This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Medicare Reform: Conflicts Between Two Political Minds

2083 words - 9 pages

On Tuesday May 13th 2014, the Coalition’s federal budget 2014/15 has been announced by Joe Hockey, the Treasurer, for House of Representatives’ discussion. The budget, as Tony Abbot, the Prime Minister described as “tough but necessary decision”, has proposed many budgetary changes including temporary 2% tax increase on high income earners, twice yearly fuel excise indexation, pension age increase, tightening the amount and eligibility of family and welfare pay, higher education budget cut with fee deregulation, and reform on health care system.
Among these modifications, Medicare program, the compulsory universal public health care insurance scheme that most Australian citizens have taken ...view middle of the document...

The report proposed a $6 patient co-payment contribution for a bulk-billed general practitioners (GP). NCOR then issued the recommendation report in February 2014, stating that “health care spending represents the Commonwealth’s single largest long-term fiscal challenge” and recommended the introduction of co-payments for all Medicare subsidized services. NCOR also proposed $15 and $5 co-payment fee respectively for general and concessional patients below safety net threshold, along with an advice to ban GPs for waiving the fee for bulk-billed patients (National Commission of Audit 2014 pp. xxi, xli, 98).
However, in the budget announced by the Coalition Federal Government, the proposed fee has been semi-finalized for Parliament discussion at the amount of $7. All patients have to pay, but the payment from concessional patients and children under 16 will be limited to their first 10 services per calendar year. To compromise with the increasing public criticism, the Treasurer has commented, two days after the announcement, that GPs “have a capacity not to charge” patient co-payment fee, if they, case by case, forego their own $2 medical rebate portion of that contribution payment (Parnell 2014, p.1).
Now that it is clear how the issue has developed into Coalition budget proposal, it may be an appropriate time to discuss the advantages as long as detrimental effects. Firstly, the most important reason of co-payment supporters is that it brings political fairness and economic efficiency. The political fairness lays in the way that who need the service has to pay, partially in this case, for it. It acts like a price signal tagged onto the service to prevent the overuse of the system, as users have to balance its gain against the cost they are personally obliged. In other words, it helps reducing the “unnecessary” demand, and then enabling the efficient use of economic scarce resources such as GP time and federal fund. The government then can direct these spared resources to those who are rightly in need.
Secondly, the federal budget cut in hospital funding is conducted on the basic principle that the ones responsible for providing hospital services are the states and the states do have their own ability to raise tax for their funding purposes. The states should therefore take more accountability in their constitutional obligations. With this way, the service efficiency will be significantly improved, since the state has the full sovereignty – both authority and responsibility in the whole management. These lines of logic, which reflect the fundamental belief of liberal minds in small federal governance, are repeatedly mentioned by the Prime Minister.
Thirdly, the budget deficit is thought to be unsustainable. Without policy change, public debt is estimated to grow to $667 billion by 2023/24. However, with the proposed reform, the federal government is expected to save $3.5 billion for co-payment fee, $1.8 billion for hospital fund cut, and $1.7...

Find Another Essay On Medicare Reform: Conflicts between Two Political Minds

The Benefits of the Affordable Care Act's Medicare Reform

1252 words - 6 pages Medicare Reform Medicare is a federal health insurance program for ages sixty-five or older, young individuals with disabilities, and individuals with End-Stage Renal Disease. There are different parts of Medicare which consist of Medicare Part A, Medicare Part B, and Medicare Part C. This paper will explore the Medicare Reform and how it is an important topic. In the depression elderly individuals were more reliant on their sons and

The Ecnomics of Medicare Essay

3629 words - 15 pages this by providing data through 1997 about how effective Medicare has been with cost containment. The only problem with this is that 1997 was the last year of a period of catch-up by private insurance, during this period the gap between Medicare and the private cost growth was significantly reduced. Now, we have data that shows since the Budget Reform Act, Medicare's cost growth has essentially stopped. This shows that Moon's assertions about

Healthcare, Medicare, and Medicaid

4773 words - 19 pages program serves 40 million Americans and costs more than $217 billion per year, nearly 12 percent of the federal budget. However, Medicare had much smaller beginnings when it was enacted in the 1960s. A Historical Perspective Medicare was created on July 30, 1965. President Lyndon Johnson as part of his “Great Society” signed it into law. Medicare was and continues to be comprised of two parts: Part A and Part B. Part A is financed by a

WHO: Organization

705 words - 3 pages pressure to support the aging population and the reduction of the social programs such as Medicare will put the entire healthcare industry under the pressure. This challenge might create dual problem-less government support – less healthcare workers – less tax revenue. Not to mentioned that the reduction in the government support in the social programs will create obvious political problems. Same is true for Social Security reform. By reducing

History of Public Medical Insurance Care in Canada

1159 words - 5 pages with the Medical Care Act of 1966 (Brown). There were significant tensions brewing between different groups of people which would ultimately result in bitter conflicts. Nonetheless, beyond all interferences, all of Canada would be covered by a medical insurance plan based on the Saskatchewan system within ten years. This proves that Medicare was successful despite the controversy and tension it first created at its formation. In Saskatchewan


10311 words - 41 pages on how to cover the uninsured and how to reform Medicaid and Medicare while stabilizing the debt. Indeed, the future of the government's two major health entitlements, Medicare and Medicaid, is likely to figure in the 2012 campaign, not just as a health policy issue, but as a deficit and debt issue. Even if the ACA had never been enacted, the presidential candidates would be debating what to do about Medicare and Medicaid, because these two

How did the U.S. health care system develop, and how has this led to problems in the current system?

998 words - 4 pages . 2005.Mechanic, David. The truth about healthcare: Why reform is not working in America. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers Press. 2006.Oberlander, Jonathon. The Political Life of Medicare. IL: University of Chicago. 2006.Porter, Michale and Elizabeth Olmsted Teisberg. Redefining health care: Creating value-based competition on results. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School. 2006.

Medicare Fraud

927 words - 4 pages approximately ten percent of all Medicare and Medicaid annual expenses, costing billions in tax dollars. Common fraudulent practices include billing for services never received, upcoding or unbundling of services, and mislabeling. Billing dishonest services occurs anytime a healthcare provider charges Medicare for a service the patient never received or billing for a more expensive service than performed. Upcoding and unbundling, two examples

Out Patient Prospective Payment

1417 words - 6 pages procedure and the like. Physicians are reimbursed for all these procedures based on a fee-for-service basis. Thus, MPFS pays a physician a set of fees based on the patient’s diagnosis. For laboratory and related services, Medicare pays based on the actual services and supplies provided at the amount set in the applicable fee schedule. The Obama administration released two final rules dictating how doctors and outpatient hospital

Issues with Long Term Care - Methodist University LTC - Research Paper

1597 words - 7 pages . spending is predicted to be in line with long-term care costs in other developed nations, such as the United Kingdom, Germany and Japan, or between 2.5 percent and 3 percent of gross domestic product (Freundich, 2014). In 1965, Medicare and Medicaid became the first public health insurance programs in the U.S. when they were signed into law by President Lyndon Johnson. Medicare was intended for individuals over 65 years old and those with end-stage

Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1987

3047 words - 12 pages government regulations and in 1987 Democrats and Republican joined forces to install this. The reason the stakeholders changed their minds was because no one in their right mind wanted to defend standards of nursing homes which were below decent. Campaigns and movements were put into place and in 1987 most of them developed into actual laws. The Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1987 was born (under the Nursing Home Reform Act). “Bruce Vladeck

Similar Essays

Coppares Canada And Austria. Shows Political And Cultural Similarities And Contrasts Between Two Essentially Non Connected Countries

1557 words - 6 pages In this essay, a small number of similarities and differences between Canada and a foreign country (Austria) will be examined and discussed. The purpose of this is to gain knowledge into the foreign country (Austria) as well as to show political and cultural similarities and contrasts between two essentially non-connected countries.The War of 1812 / The War of LiberationIn 1812, conflict broke out on the Canada/US border. Angered by the British

Prescription Drug Coverage Essay

2557 words - 10 pages Programming To gain current, differing ideological viewpoints on aspects of healthcare reform I watched three national news programs and read two newspaper articles from a national and local paper between 2/24/10 and 2/28/10. I watched “Special Report” freom Fox News on 2/24. On 2/25 I watched “World News Tonight” on ABC where the healthcare summit was reviewed. I also read the article “White House punts on key cost-saving move” from the

Medicare Essay

1581 words - 6 pages Medicare in the '96 ElectionsGovernment11 / 25 / 96Among the many differences between President Bill Clinton (Democrat) and Presidential Candidate Bob Dole (Republican), lays a common debate topic, Healthcare. The issue is the fact that funding in Medicare's budget will not last but another four years. Both Republicans and Democrats have ideas on how this budget should be reformed, but the two have not yet come to a median resolution. In the

Medicare And Medicaid Essay

1368 words - 5 pages diabetes screening tests and education and outreach programs. As the number of people eligible for Medicare rises, pending influx of the Baby-Boomers in 2011, their voice is added to strong lobbying organization that change political outcomes based on their voting records (File & Crissey, 2010). Health Care Reform Initiatives and Medicare/Medicaid “Medicare and the New Health Care Law — What it Means for You” (2010) states that The Affordable