Mediation: An Ethical Consideration Essay

1264 words - 5 pages

V. Impinging of the Role of the Mediator by Mandated Reporting
Mandated reporting for mediators will impact the Model Standards. If mandated reporting is implemented for mediators, the Model Standards will be impacted. Specifically, issues arise regarding the quality of the process, mediator impartiality and confidentiality. Reporting allegations and/or suspicions will distract from the true purpose of mediation.
According to the Model Standards, a mediator can report ongoing crime. Mediators are already permissive reporters. Mandated reporting laws were developed to require reporting of abuse or neglect by professionals that took an affirmative duty to protect vulnerable individuals. Mediators have not accepted this duty and should not be required to report all instances of abuse or neglect. Furthermore, mediators in court connected mediation are already deemed mandated reporters.
In family law, false allegations are made. A question is presented as to what type of evidence the mediator would need to make a report. Questionably, the standards would need to be evaluated to determine if they should be the same as say a psychiatrist. A psychiatrist would know the individual and would know if the threated action is plausible. A mediator might spend a few hours or even a few days on one case whereas a psychiatrist usually has a longer relationship with the potential perpetrator. Professionals required to report are better trained to make these reports.
Furthermore, a reporting requirement would hinder effective communication between parties. Participants cannot speak candidly and might even hold back on relevant information for fear that the information might be used against them in some type of way. A woman might not report the abusive husband even though both parties are aware of it. The woman could fear for her life if the soon to be ex-husband could face criminal charges because of her allegation. However, this information might help the mediator resolve the dispute between the parties or explain why the woman is so adamant about no visitation for her estranged husband.
Another concern would be whether or not a mediator could remain impartial. Would the allegations cause the mediator to recuse himself from the mediation? In some cases, the mediator would feel biased and would not have a choice but to end the mediation leaving parties to either find a new mediator or pursue the case using traditional means. The truth of the allegation would not necessarily matter if the mediator believed that it would reasonably be true. Also, if the mediator did report the mediation, the accused party might feel betrayed by the mediator in some way. This would take away from the integrity of the mediator. The participants would lose the ability to determine the outcome of the mediation. The parties would still have their dispute, investigations would take place, and the mediator would lose the mediation.
VI. Mediators Furtherance of California Law Through...

Find Another Essay On Mediation: An Ethical Consideration

A Balance Between Rehabilitation and Punitive Justice Systems

3005 words - 13 pages practice: victim-offender mediation. Because, it focuses on both the victim and the offender and actually implies an interaction between both parties, analysing victim-offender mediation is the best way to assess the impact of restorative justice as a whole. Victim-offender mediation emanated from Canada, in Ontario precisely where in the early 1970s, two young offenders who committed vandalism were asked to meet the victims their crime had

The Process of Victim Offender Mediation

1444 words - 6 pages the offender will often, for the first time, realize the level of emotional trauma caused by his or her criminal conduct. During the meeting, the offender also discusses his or her views about the crime, and this discussion will often finish in an expression of remorse for the harm that the offender has caused. In a case referred to the Victim – Offender Mediation the participation of the victim in the mediation is voluntary, while the

Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)clause that can be used by a learning team to resolve disagreements among the learning team members

751 words - 3 pages potential conflicts that might arise among or between team members were disagreements over the appropriate steps acquired to complete the assignment or lack of contribution and participation from individual team members. One type of alternative dispute resolution that was used in my prior learning teams was mediation which was very useful and another method is medarb which will be later discussed by the writer.The writer designed an ADR clause that

International Mediation During the Siege of the Iranian Embassy vs. Egypt and Istrael Dispute

1935 words - 8 pages with the issue, but also the delegation consisted of four experienced and high-positioned professional negotiators. The siege of the embassy continued for 444 days, and ended on 20 January 1981 after successful mediation exhibited by Algerian representatives, all the hostages were finally released. In contrast, the dispute between Egypt and Israel was ongoing for many years and there was no real urgency to solve issue. It was an initiative of newly

Riordan Corporate Compliance Plan August 2010 Business Law 531

1894 words - 8 pages dispute, will determine a resolution within 24 hours (not to exceed 7 days total for the dispute processes). All parties acknowledge and agree to abide by this dispute resolution determined by the appoint mediator and all terms contained herein"] (Accord Mediation).Enterprise LiabilityLiability or secondary liability states that individuals within an organization can be held liable for actions in conjunction with Riordan Industries. Riordan

The Drawbacks and Disappointments of the Victim-Offender Mediation Program

2250 words - 9 pages restorative justice (RJ) system. According to RJ perspective, a crime is considered a conflict between individuals that result in harm to victims, communities, and offenders, and so these parties are also involved in responding to it. One of the prevalent programs of the RJ system is victim-offender mediation (VOM) program. VOM program is a process which provides interested victims an opportunity to meet the offender, in a safe and structured

Dispute Summary

846 words - 3 pages bringing legitimate claims (Don't coerce patients, 2004).Mediation is different from Arbitration: the mediator does not try to solve the dispute, but rather serves as an intermediary in the two party negotiations. If the agreement has not been reached, the parties can still go to court. A mediator is a neutral party, but in a different type of ADR - conciliation - an interested third party, a conciliator may be chosen to help resolution of the

Tough Guy Case Study Analysis

1816 words - 8 pages bullying, creating dialogue for recognition of common goals in hopes of diminishing feelings of perceived threat or misunderstanding (Seagriff, 2010). Three common types which should be considered are facilitative, transformative and evaluative mediation. Facilitative mediation involves active listening and the sharing of emotions so that each party, guided by the mediator, may develop an understanding of the issue(s) and each other (Seagriff, 2010

Corporate Compliance Plan For Riordan Manufacturing

2458 words - 10 pages company. Having the ability to capitalize on a risk or an event and then turning it into an opportunity can be a great asset to Riordan Manufacturing.Corporate Compliance Plan For Riordan ManufacturingOverviewAfter reviewing various departments, processes and documentation about Riordan Manufacturing, some improvements and changes might need consideration by the officers and directors of Riordan Manufacturing and Riordan Industries as a whole

Labor Relations

1150 words - 5 pages interests do not receive enough consideration from management. One response to this is to act collectively by forming and joining labor unions. An organization formed for representing members' interests in dealing with employers is a union. Labor relations is the management specialty emphasizing skills that managers and union leaders can use to minimize the costly forms of conflict and to seek win-win solutions to disagreements. (Noe, Hollenbeck

Corporate Social Responsibility

885 words - 4 pages differ, there will be a bigger difference when comparing a culture to another. Some examples of culture difference are how an individual is brought up with a different set of mindset, manners, perception, values, and food consumed. For business context, mediation techniques and corporate culture are the major issue. According to Mills et al. (2006), mediation which is done by a middle man of 2 parties must understand the background and culture

Similar Essays

Interview Essay

2163 words - 9 pages . According to Moore, mediation is an intervention in a conflict accepting a third party to assist in reaching mutually acceptable settlements (2003). Beer, Packard, & Stief (2012) define mediation as a process for resolving disputes where an intermediary helps conflicting parties have a conversation to jointly have a conversation. During the early years of mediation, the mediation movement expanded and developed to significantly high levels (Moore

Transformative Mediation Explored Essay

2470 words - 10 pages Introduction In life we are constantly facing an array of spiraling moments, whether it is a spiral in our thought processes, day to day events, or in our relationships. These spirals in life can either move in an upward or downward direction, upward being the more positive of the two. When taking a close look at the possible situations that could take place, there are moments when mediation is a necessary tool for problem solving. Firmly

Management Of The Employer Employee Relationship Essay

1634 words - 7 pages . Unnecessary conflict may be prevented through employee involvement and treating employees in a fair manner. Ethical employment practices, involving employees in decisions, and treating employees as valued organizational members all work towards a positive employer-employee relationship. Unfortunately, however, it sometimes becomes necessary for an outside party to help employers and employees resolve differences through processes such as mediation or

Mediation Case: Colectivists And Individualists Essay

1230 words - 5 pages them that she previously had an experience when she was able to arrange two cases concurrently and besides of that, she felt that she was reconciling parties of the first mediation. Thus, J and M agreed to start mediation that week. For the pre-mediation stage, S asked the parties to send the Pre-mediation Confidential Communication and the Mediation Planning Documents, indicating BATNA, WATNA and Reservation Price. The parties also were asked to