the side of Alice against Humpty. I want to suggest, however, that, while Alice is right about something, she is also wrong about something. I want to suggest that she makes a mistake, not in her philosophy of language, but in her politics, especially the politics that surround the act and practice of reading. She makes a mistake not in the course of her defence of the objectivity or publicity of meaning, but in her acknowledgement of Humpty as a putative authority on meaning. She makes a mistake, one might say, about the nature of her rights and powers as a reader.

This mistake becomes apparent when we contrast the scenario in Chapter Six with a less famous but equally significant scenario that occurs in Chapter One of Carroll's book, a scenario which occurs shortly after Alice enters the Looking-Glass House. This is the scenario in which Alice first picks up and tries to read the text of the poem 'Jabberwocky'. At first glance it makes no kind of sense at all since it seems to be written in a strange language; then she realises that she knows the language after all, that the script of the text has...

Find Another Essay On Meaning, Understanding, and the Politics of Interpretation

Neotextual narrative and the interpretation of Stonehenge

2030 words - 8 pages subject is contextualised into a neotextual narrative that includes reality as a paradox. In light of this can it be said the Stonehenge is anything less than a Henge of Stone? "Language is part of the defining characteristic of culture," says Derrida. The main theme of Hubbard's[2] model of postcapitalist textual theory is the difference between society and sexual identity. Thus, Werther[3] implies that we have to choose between neotextual

Meaning Mishaps and the True Meaning of Art

1113 words - 4 pages Have you ever been confused about the purpose or meaning behind a certain piece of art? In my opinion, art is viewed many different ways. The artist will create a piece of art with a certain intended meaning, but it will most likely not be viewed in that way. When a spectator views a piece of art, they take into account their past experiences, and since everyone has gone through different things, their interpretations are different, as you can

How have the texts you have studied this year effectively shaped your understanding of the meaning of ?change?? Includes "The Door" by Miroslav Holub and others

1803 words - 7 pages How have the texts you have studied this year effectively shaped your understanding of the meaning of ?change??Word Count: 1380?Change? is a process that can have valuable or futile outcomes for the parties involved. The value of the outcome resulting from ?change? is determined by the dynamism of an individual or group in their ability to open their rationale to changes in perspective. This understanding of ?change? has been effectively shaped

The interpretation of dreams

677 words - 3 pages Many people often wonder why we have dreams and if they even mean anything. In Freud'sThe Interpretation of Dreams, he claims that dreams are indeed meaningful and the reason why they are is because dreams represent wish fulfillment. In The Interpretation of Dreams Freud goes into specific examples of why dreams convey unfulfilled wishes of the person that is having the dream. Freud's examples are crucial in this work because before it was

Interpretation of the Subconscious

851 words - 4 pages towards a society with more artificial intelligences, we need to be careful of the subconscious, of all living, and synthetic beings. Works Cited 1. I, Robot. Dir. Alex Proyas. Perf. Will Smith, Bridget Moynahan, Bruce Greenwood, Alan Tudyk, James Cromwell, Chi McBride. DVD. 20th Century Fox, 2004. 2. Locke, John. Essay Concerning Human Understanding. 27th ed. Vol. 1. London: T. Tegg and Son, 1836. 51. Books.google.ca. Oxford University, 16 May 2007. Web. 13 Nov. 2013.

The Meaning of The Mind and Soul

1059 words - 4 pages Death and immortality Since the times of Plato and before, humans have pondered the existence of a soul and the afterlife. I am going to present my argument for the existence of a soul and the potential for surviving one's physical death. For the purpose of my argument I will define that the meaning of the mind and soul are one and the same. The two main accepted views of the human condition are that of the physicalist and that of the dualist

The Meaning and Implication of Oral History

3290 words - 13 pages “traditionalist methodology and intellectual outlook of the established West German profession,” meaning they opposed the older historicist methods that focused on politics and diplomacy. The Bielefeld school, however, sought to explain history by analyzing society and history through “big structures, large processes, huge comparisons” and this is where Alltagsgeschichte diverges. Its goal was to develop a qualitative understanding by examining the material

Analysis and interpretation of the artwork of Durer and Grunewald

1159 words - 5 pages The late fifteenth and early sixteenth century saw the birth of two artist that were so drastically different in styles, they are still looked at in awe over 300 years later. Albrecht Durer and Matthias Grunewald each had their own style and influence in the way they completed their art. Durer remained essentially German; the influence of the art of Italy and the Netherlands was accompanying. Grunewald rejected Renaissance style and followed the

The Meaning of Life and Social Discourses

1512 words - 6 pages youngest ensign in his class, /he was the ‘old man’ of a gunboat on the Yangtze”, elevates Lowell over his father as he verbalises his father’s failures as the patriarch, reinvesting them with new significance and meaning. Thus, it is only in his dialogic relation to these men, and the spectral presence of the past that Lowell’s sense of self emerges and the ‘truth’ or meaning of his life is established, rather than Descartes’ understanding of a

The Meaning of Quantitative and Qualitative Research

1227 words - 5 pages The Meaning of Quantitative and Qualitative Research Quantitative and Qualitative are two different forms of research that complement each other either from a numerical standpoint or a descriptive one. Quantitative research comes from a numerical perspective and qualitative research comes from more of a descriptive perspective, though they cannot be described with these specific terms, they need to be elaborated on to get more of an overall

Sport, Education, and the Meaning of Victory

3385 words - 14 pages Sport, Education, and the Meaning of Victory Sport was included in ancient educational systems because it was thought to promote aretê or human excellence which could be applied to almost any endeavor in life. The goal of most modern scholastic athletic programs might be better summed up in a word: winning. Is this a sign that we have lost touch with the age-old rationale for including sport in education? I argue that it need not be by

Similar Essays

Understanding The Meaning Of Rhetoric Essay

2417 words - 10 pages ://www.pbs.org/wgbh/amex/macarthur/peopleevents/pandeAMEX96.html>. Rottenberg, Annette T., and Donna Haisty Winchell. Elements of Argument: A Text and Reader. 10th ed. Boston: Bedford/St. Martin’s, 2012. Print. Schiappa, Edward. Defining Reality: Definitions and the Politics of Meaning. Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois UP, 2003. "Truman Relieves MacArthur of Duties in Korea." History.com. A&E Television Networks, n.d. Web. 08 Dec. 2013. Vatz, Richard E. “The Myth of the Rhetorical Situation.” Philosophy & Rhetoric 6.3 (Summer 1973): 154-61. PDF.

Meaning, Interpretation, And Tension In Literature

1889 words - 8 pages interpretation. Each of these situations is like a different context, which could reveal a new sense. One area in which the possibility of the existence of more than one meaning or interpretation creates tension is literature. "Intention, text, context, reader – what determines meaning? Now the very fact that arguments are made for all four factors shows that meaning is complex and elusive, not something once and for all determined by any one of these

Media Analysis Assignment: Understanding The Meaning Of Islam

1680 words - 7 pages Among the most prominent of the world's many religions is Islam, which today is the cause of great controversy within our society. To understand the multiple meanings that Islam conveys one must ask: "What is the meaning of Islam?" The essence of the religion has been sought after by many scholars, and it is widely believed that the religion is based on one's own interpretation of the Quran, the Islamic holy book. The significance of my analysis

Dream Interpretation Of The Unconscience And Subconscience

741 words - 3 pages An important procedure for gaining data on the unconscious and subconscious mind is through the analysis of dreams (Butcher, 2013). While sleeping, a person’s mental defensive filters are lowered. Therefore, forbidden desires such as sex and emotional feelings of repression may find themselves into a clients dream. The mind interprets this unconscious cognition and disguises these feelings into symbolism. (2013) This is why dream interpretation