Mediation Case: Colectivists And Individualists Essay

1230 words - 5 pages

The mediator’s planning and preparation
J contacted S requesting that S serve as a mediator in their case and briefly explained the issues in dispute. S agreed but explained to both parties that she was about to settle another mediation case, so she asked whether they prefered to start mediation during that week or upon completions of the first mediation. J and M asked S if it could somehow affect the outcome of their mediation. S assured them that she previously had an experience when she was able to arrange two cases concurrently and besides of that, she felt that she was reconciling parties of the first mediation. Thus, J and M agreed to start mediation that week.
For the ...view middle of the document...

If their personal goal conflicts with a groups goals, they would prefer the majority’s interests rather than theirs. Collectivists usually less concerned about professional credentials and unbiasedness, but they may be concerned that the mediator be an insider, who understands and knows the parties. They prefer evaluative mediator who knows context of the issue and who could offer solutions that would reconcile parties and restore harmony in relations with people.
In contrast to collectivists, individualists believe personal value is in a high priority. Usually individualists prefer professional mediators who have special training courses in mediation. They expect that a mediator would be fair or impartial. Individualists project themselves as independent and only connected to a particular group of people of which they are a part. If their personal goal conflicts with others’ goals, they would prefer their own interests. Individualists expect that the participants involved in the dispute are the parties, who authorized to make decisions or get involved to the decision-making process, where the parties could draw a decision tree analysis. In contrast to individualists, collectivists might view members of their ingroup who are not directly involved as the parties to a dispute.
Actually cultural diversity in our life raises a question how we should interact with them and develop common understanding between us. Also, we should understand how a particular person from a different culture may behave in conflicts or negotiations. Every culture may include “outliers” who lives in one cultural group but his behavior might be significantly different from others. Therefore, we can not generalize how people from specific nation or culture could behave or think differently. Thus, in our case, we belief that M is outlier who adapted to American culture and S did not deal much with cultural diversity in the mediation.
In the first sight, S viewed M as a more powerful one who could influence the outcome of mediation or dictate under what conditions the dispute should be resolved. Only reason for that was, he was a sole wage earner and his company was mostly based on his expertise and skills. S acknowledge that power greatly could affects negotiations, and in such case, the mediator could have focused on how to move from a balance of power within mediation to a conflict-resolution approach.
In the power-balance context, the mediator could use common power-balancing techniques. S could ask the party with low power to explain her interests, needs or how she viewed things and M, who with high power, to listen carefully, limiting himself from using his strength to gain control over the party with low power. During the negotiation, the mediator also could insist...

Find Another Essay On Mediation Case: Colectivists and Individualists

Law Mediation Essay

1017 words - 5 pages There were many mediations that I observed and participate throughout this whole semester. It was really interesting to get a little taste of being a mediator, or the plaintiff and defendant. As far as I can remember the best mediation I took part off was probably when I was the defendant. The case dealt with two roommates that got into a heated argument about who was going receive gifts, or which one of the roommates where going help the other

CHildren in mediation Essay

689 words - 3 pages Should children be involved in mediation? What is the role of children in a divorce case? Should they come to court? Should they participate in mediation? When I began practicing law in 1987, it was not unusual for parents to bring their children to court, unprepared, to testify. Due to the harm that the children experienced, our committee that passed the first Rules of Procedure for Family Law Cases included a rule that limited

A Balance Between Rehabilitation and Punitive Justice Systems

3005 words - 13 pages UK and abroad, restorative justice had “substantially reduced repeat offending for some offenders but not all” . From this, mediation seems to have an impact without being completely satisfactory. However, in the same study it was found that mediation was more effective than prison in order to reduce recidivism in the case of young offenders and that is was as effective as prison in the case of adult offenders. Meetings of victim-offender

The Process of Victim Offender Mediation

1444 words - 6 pages the offender will often, for the first time, realize the level of emotional trauma caused by his or her criminal conduct. During the meeting, the offender also discusses his or her views about the crime, and this discussion will often finish in an expression of remorse for the harm that the offender has caused. In a case referred to the Victim – Offender Mediation the participation of the victim in the mediation is voluntary, while the

Mediation

1040 words - 4 pages "caucuses") are a major component of evaluative mediation. The focus of an evaluative mediation is primarily upon settlement. The mediators will make their best efforts to get the parties to compromise, if necessary, to achieve a result. (www.peoples-law.org)The specific outcome of a mediation process is dependent on the goals desired by each party and the style used in each case. There is not a "one size fits all" in conflict resolution in my mind

Civil procedure law reform

3488 words - 14 pages duty to facilitate the use of mediation when exercising its case-management pow- ers and for the parties to make use of mediation in appropriate cases for the settlement of their disputes. To what extent may the CJR and PD 31 change the practice of the courts in the administration of civil justice, and eventually affect the overall litigation culture in Hong Kong? Can the Court Order Unwilling Parties to Mediate? It's generally accepted that the

Features of The Litigation and Mediation Process

931 words - 4 pages . Legal representation additionally was found by the Australia Law Reform Commission to “assist the efficiency and efficacy of the civil justice system” . Along with Legal representation parties have full control of their case allowing them to feel in powerful and that their case is being presented in the best possible light. Mediation is a different process from traditional litigation for resolving disputes. Mediation is a form of ADR

Negotiation

1206 words - 5 pages This paper will cover the difference in the negotiation process and the mediation process and explore some of the barriers that hinder the processes. There is a distinct difference between the negotiation process and the mediation process. Negotiation as defined in Essentials of Negotiation is a process by which two or more parties attempt to resolve their opposing interests (Lewicki, Saunders, and Barry, ) The Negotiation process happens when

Dispute Resolution Processes

1425 words - 6 pages however used in nearly every area of human interaction. In some cases, mediation is a more useful and efficient alternative dispute resolution option. This is particularly the case if there is an on-going relationship between the parties (in either a direct or indirect way) and/or there is a relatively small amount of money in controversy. Mediation could be confidential and it allows for any creative settlement options that are satisfactory

The Goodman Conflict

1154 words - 5 pages opinion. Moore expresses that mediation involves using a mediator to extend bargaining with parties using various dynamics (2003). Goodman (2005) discussed on going over with each participating side on the strengths and weaknesses of their case. Mediators have the ability to help parties in conflict and not break down their viewpoints but to help them identify interests. Another thing I found interesting is that time limits are suggested for the

Wamu River Basin Project

3430 words - 14 pages a decision. The adjudication process is costly and does not present a win-win situation for all parties. Avoiding this process is the reason for ADR plans. Many times arbitration is the only alternative because the parties fail to agree to negotiate. WBMC may find itself using the judicial process. The purpose of the mediation plan is to1) confront the facts and issues in the case, 2) engage each other in a discussion of those issues, 3) analyze

Similar Essays

The Protection For Mediation Communications Essay

3208 words - 13 pages posthearing motions, conferences and discovery; or a legislative hearing as well as similar process. In the other words, the word “proceeding" encompasses the whole of the mediation process, simi¬lar to the word "case" in the litigation context. Therefore, any communication made or materials submitted in, or in connection with, the mediation proceeding, whether made or submitted to or by the mediator, a mediation organization, a party, or any

The Pros And Cons Of Alternative Dispute Resolution

3748 words - 15 pages nature of mandatory mediation does not allow parties divulge adequate information; • the system is so confidential that its confidentiality may hinder the complete development of a case thereby leaving some essential matters unresolved • Parties may pay higher cost overall if no settlement is reached. Argument on the Voluntary Nature of Mediation ADR techniques like mediation are intended to serve the public, as it is inexpensive and

Interview Essay

2163 words - 9 pages table of mediation, Another concern of Hartgering, with people in mediation field take on too many cases which gets them too busy and can get burned out quicker. He suggests that with every mediation case, a mediator must have a beginner’s mindset. Each case is different and every party has different experiences. Hartgering’s other future concern is that judges will use the option of mediation for divert cases to get away from dealing with the

Transformative Mediation Explored Essay

2470 words - 10 pages they are asking proper questions to clarify all points. (Brigg) Transformative Mediation as it relates to following Case Example Why Transformative Model? Transformative mediation would work for the conflict between colleagues, Alicia and Holly because it allows the both of them to share explicitly how they feel in the current situation. Through the transformative mediation model, Alicia and Holly can also process through their past