Meno´S Paradox Presented By Plato Essay

1044 words - 5 pages

The critical argument, known as Meno's Paradox, as presented in Plato's “Meno”, questions the very basis of Socrates method of arriving at knowledge of unknown things through inquiry. If Socrates truly wants to gain knowledge of what no one else knows, then the content of that “unknown” thing will produce absolutely nothing. The paradox bases itself in stating that humans can never learn anything that they don't already obtain knowledge of. As identified by Meno, the paradox is this: "And how are you going to inquire about it, Socrates, when you do not at all know what it is? For what sort of thing, from among the ones you do not know, will you take as the object of your inquiry? And even if ...view middle of the document...

If one may interpret the "something" you can or cannot learn to be universal than the argument becomes sound again. Since a universal is defined as the common principle of a group of facts, there is no way for a person to only somewhat understand the meaning. It would be inadequate understanding to do such a thing.

To disprove the paradox that Meno offers, Socrates then presents the theory of Recollection. He claims that a person is merely recollecting what the soul had already had knowledge of but somehow the soul just forgotten overtime. In recollection, Socrates says that the human soul is reincarnated in a cycle of life and death, and between them both your soul stays in the Underworld. Once the soul is reborn, it then recollects information that it already has knowledge of, rather than really learning anything new. Though, It would seem that a mortal body should not know such knowledge of the soul because the knowledge is a type of immortal knowledge. Obtaining “knowledge” of this type would require someone to have had significant information on it, as Socrates would say, in order to recollect this type of knowledge. But what is the content of the information and what was said in it, so that other people may also come to fully understand such overwhelming immortal knowledge through the soul’s journey? This is something that I don’t even think Socrates would have the answer for.

Socrates presents a brilliant example to support his claim, and I find the way in which he explains it very convincing and easy to comprehend. In attempting to show that even if you don’t know something, that something can still be learned, Socrates speaks with one of Meno’s slaves and “teaches” him how to compute the baseline of an eight-foot square. He asks a simple slave boy, who has no prior knowledge of what he’s about to be presented, a series of questions about the areas of some squares, which grow increasingly difficult. Socrates, throughout this experiment and explanation to Meno, is present to act as...

Find Another Essay On Meno´s Paradox Presented by Plato

Plato’s Theory of “Recollection” Essay

1678 words - 7 pages stirred up like a dream, but if he were repeatedly asked about these same things in various ways, you know that in the end his knowledge about these things would be as accurate as anyone’s.” (Plato, Meno p77, 85c-d) 3) Two types of causing people to “recollect”. a) When people are asked some smart questions, they will be guided by that kind of questions; “right opinion” within their soul awakes like waking up from a dream. In other words

Can Excellence Be Attained? Essay

1574 words - 6 pages In Plato’s Meno, Socrates uses ignorance to prove excellence cannot be taught or even attained by human actions. The process involves Socrates purposefully contradicting himself to entice Meno’s focus. Through Socrates, Plato argues particular criteria cannot determine excellence within a collective. Instead, Socrates asserts excellence must be a universal quality and applicable to all individuals, by comparing the human collective to a bee

History of Philosophy Meno's Paradox

1101 words - 4 pages 1. A Puzzle about DefinitionsSocrates has told us he knows how to reject faulty definitions. But how does he know when he has succeeded in finding the right definition? Meno raises an objection to the entire definitional search in the form of (what has been called) "Meno's Paradox," or "The Paradox of Inquiry" (Meno 80d-e).2. An Objection to Inquiry1. The argument reformulated:1. If you know what you're looking for, inquiry is unnecessary.2. If

Why Plato Says Recollection

1571 words - 7 pages of different knowledge of “inner knowledge”. In Meno, Socrates says “These opinions have now just been stirred up like a dream, but if he were repeatedly asked about these same things in various ways, you know that in the end his knowledge about these things would be as accurate as anyone’s.” (Plato, Meno p77, 85c-d) 3) Two types to contribute or to cause people to “recollect”. a) When people are asked some smart questions, they will be guided by

Platos Meno

803 words - 3 pages him questions about a geometrical problem. Socrates has shown that there exists an additional cognitive state that can guide one much in the same way as one guided by knowledge. This state is the state of true opinion. Although true opinion is always true, it is fleeting and impermanent. I believe virtue is anything that may be advantageous in one’s own way. It may be good, it may be bad in different peoples perspectives. Unlike, Plato I believe

The example of the slave boy in Plato's meno

1039 words - 4 pages the main problem of the paradox of enquiry. It also looks at the difference between knowledge and self belief- and we can observe that Plato is perhaps suggesting a posterion knowledge, which is based on observation.Socrates explains to Meno that ''we have lived man lives, seen things. and the soul has learned everything; we are able to recall what we have learned.'' He believes that he cannot teach knowledge, and when he brings in the slave boy

The Ambiguity of Plato

1942 words - 8 pages Plato the artist is "Simile of a Cave." In this very short section of The Republic, Plato draws us a picture of the very difficult path to knowledge. The paradox of this text is that he wants to convey truth through what he calls an illusion. Art is nothing but an illusion; yet, he uses this illusion to show us the path to the ultimate knowledge. In the cave, people are in chains facing a wall of shadows. Everything in the cave represents something


825 words - 3 pages Meno, Plato believes that true beliefs becomes knowledge by the grounding true belief. As mentioned before, if virtue is x, then it can be taught (because knowledge can be taught), therefore virtue (x) is equal to knowledge. Plato's expositions of elements of his own theory of knowledge, yet, the investigation of knowledge is indirect. I believe Socrates states that everyone was born with a knowledge of right and wrong, he / she needed to experience


1284 words - 5 pages Birth and family The exact birthdate of Plato is unknown. Based on ancient sources, most modern scholars estimate that he was born in Athens or Aegina[b] between 428 and 427 BC[a] His father was Ariston. According to a disputed tradition, reported by Diogenes Laertius, Ariston traced his descent from the king of Athens, Codrus, and the king of Messenia, Melanthus.[4] Plato's mother was Perictione, whose family boasted of a relationship with the

The Apology Written By Plato

1134 words - 5 pages ’ method of inquiry drove his listeners to question their beliefs and often brought them to a state of puzzlement, or a state Plato calls ‘aporia.’ There are many examples of the Socratic method present in The Meno, which is also written by Plato. The entirety of The Apology consists of Socrates explaining his methods, like those in the Meno, and telling the jury that his intentions were all for the best sake of the city of Athens, which he implies


3067 words - 12 pages world consists of remembering, in reminiscence or recollection. What the mind or soul once knew is raised to present awareness by a process of recollection aided by the technique of dialect or the Socratic method. (Stumpf 260) This is known as the theory of recollection. The theory of recollection is told through Plato in the Phaedo and the Meno. In the theory of

Similar Essays

Recollection In Plato's Phaedo And Meno

590 words - 2 pages Recollection in Plato's Phaedo and Meno As the earliest philosopher from whom we have written texts, Plato is often misrepresented as merely reproducing Socratic rhetoric. In Meno, one of the first Platonic dialogues, Plato offers his own unique philosophical theory, infused with his mentor's brilliant sophistry. Amidst discussing whether or not virtue can be taught, Meno poses a difficult paradox: How can one be virtuous, or seek virtue

Meno's Paradox Essay

3078 words - 12 pages what lines will you look, Socrates, for a thing of whose nature you know nothing at all? Pray, what sort of a thing, amongst those things that you know will you treat us to as the object of your search? Or even supposing, at the best that you it upon it, how will you know it is the thing you did not know?' 80D The paradox arises due to a number of assumptions concerning knowledge, inquiry and definition made by both Socrates and Meno. The

Meno And The Theory Of Recollection

1274 words - 5 pages knowledge or fact.Socrates connects the theory of recollection with solving the problem presented by Meno?s paradox, or the notion that there is no point in looking for what one does not know because what one does no know one can never discover, by stating, ?If the truth about reality is always in our soul, the soul must be immortal, and one must take courage and try to discover -that is to recollect - what one doesn?t happen to know, (or more

Can Virtue Be Taught? Essay

1209 words - 5 pages education. Overall, even Meno is an important step based on Plato's Protagoras, but it 's hard to say this dialogue is a kind of Plato’s stereotypical thinking, but rather saying like Protagoras, it reflects some kind of loss in his purist for truth. Throughout the whole dialogue, Plato actually is caught into some kind of misunderstanding at the beginning that is trying to find the so-called universal nature of virtue. This is the limitation of