Metaphysics: Ontology: Dualism Vs. Materialism Essay

2277 words - 10 pages

Metaphysics: Ontology: Dualism vs. MaterialismThe original idea of the word 'philosophy' was a 'love of wisdom' (Cowan 2). Philosophy is meant to explore the 'big questions' and try to find answers as best we can in the time we have been given. One of the areas of study in philosophy is metaphysics, which deals in the ideas of the nature of reality. "We look at the world, and we assume that it is the way it appears to be. It is not." (Carreira 7). There is much to reality that can be discussed, debated, and disagreed upon. Within metaphysics is the realm of ontology, which poses the question 'what is there?' (Cowan 146). Two of the major views in ontology are Dualism and Materialism, both ...view middle of the document...

Kant argues that reality is separated into two worlds, one that we are able to perceive and a second that we cannot. Logical positivism poses that the only knowledge and information that is meaningful is verifiable, at least in principle. These two arguments, while they oppose the field of metaphysics, do have pitfalls of their own that keep them from completely blocking the possibility of metaphysics (Cowan 147-152).Kant's "Copernican Revolution" consists of the argument that there are two worlds that comprise our reality. The first is the 'phenomenal' world, the world we are able to see, taste, touch, smell, and hear. The world we comprehend and understand. The second is the world of 'noumenal' world, the 'real' world that we cannot really understand and comprehend (Cowan 149). He has divided the world into a world of senses and a world of intellect, claiming that the world of the 'noumenal' is not accessible by either (Kenny 621). If we cannot gain knowledge of this 'noumenal' world than we cannot really gain any metaphysical knowledge. There are of course fallacies and problems with the Kant's "Copernican Revolution" argument.It is posed that Kant's distinction between these two worlds he has presented is self-defeating. "Kant attributes properties to the noumena such as being atemporal and nonspatial. But, if Kant's view were true, these properties would not apply. Rather, Plantinga shows that, on Kant's view, "the noumena would have to drop out altogether, so that all that there is is what has been structured or made by us. The idea that there might be reality beyond what we ourselves have constructed out of experience would not be much as thinkable."" (Cowan 150). This could lead to radical relativism and antirealism, basically, the world we perceive would be something that is built by our own minds and reality is defined by what is real to you. This creates the possibility of contradictory realities and even the idea that no one besides oneself exists as they are all constructs of your mind. This makes Kant's "Copernican Revolution" less of an obstacle to the field of metaphysics (Cowan 150).Logical positivism is the second presented obstacle to the study of metaphysics and much simpler than Kant's "Copernican Revolution". Stared by Schlick and the Vienna Circle the viewpoint of logical positivism sought to set up science to a standing as a 'unique and privileged' way of knowing and get rid of speculative metaphysics (Cowan 150). They contended that knowledge was only gained through experience and theories were only worthwhile if they could be proven or disproven by experience (Kenny 799). This 'verification principle' has undergone several changes and versions since its original development, but one of the most well-known defenders of the viewpoint, A.J. Ayer worded it this way: "A proposition is meaningful fi and only if it is empirically verifiable in principle." (Cowan 151). In other words, an idea or concept is only meaningful if it...

Find Another Essay On Metaphysics: Ontology: Dualism Vs. Materialism

The Mind/Body Problem Essay

1589 words - 6 pages solving the mind/body problem, we must come to the sad realization that we have not yet solved it; but thankfully, much progress has already been made.Over the course of all the work that has been done, two major schools of thought have been developed, which are dualism, and monism (specifically materialism). Dualism, which was founded by Rene Descartes, and outlined in his Meditations, is based on the fundamental claim that the mind is a metaphysical

A Response to Functionalism Essay

2380 words - 10 pages universality of physical laws as David Hume proposed with 'any volume of divinity or school metaphysics', that is, they should be committed 'to the flames'. My case may well be criticised on the grounds that it falls into the trap of Cartesian dualism which functionalism very carefully tries to avoid. Materialism, double-aspect theory and functionalism are responses to the perceived failure of dualism 'in to resolve the very difficulties it

What is the meaning of Philosophy?

1152 words - 5 pages materialism, scientific determinism, logical positivism and naturalism.Thus, modern philosophy has had two schools of thought in its history. Both accepted Plato's dualism, but simply picked opposite sides of the same coin. Rationalist's selected the mind and rejected the world. Empiricist's selected the world and rejected the mind. The problem is that it is the coin itself which is counterfeit. There is no dichotomy between mind and body, real and ideal

The Relation of Consciousness to the Material World

866 words - 3 pages interaction of mind with body rather than an actual one. This view resurfaces in the contemporary assumption that for every conscious experience there is a distinct neural "correlate." However, attribution of such correspondences to the workings of a munificent Deity has little appeal to the modern scientific mind. Within twentieth century philosophy and science it is far more fashionable to reduce dualism to a form of materialism, for

Psi and Ontology

2090 words - 8 pages closet is not exactly that thing thereby resulting in unconscious associations warping the information. A way to get around these short comings is to create an ontological model of sorts which can serve as an epistemic framework in which to house information. Ontology Often times used as a synonym for Aristotle? metaphysics (what he refereed to as first philosophy), ontology can be thought of as the philosophy and/or science of analyzing

Behaviorism, Functionalism and the Identity Theory

1134 words - 5 pages . In summary, it can be deduced that most philosophical discussions relating to materialism are normally, related to physicalism. Materialism belongs to the class monist ontology. In addition, ideas related to metaphysical naturalism and methodological naturalism are also inclusive in this content. The only philosophical alternatives to materialism are some forms of idealism, monism and dualism. However, there are some scientific rejections to materialism mostly emanating from the modern science writers and physicists whose scientific findings such as the chaos theory and quantum mechanics have openly disproven materialism.

Dualism: Concerns and Issues

2289 words - 9 pages Dualism is a broad term that can encompass many areas within philosophy itself. In aspect to metaphysics, it classifies the types of entities in the world into two subcategories, physical and non physical substance. While this may appear to be a very wide and ambiguous opinion, it becomes very specific in regards to our own existence. Paul Churchland puts it very explicitly in his book Matter and Consciousness, and defines

Aristotle's Theory of the Soul in the De Anima

778 words - 4 pages activities that are characteristic of living things of its natural kind. Aristotle’s De anima is a very fashionable book. It is fashionable chiefly because Aristotle develops a doctrine of the soul, as the form or ‘first actuality’ of an organic natural body, which seems to offer a via media between materialism and dualism. On Aristotle’s account, an animal’s soul is something other than its body, indeed something of a different ontological type from

When Men Began To Think: Revisiting the Ancient Asian Thinking

818 words - 3 pages dualism and materialism during the advent of Pythagoreanism and Platonism representing the dualist position, Atomism and Epicureanism the Materialistic, and Aristotleanism and Stoicism as a sort of holistic or quasi-holistic "third way" between the two. Simply put, the Greeks theorized that the universe originated from water, fire, etc., while the Asians were already discussing about the "being" in relation to its universe.I am sorry. I will never

Arguments Given by David Chalmers for Rejecting a Materialistic Account of Consciousness in His Book

5853 words - 23 pages Arguments Given by David Chalmers for Rejecting a Materialistic Account of Consciousness in His Book In this paper I will examine and criticize the arguments David Chalmers gives for rejecting a materialistic account of consciousness in his book The Conscious Mind. I will draw upon arguments and intuitions from the three main schools of thought in the philosophical study of consciousness(a) forms of dualism, (b) materialism, and (c

Heidegger's Reading of Descartes' Dualism

4301 words - 17 pages most primordial self. Heidegger suggests that Dasein as being-in-the-world solves the dichotomy of the subject-object ontology. The subject-object picture of our ordinary existence predicament appears as a derivative mode as Being-in-the world. If the dualism of subject and object is a derivative mode, then it cannot be a primordial mode of the Being of Dasein. In this sense, a dualistic picture of the Cartesian understanding of Being cannot

Similar Essays


1007 words - 4 pages Running head: METAPHYSICS AND EPISTEMOLOGY PAPER 1 METAPHYSICS AND EPISTEMOLOGY PAPER 5 PHL 215 Metaphysics and Epistemology PaperEpistemology and Metaphysics Schools Paper Write a 1,050- to 1,750-word paper that includes the following information: Explain the historical development for each of the following schools of thought: o Skepticism o Rationalism o Empiricism o Realism o Idealism o Materialism o Determinism o Existentialism Day

Paul Churchland's Argument Against Dualism Essay

960 words - 4 pages , C. (2004) "Dualism" [Online] Available at:Lee, R. (2004) "Churchland's Arguments Against Dualism" [Online] Available at:Robertson, M. (Accessed: 2006) "Dualism vs. Materialism: A Response to Churchland" [Online] Available at:Trout, J. & Moser, P. (2004) "Materialism" [Online] Available at:

Materialism Versus Non Materialism In Western Science

1034 words - 5 pages In regards to ontology and Metaphysics, there has always been the question of whether or not the nature of reality is fundamentally material or phenomenal, or whether or not mental states emerge from material causes thereby making them causally inert in themselves or whether or not material things are subsets of an underlying phenomenal realm where this has given rise to two branches of philosophy – materialism and non-materialism. Materialism

Tractarian Dualism Essay

4002 words - 16 pages While Wittgenstein’s Tractatus keeps issues of metaphysics and ontology at arm’s length, the world it presents seems altogether monistic in character. In Wittgenstein’s account, it is a world of objects and facts, a world which lacks selves, values, cognitive relations (such as belief), and God. I argue that the Tractarian world is nevertheless dualistic. I defend the view that the Tractatus points away from monism towards dualism and that