This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Miracles Identify A Philosopher And Examine Their Understanding Of The Term Miracle. Examine Arguments That Can Be Used To Discredit Belief In Miracles. How Is Belief In Miracles Still Strong?

2604 words - 10 pages

MiraclesIdentify one philosopher and examine his/her understanding of the term miracle (6 marks)Examine the arguments, which can be used to discredit belief in miracles. In what respect do you consider belief in miracles to be strong in spite of these criticisms (14 marks)The topic of miracles and their existence is a controversial one due to the lack of proof of their existence and a recognised definition. Philosophers have long debated miracles, their occurrence and the necessary boundaries that should universally define events worthy of being deemed a miracle. Views upon the subject of miracles are widely varied due to diversity in religious beliefs, both theists and atheists deliberating over their existence. The problem with the assortment of perspectives is that where one group claim that God is responsible for the occurrence of a miracle, another group discard this explanation. Similarly, there is a combination of beliefs on how to define a miracle, as some people would perceive the sun stopping in the sky as a miracle, whereas others claim that the birth of child is 'miraculous'.One of the most influential theologians involved in the determination of miracles and their existence in the world today, was St. Thomas Aquinas. For centuries, scholars and philosophers have deliberated not only over the existence of miracles, but that if they do exist, over what boundaries to term them within. Aquinas is one of the most recognised philosophers, who came to the conclusion that miracles, in their entirety, could be defined as "Those things..., which are done by divine power apart from the order generally followed in things."For Aquinas, due to his belief that God was that of an interventionist, there were three types of miracles that could take place. The first of the three kinds of miracles was determined by Aquinas as an event done by God, that nature was not capable of doing. An example in the Bible being the account of the sun being stopped in the sky, Joshua 10:13, which would be recognised by today's standards as physically impossible. This type of miracle encompasses the types of events that cannot be logically explained and therefore are deemed a 'natural impossibility'. The second type was recognised as events done by God that nature would be capable of accomplishing but either not as well or not in the order that they occurred, for example, the healing of paralysis as well as the narration of exorcisms in Mark 1:31 of the Bible. Although nature may very rarely be capable to heal on this kind of scale, it would be highly unanticipated and would take a very long time, whereas Jesus was known to have regularly performed miracles invariably. He would have demonstrated his healing powers to heal someone of paralysis on a much smaller time scale, which therefore could render his work as a miracle. The occurrence of exorcisms, which although would not be thought of as entirely implausible, would be seldom expected, and therefore can be reputed...

Find Another Essay On Miracles - Identify a philosopher and examine their understanding of the term miracle. Examine arguments that can be used to discredit belief in miracles. How is belief in miracles still strong?

Miracles Essay

896 words - 4 pages . These miracles show that God has power over life and death. The demonstration of this supernatural power is one aspect of the fingerprint of God. Another mark of the supernatural is power over nature, excluding humans. The accounts of Moses and Jesus show the power of God. The power of healing is a topic of today. Although in order to be the same as the biblical miracles, they will have to include all kinds of diseases. God has power over all

Miracles Essay

908 words - 4 pages . These miracles show that God has power over life and death. The demonstration of this supernatural power is one aspect of the fingerprint of God. Another mark of the supernatural is power over nature, excluding humans. The accounts of Moses and Jesus show the power of God. The power of healing is a topic of today. Although in order to be the same as the biblical miracles, they will have to include all kinds of diseases. God has power over all

Miracles

965 words - 4 pages Miracles do happen; I personally think that it is a life check to realize what is important in life. What will I face today First of all, my parents have their own business called Rainbow Vacuum. They have been doing this for twenty-nine years. It was the day after my twelfth birthday and the day before a concert I was thrilled about going to. Well my dad fixed the ladies vacuum and wanted to collect the customer’s money before going to a

Miracles in the Modern Day

1706 words - 7 pages . were tremendous underdogs in the game but can their win classify as a “miracle”? We use the word miracle so loosely that the word has become more of a myth and we can never find a real miracle. Determining what miracles are, if they happen throughout in the present world and how miracles actually happen is what we need to find out in order to fully understand miracles. Dictionary.com says a miracle is an effect or extraordinary event in the

The Existence of Miracles

1070 words - 4 pages claimed that a miracle was a "violation of the laws of nature" and that the very definition and also nature seems to exclude all possibilities of a miracle; an event can only be classed as a miracle if it is an event which is impossible, otherwise it would not "merit that appellation". Hume systematically denied the existence of miracles through different arguments, claiming that no miracle was "attested by a

The Miracles of Jesus

1770 words - 7 pages Excuse"). In addition to teaching that belief is as important or more so that behaving according to the rules, Jesus miracles show the importance of love. Jesus performed miracles for everyone. A powerful centurion was no more or less important than an outcast leper. In their pain and their love, people are made equal. Jesus' actions show that the hierarchy of worldly privilege means nothing to those people whose beliefs are congruent with their

The Miracles of Cannabis

1148 words - 5 pages available, or take a chance on the consequences to obtain it illegally, and gain themselves a criminal record. The medical benefits that cannabis has to offer are far too great to ignore. Cannabis is one of the safest drugs, prescription or illegal, known to man. No one has ever died from on over dose. Having a drug this safe available, which effectively can treat so many different serious illnesses should be legalized in all states. “After

Demons, Miracles, and a Secret

1040 words - 5 pages secret until they become afraid of the consequences. The Messianic Secret is a topic that is still in discussion. Some scholars believe that the evidence is weak, while others are strong advocates for Wrede’s ides from the early 1900s. Jesus seemed to be more than a prophet due to his many miracles, but there are disagreements on if he was the Messiah. While the Gospels of Mark explicitly state that Jesus did not want witnesses to share his

The Ancient Greeks and their Strong Belief in their Gods

1237 words - 5 pages strongly believe in their gods to the extent that they believed that the gods would interfere in their day-to-day living. Due to their strong belief in their gods, the Ancient Greeks had a relationship with the gods that gave them utmost respect and reverence. Homer illustrates these ideals in his epic poem, The Odyssey. First of all, the relationship that the gods have with the mortals can be demonstrated through them interfering with the

Medical Miracles on the Horizon, in the future to come?

1149 words - 5 pages the medical field after I graduate from The University of Tennessee. Of all occupations in the next millennium, medicine will be perhaps the most important and influential in combating the problems of mankind and in solving them.People in the field of medicine will continue, as they have in this century, to address and participate in almost all concerns. For example, methadone is currently being used as a therapeutic intervention for some drug

Medical Miracles and Their Apocalyptic Counterparts

1067 words - 4 pages lunatics and steadfast scientists. Until the Apollo 11 mission in 1969 happened of course. How far has medical technology progressed already? People can be artificially sustained in order to survive paralytic diseases such as polio or the devastating effects of botulism. Entire limbs and skeletal structures can be replaced with synthetic materials. There is even research into regenerating missing organs and appendages with a combination of a

Similar Essays

Accounts Of Miracles And Their Support Of Belief In God

841 words - 3 pages Accounts of Miracles and Their Support of Belief in God The definition of a miracle is a violation of the "laws of nature", it is an exception that is beyond all naturalistic explanations, meaning they must be explained supernaturally. So do accounts of miracles support the belief in God? Firstly, one must decided whether there is sufficient evidence to prove the existence of

David Hume's Argument Against Belief In The Existence Of Miracles

2170 words - 9 pages could perhaps be a mistake. Lastly Hume gives his argument from parity. He gives accounts of two miracles accredited to Vespasian and a catholic miracle at Saragossa and he then goes onto account a number of miracle ascribed to Abbe Paris a famous Jansenist. Here Hume is trying to show that the miracles of each religion argue against all other religions and their miracles. Basically how can people of one religious group accept one account of a

David Hume's Critique Of The Belief In Miracles

1721 words - 7 pages final point Hume gives to discredit the validity of amiracle is that there must be a number of witnesses tovalidate the miracle. "So that not only the miracle destroysthe credit of testimony, but the testimony destroys itself."(Hume p.892). This basically means that the witnesses mustall give the exact same testimony of the facts of the event.Hume finds difficulty in the belief or integrity of anyindividual, and the difficulty of detecting

Miracles Essay 1353 Words

1353 words - 5 pages can be seen in Hume’s first reason against the existence of miracles. He states that there has never been anyone attesting a miracle “of such unquestioned good-sense, education and learning, as to secure us against all delusion in themselves” and persuade us that a violation of a natural law is possible. Hume suggests that whenever anyone has witnessed a “miracle” they have been deluded into thinking so and this person has not used any reasoning