Mental Health Within The Criminal Justice System

2683 words - 11 pages

This essay intends to address the role that state agencies, both within the Criminal Justice System (CJS) and more broadly the institutions of education, employment and health, play in supporting and implementing diversionary programs for offenders with mental health problems. Mental health is clearly one of the most critical issues facing the Australian and New South Wales (NSW) CJS with research indicating that offenders with mental health problems constitute the majority of those within the prison system. The current strategies for diversion will be critically evaluated in order to determine their effectiveness with regard to the delivery and production of justice, cultural sensitivity for Indigenous Australians will also be considered. The social construction of mental illness and the associated process of stigmatisation of this particular group will be explored in conjunction to explain why society still fails to prevent the mass entry of people with mental health issues into the traditional CJS.

Critical to understanding the extent of the problem is a clear definition of mentally ill, “a person suffering from mental illness and, owing to that illness, there are reasonable grounds for believing that care, treatment or control of the person is necessary for the person’s own protection from serious harm, or for the protection of others from serious harm” [Mental Health Act 2007 (NSW)]. Noting that the statute specifies the ‘control’ of this group which adds to the notion that people with mental health problems are inherently more dangerous members of our society. Furthermore mental health problems within the prison system (inmate population) are estimated to be three to four times higher than in the general Australian population (Beyond Bars Alliance (BBA) 2007, p. 1). Results from a 2001 study of 953 inmates who were screened at four of the five male reception centres and one female reception centre in NSW indicates that the twelve month prevalence for any psychiatric disorder among inmates was 77%, significantly higher than that of the Australian population 22% (Butler & Allnutt 2003, p. 48). Also for any mental disorder the inmate prevalence rate was almost three times the rate of the Australian population (15% vs. 42% among inmates) (Butler & Allnutt 2003, p. 48). These statistics clearly demonstrate the critical nature of the mental health issue within the NSW CJS and in particular the prison system.

The social construction of mental illness limit an individual’s life opportunities as they are labelled “psychotic stalkers, comic figures, neurotics who do everything to excess, or sometimes as sympathetic characters” (DeVoe 2003-2004, p. 926) rarely are they viewed as competent members of society as illustrated by Howard Geld experience, “many years ago, I was diagnosed manic depressive psychotic and ever since then I have tried to live up to it.” (Howard Geld cited in DeVoe 2003-2004, p. 925). However events such as NSW Mental...

Find Another Essay On Mental Health within the Criminal Justice System

The Criminal Justice System Essay

3698 words - 15 pages The Criminal Justice System Is this a hellish nightmare that I have to awaken from? Caged and confined, thinking and pondering, I wonder what human is this that he should be subjected to imprisonment that neither improves nor corrects his soul? Is there no compassion for restoring a man to contribute to this nation? Or does the dark side of humanity see offenders of the law as utter undesirables unworthy of aid and therapy

The Criminal Justice System Essay

901 words - 4 pages The Criminal Justice System The Criminal Justice System is one of the most important tools available to society for the control of anti-social behavior. The criminal justice system needs to prove a balance between punishing the guilty and protecting the innocent being found guilty; however it is not as easy to convict those who are guilty of committing crimes. There have been many miscarriages to justice where innocent

The Criminal Justice System

1487 words - 6 pages The Criminal Justice System After speaking with several different individuals, I think the reason I chose to use the responses and thoughts of Alissa C. in my paper is because she had straight yes and no answers with thoughtful explanations, and she had very few "I don't know" or "maybe" type answers. Alissa C. seemed genuinely concerned about the state of the criminal justice system and, obviously, had given it a great deal of thought

Prevalence of Mental Illness in our Criminal Justice System

2518 words - 10 pages association with crime and based on the information that has been found, this paper will attempt to further define the problem of mental illness within our criminal justice system and offer alternatives or insights as to how to possibly help with this problem. Literature Review In the United States alone, 57.7 million individuals suffer from mental illness. These illnesses range anywhere from mood disorders to anxiety disorders or to personality disorders

Criminal Law, Criminal Careers, and the Criminal Justice System

2544 words - 10 pages "America imprisons 756 inmates per 100,000 residents, a rate nearly five times the world's average. About one in every 31 adults in this country is in jail or on supervised release. Either we are the most evil people on earth or we are doing something very wrong." (Webb, 2009, p. 4) This paper will look at basic criminal law, the reasons for lives of crime, a brief outline of the modern criminal justice system, and its future.Criminal

Criminal Justice System

1518 words - 6 pages social order and are doing this by applying particular type of functions. “Function implies that the role of the police is concentrated on the maintenance of law and order and the prevention end reduction of offences (Mawby cited by Newburn, 2009, pp16). Their functionality is necessary part for the Criminal Justice System role not only because are the largest agency within it, but also because are the primary to deal with the actual crime. The

U.S. criminal justice system

1008 words - 4 pages U.S. CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEMIn order to keep a safe society, it is important to establish a nation with good education to teach people judging from right or wrong , excellent police force to keep our street safe, and most of all, a good criminal justice system to carry out the justice. United States is a place with little crimes, a nation with nice houses, beautiful beaches, and expensive shops without property just like what I seen in the

Canadian Criminal Justice System

2284 words - 9 pages Introduction The Canadian Criminal Justice System is, for the most part, reflective of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms and various Supreme Court of Canada case-law. Everyone who finds themselves on the opposing end of the Criminal Justice System is entitled to certain protections every step of the way, beginning even before the arrest; laws protect us from unreasonable investigative techniques, guarantee certain rights at point of arrest

U.S. Criminal Justice System

1847 words - 7 pages Before proposing a reform to the American criminal justice system, we must first examine the problems that plague the process of justice on all levels. American society plays an important role in shaping the criminal justice system. Their beliefs and values determine the type of deviants and the consequences of the crimes. Often their beliefs contradict each other. Americans believe that the more serious a crime is, the longer a person

Criminal Justice System

1183 words - 5 pages World War II and embroiled in three separate controversies. The Organization for the Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), in 1969 the European Union in 1995 and the Eurozone at its inception in 1999. During this time, it assembled and vast Nordic-style welfare state. The justice system in the United States has two systems, federal and state levels and not only one nationwide structure such as in Finland. The resemblance and differential

Intersectionality in the Criminal Justice System

2262 words - 9 pages implications, has become a better method of resolving challenges victims particular those from sexual cases undergo. One of the biggest flaws in the criminal justice system in tackling intersectionality is seen in the series of cases of sexual assault. Victims influenced by their gender or mental health are greatly undermined with traditional approaches taken. Non-traditional and alternative justice systems have provided some more benefits in

Similar Essays

Inequalities Within The Criminal Justice System

3303 words - 13 pages units have been available however for fathers the criminal justice system do not think that there should be a fathers and baby units (Women in Prison, 2013, p. 4). They would also suggest that there should be more visiting days that is not available which can have a huge strain on mental health and anxiety within custody which can lead to anger, frustration and violence. The whole situation shows a huge section of inequality against fathers with

Diversity Within The Criminal Justice System

2845 words - 11 pages of convictions of black men versus whites and Hispanics. These factors are the lack of diversity among legal professionals in positions of power for decision-making, specifically those in the criminal justice system; secondly, the racial disparities that exist in arrest conviction and sentencing and thirdly, the incidence of discriminatory actions within the justice system. The paper seeks to examine literature related to diversity within the

Jurisdictional Issues Within The Criminal Justice System

1964 words - 8 pages Within the United States’ Criminal Justice System, problems pertaining to jurisdiction issues are quite common due several reasons. The United States v. Thomas J. L Smiley case and the United States v. Jared Lee Loughner case both had jurisdiction issues. Smiley and several other men obtained permission through a license from Mexico to search for treasure on an expedition; the treasure belonged to the steamer Golden Gate, which belonged to the

The Criminal Justice System Essay

2417 words - 10 pages criminal and restorative proceedings in helping the offender be reinstated within society (Newburn, 2007). Braithwaite was working with offenders and victims and focusing on ways to reintegrate them back into society through restorative means instead of going through the criminal justice system and the stigmas attached to being labeled a criminal. Before Braithwaite began to develop this idea the punitive justice and penitentiary system had been