This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Military Commissions Act Of 2006 How Should Detainees Be Treated?

2159 words - 9 pages

Guantanamo Bay in Cuba houses some of the most dangerous people. The people being held have ranged in committing various crimes. What makes Guantanamo Bay well known is how the time period a detainee has spent in prison without a trial. While in prison for an extensive period of time, a detainee is bound to receive discipline for not following the guards. There are often a variety of different methods that the guards use to teach discipline to the detainees. All who follow Guantanamo Bay as institution often criticizes the measures taken. What makes Guantanamo Bay an ironic place to start this journey is because Guantanamo Bay is at the center of attention to a very important, controversial law passed in 2006. The controversial law was called the Military Commissions Act of 2006. The basis of this law was to define how a detainee in Guantanamo Bay and other prisons should be treated and if one is granted a fair trial. “No president should ever be given the power to call someone an enemy, wave his hand, and lock them away indefinitely” (Military Commissions). Instead, the way detainees are to be treated is up to the country in control of the prison, not just one person.
When President Bush runs and succeeds getting into office for a second term in 2005, he had more policy initiatives he wanted to put in place. One of his many policy initiatives was centered on the idea of counterterrorism (Head). After the September 11th attacks and the creation of the Department of Homeland Security, President Bush felt there should be more to help create a peaceful place for Americans to live in. This is how Guantanamo Bay came to be well known. Guantanamo Bay would be used to house dangerous criminals and terrorists that had ties and dangerous intentions to harm the United States and the citizens living in it. President Bush and the entire Congress at the time decided to take the protection of American citizens to the next level. By passing the Military Commissions Act of 2006, the person in control of all decisions would be the President. “ They also gave the president absolute power to designate enemy combatants, and to set his own definitions for torture” (Military Commissions). If someone were to identify the players who were deemed responsible for this act to pass, that someone would most likely identify President Bush and Congress. These central figures wanted to take the extra step in keeping the United States protected from any additional acts of terrorism. With what is stated in the Military Commissions Act of 2006 and those who stressed for the passage of the act, mixed messages are sent. President Bush, at the time, believed in less harm and more protection for the United States due to the extenuating circumstances. By creating a law that gives the President absolute authority and leaving no room for improvement, how was the United States going to look like? What it going to be looked at as a weak country with no control of power? The other player...

Find Another Essay On Military Commissions Act of 2006 How Should Detainees Be Treated?

Should The Newly Elected Hamas Government Of Palestine Be Sanctioned Or Engaged? (2006)

1226 words - 5 pages that the new government should be sanctioned in order to smother any prospect of the developing terrorism-related activity.Two polarized possible approaches, with regard to the way in which relations international relations should be cultivated with the new Palestinian Authority have surfaced in the aftermath of the election: sanction and isolate the Hamas regime, or execute a policy of engagement with the government. The United States and Israel

Military Service Should be Mandatory Essay

821 words - 3 pages Military Service Should be Mandatory Americans, especially baby boomers, should be ashamed of themselves. How can the world's richest population let its military go begging for recruits? Each year, the military services -- Air Force, Army, Marines, Navy -- establish recruiting goals to maintain adequate numbers of personnel. The numbers change annually depending on, among other factors, service needs, recruitment figures the year before

Military Service Should be Voluntary

897 words - 4 pages 28 in countries such as Iraq, Iran and Syria. Each young person is snatched away from their innate life, innocence, friends, and family in order to be drafted to the military. I do not support this policy because these venerable youth experience emotional tribulations, and mental instability from the trauma they have experienced in those two years, in addition this policy would be breaking the boundaries of the unalienable rights that each USA

Asylum seekers in Australia should be treated with greater respect

589 words - 2 pages Australia should be treated with greater respect. They are hereon humanitarian ground and the Government should treat anyone in danger with basicrespect, regardless of their social, ethnic or religious background. Treating refugees withgreater respect is the least the Howard Government can do after violation of human rights,mandatory detention centre and their unfulfilled obligation to international treaties.

PTSD: how it affects and how it can be treated

1387 words - 6 pages Posttraumatic Stress Disorder(PTSD) is commonly known to affect military personnel but anyone is able to get it. PTSD can be diagnosed because of an experience of a death or serious illness of a loved one, War or combat, Car accidents and plane crashes, Hurricanes, tornadoes, and fires, or Violent crimes, like a robbery or shooting. While all these reasons can cause PTSD, these reasons do not mean that all people who experience these will

The Adam Walsh Child Protection and Safety Act of 2006

715 words - 3 pages The Adam Walsh Child Protection and Safety Act of 2006 was established because an American boy was abducted form a Florida shopping mall and was later found murdered. The act was signed into law by George W. Bush on July 27, 2006. This act is established to protect children from sexual exploitation and violent crime to prevent child abuse and child pornography to promote internet safety. This act is also known as the sex offender registration

A dercription of Gout how it can be treated, what causes it, and who is affected by it,

611 words - 2 pages gout. Therapy that is directed at normalizing uric acid levels in the blood should only be used for patients who have had multiple gout attacks or developed tophi or kidney stones. Several drugs that help the kidneys eliminate uric acid are available, such as probenecid, and a drug that blocks production of uric acid by the body, such as allopurinol. The choice between these two types of drugs depends on the amount of uric acid in the urine. With the correct treatment, gout should be well handled in almost all cases.

Should The Racial Discrimination Act Be Reformed?

1811 words - 7 pages Should the racial discrimination act be reformed on the grounds of upholding free speech, as is currently claimed by the Abbott government? We are now in a time where the right to free speech could mean more to a country’s own development than ever before. Our nation is quickly becoming more and more apposed to one’s own opinion (especially in the political sector) whether it be bigoted or non-bigoted. Australia is well known as one of the most

Military Women Should NOT Be Allowed in Combat Positions

1652 words - 7 pages The prospect of women in ground combat or on the front-line in the military has proven to be a controversial issue throughout decades of war. This controversy stems from criticisms such as women’s physicality versus men’s, the association of sexual-related situations within the military, and a history of failed gender-integration training. The bottom line, however, is that women should not be allowed in front-line or ground combat unless they

Should Military Service be Required in the USA?

1045 words - 5 pages Military service in the United States should be compulsory (required) because it will provide economic and social benefits to those people who are serving as well as create a benefit for the general public as well as nation as a whole. “The United States relinquished mandatory military service after the Vietnam War in 1973” (Kestnbaum, 18). Since then, the idea of reinstating a draft entered the public discourse on several occasions. Its

Border Fence, Made To Fail? - Opinion essay. For or against Bush's Border Fence Act of 2006

1182 words - 5 pages that the only reason he voted for the fence is to show that border security is well on its way will make anyone sick. Obviously U.S. government officials do not take the time out to review the facts of immigration, and if the Secure Border Act of 2006 is their defense to that, then congress has set themselves up for failure in the long run. As far as the U.S. and Mexico is concerned, rather than isolating themselves, they should put aside the

Similar Essays

"Let The Government Do Its Job" A Paper Arguing In Support Of The Government In The Aftermath Of Sep 11th. Touching On The Patriot Act, Military Commissions, And Classification Of Doc

1624 words - 6 pages , this is what good government is. The idea that "freedom is indivisible and that if you lose a little you have lost it all, that if one person is deprived of liberty then we all are"2, is a nice idea, but it just isn't true. How many people is the patriot act really going to effect? How likely is it that your liberties are going to be infringed upon on because of the new legislation adopted since our war on terrorist ideology began? Chances are

How Should Prisoners Of War Be Treated?

3149 words - 13 pages How Should Prisoners of War be Treated? In an op-ed piece for the New York Times, entitled "George W. to George W.," Thomas Friedman writes about the treatment of prisoners in United States custody being held in Iraq and Afghanistan. Friedman writes in his "George W." piece that “We killed 26 of our prisoners of war. In 18 cases, people have been recommended for prosecution or action by their supervising agencies, and eight other cases are

How Should Childhood Depression And Anxiety Be Treated/Dealt With?

1643 words - 7 pages Inquiry question: How should childhood depression and anxiety be treated/dealt with? Introduction: Clinical depression, depression, biological depression, and major depression, all refer to the same thing: feeling sad for weeks or months on end. Depressed individuals struggle with feelings of dispaer, hopelessness, and no energy; things like getting out of bed, taking a shower, and eating become hard to do. Recent evidence has validated

Terrorists Should Be Treated As Prisoners Of War

2961 words - 12 pages . "Terrorists Should Be Tried in a Military Tribunal." Criminal Justice. Ed. Jill Karson. San Diego: Greenhaven Press, 2004. Opposing Viewpoints. Opposing Viewpoints In Context. Web. 15 Oct. 2013. Shapiro, Bruce. "Detainees in the War on Terror Should Be Treated as Prisoners of War." War. Ed. Louise I. Gerdes. San Diego: Greenhaven Press, 2005. Opposing Viewpoints. Opposing Viewpoints In Context. Web. 15 Oct. 2013. Taylor, Robert. History of Terrorism. San Diego: Lucent, 2002. Print. Winn, Aidan Kirby. "Can Gitmo's terrorists be rehabilitated?" Christian Science Monitor 29 June 2009: 9. Opposing Viewpoints In Context. Web. 30 Oct. 2013.