Medical Ethics In Drug Trials Essay

1316 words - 5 pages

Medical Ethics in Drug Trials
Thousands of people voluntarily enroll in clinical drug trials every year. They are putting their health and safety at risk by participating in a drug trial. One would think they would be doing this to promote medical advancement, but in all actuality, it is for the high dollar amounts they receive for compensation. People that frequently enroll in drug trials are often called “guinea pigs.” The monetary amount people are paid can go as high seventy-five hundred dollars. The more invasive the procedure is the higher the compensation. These “Guinea pigs” are required to pay taxes on the money they do make. (Elliott, 2008)
Reasons for Drug Trials
Clinical trials are designed to test the safety and efficiency of potential interventions in humans. Trials of treatments, prevention modalities, medical devices, and other interventions are the fastest, safest, and best way to determine the failure or success of the product being tested. Treatment trials are experimental treatments. They test new drugs, new combinations of drugs; as well as, approaches to surgery and/or radiation therapy. This is the fastest way to discover the possible therapeutic options. Prevention trials test medicines, vaccines, vitamins, or lifestyle changes.
History of drug Trials
The largest drug-testing site, a 675-bed motel in Miami-Dade County, Florida was demolished in 2006. The participants were undocumented immigrants who were paid minute amounts as compensation. Conditions at the site were deplorable and the living conditions were repulsive. The paint was peeling from the ceilings and half a dozen, or more, individuals were forced to endure their trials in one room. Lisa Krinsky, a Miami native, the medical director who managed this facility was not licensed to practice in the United States. She was previously employed as a licensed clinical laboratory technician after receiving a medical degree from Spartan Health Sciences University, a medical school on the Caribbean Island of St. Lucia. As the owner of a commercial ethical review board and wife of the South Florida Bioavailability Committee (SFBC) vice president, she approved many of the studies brought to the board.
Due to the fact that because drug trials were poorly regulated in the early 1970’s Phase I research was conducted on prisoners. The FDA was granted authority to monitor research that involved humans in the 1978; at which time, the FDA ordered each institution to devise an Institutional Review Board (IRB). The IRB was to generate and monitor the rules of the trials on all studies done within the universality. The IRB was comprised of faculty members who volunteered to evaluate their colleagues’ studies. Unfortunately, before 2005, FDA inspectors’ primary focus was on verifying the clinical trial data, not the human subjects involved in them.

Benefits of Drug Trials

Who Enrolls in Drug Trials? Healthy experienced testers are used during Phase I where the...

Find Another Essay On Medical Ethics in Drug Trials

Testing New Medications Essay

1403 words - 6 pages The final part of maintaining patient autonomy is assuring their safety. The AZT, Nuremberg, and Tuskegee Trials gave way to reform in the methodology of medical trials. In the late 80’s the drug zidovudine (AZT), a drug to reduce the vertical transmission of HIV, was in the trial phases of its life. This trial gained much recognition and eventually became one of the major trials to change how medical trials were carried out (Bhutta, 115). The

Control in a Clinical Trial Essay

1423 words - 6 pages result, drug companies lean to conduct clinical trials in developing countries where patient accessibility is high and recruiting patients to participate in a placebo controlled trial is effortless. This approach, however, created discomfort in the human right and medical ethics proponents. In most developing countries, patients do not afford to pay for medical treatments and clinical trials conducted in these countries could benefit patients

Nazi Medical Trials: the “Good,” the Bad, and the Ugly

657 words - 3 pages As the human species develops, medicine follows suit. Researchers look down medicinal avenues which promise a better life-- a longer life. However, red and blue paint cannot engender purple paint without proper mixing. Thus, health sciences cannot expand without thorough experimentation. The Nazis exemplified this concept of “thorough experimentation” with their cruel and inhumane medical experiments. The trials varied in nature and reason. Some

Placebo Studies Should be Used in the Health Trials in Pharmacological Research

2350 words - 10 pages drugs for sale. The purpose of this project is to argue that placebo studies should be used in the health trials in pharmacological research because these studies determine the real treatment effect of a drug. The first section of this paper will briefly explain what "placebo" is , then clinical trials, based on this effect will be examined. Then, the importance of using placebo studies in medical research will be assessed, and finally some

Drugs: The Blood Diamonds of the Pharmaceutical Industry

1508 words - 6 pages future of clinical trials in “Medical Trials in India”. Clinical trials are an integral part of medical research. However, while the globalization of clinical trials will benefit the world in the long run, it has lead to some serious unethical conduct. In order to prevent this, the Food and Drug Administration in conjunction with both private and public Internal Review Boards need to take a stronger role in the regulation of clinical trials. This

New Drug Reseach and Development in America

2639 words - 11 pages , multiple phase I trials may be needed to gather information on how the drug interacts with people of different age, sex, and ethnicity (Boe, et al. 75). In the article, "Ethical and Scientific Implications of the Globalization of Clinical Research", a point is made that, “Geographically distinct populations can have different genetic profiles, and these differences have been shown to be related to the safety of drugs and medical devices


1237 words - 5 pages Research. Medical New Today. Retrieves November 12, 2013 from This source describes the very serious problem of data that is not included in publication of clinical trials. This distorts the scientific record of a drug and prevents physicians from being able t make the best clinical decisions based on the best data being available. Shuchman, M., (2007 October 4) Commercializing Clinical Trials

Testing New Medications

1750 words - 7 pages in that area. In most cases in developing countries there are not a facilities where people can seek the medical attention they need. This is another reason it is a suitable reason to have these countries participate in medical trials. The countries that do not have the resources for medical facilities tend to view clinical research as a way to provide unaffordable medical care (Farrell, 136). The devastating thing is that the people living in

Medical Marijuana: A Safe and Effective Alternative Medication

1769 words - 7 pages my health with an illegal drug or obeying the law, I would choose to maintain my health (ASA : Multiple Sclerosis).” There is still the need for more regulated trials without doubt. Even in spite of the impediments that federal agencies have erected to the conduct of scientific evaluations of the medical use of marijuana, several scientific bodies have suggested that the FDA allow such studies to proceed. They have proposed that its formal

Ensuring post-trial treatment to the research participant: who should be responsible for it?

1115 words - 5 pages trials may need, alternatives should be discussed and the impact of these decisions on drug development and innovation in the healthcare should be analyzed. One suggestion that seems fair it would be that the industry which is developing a new drug that was able to prove higher efficacy and safety compared to a standard of care should be fully responsible to provide free access to the treatment until the drug is approved and is available in the public

Clinical Trials

1279 words - 6 pages Every medical innovation starts with an idea or vision, and goes through several developmental stages, namely, basic research, translational research and clinical research before being able to market the treatment. (4) This treatment can be a drug, a medical device, a vaccine, a blood product or gene therapy. (3) The basic research is done in a laboratory, where cell function is studied, and it is determined under what conditions the treatment

Similar Essays

Medical Marijuana Marijuana Is A Drug That Has Been In

1061 words - 4 pages Medical Marijuana Marijuana is a drug that has been in the media for years. There is a constant debate about if it should be used medically. The world is afraid of what they do not know about marijuana; for years we’ve been told, “say nope to dope.†While marijuana can help for medical purposes it can also be of great danger. This is not true however, if it is used correctly. Historically

Euthanaisa, One Of The Most Acute And Uncomfortable Contemporary Problems In Medical Ethics

1600 words - 6 pages Euthanasia is one of the most acute and uncomfortable contemporary problems in medical ethics. Is Euthanasia Ethical? The case for euthanasia rests on one main fundamental moral principle: mercy.It is not a new issue; euthanasia has been discussed-and practised-in both Eastern and Western cultures from the earliest historical times to the present. But because of medicine's new technological capacities to extend life, the problem is much more

The Ethics Of Reductionism In The Medical Sciences

1763 words - 7 pages While Marcum’s philosophy focuses on medical research at the molecular, genetic, and tissue levels, Elisabeth Lloyd emphasizes the socioeconomic factors of health. She presents an empirical trend that permeates through a number of cross-national studies: the degree of income inequality in any given society is strongly correlated with the society’s level of morbidity and mortality. This means that if a society’s income gradient is steep (the poor

Outsourcing Of Clinical Trials To Developing Countries

1913 words - 8 pages ethical conduct. Introduction: Clinical Trial Outsourcing: Global Drug and Medical Device makers based in developed countries are now focusing on developing countries to carry out their clinical trials. These players (pharmaceutical and device makers) have embraced outsourcing as a core component of their business models especially in realm of clinical trials. “Outsourcing may be defined as shifting or delegating a company’s day to day