This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Men Are Women And Women Are Men

1383 words - 6 pages

In Shakespeare's play, "Macbeth", the characters defy their own gender norms by exhibiting traits of the opposite gender. Women are portrayed as villainous and men are portrayed as good. The women are dominant and the men, alternately Macbeth, are passive, since he is the victim to the women's manipulation. The women are not sensitive, rather they are more emotionless than the men. Though the play sets gender norms through the lines of the characters, these characters defy their own norms.
For instance, Lady Macbeth, the main female figure in the play, calls upon the demons to take her "femininity", and in place she is given masculine traits. "Come, you spirits that tend on mortal ...view middle of the document...

" (I v. 4)
Even before her unsexing, Lady Macbeth demonstrates dominance over her husband. With no hesitation, she assumes that she will be able to persuade him to take the crown. She does not consider the possibility of being overpowered.
These lines are all spoken before her famous soliloquy, proof that she already possesses masculine traits. Additionally, even she admits that Macbeth is "too full o' the milk of human kindness". She believes, and admits, that she is crueler than her husband . A woman is crueler than a man, and the gender norm set by the character's own mindset is broken.
Aside from Lady Macbeth's soliloquy, there is further contrast between the goodness of women and men. The women manipulate and the men engage in direct violence. Normally, manipulation is immoral while direct violence is more moral. Manipulation involves deceit and the hiding of true intentions, and this two-facedness is often more hateful than the principled violence of men. In consequence, the gender roles are once again swapped; the men are honest and moral and the women are immoral.
This contrast of morality is especially clear between Lady Macbeth and Macbeth. Lady Macbeth orders the demons to take her femininity, her "moral thoughts" (I v. 30), yet these morals are present in Macbeth. When Macbeth decides to remain loyal to Duncan, she questions his masculinity by saying, "and to be more than what you were, you would be so much more the man". (I vii. 50) Though Macbeth is the one who murders Duncan, Lady Macbeth is the conspirator who persuades him to do so. Her hands are not dirtied, yet in the end her character is more tainted than Macbeth's.
In addition, Lady Macbeth says "I have given suck and know how tender 'tis to love the babe that milks me. I would, while it was smiling in my face, have pluck'd my nipple from his boneless gums and dash'd the brains out had I so sworn as you have done to this." (I vii. 55) Lady Macbeth uses this line as a ploy to harm Macbeth's dignity. Macbeth will believe he is backing out of an agreement, and to prevent this, he will decide to stay true to his word. Due to his noble character, this line, along with the questioning of his manhood, seem to greatly influence Macbeth to carry through with the murder. He immediately asks "If we should fail?" (I vii. 58), conclusively manipulated by Lady Macbeth. This scene, again, demonstrates Lady Macbeth's dominating role in the relationship. Moreover she is made to be the villain and Macbeth the victim. Macbeth tries to retaliate with moral thoughts, yet he is corrupted by the lady's words. She is the source of evil while Macbeth is good.
Aside from Lady Macbeth, the three witches persuade Macbeth to perform additional murders through vague prophecies. "All hail, Macbeth! Hail to you, thane of Glamis! All hail, Macbeth! Hail to thee, thane of Cawdor! All hail, Macbeth, that shalt be king hereafter!" (I iii. 49) They say he will be...

Find Another Essay On Men Are Women And Women Are Men

Are Men or Women More Fortunate?

840 words - 3 pages Who is more Fortunate?      Are men or women more fortunate? Physically, men may be more fortunate; for men do not give birth, do not have to deal with periods and menopause, and do not spend a long time getting prepared each morning. But what is the answer if we just look at the temperament? In relationships, men are surely less fortunate than women: men often must take risks for the relationship; women can

All Men Are Created Equal: Except Women

1732 words - 7 pages slut shaming since they believe they are correcting a woman’s “immoral” behavior, even though it is still sexual harassment. Women are treated differently than men are for their sexual behavior, as they are quickly judged and usually scolded, whereas men are congratulated for being a “stud” and “getting it in”. In the article “Take It from Someone Who Has Danced Half-naked on Stage: Slut-shaming Is Never All Right” by famous feminist blogger Laurie

Are women more polite than men

3834 words - 15 pages Wears Prada, 2006). In 1972, Lakoff in "Language and Women's Place" has argued that women have a different way of communication than men; as each reflects and produces a certain position in society. This claim has asserted that when women have a subordinate status, it is actually reflected on their language. For women, language is learned as a part of "learning to be a woman", in which women are forced to speak in a certain way, which their

Are women better rulers than men?

640 words - 3 pages . Others say that she never married because she was deeply passionate about Robert Dudley and she could not marry him for a number of reasons cheifly because he was extremly unpopular with the parliament because his family was a long line of rogue nobles.Over all I think that elizabeth proved that women are very much better rulers than men as there is no other monarchs time of reign that was called THE GOLDEN AGE[1].Bibliographyhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elizabeth_I_of_England

Are Men and Women equal according to Elizabeth Cady Stanton

639 words - 3 pages Willie BynumIntro to WritingDr. Sally Canapa25 November 2002Men and WomenAre They Equal?Are men and women equal? This question has been contemplated for many years. The answer may never be found, but it's a lot closer than it used to be. Elizabeth Cady Stanton writes in "Declaration of Sentiments and Resolution":We hold these truths to be self-evident: that all men and women are created equal; that they are endowed by their Creator with certain

Advertisements         In advertisements today, women and men are depicted as

667 words - 3 pages Advertisements In advertisements today, women and men are depicted as sex symbols and models of what everybody wants them to look like. For instance, women are usually advertised as needing to be sexy and innocent. Men on the other hand are advertised as strong and burly. The women are usually advertising housework, make up, or shampoo. The men are covered in dirt at a construction site while carrying a piece of timber or metal. In this

John Grey's "Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus."

465 words - 2 pages Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus,written by John Grey, brings up the idea that men and women are from separate planets and speak different languages. He explains that men and women are so different they often misinterpret what the other means to say. A Martian/Venusian phrase translator is included in his book; it translates common phrases into the languages of the opposite sexes. I believe that misunderstanding may be a common mistake in

Women, Men, and Competiton

945 words - 4 pages popular with boys. As adults, they objectify men as success objects. The means for impressing other women. Effectively, they use men to tell one another, 'Here is my man: with him, I buy cars, clothes, entertainment, vacations, trips to the beauty parlor and, if I'm so inclined, motherhood or early retirement.' The consequences of this are devastating. The consequences of turning women into sex objects include rape; the consequences of turning men

Men And Women Communicating

1829 words - 7 pages Men And Women Communicating Communication between males and females has always been somewhat complicated. Because we are arguing that males and females have different cultures we wanted to take a look at what some of these differences might be. According to our research the inherent differences between male and female culture are the different roles that society holds for them and the ways these roles lead to different communication styles

Misunderstanding Men And Women

2217 words - 9 pages Misunderstanding Men and Women Since the beginning of biological time, males and females have had noticeable and unnoticeable differences. These differences have caused conflicts, which have endured time and are still a part of our modern everyday lives. However, the discord has become more defined than what is characterized as a woman and a man. In order to attempt accordance between the sexes, it is essential that we educated ourselves in

Asian Men And Women

1129 words - 5 pages How society treats Asian American men and women differently Race and gender are two critical factors that influence the society greatly. There are other factors such as income, power, and prestige that also are social constructs. In the book American Knees by Shawn Wong, he explores these social identities through many of the characters. Many of these social identities are different for Asian American men and Asian American women. I'm going to

Similar Essays

Men And Women Are Made Not Born

835 words - 3 pages In this essay I will write about how women and men are made not born. I will beintroducing different cultures and their views on men and women, how women at onestage in time did not have any rights to become what they wanted, I will give my ideas onthe subject and I will also research other authors work to get a different variety about whywomen and men are made not born.Firstly I will start by researching different cultures and their ways of

In Literature, Women Are Good And Men Are Evil

3460 words - 14 pages see the opposite of evil and vice versa. Throughout many works of literature, men have been known to be evil/deceitful when it comes to women. Women are seen as the good in literature, not in all but in most cases. Authors such as William Blake and Christina Rossetti illustrate this and also evil in their literature to show their belief that evil dominates the world and good lies in the shadows but in the end, the good always prevails. In

Are Women Just As Violent As Men?

973 words - 4 pages In our debate we discussed whether women are just as violent as men. The pro side of the debate said yes women are just as violent as men, and the opposing side said men are more violent than women. In the yes side of the debate violence was described as physical and emotional assaults. As in violent acts carried out with the intention of causing another person physical pain or injury, no matter whether actual injury occurs, and any unjust

"Are Women As Effective Leaders As Men?"

1177 words - 5 pages frequently even better than their men colleagues. Especially it is common in Kyrgyzstan.The statistics are not on the side of the weaker sex. Women leaders of large companies and women-politicians in the government or non-government structure make little number than men, which give the basis again to specify ladies, their place: if not in the kitchen, then on positions below men's. Laura Lopez, leadership specialist and author of "Connected and