This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Medicine And The Law Of Negligence

1717 words - 7 pages

1.0 Introduction
The tort of negligence is designed to give citizens of society protection from personal injury damages caused by negligent action of someone else. The reform of negligence adopted from the ‘Ipp Report’ in 2003, have gone too far in trying to decrease the number of negligence claims against professionals. Due to these reforms of 2003, citizens who have legitimate claim to compensation, are now left with less chance to hold a professional liable for the damage caused. The reforms, which now make up the current law, must be again reformed to balance the litigation in favour of no one and to make sure that there are fair and just outcomes in the courts. The Act in question is the Civil Liability Act 2003. Section 22 of this Act focuses on the Standard of care for professionals. This is the section that is in most need of reform, due to its excessive protection of professionals from liability.

2.0 Medicine and the Law of Negligence

2.1 History of Negligence and Medicine
One of the First principles used in this field of the law, was the Bolam principle. In the words of Mr Justice McNair, in his direction to the jury: “[a doctor] is not guilty of negligence if he has acted in accordance with the practice accepted as proper by responsible body of medical men skilled in that particular art …” Putting it the other way round, a man is not negligent, if he is acting in accordance with such a practice, merely because there is a body of opinion who would take a contrary view. This principle made in the House of Lords, was thought by many to apply in Australia. However, the in case of Rogers v Whitaker (1992) the six high court judges concluded that the Bolam principle was not the sole decider in the issue of if standard of care owed to a patient in all things is determined by medical judgment. This was to be the precedent for all cases of its kind to come according to a comment from the high court judges which reads “The decision is an important one, not only because it is the first time the High Court has considered this type of case… there is now little room for doubt in Australia as to the legal principles to be applied in similar cases.”
2.2 The Need For Change
From the early ‘80s claims involving personal injury started gaining popularity amongst society. Although the claims might not have involved professionals a trend was being set that would eventually lead to tort reform in many areas. The area of law involving professional’s e.g. medical practitioners, was reformed in the early years of the 2000’s. The insurance crisis was leading to more and more claims against professionals being lodged with the courts and the Howard government tasked Justice Ipp, with writing a report, detailing; his and the panel of experts he was working with, opinion and recommendations they had about the current law. This led to a chain of reforms in all states, with Queensland implementing the Civil Liability Act 2003 in response to the report.

Find Another Essay On Medicine and the Law of Negligence

Aspects of Contract and Negligence for Business

2074 words - 8 pages report is related with the elements of vicarious of liability and their implementation in these situations. It includes four different scenarios and some of them are affected by the Occupiers’ Liability Act, 1957. Introduction Tort of negligence and defences and the elements of vicarious liability are important part of the law. Their meaning and appliance need to be understand correctly and use them properly. We can use the tort of

The Benefits of Complementary and Alternative Medicine

1661 words - 7 pages In today’s world, many people assume that the latest medical technology and treatments are always the best option. However, all over the world, different techniques for curing diseases and aliments are being used. These methods fall under the category of complementary and alternative medicine. According to Sandra Augustyn Lawton in Complementary and Alternative Medicine for Teens, complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) can be defined as

the Pros and Cons of Nuclear Medicine

678 words - 3 pages According to Helibron and Seidel (2011) nuclear medicine began as a simple experiment in the early twentieth century by George de Hevesy. De Hevesy started the experiment by deciding to test the effects of radiation on living things, beginning with bean plants, then onto furred animals, and then continued onto finding the effects of radiation on the human body, when he did this he became the first person to ever use radiation on a human being

The Successes and Failures of Personalized Medicine

870 words - 4 pages The twentieth century marked a revolutionary transformation in the field of molecular biology and human genetics. This profound scientific advance gave birth to a new perspective in medicine, known as personalized medicine. This approach of targeted therapy focuses on the distinct molecular characteristics of an individual, and uses this information as a way to diagnose a person's disease as well as choose specific treatments that target the

The Practice and Participation of Alternative Medicine

1290 words - 6 pages The practice and participation of alternative medicine or complementary medicine is becoming more and more accepted, accessible, and utilized on a worldwide scale. Some possibilities to explain this are the perception of alternative medications and therapies as being more effective when reversing or treating chronic conditions and having fewer and less harmful or painful side effects as the pharmaceuticals which the majority of doctors

Nursing: The Life of Medicine and Selflessness

2587 words - 10 pages and responsibilities. Since nursing has evolved, the lives of the people are better protected, education is a major factor and nursing has steadily progressed in technology and medicine. Nursing has been around for hundreds of years. As these years have come about there has been drastic changes within nursing. From the clothes they wore, to education and training and technology as it is (Christensen 1). During the nineteenth century, the

The History of Medicine

1531 words - 6 pages Medicine and useful healing products have been around since before 0 BCE, but how effective has it been? Before 0BCE, many medical procedures we still use today have started. The first known surgery was performed around 2750 BCE. The Edwin Smith Papyrus was medical text in Ancient Egypt that had information containing the oldest known surgical treatise on trauma. The Edwin Smith Papyrus is regarded as a copy of several earlier works and was

The Ethics of Medicine

1747 words - 7 pages . Hard decisions always have to be made in medicine. These decisions include things as simple as whether or not to give a patient a minimally invasive surgery, and as complex as what to do in the case of a young girl becoming pregnant and wanting an abortion, against her parent's wishes or knowledge. I first became interested in the Hippocratic Oath after spending seven months researching medical ethics and fallibility of humans practicing medicine

Legal cases: possible claim against Australian manufacturers of the Waist Waster and Myways supermarkets for negligence and breach of contract

1610 words - 6 pages Question 2.Buck Spumante might have claims against the Australian manufacturers of the Waist Waster and Myways supermarkets in this matter under these possible actions.(A). Possible claims against Australian manufacturers of the Waist Waster1. NegligenceTo identify whether Australian manufacturers of the Waist Waster is liable for the tort of negligence, we have to establish the following:a. Duty of careTo prove that the duty of care exist

The Test Of Remoteness In The Tort Of Negligence

826 words - 4 pages The law places a limit upon the extent to which the defendant is liable for the loss which occurs from his breach of a duty of care to the plaintiff, once it is established that the loss sustained by the plaintiff is one recoverable in negligence. The test of remoteness of damage limits this liability by defining certain types of damage or losses as being irrecoverable as a matter of law. The test is carried out to protect the defendant in

The Ingredients Required to Establish the Tort of Negligence

2281 words - 9 pages The tort of Negligence is defined by Winfield as, ‘as breach of a legal duty to take care which results in damage to the claimant’ . To bring an action in the tort of negligence it’s not enough to prove that defendant behaved carelessly. It is just one of the ingredients required to establish the tort of negligence, the claimant must prove that the defendant owes the claimant a duty of care. The defendant has acted in breach of that duty and as

Similar Essays

The Law And Medicine Essay

2066 words - 9 pages The law and how it is interpreted and followed in the administration of medicine is an important aspect that must be placed at the forefront. The law, simply put, refers to social rules of conduct that are enforceable and are not meant to be broken. While the practice of medicine carries a myriad of systematic complexities which expose healthcare organizations to potential legal problems, healthcare leaders must establish procedural methods and

Common Law In Australia: The Tort Of Negligence

9095 words - 36 pages TORT - A Tort is a civil wrong that is outside of Contract Law and arises out of a recognition that a person is responsible for their acts and omissions when dealing with others. The term "Tort" refers to a number of different laws such as nuisance, trespass and assault. Torts action generally compensates the individual for personal loss where the loss was caused by another person. It is based on Common Law.NEGLIGENCE - Negligence is one of many

Australian Law Assignment Discuss The Elements Of The Law Of Negligence Highlighting Recent Developments

2403 words - 10 pages Australian Law AssignmentQuestion: The test in Australia has been applied as a two part test, one of foreseeability and proximity. Discuss the elements of the law of negligence highlighting recent developments.Table of Cases CitedCases CitedCaparo Industries Plc v Dickman [1990] 2 AC 605Chapman v Hearse (1962) 106 CLR 112Donoghue v Stevenson [1932} AC 562Hill v Van Erp (1997) 71 ALJR 487Jaensch v Coffey (1984) 115 CLR 549Nagle v Rottnest Island

Legal Systems: Duty Of Care And Negligence

1406 words - 6 pages Legal systems are critical to the functionality of any given society. In particular, issues of duty and responsibility are fundamental to address especially when one party causes harm or injury to another. In this respect, the concept of duty of care and its connection to negligence serve a key role in the society. Tort law provides for legal processes following acts of negligence that exhibit duty of care. The underlying liability in negligence