This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Metaphor, Sociobiology, And Nature Vs. Nurture: The Biological Battle Of The Century

2375 words - 10 pages

Metaphor, Sociobiology, and Nature vs. Nurture: The Biological Battle of the Century

Ladies and Gentlemen! I am proud to present one of the biggest and longest-running biological battles of the century! Tonight we recap the surprising nature vs. nurture fight. The following pages will explain the highlights, but if you want to learn about this war in its entirety, you’ll find the blow-by-blow account available to the public in Connie Barlow’s collection, From Gaia to Selfish Genes, in a chapter entitled "Nature, Nurture, and Sociobiology."

What began this brawl of the biologists? Was it a woman? No. Was it a war? No. It was a metaphor. And the metaphor states that society is an organism. This metaphor believes that individuals in a society work together in order to function like an organism. But this isn’t the dispute—the real fight lies within the question, How is this organism organized? In other words, do we inherently possess the knowledge to function like an organism or are we taught this skill? Here come the returning champs now!

In the Blue Corner—The Returning Champs:

The Anti-Sociobiologists

Weighing in with a professor from Harvard, a chair of neurobiology from the Open University, and a chair of psychology from Northwestern University, the anti-sociobiologists defend the idea that genes and environment work together, much like a dance, in which the individual is taught social behavior. In an excerpt from their book, Not in Our Genes, theorists Richard Lewontin from Harvard, Steven Rose from the Open University, and Leon Kamin from Northeastern University propose, as the title suggests, that social behavior is not genetic. Rather, it is taught or influenced by an individual’s surrounding environment. In this nurture argument, supporters claim that the individual’s genetic material influences the environment, and vice versa, to result in a society that works collectively, resembling an organism: the individual is taught, in accordance with his/her inherent nature, how to play a role in society. However, anti-sociobiologists do not disregard genetic behavior; rather they state that nature and nurture converse in a dialogue where neither is overpowered. But here come the challengers now!

And In the Red Corner—The Underdogs:


Weighing in with a Pulitzer Prize, a National Medal of Science, and a 1986 National Magazine Award, the sociobiologists argue that social behavior is inherent and that complex behavior can be reduced to simple genetic, or physical, explanations. This is the nature argument. Edward O. Wilson, the Harvard professor who is the founder of sociobiology, as well as the winner of the Pulitzer Prize and National Medal of Science, defines sociobiology as "the systematic study of the biological basis of social behavior in every kind of organism, including man" (163). According to Wilson, "what is new is the way facts and ideas are being extracted from their traditional matrix of...

Find Another Essay On Metaphor, Sociobiology, and Nature vs. Nurture: The Biological Battle of the Century

The Importance of Nature and Nurture

1316 words - 5 pages of separation, adoptive family cultures, and years before reuniting. These factors seem to have little to no impact on behavioral similarities between the twins, leading some researchers to believe that genetics have a more powerful influence. (“Nature vs. Nurture - Twin Study Overview”) A recent field of biology, called epigenetics, is rapidly transforming previous ideas on the impact of genes. The epigenome, literally meaning above the

Nature vs. Nurture and the Impacts on Human Intelligence

2276 words - 9 pages In current times many psychologists agree that nature (genes) and nurture (environment) both play important roles in the sculpting of intelligence in individuals, they work together constantly to guide maturity. This paper will look briefly at how intelligence is measured and the validity of those measurements. Additionally an argument for how environmental factors; education and parental health may influence the intelligence level of the

The Creation of a Serial Killer: Nature vs. Nurture

1481 words - 6 pages exactly drives someone to kill another human being? What plays as a more drastic motivator for their actions, nature or nurture? Nature refers, in this case, to how the subject is genetically made-up. It is the belief of many researchers that damage to the brain or front lobe causes the violent behavior demonstrated by serial killers. The frontal lobe is in charge of social relations and maintaining adequate relationships with others

Nature and Nurture, not Nature vs. Nurture

1974 words - 8 pages which both nature and nurture play roles, it would not be farfetched to suggest that both heredity and environment have influence in the development of human personality traits. There are those that would mistakenly argue that it is a matter of heredity which determines morality. Richard Rorty, philosopher and author of “Born to be Good,” introduces his audience to a Harvard scientist, Marc Hauser. Hauser, an evolutionary biologist and professor

Nature Vs. Nurture In the Novel Frankenstein

2205 words - 9 pages Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences, “Nature, which may be defined in terms of inheritance, biological background, and genetic makeup, must be taken into account, along with nurture, which may be defined in terms of experience and learning.” The debate is whether a persons innate qualities or their personal experiences make up individual differences. We are aware that physical characteristics are genetic, but many physiologists differ on the idea if

Nature vs. Nurture: Leaning Towards the Nurture Theory

2205 words - 9 pages if he or she grows into a well behaved young person, or one with personality issues (Onkal, 2005). Nurture also refers to a child’s life experiences. These experiences shape and define the way a child thinks and acts (Onkal, 2005). Research has been conducted for both sides of the Nature vs. Nurture debate and, while no solid conclusion has come to the argument, research tends to favor the environment’s influence on personality. The first side

The American Pit Bull: Nature vs Nurture

2176 words - 9 pages When the American Pit Bull is discussed, the subject of nature versus nurture is often the primary topic. Over the last ten to twenty years, thoughts have changed greatly in respect to dog fighting. Throughout history, several different types of dogs have been used for dogfighting. Ancient Romans had displays of dog fights, as well as gladiators, in their great arenas long before the bully breed ever came into existence (Hsu & Sun, 2010

The Meaning of Nature and Nurture in Psychology

1863 words - 7 pages together, that they are contradictory and exclusive one from each other. Biological and environmental explanations of human behaviour do not need to be contradictive; the biological factors work inside of an environmental context, and this context is formed upon a biological base, that is why nature and nurture can not be a dichotomy. But what does nature and nurture mean in psychology? Nature is everything determined in

The Nature-Nurture Debate

1695 words - 7 pages How the Pendulum Swings: The Nature-Nurture Debate One of the most intriguing science-and-culture debates of the twentieth century is that of the origin of behavior. The issue that has its roots in biology and psychology is popularly framed as the "nature versus nurture" debate. At different points in time, consensus has swung from one to the other as the supposed cause of our actions. These changes are not only the result of an

The nature/nurture debate

794 words - 3 pages genes and the environment steps in. As with all of these 'nature-nurture' discussions, this 50-50 percentage is not concrete. There's no way to tease apart the contributions of heredity vs. environment for any given trait. First, there's no way something can be affected by just "heredity" or just "environment" -- you must consider a third, unique source of variance, the dynamic interaction of heredity X environment. Second, for each

Pedophilia and the Nature-Nurture Controversy

969 words - 4 pages . More recently, in the United States, Ariel Castro was convicted of kidnapping and raping three young girls; Georgina “Gina” DeJesus, Amanda Berry, and Michelle Knight. How can we explain pedophilic tendencies? Are pedophiles born that way or are they conditioned to be that way? There is no definite answer, but there are arguments to support both sides of this statement. This essay seeks to demonstrate that there are both biological and

Similar Essays

The Role Of Nature Vs Nurture

631 words - 3 pages The Role of Nature vs Nurture "We used to think our fate was in our stars. Now, we know, in large part, that our fate is in our genes." ---James Watson While social research has been steady and ongoing, our biological knowledge has advanced disproportionately in recent times. As we discover more about the role of genes in pre-determining who we are, the nature versus nurture debate seems headed for a tilt of the biological over the

The End Of Nature Vs. Nurture

1274 words - 5 pages The End of Nature Versus Nurture The article "The End of Nature Versus Nurture" was about the arguments and debates over the past fifty years over the issue of nature versus nurture. The first thing that de Waal mentioned in the article was how we can't possibly think about where the issue will be at fifty years from now without looking back fifty years first (1999). He talks about learning and instinct, which fifty years back was as hot a

The Nature Vs. Nurture Debate Essay

1757 words - 7 pages The Nature vs. Nurture Debate No change in circumstances can repair a defect of character. Ralph Waldo Emerson One of the great controversial debates in Psychology is determining if characteristics and behavior are primarily due to genetics or the environment. We can now readily accept that genes determine our eye color, height, blood type, and other biological factors. Do these same genes that determine anatomy also determine our

The Battle Of Mankind Vs Nature

1296 words - 5 pages The Battle of Mankind VS Nature  Due to devastation caused by the dropping of the atomic bomb, man kind has only used nuclear weapons twice in war. In August 2026: There Will Come Soft Rains, the author, Ray Bradburry, writes about a nuclear holocaust in the year 2026. He writes about a house that services the nuclear explosion, and the house, which has advanced technology , performs daily activities to aid the Fetherstone family. The house is