This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Mental Health And Assisted Suicide Essay

1606 words - 6 pages

Mental Health and Euthanasia/Assisted Suicide

    It is obvious to the TV viewer that under the banners of compassion and autonomy, some are calling for legal recognition of a "right to suicide" and societal acceptance of "physician-assisted suicide." Suicide proponents evoke the image of someone facing unendurable suffering who calmly and rationally decides death is better than life in such a state. They argue that society should respect and defer to the freedom of choice such people exercise in asking to be killed. This essay intends to debunk this point of view on the basis of mental illness among those patients involved.


What would be the consequences of accepting this perspective? Let us examine the facts. Accepting a "right to suicide" would create a legal presumption of sanity, preventing appropriate mental health treatment. If suicide and physician-assisted suicide become legal rights, the presumption that people attempting suicide are deranged and in need of psychological help, borne out by many studies and years of experience, would be reversed. Those seeking suicide would be legally entitled to be left alone (Sullivan) to do something irremediable, based on a distorted assessment of their circumstances, without genuine help.


An attempt at suicide, some psychologists say, is often a challenge to see if anyone out there really cares(Stengel). Indeed, seeking physician assistance in a suicide, rather than just acting to kill oneself, may well be a manifestation, however subconscious, of precisely that challenge. If society creates a "right to suicide" and legalizes "physician-assisted suicide," the message perceived by a suicide attempter is not likely to be, "We respect your wishes," but rather, "we don't care if you live or die."


Almost all who commit suicide have mental health problems. Few people, if any, simply sit down and make a cool, rational decision to commit suicide. In fact, studies have indicated that 93-94% of those committing suicide suffer from some identifiable mental disorder(Barraclough). In one such study, conducted by Dr. Eli Robbins of suicides occurring in St. Louis, Missouri, 47% of those committing suicide were diagnosed as suffering from either schizophrenic panic disorders or from affective disorders such as depressive disorders, dysthymic disorders, or bipolar disorder. An additional 25% suffered from alcoholism while another 15% had some recognizable but undiagnosed psychiatric disorder. 4% were found to have organic brain syndrome, 2% were schizophrenic, and 1% were drug addicts (Robins). The total of those with diagnosable mental disorders was 94%. An independent British study came up with a remarkably similar total figure, finding that 93% of those who commit suicide suffer from a diagnosable mental disorder(Barraclough).


Persons with mental disorders make distorted judgments. Suicide is often a desperate step taken by individuals who consider their problems...

Find Another Essay On Mental Health and Assisted Suicide

Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide Essay

869 words - 4 pages should have paramountcy. Works Cited Re C (n 31) Termination of Life on Request and Assisted Suicide Act 2002 Penny Lewis, ‘The Empirical Slippery Slope from Voluntary to Non-Voluntary Euthanasia’ [2007] Childhood Obesity 197, 199 John Keown, Euthanasia Ethics and Public Policy: An Argument Against Legalisation (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press 2002) Raymond J Devrette, Practical Decision Making in Health Care Ethics: Cases

Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide Essay

1538 words - 6 pages Euthanasia and Assisted SuicideIntroductionWhile medical life-ending behavior occurs in a great many jurisdictions, only very few have explicitly legalized euthanasia, physician-assisted suicide, or both. There are various forms of medical life-ending behavior that are classified as euthanasia. These include "active voluntary euthanasia," when medical intervention takes place, at a patient's request, to end the patient's life; "passive voluntary

Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia

3181 words - 13 pages right to obtain a doctors help in ending their lives. Assisted suicide and euthanasia also called the right to die movement, which has either been barred by the law or has been prohibited by court rulings in almost every state. In 1997, the Supreme Court upheld two state laws that barred assisted suicide. The court ruled that the constitution sis not guarantee an individuals "right to die."Euthanasia must be legalized in a way that individuals are

Physician Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia

799 words - 4 pages Physician Assisted Suicide (PAS) and euthanasia raise ethical questions about the medicalisation of death (J Hardwig, 2006; Kavanaugh, 2000) and whether it is worse to kill a patient, or to let them die through omission of treatment (Kavanaugh, 2000). All have the same outcome – the death of the patient – the ethical dilemma arise when considering how the patient’s death occurred (Rachels, 1975). Allowing a patient to die from the cessation of

Mental Illness and Mental Health

2797 words - 11 pages extreme life stressors, physical or psychic trauma, illness, and environmental problems? Describing behavior, thinking, and interpersonal ways of relating as normal or abnormal contribute to the stigma our society attaches to patients that seek mental health treatment. Looking at people’s difficulties as adaptive versus maladaptive can reframe the situation presented before us, possibly allowing for a sense of awe at how truly strong a person was

Assisted Suicide and the right to die

1418 words - 6 pages being medicated to them. The request is much deeper than drugs but a mental state that the patients want to just stop suffering and rest. Ezekiel and his team conducted a survey with oncology patients and oncologists and their experiences with physician assisted-suicide. The results of the survey were quite shocking. Majority of the patients did not request for assisted-suicide. The patients who did request suicide were mentally and physically

Problems with Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide

1303 words - 5 pages found most doctors had a tendency to overestimate survival time. But among patients who lived longer than six months, 40% had been expected to die sooner. The results are relevant to decisions to refer patients to hospice care -- and also to decisions for assisted suicide, which in Oregon can only be made by patients who are expected by their doctors to die in six months [A. Vigano et al., "The Relative Accuracy of the Clinical Estimation of the

America Needs Voluntary Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide

1461 words - 6 pages jobs correctly and with care (Vogel). When staying in a home care facility, the patient can develop many mental disorders such as depression and dementia or become worse than what they were before (Fenigsen). The author Fenigsen acknowledges those who oppose euthanasia, medical assisted suicide, or physician assisted suicide tend to throw in many good arguments, but do not stop to think about others and take themselves out of the equation. They

Essay on Euthanasia and Doctor-Assisted Suicide

1188 words - 5 pages Understanding Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide   This paper will address some of the more popular points of interest involved with the euthanasia-assisted suicide discussion. There are less than a dozen questions which would come to mind in the case of the average individual who has a mild interest in this debate, and the following essay presents information which would satisfy that individual's curiosity on these points of common interest

Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide arguementive essay

578 words - 2 pages Word Count:583Euthanasia and Assisted SuicideThe issue of euthanasia and assisted suicide to be legalized has been openly debated in our society recently. These issues are important because it raises traditional moral and ethical questions about how our society views human life. Number of arguments has been reviewed about these issues, and most doctors are in favor for euthanasia and assisted suicide under strict guidelines. This issue considers

Physician-Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia are Murder

1924 words - 8 pages follows Kevorkian's ideals and is against him instead. (Shapiro and Bowermaster, 94) Over 52 patients were killed in "Dr." Kevorkian's presence. (Online, 99) What if they could have found the help that they needed?   Euthanasia is ending one's life if one has a terminal disease is an incurable condition, and is done by a lethal injection. Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide began in ancient Rome and Greece. They believed that it was okay in

Similar Essays

Animal Assisted Therapy In A Mental Health Perspective

1420 words - 6 pages , nursing homes, therapy sessions, mental healthcare facilities, and even in people’s homes. These amazing animals are used on a wide variety of different disorders, but they are utilized mostly by people suffering from depression, anxiety, and PTSD. For people with these mental health disorders, everything in live can be difficult and challenging, however with the help of animal-assisted therapy, their mood, motivation, and life can dramatically

Assisted Suicide And Euthanasia Essay

1222 words - 5 pages conclusion, assisted suicide is supported by the right of people to make decision about their life provided the patient is in the right mental state to do it. Another reason to legalize assisted suicide is the empathy for our fellow. For some people who suffer chronic pain or terminal illnesses, suicide is a more ethical and respectable solution than suffer great pain until the day of their death, whereby people should have the obligation to relieve

Assisted Suicide And Euthanasia Essay

1438 words - 6 pages Suicide. ?Sanctity of life is an argument that points out strong religious and secular traditions against taking human life. Passive vs. Active distinction is an argument that states there is an important difference between passively ?letting die? and actively ?killing?. There is also the potential for abuse, burdened family members and health care providers may encourage the option of assisted suicide. Professional integrity is also involved. The

Euthanasia And Assisted Suicide Essay

1112 words - 4 pages Euthanasia Evaluation How much do you trust your physician? Do you trust them enough to put the faith of your life in their hands? The focus of this evaluation is on euthanasia, or also known as physician assisted suicide. Physician assisted suicide is the practice of putting the end to a terminally ill person who requested this option. Should euthanasia be legalized? The practice of euthanasia is becoming more and more widely accepted