Brain Versus Mind By Logic,A Historically Irresolvable Debate

2449 words - 10 pages

Brain versus Mind By Logic,A Historically Irresolvable Debate

As computer and neuroscience technology progresses, the perceived role of the human brain grows ever more complex and seemingly more determinant as to what makes a person, a self. Research and development projects in both the fields of neuroscience and artificial intelligence add fire to the Mind versus Brain debate. Are the biochemical mechanics of the brain sufficient explanation for human behavior, or is there a “mind”, distinct from the brain, which harbors free will? In other words, are human thoughts and conscious actions[1] entirely based on science or on purposive cause, calling for unscientific philosophy and/or religion? Whether there is a teleological explanation[2] for human behavior and brain activity centers around the issue of determinism. A purely mechanical explanation is intrinsically deterministic, whereas a teleological explanation leaves room for free will. Because the Mind versus Brain debate rests on whether there is free will, and because neither a purely mechanical nor a teleological explanation is logically defensible to a satisfactory extent, the teleological debate concerning human behavior and brain activity is logically irresolvable.

To understand fully teleological and purely mechanical explanations of human behavior and brain activity, it is first necessary to understand the fundamental biochemistry of brain function. Although the brain is the most complex and least understood organ of the human body, its functionally essential constituent is the neuron, which exists in clusters called ganglia.[3] A neuron, or an excitable nerve cell, transfers within the brain an electrochemical (or sometimes a purely electrical) signal to other neurons. This signal can be either excitatory or inhibitory, depending on how a receiving neuron chemically reacts to the signal.[4] A neuron is excited when it receives a signal and its interior and exterior ion concentrations change, allowing for passage of the signal. At rest, or when not excited, the cell has a central shaft, an axon, whose interior is 70mv (millivolts) negative with respect to its exterior.[5] This polarization is due to a transmembrane ion gradient; the exterior medium of the neuron is ten times richer in sodium ions ( ) than the interior, and the interior is ten times richer in potassium ions ( ).[6] When the neuron is excited, axon permeability to increases and a wave of voltage passes through the axon like a flame along a firecracker fuse. When the voltage, the electrical signal, reaches the posterior end of the neuron, it triggers the release of chemicals called neurotransmitters across a physical gap, known as a synapse, between the neuron and another “postsynaptic” neuron.[7] That is how signals pass between neurons in the human brain. As to how signals originate, the cell body is believed to generate an electrical impulse, by means unknown.[8] Also unclear is how...

Find Another Essay On Brain versus Mind By Logic,A Historically Irresolvable Debate

The Brain By Sexy Body a research paper of 11 pages

3346 words - 13 pages produce the cerebrospinal fluid.) produce a protective cerebrospinal fluid (cerebrospinal fluid: this what the brain floats in.) This fluid is what the brain literally floats in.A third protective measure taken by the brain is called the blood brain barrier (blood brain barrier: A set of special capillaries (capillaries: Tiny blood vessels, that are only found in the brain). Their purpose is to filter the blood so only oxygen, glucose (glucose

Criminal Shadows: Inside the Mind of a Serial Killer. A book by David Canter. Book Review

1022 words - 4 pages David Canter, professor of Psychology at Liverpool University, has written more that a dozen books on psychology, and his biography states he "....is the pioneer and leading expert in psychological profiling......" Criminal Shadows: Inside the Mind of the Serial Killer (1994) is a factual book, based on his own experiences, on the evolution and development of profiling and is set out chronologically. He explains that he believes a criminal

How the human condition is portrayed in the film "A Beautiful Mind" directed by Ron Howard

657 words - 3 pages What does it mean to be human? This is a question that has occupied the minds of people for centuries. Human beings are complex creatures and trying to understand the experiences in human life that make up the human condition can be very baffling.The film, "A Beautiful Mind", directed by Ron Howard, is a life story of a brilliant mathematician, John Nash and his struggle with schizophrenia. This film helps us to learn about the human condition

The Mind, the Final Frontier is a critical thinking paper,The brain is like an extensive intricate sponge through nuclei within its path, absorbing every crumb within its path.

596 words - 2 pages / mind, we have not even begun to scratch the surface.However the soul that functions within society requires the need for human contact and social acceptance by interacting, this gives us (the mind, body, and spirit) a sense of self worth. It's (the mind) interaction that dramatizes us physically, as well as intellectual stimulus on regular basis, which permits the achievement of everyday tasks placed at hand. As for withdrawal and antisocial

Advice to Laertes from Hamlet by William Shakespeare versus Advice to a Young Man by Benjamin Franklin

938 words - 4 pages Advice to Laertes from Hamlet by William Shakespeare versus Advice to a Young Man by Benjamin Franklin "I told you so!" This is what my mom would say after giving me advice, and me not taking her advice. It was so eerie how my mom was always right, like she knew exactly was going to happen. I'm sure that everyone has gotten advice at least once in their lifetime, especially from their parents. Elders usually know what's best for you

A Paradox: Written Through The Eyes of a Woman By The Mind of A Man: Issues of Patriarchy in Sinclair Ross's "As For Me and My House"

2521 words - 10 pages small town house wife. This was deemed innovative - especially regarding the time frame in which it was written. Many attributed the method used by Sinclair Ross to his own sexuality and gender issues and the birthing of the feminist movement. If the reader delves deeper into this idea and explores the material thoroughly issues of patriarchy are prevalent. Sinclair Ross's As for Me and My House was written through the eyes of a woman yet exhibits

The Dangers of a Conscious Mind 1984 by George Orwell

1735 words - 7 pages In society today, the horrific truth is that numerous people are hungry for power, and desire to be in a position that is exceedingly high above the rest. This is the general ideology of the Party, the supreme and ruling government in the legendary narrative 1984, written by George Orwell. 1984 is a dystopian, science fiction novel that is set during the year 1984 in the superstate of Oceania. In a malevolent world of continuous warfare

Role Playing Sectional Debate Speech by A Cotton Farmer

717 words - 3 pages hand conditions are just as bad or worse in northern factories.I being a southern plantations owner make my slaves work the fields throughout the day and they are able to help enormously with the production of cotton. I then sell this cotton to northern factories. The money I make in exchange for the cotton is just enough for me to get by. The cotton I sell is used by the northern factories which use their factory workers and the cotton is used to

Awake and Sing by Clifford Odet versus A Raisin in the Sun by Lorraine Hansberry

649 words - 3 pages Clifford Odet's play, "Awake and Sing", and Lorraine Hansberry's play, "A Raisin in the Sun", both revolve around the struggle of attaining the American dream during the hardships of a struggling economy and most important the value of a family. By analyzing the main characters, Ralph and Walter, it can be seen that even though they wish to use the insurance money to fulfill their dream they eventually realize that with family they can survive

It's Not About the Bike: My Journey Back to Life by Lance Armstrong versus The Hobbit by Tolkien. this essay is a comparison between the two books.

733 words - 3 pages Armstrong's book the main character, Lance Armstrong, was a professional bike rider who got cancer. Now he had to fight to survive. In The Hobbit the main character, Bilbo, was forced to help the Dwarves, led by Thorin, to reclaim his treasure which was stolen by the dragon Smaug. Bilbo would have to be the burglar, the person who steals the treasure. But in the story Bilbo helped in more ways than that. The conflicts were resolved in

Right vs Left Brain Learning

1255 words - 6 pages independently. They read by themselves and amalgamate research into their work. Left-brain individuals prefer a quiet setting with minimal distractions. Right-brain students handle learning very different. They would prefer to accomplish an art project compared to a term paper. Right-brain individuals choose group work over individual study (Connell, 2014). The human brain continues to develop as a person ages. But the right versus left brain learning

Similar Essays

"Logic In Love" : Analysis Of John Nash's Nobel Prize Speech In The Movie "A Beautiful Mind"

664 words - 3 pages "I've always believed in numbers. In the equations and logics that lead to reason; but after a lifetime of such pursuits I ask, what truly is logic? Who decides reason? My quest has take me through the physical, the metaphysical, the delusional and back, and I have made the most important discovery of my career... the most important discovery of my life. It is only in the mysterious equations of love that any logical reasons can be found."This

The Formula For Fruition: The Age Old Debate Of Nature Versus Nurture By Kendra Cherry

1887 words - 8 pages that we are and all of our knowledge is determined by our experience.” (Cherry) . Over time, with more research, it seems to be that nature and nurture work together to form who a person is, but when it comes to intelligence, scientists still debate which of the two may be a more powerful determinant. When I realized just how many aspects of life “nature vs. nurture” applies to, I decided to narrow my search down to how it affects your

"Hillside Strangler: A Murderer's Mind", Written By Ted Schwarz.

2298 words - 9 pages an explanation for Bianchi's MPD.In the end, Bianchi was interviewed by six different psychiatrists; two for the defense, two for the prosecution, and two to advise the judge, all with varying expertise in MPD, hypnosis, murder and madness, and child abuse. In the end, a clear and decisive opinion that Bianchi suffered from MPD did not emerge, rather a contentious debate as to Bianchi's state of mind occurred. Three rather different opinions

What Claims Have Been Made About The Differences In Psychological Functions Performed By The Left Versus Right Hemispheres Of The Brain? .

877 words - 4 pages about the functions of the left versus the right hemisphere? Does this evidence have anything to do with these stereotypes? What happens to an adult's personality after a left versus a right hemisphere lesion?INTRODUCTION 100 WORDSPart one 500 words4 claims 120 words eachPsychology Right Brain, Left Brain. The article in which I chose to examine is called Right Brain, Left Brain: Fact and Fiction, written by Jerre Levy. In the past fifteen years or