Milton And Rossetti Comparing Their Treatment Of Women

2258 words - 9 pages

The Treatment of Women in John Milton's Paradise Lost

And Christina Rossetti's "Goblin Market"

In literary history, the theme of the apparent female inability to curb curiosity has been a reoccurring one. In Greek mythology, Psyche's curiosity proved her undoing, when she fetched a lamp to see her husband's features that had been proscribed to behold. In Perrault's "Bluebeard", the fatal effects of curiosity are again depicted, with his new bride succumbing to the temptation to open the one door that was forbidden to her, with disastrous results. It would seem that the image of `woman' through the ages is somewhat unfavourable, suggesting that she is often weak, untrustworthy and is the harbinger of ill events. There is evidence of this doctrine of thought in both Paradise Lost and "Goblin Market", and yet it is manifested in dissimilar ways, influenced greatly by the fact that one author is male, the other female. It is arguably this factor which generates such differences in tone between two pieces which thematically are similar.

Both texts concern temptation - of which in each instance is symbolised by fruit - and the moral `fall' of a female character. Yet the approach to this theme in each piece differs, being inherently influenced by the period and social contexts at the time of writing, as well as the personal values of the respective authors. In Paradise Lost the only two female characters, Sin and Eve, are portrayed in a poor light. Sin is immediately introduced as `fallen', being the daughter and lover of Satan. Initially beautiful, being ."..a goddess armed/Out of thy head I sprung..." (2:766-767), she is borne out of the head of Satan. Her enamouring beauty leads to his incestuous pursuit of his `daughter' and culminates with Sin's womb conceiving ."..a growing burden..." (2:784-786), and suggests that her beauty, not the male persona, was to blame for the pregnancy. The subsequent birth of Death destroying her beauty from the waist down as he "Tore through my entrails, that with fear and pain/Distorted, all my nether shape thus grew/Transformed..." (2: 784-786) seems to be a punishment, for nothing other than being attractive. The violent rape by her `son` that precipitates her eternal torture by the "hell hounds" that ."..about her middle...never ceasing barked...and rung hideous peal...there still barked and howled/Within unseen..."(2: 654-659), so encourages an unhealthy insinuation that she must also pay for her `crime` of incest, and cordially appears to justify it. Hence Milton's misogynistic doctrine is manifested, and begins a perfect prologue to the parallels with subordinate and weak Eve.

Conversely, Christina Rossetti's approach has a fairy-tale element which is the perfect vehicle for teaching a moral lesson, without the negative connotations implied by Milton. "Goblin Market" deals with temptation through an almost childlike innocence, with the poem...

Find Another Essay On Milton and Rossetti - Comparing Their Treatment of Women

Treatment of Women and the Sense of Being

862 words - 4 pages difference in treatment of one sex over the other affects society as a whole. Society would function much better if women, and all people for that matter were treated equally and given all the same rights and opportunities for succeeding in life. It does not matter whether one is a woman or a man when they are stripped of their human rights, they will all feel as though they do not belong to society nor are they really human beings like all others because they see that they do not have the same entitlements or privileges as everyone else. Works Cited Mill, John Stuart. The Subjection of Women. Mineola, NY: Dover Pubications, 1997. Print.

The Treatment of Women in Romeo and Juliet

1991 words - 8 pages having children with her, and has no regard for her youth. Young women could also be harmed if they were not ready to bear children, which shows that the treatment of women was harsh and that their ability to produce children was more important than their health. Capulet is very complimentary to females, and calls them ‘earth-treading stars that make dark heaven light’, using a beautiful metaphor and contrast between dark and light to show he

The Treatment of Women in Romeo and Juliet

3464 words - 14 pages and having children with her, and has no regard for her youth. Young women could potentially be harmed if they were not physically ready to bear children, which highlights that the treatment of women was harsh and that from a male perspective, their ability to produce children was more important than their health. Additionally, Capulet is very complimentary to females, and calls them ‘earth-treading stars that make dark heaven light’, using a

Unfair Treatment of Women in Antigone and A Doll’s House

1668 words - 7 pages From the times of Ancient Greece, women have been questioning their unequal role in society. According to an unknown source “Women have been taught that, for us, the earth is flat, and that if we venture out, we will fall off the edge.” Unfortunately, this unfair treatment of women still exists today. In the business world, men continue to make 20% more money on average than a woman in the exact same position. But this unfair treatment goes

The Treatment of Women and Men Sports Players

6468 words - 26 pages The Treatment of Women and Men Sports Players Sport plays a major part in the culture of today’s society. Many people spend considerable time in front of the television, in sports grounds and traveling all over the country to support their respective club whether it be football, rugby, cricket or netball etc. However whilst playing, spectating or just generally being involved in a sport, things can go wrong and this

The Life and Times of John Milton

1424 words - 6 pages John Milton lived from 1608 to 1674 and was therefore a major part of the Neoclassical Period. Paradise Lost by John Milton was and still is an extremely controversial piece of literature. I have found that the more controversial and disputed a subject is, the more interesting it is to read about. Christianity is a notoriously touchy subject, so naturally I was pulled towards Paradise Lost. When I began my research on this “lost

George Milton in Of Mice and Men

1021 words - 4 pages George Milton in Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck is crude, snarky, and downright normal. He’s a character that, while some of his decisions are questionable, is easy to relate to from his actions, thoughts, and personality. The idea of such a character being remindful of the reader by spirit or another is emphasized by Alan Moore’s quote, “I suppose all fictional characters, especially in adventure or heroic fiction, at the end of the day are

The Unfair Treatment of Women

1567 words - 6 pages . Domestic violence was not the crime that it is today. In Texas, it was legal for a man to shoot his wife and her lover if he caught them in bed together, but the reverse was not true. Women everywhere in our culture were having similar experiences of unfair treatment because of being female, so they banded together to improve their social and professional status. Women created several support systems for each other, because they knew that the

Treatment of Women throughout Othello

2308 words - 9 pages Iago his depression and suicidal feelings over the loss of Desdemona, the ancient seeks to keep him alive by saying that Othello will soon grow tired of his bride (and then Roderigo will have her), stating indirectly that women are chattel and expendable:      These Moors are changeable in      their wills: fill thy purse with money:--the food      that to him now is as luscious as locusts, shall be      to him shortly as bitter

Women And Their Adversities

804 words - 3 pages Woman, half of the population is made up of us. Woman is the mother of life. If we are not here, there will be no father, no sons, no husbands, and no human beings. Adversity is a very difficult situation or problem that you face in lifetime. Every day women around the world face their adversities because of their sex, their colour, their religion, and what they wear.Good morning, everyone! I am Alice Walker. I am a black woman. From my

Various Sports Injuries and their Treatment

1609 words - 6 pages brain.Thirty years ago, all of these injuries were near impossible to treat, but due to the vast improvements in medical technology, doctors are more able to determine the anatomy of the different joints and how they have been damaged. With this improved knowledge, better methods of treatment have been developed and are still being developed. Today, if an athlete is injured, they can still return to playing their desired sport.

Similar Essays

Comparing Various Treatment Options For Sexual Offenders And Their Efficacy Rates

2063 words - 8 pages Treatment for Sexual OffendersComparing Various Treatment Options for Sexual Offenders and Their Efficacy RatesDenay TaylorAmerican Public University SystemCMRJ205 Rape and Sexual AssaultDr. Cassandra EmeryJune 22, 2014AbstractThe assessment and treatment of sexual offending has varied greatly within the last 40 years. The establishment of sexual offender treatment began in the 1970's where medical officials focused on reducing criminal

Comparing The Role Of Women In Their Eyes Were Watching God And Go Tell It On The Mountain

2155 words - 9 pages Role of Women in Their Eyes Were Watching God and Go Tell It On the Mountain Literature is a reflection of the community from which it comes. Understanding the role of women in the African-American community starts by examining the roles of women in African-American literature. The portrayal of women in Zora Neale Hurston's Their Eyes Were Watching God (1937) and James Baldwin's Go Tell it on the Mountain (1952) provides tremendous

Greek Women: Comparing And Contrasting The Status Of Women In 5th Century B.C.E. Athens To Their Status In The Hellenistic Age (4th 1st Centuries B.C.E.)

538 words - 2 pages but the Hellenistic women were given some political rights.Women in Athens were given very poor standards of education. They were educated only with the consent of their father. They learnt household jobs and probably how to read. The Hellenistic women were more educated. Hipparchia, one of the first female Cynical philosophers received an education based on rudimentary mathematics, music, literature, and of physical education. The reason why I

Treatment Of Women In Hamlet And Trifles

2819 words - 11 pages Treatment of Women in Hamlet and Trifles Of all Shakespeare’s thirty-seven plays, perhaps the best known and loved is Hamlet, Prince of Denmark. Many people think that it is unforgettable because of its poetic language and style. But, while these are factors that mark the play as a classic, it remains timeless because it explores many of the issues that are still important to people today. These issues, including loyalty to family and