This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Merit Pay Demise Essay

1145 words - 5 pages

The dispute surrounding merit pay for teachers has existed for decades in many countries across the globe. The debate has been particularly heated in the United States. Since the 1920s, public schools began awarding pay mostly according to title, and seniority rather than merit. Numerous attempts have been made to introduce merit pay systems throughout this period, but it never gained widespread popularity on a national level. Now, however, political leaders such as Barack Obama have supported merit pay for teachers. This has reinvigorated the debate, with many groups falling on either side. The National Education Association, for example, has opposed merit pay, while the United Federation of Teachers supports the idea. The modern day merit pay, or pay-for performance programs offers teacher monetary bonuses for student achievement on yearly standardized test scores.

Merit pay conflicts with the way we are to teach in today’s schools, and cannot be fully effective. This form of motivation, for teachers, will be impossible to be evenhanded, and the broad term of “merit” does little for the long term success of the students. No “good” teacher is in it for the money, anyway. This newly rediscovered answer, to public education, could set back and delay the entire system.

Many advocates agree that merit pay systems typically have been one of the most valuable tools of motivating employees to perform to the best of their ability. It is recognition for the employees who achieve the highest productivity and results for the business or organization. A monetary reward in terms of a higher pay is the strongest incentive for an employee who is working with a greater enthusiasm, commitment and proficiency than the rest of his/her workforce. Even so, the supporters may a valid point; teaching is not like another other profession, and is impossible to compare the motivational tools used. A 2007 national survey of teachers by the nonprofits Public Agenda and the National Comprehensive Center for Teacher Quality found that, if given an option between two otherwise identical schools, 76% of secondary teachers and 81% of elementary teachers would rather be at a school where administrators supported teachers strongly than at a school that salaried significantly higher salaries (Toch, 2009, p. 99).
One of the main issues with merit pay for teachers is found in the manner in which it is measured. Most of the new performances pay laws and union contracts measure “effectiveness,” at least in part, by looking at the students’ test scores from one year to the next. One test score cannot paint a full picture of a student's accomplishment. Teachers unions have historically opposed merit pay, arguing that test scores are not an accurate measure of student achievement (Turner, 2010, para 15). Most teachers will report that a test will only show part of the picture. Standardized tests do not reflect life lessons, effective citizen traits, or character...

Find Another Essay On Merit Pay Demise

Margin Call Analysis

2262 words - 10 pages leave with a little extra money in my pocket. I believe her action does indeed deserve a merit for that fact being that she was fired and ask to stay until the end of the situation. Aasif Mandi a firm in house counsel does not have a very big role in the movie, but does point out the problem and effects. His action is getting his job done and motivate behind that is getting pay. The worldview the influence his action is having bills to pay and a

Green Marketing Essay

2404 words - 10 pages Altruism can be defined as ‘unselfishness.’(Merriam-Webster, 2010) If one is said to be carrying out an act of ‘altruistic’ merit, this act could be defined variously as an act of ‘self-sacrifice’ or ‘philanthropy.’ In other words, to act in an altruistic fashion is to prioritise the needs of others above and beyond the needs of the self; to act in a way that is not motivated at all by self-seeking interests. In their illuminating article

Age Discrimination in the Public Sector

3396 words - 14 pages less than younger employees if the differences in pay are legitimate; that is, older employees must, in fact, be less productive than younger employees. To be sure that the pay system does not discriminate illegally against older workers, the organization should compare the merit ratings of both groups to determine whether older employees systematically receive lower evaluations. If they do, the organization should make sure that the ratings are

Business Bluffing Reconsidered

3785 words - 15 pages husbands and wives should, ideally, share the same goals and cooperate. When disagreements do occur (such as on how much to pay for a new house), they should not negotiate against each other to determine their collective reservation price but rather should debate the issue and build a consensus as a unified front. I think that husband or wife is a role in which bluffing is not morally permissible, but there are others, such as any fiduciary role

Ships of the Honourable East India Company J Murdoch The Honourable East India Company was a response to the Dutch East India Company . This paper discusses the evolution and design of their ships

2810 words - 11 pages a ton, and decide amongst prospective suppliers as to who would given the contract. Once a ship was accepted in Company service it was guaranteed work for its life and upon the end of its useful life the Company would pay for its replacement. Although there was no binding contracts to support this practice all involved honoured the convention. However the system began to be subject to abuse and new investment into the company was prevented by

Roman Parents Did Grieve for the Death of Their Children

2706 words - 11 pages Roman parents attitudes to children will not completely match up to their modern equivalents. Historical opinion on how Romans treated the death of a child has steadily moved towards the belief that parents did indeed care about their child’s demise. The problem for most historians has been that surviving evidence mainly comes from the elites of roman society. As such generalisation about all of roman society is difficult to conclude since

Vigilantism During the California Gold Rush

2949 words - 12 pages , African-American, Mexican, Chinese, and a wide range of other nationalities that co-existed during the Gold Rush. For example, “California was often described in those years as a land where every man stood on his own individual merits and where a man’s former social class or his origin was of no matter.” In many ways, this romanticized view of the Gold Rush has some merit. Crimes that occurred within California, had they been committed in Texas or

black crisis

2963 words - 12 pages commitment to black ecumenism. But nowhere is this reality more poignant than among black United Methodists. Not only did they shrink by 140,000 between 1940 and 1964, but their attrition from an estimated 385,000 since the 1968 decree of "no more segregated jurisdictions" has paralleled the demise of the segregated Central Jurisdiction. A Disquieting Inertia Since there is no significant countervailing evidence in any integrated and

THE RISE AND FALL OF THE eBay REICH Essay (2008) on eBay by Richard Bilderberg. Works cited, Appendix. No attachments. Media & Business Studies: E-commerce

10718 words - 43 pages anything they are told. Take for instance the blatantly obvious eBay Live! Events, an annual -sponsored convention where eBay staff (all wearing blinders) spend the entire time pretending there is nothing wrong with eBay. This is a great opportunity for eBayers everywhere to over-pay to stand in long lines to hear self-serving tripe and receive schlock. It is much reminiscent of Paul Joseph Goebbels and his famous plenipotentiary for Total War

Kim Campbell - First Female Prime Minister

4349 words - 17 pages factors that would ultimately be her demise were stronger than those that had helped her there, the media and internal fighting made it impossible for Campbell to continue as Prime Minister after the 1993 election. Academically, Kim Campbell was a longtime student of government and politics. She first studied at the University of British Columbia; then moved onwards and upwards to the London School of Economics. Although she had received her

Democracies and Success in War

5454 words - 22 pages . Prime Minister Eshkol of Israel also feared that he would loose his status if nothing were to be done against the Arab nations. The decision-making process constrained Eshkol to only have one option which was to attack. An authoritarian leader may see that a preemptive strike against numerous opponents may seem like a risk and would not pursue such policies. In this case the price Eshkol would pay for not acting would supersede the risk of fighting

Similar Essays

Nathaniel Hawthorne's My Kinsman, Major Molineux As An Allegory

1818 words - 7 pages ). Becoming more familiar with the history of his young nation, he even published “a child’s history of colonial and revolutionary New England” (1249). This being as it is, it would do Hawthorne’s short stories a great injustice to dismiss their merit as historical commentaries. Obviously, Hawthorne’s works are multifaceted, and one must determine how to best read and interpret them. Can the reader of Hawthorne’s short story “My Kinsman, Major Molineux

Human Resource Management In The Us

1770 words - 7 pages begun to try more innovative pay for performance and skill‐based compensation practices (see skill‐based pay design). These vary from rather simple merit pay systems, where employees' raises are determined by their annual evaluation, to gainsharing systems, where employees receive bonuses based on cost‐cutting, to more complicated stock options plans (see employee stock ownership plans). In all, a trend toward pay for

Examine The Issues And Implications Associated With Strategically Integrated Renumeration System

2051 words - 8 pages unable to pay for increased remuneration then they have to agree to such changes is likely to result the demise of the business.The last not the least factor is External labor market must be examined before establishing a remuneration system. It is to know about what competing employers are paying to their labors with similar skills, abilities, qualifications and experience. Once an employer is able to know that higher wages are paid in some other

Factors And Influence Of The Salem Witch Trials

2589 words - 10 pages The Salem witch trials transpired in the late 1600’s and caused uncertainty and controversy throughout the society. The town of Salem is where most of the trials occurred, and practicing witchcraft, and our American government forced over a dozen citizens to pay with their lives. The witch trials happened because of conflicts dealing with religion, fear, and feuds. The trials began during the spring of 1692, after a group of adolescent girls