This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Mechanistic Versus Organic Organisational Structures. Essay

1282 words - 5 pages

In this vast growing global economy, organizations are often confrontedwith increasing instability due to continuous changes in technology, an influx ofcompetition and rapidly changing customer needs. With respect to this it is imperativethat organizations respond to required or forced changes to their environment if the firmsexisting goals are to be achieved.With this in mind, organizations turn to management to combat the budding problem, through organizing. Organizing involves the structuring of the resources of the organization in order to achieve its objectives. This structuring includes:*Dividing tasks into jobs (Adam Smith 1700's).*Assigning jobs.*Clustering of jobs into units, departments etc. to form the shape of the organization.*Delegating authority and establishing a chain of command.However, we cannot see the management function of organizing as the sole function of the manager, in order to combat these changes (individuals and groups in organizations will inevitably contribute to organizing the organization by the way they "do" or "don't do" activities). Organizing involves the way people impose meanings, interpret actions and make responses to things, when they cannot make sense of these things; people reinterpret them according to their own views and often try to impose them on others. Therefore, the organizational structure is strengthened, through various means for example performance appraisal, different pay rates etc.In light of this, they are many factors to consider for organizations to design the type of structure which best suits the way they wish to achieve their goals. What design is finally agreed upon depends on a number of decisions such as:*Do we want/need to decentralize decision making.*Are they needs to deal with problems such as the effect of structure on communications; staff/line conflict especially the tension between employees and experts and line managers; centralization versus decentralization etc.This leads to the most important question, which design options should be considered, but before considering however, there are a number of variables which need to be taken into account with design options such as strategy, size, technology and the environment surrounding the organization before any decisions can be made.Although these differences between organizations or enormous, they are many similarities that enable them to be classified into models. Two of these extreme models are mechanistic and organic which was developed by Tom Burns & G M Stalker in there study of electronics firms in the United Kingdom.Mechanistic and organic management systems are at opposite ends of the range of design systems that organizations adopt, firms can move along this range from one end to the other, or occupy positions in between (boundaryless organization) depending on the nature of there work, and changing circumstances. The kinds of practices organizations choose along the range vary according to whether the...

Find Another Essay On Mechanistic versus Organic Organisational Structures.

Remuneration and Performance Management System Essay

1926 words - 8 pages pay structures and status recognition (Milkovich, Newman, Gerhart, 2011). However, grouping countries into cultural categories depending on their values is highly stereotypical as it does not account for differences within nations (Milkovich, Newman, Gerhart, 2011). It would be better to use a ‘best fit’ strategic alignment based on whether the business strategy is a prospector, analyser or defender, if the organisational structure needs to be

The Definition of Organizational Culture Essay

1044 words - 4 pages creates the culture or the personality of the business. The definition of organizational culture is ‘The shared values, principles, traditions, and ways of doing things that influence the way organizational members act’ (Robbins, Decenzo, & Coulter, 2013, p. 39). Structures can be some form of either a Mechanistic or an Organic formation. Mechanistic structures are a top down organization, which is more formal, using the traditional chain of

Critically assess the degree to which contingency approaches can provide guidance in designing effective organisations

1469 words - 6 pages organisational model as the optimum one, which promoted a militaristic, mechanistic organisation, which stressed discipline, command and order through six managerial activities ~ Forecasting, Planning, Organizing, Commanding, Co-ordinating and Controlling.2, The Contingency ApproachThis approach has been popularised since the 1950's and 1960's, and was a reaction to the traditional management thinking of Taylor, Weber and Fayol. Which although

Critically assess the degree to which contingency approaches can provide guidance in designing effective organisations

1456 words - 6 pages organisational model as the optimum one, which promoted a militaristic, mechanistic organisation, which stressed discipline, command and order through six managerial activities ~ Forecasting, Planning, Organizing, Commanding, Co-ordinating and Controlling.2, The Contingency ApproachThis approach has been popularised since the 1950's and 1960's, and was a reaction to the traditional management thinking of Taylor, Weber and Fayol. Which although

Leadership, a gender comparison

1360 words - 6 pages willing participation in the organisation hence the aim of all organisational structures is to allow people and groups to cooperate and work together effectively to meet goals and objectives. Organic structures have a more decentralised authority, loosely defined tasks with greater individual authority and horizontal communications characterised by flexibility and adaptability. However this model is rare and is found mostly in new industries

Organizational Management

1634 words - 7 pages activities, clear lines of communication, coordination and control. Some organizations do well by combining mechanistic and organic structures “Units that have a more stable environment, such as routine, administrative departments, may favor a mechanistic structure” (Helms, M., Cengage, G., 2006) and sales, research and development perform better in the organic structure. Describe managerial skills and behaviors that would be required to manage

A Comparison of Classical Management Theorists and Contingency Theorists

2360 words - 9 pages context is identified by Robbins and Barnwell (2002) as everything outside an organisation?s boundaries. Burns and Stalker (1961) established the distinction between ?mechanistic? and ?organic? approaches to an organization and its environment. The management practices of 20 manfacturing concerns in Scotland and England were compared with respect to the stability of their environments as deternined by rate of change in the relevant markets and

Leadership: Succeeding in the IT Sector

2492 words - 10 pages satisfaction (Fontaine, 2007). The structural design affects; morale and job satisfaction of individuals in the organisations, also the way individuals behave, therefore should encourage willing participation in the organisation hence the aim of all organisational structures is to allow people and groups to cooperate and work together effectively to meet goals/objectives. Traditional hierarchical model viewed as slow mechanistic with centralised control

Organizational effectiveness depends largely on the degree of "fit" between an organisation's structure and its environment

1170 words - 5 pages was assumed to apply in all organizations.1. L. J. Mullins, Management and Organisational Behaviour, 4th Edition, page 10.The next model was Weber's Bureaucracy theory in which the organisation's structure contains a high level of specialization of duties and roles characterized by high levels of formalization. Its assumptions relied on the division of work by experts, a formal chain of command, rules and procedures to be applied impersonally

Management control system

3032 words - 12 pages of a social and pleasant shine.The Mechanistic type of control applied in the two organisations, do not appear to be the appropriate application of this Mechanistic type of control.TECHNICAL CONTROLSThe USE OF Technical controls is more common at PH&R than at the OUW. At PH&R technical controls are used operationally. At OUW technical controls are used to access financial information. Given the respective organisational contexts the, the

organization structure

3968 words - 16 pages PART FOUR CHAPTER TEN Organizational Structure and Design 10 Lecture Outline Introduction Defining Organizational Structure Work Specialization Departmentalization Chain of Command Span of Control Centralization and Decentralization Formalization Organizational Design Decisions Mechanistic and Organic Organizations Contingency Factors Strategy and Structure Size and Structure Technology and Structure Environmental

Similar Essays

Different Types Of Structures Within An Organization

1812 words - 7 pages form an organization. Based on the organization's goals and objectives it may be structured in various ways. This structure includes two important mechanistic and organic structures. Organic structures used in organizations with an unstable environment and must have the ability to change accordingly. They have the ability to process, analyze and disseminate information and knowledge quickly. This proves that they remain competitive than other

Organizational Culture And Structure Essay

1503 words - 6 pages utilize to structure the elements within the organization. The structure of an organization can be divided into two generic organization structure models. Below is a chart as presented by Robbins et al. (2013) (see Figure 1), that outlines the characteristics of a mechanistic organization versus an organic organization. Mechanistic Organic Rigid hierarchal relationships Vertical and horizontal collaboration Fixed duties Adaptable duties Many

Relationship Among Organisational Theory, Design, Culture, Structure And Design And How They Contribute To The Organisation

2322 words - 9 pages structure is integrally related to the evolution of its culture and vice versa. Mechanistic structures and organic structures, for example, give rise to totally different sets of cultural values. In a tall, centralised organisation, people have relatively little personal autonomy, and desirable behaviours include being cautious, obeying superior authority, and respecting traditions. Thus, mechanistic structure is likely to give rise to a culture in

Case Study On Mayne Nickless

1301 words - 5 pages .costly.html>Business Expansion, 2005, Encyclopedia in Small Business, viewed April 13. 2007Gemmy, A 1998, Organising Process, Management Model, viewed April 12, 2007.Lloyd, A & Zorab, J, 1995, Management for doctors, MBJ, viewed April 12, 2007< http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/310/6978/514>Organic vs Mechanistic Structures, viewed April 12, 2007Sherma, S 2001, Organisational structures, University of Toronto, viewed April 13, 2007.Wikipedia, 2007, Organising, Wikimedia Foundation Inc, US, viewed April 10, 2007.