Messerschmidt’s Theory Of Hegemonic Masculinity Essay

2570 words - 10 pages

Messerschmidt's Theory of Hegemonic MasculinityBy Rachel Bustamante, A #01507521December 11, 2012"Masculine domination…is neither fixed nor inevitable, but results from social struggles" (Messerschmidt, 1993). In order to better understand the male-dominated crime I have encountered personally, I thoroughly researched the theories in class and have chosen Messerschmidt's theory of hegemonic masculinity as the best possible explanation for male crime. Hegemonic masculinity deals with the culturally normative ideas of who a male is and how he should behave. It is a social process. However, the method of displaying one's maleness can vary with each situation, culture, race, and class. If legitimate opportunities are not available in order for one to prove his maleness, then force may be used and opportunities created through criminal activity. From the time we are born, we are conditioned to act a certain way based on only two concepts of gender: either male or female. Those born with male genitalia are often taught to be aggressive risk-takers and also to dominate over women. Those born with female genitalia are predominantly taught to be "ladylike," be the main caregivers for children, and be subservient to males. This leads to the stereotype of a typical male persona, one which is often vulnerable to being challenged and frequently requires considerable effort to maintain it.Messerschmidt states that "any attempt to understand masculinity and crime must begin with a comradely friendly scrutiny of the theoretical positions of radical and social feminism on men, masculine dominance, and crime" (Messerschmidt, 1993). It is important to examine both types of feminism because the hegemonic male intertwines, and is influenced by, a combination of these two movements.Although radical feminism in itself is not a viable theory, the importance of it to Messerschmidt's theory is that it brings the intense changes in our social consciousness into focus. Power in gender relations is first brought into play by radical feminism. By concentrating on violence against women, the goal becomes to understand and eliminate male domination. Radical feminism views patriarchy and male power as the root cause of all forms of inequality, with the family being the chief institution of patriarchy. In my experience, this has been the case. From a very early age, I was taught by my parents that a woman was created to be a support system for the more dominant male. Submission was required. If you had asked me what I wanted to be when I grew up, I would have responded that I wanted to be a housewife and mother. This was the typical response of my peers as well. The church I attended did not allow for women leadership, and Biblical submission of wives to their husbands was emphasized. Not once were we told the other part of that Biblical commandment: husbands should love their wives and treat them as they would themselves. I remember one particular incident, when I was in...

Find Another Essay On Messerschmidt’s Theory of Hegemonic Masculinity

Compare and Contrast the Representation of Masculinity of John Wayne’s Rio Bravo (1959) and Die Hard (1988).

2209 words - 9 pages prominent feature of his masculinity. At only 5 feet 11 inches, John McClane (Bruce Willis) falls short of the towering figure of John Wayne. Thus, Rio Bravo attributes symbolic power to John Wayne and his representation of hegemonic masculinity. His dominant height has been referred to phallic symbolism in gender theory. The establishing shot of the morning sunrise frames the western landscape and centres on a tall cactus protruding upwards which

Examining Sub-Cultures: The Goth Culture Essay

1825 words - 7 pages these practices can be seen to challenge hegemonic societal norms, this is but half the full picture as we will hope to show. Studies of Goth cultures highlight practices that appear to challenge hegemonic norms of masculinity. Each of these subcultures norms and values serve to defy and rebel against traditional society. In theory, this can be applied to Goth culture. However in their attempts to challenge the idea of hegemonic masculinity

Feminism and Masculinity

829 words - 3 pages In contemporary society, hegemonic masculinity is defined by physical strength and boldness, heterosexuality, economic independence, authority over women and other men, and an interest in sexual relationships. While most men do not embody all of these qualities, society supports hegemonic masculinity within all its institutions, including the educational institute, the religious institute and other institutes which form the ideological state

Culturally Dominant Models of How to be and Look a Man

2511 words - 10 pages female characters. The Doctor is subject to cultural developments in his masculinity depending on the hegemonic norm; he is white, middle class, independent heterosexual embodying the current extrovert nature of the young male sex symbol. Contemporary theory on masculinity in media to Baker (2006) constructs the basis of masculinity in a period as the reflection of changes in political ideology. Centralizing a thesis that ideology has a need to

Masculinity in the Workplace

1404 words - 6 pages explained by Williams is hegemonic masculinity. It is a concept that was first introduced by R. W. Connell and he defines it as follows: ”The socially dominant form of masculinity in any given historical period. Qualities currently associated with hegemonic masculinity include physical strength and bravado, exclusive heterosexuality, stoicism, authority, and independence.” According to Martin Kilduff and Ajay Mehra, male hegemonic masculinity is

Gender Symmetry

1075 words - 4 pages Gender Asymmetry is a term that says that masculine qualities tend to be more valued in our society than feminine qualities. This is a term that is made up by our society. We are taught how to behave as a male or a female in our society. This theory allows the concept of male privileged to rule. Hegemonic masculinity, the gender wage gap, marital power and meritocracy all show evidence of gender asymmetry. “The concept of hegemonic masculinity

The Continuation Of Patriarchy In Our Culture

1538 words - 6 pages risk. The connections that are formed around this behavior are one of the many reasons patriarchy continues in our culture. Many men are afraid to go against other men in fear of seeming feminine. This pressure for men to appear masculine is one of the many parts that form the system of patriarchy. Hegemonic masculinity reveals the male-dominance of patriarchy. This term refers to what is considered normal male behavior in our culture

Hegemonic Masculinity in American Society

1529 words - 6 pages Masculinity is described as possession of attributes considered typical of a man. Hegemonic masculinity is a form of masculine character with cultural idealism and emphasis that connects masculinity to competitiveness, toughness, and women subordination. Masculinity hegemonic is the enforcement of male dominion over a society. Masculine ideology dates back to the time of agrarian and the industrial revolution in Europe when survival

The Importance of Maintaining Gender Roles

1574 words - 7 pages the child will be deemed socially inappropriate. There are different theories regarding development of gender roles in individuals, but the social-developmental theory states that as a child matures, he or she will more strongly acquire and apply the relative gender role. Since masculinity is considered to be the highest tier in the gender role hierarchy, how is the boy able to express his emotions without punishment for breaking masculine gender

Juvenile Homicide Can Be Prevented

2365 words - 9 pages . Krienert, J. L. (2000). Masculinity and Crime: A Quantitative Exploration of Messerschmidt’s Hypothesis. Electronic Journal of Sociology . Levitt, S. D. (2000). The determinants of Juvenile Crime. Chicago: University of Chicago and American Bar Foundation. Merton, R. K. (2008). Social Structure and Anomie. American Sociological Review , 672-682. Robert V. Heckel, D. M. (2001). Children Who Murder: A Psychological Prespective. Westport: Praeger

South Park: Fun With Veal

2570 words - 10 pages of femininity and women by using the vagina pejoratively as a symbol of infirmity. Thus, the episode suggests that vegetarianism’s feminine connotations render abstention from consuming animals incommensurate with demonstrating hegemonic masculinity. Thereby both supplying justification for the subordination of women and the nonhuman natural world and implying the interconnectedness of either victim(s) of oppression and correlative cultural

Similar Essays

Messerschmidt’s Theory Of Hegemonic Masculinity Essay

2570 words - 10 pages Messerschmidt's Theory of Hegemonic MasculinityBy Rachel Bustamante, A #01507521December 11, 2012"Masculine domination…is neither fixed nor inevitable, but results from social struggles" (Messerschmidt, 1993). In order to better understand the male-dominated crime I have encountered personally, I thoroughly researched the theories in class and have chosen Messerschmidt's theory of hegemonic masculinity as the best possible explanation

Comparative Anaylsis Of Hegemonic Masculinity Essay

1652 words - 7 pages that men need to be educated in order to succeed and exert power and dominance over women. For men to be educated, they are able to attain good paying jobs to support their families. Although both articles discuss the importance of educating men, Tragos largely focuses on hegemonic masculinity in the context of exclusively white men. The article targets white men and women which insinuates that people of different race are to be minorized. In

Critically Evaluate The Argument That The So Called "Crisis In Masculinity" Paradoxically Furthers Forms Of Hegemonic Masculinity.

2586 words - 10 pages that masculinity qualities are being challenged by our society and feminism. Men are now being portrayed as trouble makers because statistics show that they have been doing worse than women in various areas. Nevertheless, people argue that this so-called "crisis in masculinity" is paradoxically further forms of hegemonic masculinity. This essay will establish the origin of the crisis in masculinity, which is believed to be the male liberation

Masculinity Essay

1298 words - 6 pages things physically, (3) a man confronts his adversaries and problems, (4) real men take responsibility for their actions, (5) men are not whiners, and (6) men are winners (Soulliere 2006). Finally, all of these messages support Soulliere’s theory that the WWE contributes and promotes the dominant hegemonic form of masculinity. Critique Soulliere’s topic choice regarding how the hegemonic form of masculinity is portrayed in WWE, fluidly connects