Medievil Society In Relationship To The Name Of The Rose By Umberto Eco And The Return Of Martin Guerre By Natalie Zemon Davis. A Comparisson Of The Two Books And How They Relate To Medievil History.

2046 words - 8 pages

Many people are interested in the Middle Ages, while others are not. But no matter what the preference is the Middle Ages offer a lot of material for entertainment like movies or novels. Some of these are actually historically correct, but most are not. There are two books that directly deal with the Middle Ages. These two books are The Return of Martin Guerre and Name of the Rose. They deal with village life and monastery life respectively.The monasteries were the center of life for a lot of the monks in the Middle Ages. Monastery life also called monasticism, rose from small groups of devout Christians. These groups of people wanted to lead a more perfect life that was free from all the harm of regular life. They secluded themselves from the rest of society in deserts and mountains. Some of these groups started harming themselves to try to gain holiness. Shortly there after leaders sprang up and laid down rules that the monks could not injure themselves anymore they had to start up manual labor instead. The principal figure in the shaping of monasticism in the West was Saint Benedict, who founded a monastery at Monte Cassino in 529. He said that monks should live in poverty, study, and do manual labor. They should also at all time obey the abbot or head of the monastery. The monks are expected to pray, learn, talk little, and give up all personal belongings. Benedict's monastery became the standard for all monasteries in Western Europe.Villages started to emerge again in Europe in the twelve century. Through the towns the middle class emerged. The middle classes were usually merchants. These people were not attached to the land. Because of this they had a different value system then that of lords and serfs. Since many of the towns were located on lords land the towns still incorporated feudalism. Most of the villages were small and located at easy trade routes. Many the villagers were poor. Many of them could not read or write also.These two aspects of life are going to be the main focus and how the two books relate to them. First we're going to go into the basic story of the two books and style. Then we're going to exam how these books deal with the medieval society.Name of the Rose was set in the year 1327. It took place in an Italian monastery that was located on a mountain plateau with a village at the foot of the mountain. In the Abby the main focus was on the library. The library was the mysterious place of learning that was well guarded. The book had a couple main characters and many supporting characters. William and Adso were the two main characters. William was a Franciscan monk from England. He is Adso's master. William was an intuitive thinker. He relied heavily on reason and scientific thought. William is the main driving force of the investigation. Adso is a young novice. He is Benedictine. Adso is the narrator of the book. Everything is seen through his eyes. He is somewhat naïve, but he is still young.Then there are the...

Find Another Essay On Medievil Society in Relationship to The Name of The Rose by Umberto Eco and The Return of Martin Guerre by Natalie Zemon Davis. A comparisson of the two books and how they relate to medievil history.

Compairing the two books, "Dispatches" by Herr and "Batman: The Dark Knight Returns by" Miller. Focuses on an indepth look at the main characters and how they are seen in the eye's of the reader

1348 words - 5 pages . Eventually Robin saves Batman foiling the cops yet again. If the police would have respected Robin for her ability and not her age, things may have gone for the worse for Batman. However you might emphasize age as being important, indifference should be felt in that no life young of old is of more emphasis than the other.Intelligence is frequently linked to the value of a life. The uneducated are seen as a burden to society, worth less than they can

The play of Oedipus the King deals with many different issues. Oedipus unknowingly killed his father and slept with his father and slept with his mother. In addition to their incestual relationship...

589 words - 2 pages The play of Oedipus the King deals with many different issues The play of Oedipus the King deals with many different issues. Oedipus unknowingly killed his father and slept with his father and slept with his mother. In addition to their incestual relationship they had four kids; two girls and two boys. During this time of the earth everyone was thought to be ruled by Gods and other supernatural beings; which were of or relating to God

An essay discussing the christian holidays Christmas and holy sunday. Compare/contrast the two and how they effect the religion and modern american society

931 words - 4 pages Christianity EssayChristianity as a whole has many different holidays and "days of obligation", from The Sabbath, which occurs every seven days, to holidays like Christmas and Easter which are observed only once a year.Christmas is probably the most note able of all these. Not only is it observed by the Christians but it has become so ingrained in modern American society it is expected by all to receive a "Christmas break" in late December

Why do people marry?I believe that two people get married because they love each other. Our society today is in love with the idea of love. Almost

1081 words - 5 pages I believe that two people get married because they love each other. Our society today is in love with the idea of love. Almost everything revolves around love and your significant other. Ever since we were little we have grown up watching fairy tales and love stories, and little girls grow up planning exactly what their wedding is going to be like. We grow up wondering when we are going to meet "the right one". Many people believe that there is

The Wife of Martin Guerre

844 words - 4 pages day society it would be perfectly acceptable to leave Martin for the imposter and no one would take a second glance. However, Lewis wrote with no artistic license as far as how the characters act. In the sixteenth century Bertrande has no choice, she is socially, spiritually, and morally committed to return to Martin, regardless if she was happier with the imposter. “[Lewis] is not interested in adding to the literature of passionate love

The Wife of Martin Guerre

1003 words - 4 pages the household how she feels: no father for Sanxi; ruining the family's harmony and ridding herself of a partner. At first no one believes her. Martin's sisters claim she is mad and motivated by power and the Cure` suggests she is replacing one sin with another.Her religious values are pointing her to accuse him as she is committing adultery by sharing intimacy with a man who is not her husband but the fate of the whole Guerre household lies in

A camparison of the presenatation of the main characters as they learn to cope with the situation they face in their lives ; Three books by roddy doyle

4651 words - 19 pages about the smell of a hot water bottle; the concern he feels when hearing his parents argue; a conversation between him and the gang; an earlier memory of his father and an episode at school. They are in no particular order, illustrating the jumble in Paddy's mind and how he notices the situation more as he realises his mother's fascination with reading books at night:"My ma read books. Mostly at night. She licked her finger when she was coming to the

The Responsibility of Redemption Essay discusses the angst and emotion of seeking redemption, or helping others to find redemption, specific to characters in two recently read books, A Lesson Before...

1246 words - 5 pages sins. Both novels and their main characters; Grant and Simon, are dealing with the challenging theme of redemption through death.Simon Wiesenthal was a survivor of the Nazi death camps during World War 2, and since then, he dedicated his life to finding guilty perpetrators and making sure that they were held accountable for their injustice to humanity. During his time in the death camps, Wiesenthal was faced with the decision of forgiving a Nazi

Text Response- The Wife of Martin Guerre

745 words - 3 pages the second child and the Guerre estate? Of Bertrande?"God knows, my child, and the priest will so instruct you, that a man of evil ways may by an act of will so alter all his actions and his habits that he becomes a man of good." The Wife of Martin Guerre showed appearances of love transforming evil into good, though this ultimately proves not to be the case. The characters depicted in the story were all looking at life through rose-colored

The Mystery of the Rose and the Narrator in A Rose for Emily by Faulkner

1187 words - 5 pages .” (126) This is one of many key arguments by Arensberg and Schyfter and it’s a pretty basic one. Another interpretation of the story is one where Alice Hall Petry analyzes five adjectives that Faulkner uses in the story to describe Emily and how they pertain to certain parts of the story. I actually did not realize this connection between the adjectives and how each one corresponds with a certain part of the story and I guess I was not the

Essay on the themes of ozymandias by P.B.Shelly, and how they are demonstrated to the reader

952 words - 4 pages ", "passions", "stamped", "hand" and "sands". This straight forward, unemotional tone reinforces the inevitable destructiveness for all things by the passage of time.Another sound device the poet uses to convey his theme is alliteration. This can be seen in "stone stand" to suggest how heavy and solid the legs of the statue are and how Ozymandias believed his work to be a permanent testimony to his greatness. Alliteration reinforces the arrogance

Similar Essays

An Analysis Of Natalie Zemon Davis' Interesting Book "The Return Of Martin Guerre"

2959 words - 12 pages Although most, if not all, would assume the lives of peasants are insignificant in the greater scheme of things, the popular story of Martin Guerre unfolds via peasants making major, life-altering decisions based on self-interest. The individual lives of the peasants do make a difference. Natalie Zemon Davis tells the tale of peasants looking out for themselves in The Return of Martin Guerre, and rarely do they allow others to interfere with

Peasant Lifestyle In Davis´ The Return Of Martin Guerre

1854 words - 7 pages The Return of Martin Guerre, written by Natalie Zemon Davis, is the tale of a court case that takes place in sixteenth century France. Martin Guerre is a peasant who deserted his wife and family for many years. While Martin Guerre is gone, a man named Arnaud du Tilh arrives at Martin’s village and claims to be Martin Guerre. Bertrande, who is Guerre’s wife, Guerre’s sisters, and many of the villagers, accepts the imposter. After almost three

The Return Of Martin Guerre Essay

620 words - 2 pages The Return of Martin Guerre is a controversial film taking place in the sixteenth century. It is about a legal dispute taking place is the French village of Artigat. The villagers are typical peasant farmers and craftsman of the time period. They demonstrate the rural lifestyles and thought patterns found throughout much of Europe in the sixteenth century.This film showed the importance and significance of religion in Europe during the sixteenth

Book Review Of "The Return Of Martin Guerre"

1169 words - 5 pages In The Return of Martin Guerre, one man's impersonation of an heir from an influential peasant family in the French village of Artigat ultimately leads to his public execution. The tale of Arnaud du Tilh alias Pansette (meaning "the belly") is full of ironies, not the least of which is his death at the hands of a man who by some accounts harbored some admiration for the quick-witted peasant. Set in a time and place where a hardly discernible