Minority Report: Film Vs. Short Story

966 words - 4 pages

Minority Report: Film vs. Short Story

Mutant humans, nicknamed precogs, have visions of future crimes. An entire police force is dedicated to interpreting these visions and catching the future criminals before they commit these foreseen crimes. Commissioner John A. Anderton was the creator of this institution called Precrime in New York City and has a strong pride in his work. Everything had seemed to be a success, there had not been a murder for five years, but it all starts to fall apart when the precogs have a vision of Anderton committing a murder of a man he has never met before, named Leopold Kaplan. The commissioner believes he has been set up by a young man, Ed Witwer, who will be taking Anderton’s place when he retires and also possibly his wife, Lisa. Anderton goes on somewhat of a quest to find out who is behind all of this. Through his quest he discovers that the strongest precog, which is the female named Donna, sometimes has different visions than the other two male precogs. These are called minority reports, and Anderton finds that he does not have one. He finally finds who is behind his setup, and it is Kaplan, a retired Army General and the man he is supposed to murder. Kaplan had a plan to bring down the Precrime system by keeping Anderton from killing him even though the precogs had envisioned that Anderton would kill Kaplan. In the end, Anderton does kill Kaplan to prove the system still works and Precrime continues (Dick, 1987).

This concept of Precrime was created in a short story entitled The Minority Report by Philip K. Dick. Fourty-six years after Dick wrote this story in 2002, Steven Spielberg directed the film Minority Report based on Dick’s story starring Tom Cruise. There are many differences between the storylines, characters, settings, etc.

In the film, the story takes place in Washington D.C. The precogs are not mutant humans, but are praised as wonderful beings. John Anderton was not the creator of Precrime, Director Lamar Burgess and Iris Hineman were the “mother and father” of Precrime. Anderton’s pride in Precrime came from a previous experience he had with the kidnapping of his only child. His wife, Laura (not Lisa), separated from him and lived near a beach away from Anderton and Precrime, but in Dick’s story they are married and she works at Precrime with John. Danny Witwer (not Ed) is an FBI investigator, not Anderton’s replacement, who enters the film to discover flaws in the Precrime system, specifically human flaws. The precogs vision of Anderton’s future murder depicts him killing a man he does not know, but the man is Leo Crow, not Leopold Kaplan. Anderton, in the film, still believes he is being set up and goes on a quest, which is drawn out more than in the short...

Find Another Essay On Minority Report: Film vs. Short Story

A Rose for Emily. A summary report on the short story by William Faulkner.

1342 words - 5 pages A rose for emilyLove, obsession and Gossip In "A Rose for Emily," William Faulkner uses the point of view of the townspeople to show their personal opinions and judgment's of Miss Emily. He writes a story about a woman who is traumatized by the way her father has raised her and the effects of his strict and overprotective mentality. Because of her father's death she finds it difficult to let go and live a normal life that involves social

Sensuality vs. Reality in Ernest Hemingway's Short Story A&P

965 words - 4 pages Sensuality vs. Reality in Ernest Hemingway's Short Story A&P John Updike once said, "Man lacks grace because he has retreated from responsibility into sensuality." Sammy, the protagonist in Updike's short story, "A&P", is a perfect literary representation of this quote. During the course of "A&P", he runs from every responsibility he has, just to make himself feel better. He gets distracted from his duties at work and makes mistakes

Analysis of the film "Speed", through looking at story vs. plot, range of narration, depth of narration, and narrative structure. Including Bibliography.

1311 words - 5 pages Question:Discuss two or more of the following issues: story vs. plot, range of narration, depth of narration, and narrative structure. In addition, pay attention to the film's stylistic choices, and how they relate to formal strategies in the narrative and narration.The film "Speed", starring Keanu Reeves and Sandra Bullock is classed as a film where narrative plays a very large role in delivering the viewer with a broader understanding of the

A critical comparison of Dr. Jekyll and Mr.Hyde original book version vs. a film version of the story

1200 words - 5 pages the film and book. There are several elements or subplots that were evident in the movie version of the novel that was nowhere to be found in the book. The most influential character in the movie believe it or not, appeared to be Ivy Pearson; a common whore to some, however, a "metamorphic" tool to this great classic. The capacity of this plot is to serve as a portrayal of the division that exists in Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde.In the movie we are

Minority report Compare and contrast essay

1065 words - 5 pages Imagine a country with no murder crimes based on “non-human” life form that can see the future based on different murders. This process of stopping murderers is created in a short story named Minority report and then is later created into a film. The short story and the film are based on the same plot and the same ideas but still have some interesting changes throughout the whole story. When making a short story into a film there are going to

P.K. Dick’s The Minority Report and Steven Spielberg’s The Minority Report

1063 words - 4 pages P.K. Dick’s The Minority Report and Steven Spielberg’s The Minority Report Death can occur in four ways. A person can die from a physical illness, viruses and infections. A person can die from an accident. A person can commit suicide. Finally a person can be murdered by another person. What if murders could be prevented? In P.K. Dick’s story The Minority Report, and in Spielberg’s film The Minority Report, the future can be altered by

Portrayals of John Anderton

1177 words - 5 pages release the film version of Dick’s short story in 2002. Furthermore, this futuristic age film was directed by the famous director, Stephen Spielberg. The main focus of the short story and film surrounds the lead character John Anderton and his efforts to understand the minority report. In comparing the portrayal of John Anderton’s physical characteristics and the conspiracy surrounding him in the short story and film, one can clearly state that

Minority Report

1062 words - 4 pages An Analytical Exposition Essay based on the Film "Minority Report"Imagine a place where everyone knows your name, the streets are filled with smiling faces, and murder has all but been obliterated. Minority Report, one of Steven Spielberg's latest films set in 2054 Washington DC, encapsulates the very real struggle between law enforcement and civil liberties in an accessible yet thought-provoking way. It is a story that dramatises issues of

Blade Runner - The Director's Cut... Is the setting of Blade Runner credible? Are there any elements of society today evident of the futuristic setting of 2019?

686 words - 3 pages society may have on our future.In comparison to a more modern futuristic movie of Minority Report, also based on a science fiction novel written by Phillip K. Dick, Blade Runner - The Director's Cut shows a very different aspect of the future of our world. Minority Report contrasts the setting of Blade Runner entirely, with sunny skies and a far more credible setting of the future in the sense that it does not exaggerate the impact of technology, and

Female Film Directors and the British Film Industry

3948 words - 16 pages decreased in the past few years, as reported by The British Film Institute. The BFI releases a statistical yearbook every year. One of these statistics is the number of women employed (predominantly directors and writers) within the industry, which is included in the Employment in the Film Industry section. ‘This year's report, which draws on data from 2012, showed that UK women film writers declined from 18.9% of the total writers in 2011 to 13.4

Features of Narrative and Genre in First Ten Minutes of Minority Report

3666 words - 15 pages . The Matrix has the colour scheme of green, which makes things look futuristic but at the same time adds an air of mystery towards the story. Whereas the colour blue is transparent giving us the idea that somebody is watching. The eye is a very important symbol in the Minority report. The eyes are believed to be window of the soul and the eye is portrayed a lot in the film. The montage sequence with the boy cutting through

Similar Essays

Film Analysis: The Minority Report

1954 words - 8 pages The Minority Report is a film that tries to stop crimes before they happen, with the enlistment of 3 teen pre-cogs. These pre-cogs predict future murders and the authorities swoop in and arrest the would-be murders, before they have the chance of committing the crime. Even thing goes great until Anderton, a cop played by Tom Cruise, is suspected. Written by Philip K. Dick and then turned to film by Steven Spielberg in 2002, the short story to

Minority Report: From Story To Screen

1050 words - 4 pages Minority Report: From Story to Screen Adaptations are never carbon copies. A prime example is Philip K. Dick’s short story and Steven Spielberg’s 2002 film, Minority Report. The structure of the storytelling is indeed different as well as other key elements. The narrative transforms its structure into a more episodic approach when brought to the screen. Words on paper take on a new identity when brought to life on a visual basis

The Rosewood Film Vs. The Rosewood Report

1590 words - 7 pages whites. In less than a month the black community of Rosewood felt the assertiveness of the white mobs Rosewood Report, 1993, pg8). In Singleton’s film, Rosewood, he tells the story of the huge massacre. In the beginning Fannie Taylor is running out of her house yelling that she had been beaten by a black man. However, the man who attacked her was really white and she was having an affair with him, but one person who knew the truth was her black

This Is A Characterization Report On A Short Story By Sherwood Anderson, Entitled "Brother Death".

1469 words - 6 pages constant conflict until one of the characters either changes, or disappears from the story all together."Brother Death" by Sherwood Anderson is a short story about power. Don and Ted both want to be in control of their life, but different circumstances take that away from them. Ted wants to live a normal life, but his family prohibits him because of his fatal heart condition. Mary, the only one who understands Ted's misery, shares a special bond