Miscarriage Of Justice Essay

1830 words - 7 pages

Arguably three of the most sensational criminal trials in American history are the Commonwealth vs. Borden, California vs. Simpson and Los Angeles vs. Rodney King. All three of these cases received unprecedented amounts of media attention and verdicts from the jury that shocked the country. In my opinion justice, especially social and moral justice, was not achieved in these trials. Social class, race and gender all had a huge impact on the jury’s decisions in each of these cases. High priced defense attorneys were able to place reasonable doubt in the minds of the jurors despite the substantial amount of evidence proving the seemingly obvious guilt of Borden, Simpson and the Los Angeles Police department. This paper will focus on these criminal trials and the fact that justice or moral rightness was not achieved by the outcome of the jury verdicts.
The trial of Lizzie Borden, in June of 1893, captivated the nation. It was covered extensively in newspapers throughout the country probably, in part, because it was extremely rare for a woman to commit a horrific act such as the one she was accused of. Being from a wealthy family that outwardly seemed happy and normal, made it very difficult for people to believe that a woman with her background could be responsible for the bludgeoning death of her father Andrew Borden, a predominate member of town, and her stepmother Abby Borden. The police, however, came to the conclusion that the Borden’s murderer must have been someone within the home since the house was otherwise untouched, nothing was missing and there was no sign of any commotion. The only person having both the motive and opportunity to commit these murders was Thirty three year old Lizzie Borden.
Here are some intriguing facts of the case: Lizzie was the only person in the house besides the housekeeper who at the time of the murders was in her room resting. She tried purchasing prussic acid the day before the murders, also her parents suffered from severe stomach sickness in the days before their untimely deaths. Relations between Lizzie and her stepmother were strained. There was a newly broken axe found in the basement of the home but fingerprinting was not allowed. Lizzie was known to have “funny spells” which caused her to act oddly and erratically. At the time of the murders she claimed to have been in the barn loft, which would have been stifling hot, looking for fishing lures she surely knew were not there but at their vacation home. A friend, Alice Russell, saw Lizzie burning a light blue dress that Lizzie claimed was old and covered in paint. She was, however, seen wearing a similar dress on the day of the murders.
Based on all the above information, how is it possible that the jury deliberated for a mere hour and a half before returning with a not guilty verdict? Well, the highly skilled defense team used holes in the prosecution’s case to cast doubt in the minds of the jurors. Where, the defense asked, was the handle that...

Find Another Essay On Miscarriage of Justice

To Kill a Mockingbird - Review - Elderslie high school/English - Review

563 words - 3 pages , not giving descriptions of the characters, but slowly forming them right until the very last page. The way that she manipulates Scout and Jem Finch to expose the immorality, miscarriage of justice, and racial prejudice of their community is done in such a way that captures the innocence and sympathies of a child, the understanding and empathetic values of an adult, within one character. This is possible due to the dual narrative style that Harper

Capital Punishment Essay

579 words - 2 pages It has been noted that Capital Punishment has a number of unquestionable arguments against it. First of all, genuinely innocent people will be executed and that there is no possible way of compensating them for this miscarriage of justice. In addition, something that is often overlooked, the torture the innocent family and friends of criminals must go through in the time leading up to and during the execution. Finally, Capital Punishment

The Sad Statistic Behind Wrongful Convictions

1546 words - 6 pages convicted individuals have been exonerated. Wrongful convictions resources explosion show the failure of the justice system, and it will continue to occur, the challenge that the justice system is facing now is not trying to stop the wrongful convictions, it is to minimize the number of miscarriage of justice that occur. Wrongful convictions are an extremely important case of social injustice. Wrongful convictions occur when the miscarriage of

Wrongful Conviction

1304 words - 5 pages Wrongful conviction is an issue that has plagued the Canadian Justice System since it came to be. It is an issue that is hard to sort out between horrific crimes and society’s desire to find truth and justice. Incidences of wrongful conviction hit close to home right here in Saskatchewan as well as across the entire nation. Experts claim “each miscarriage of justice, however, deals a blow to society’s confidence in the legal justice system

miscarriages of justice

1957 words - 8 pages only become exceptional but ideally cease to occur altogether. A miscarriage of justice is basically "a failure to attain the desired end result of justice". In our society, every person should be treated equally and fairly as "our legal institutions are premised on the idea that our legal system is both neutral and impartial, and that all persons are equal in the eyes of the law". The country in which we were born, the

Time to End the Injustice Retaliation

1600 words - 7 pages by the government, and as a result, government destroyed their families. If those innocent people were not sentenced to death but life imprisonment, they might be free again and compensated by government. It’s unfair for those who were wrongfully executed because those lost their live, future, families. Cases of miscarriage of justice are cruel to the innocent people. They were not the real criminals, but they suffer the punishment like

Capital Punishment Essay: It's Fair and Effective

992 words - 4 pages Capital Punishment - It's Fair and Effective     Confronting head-on two of the most prominent objections to the death penalty is the object of this paper: Is the death penalty a miscarriage of justice? And Does it Deter Crime?   It's a miscarraige of justice. In a survey Professors Hugo Adam Bedau and Michael Radelet found that 7000 persons were executed in the United States between 1900 and 1985 and that 35 were innocent of

The Alfred Dreyfus Affair

1193 words - 5 pages The Alfred Dreyfus Affair Alfred Dreyfus affair was a political and legal scandal in 1894-1906. The affair divided France political landscape and viewed as an extreme case of justice miscarriage, and developed global and modern recognizance. This affair involved the conviction of Alfred Dreyfus on charges of treason. He was an artillery officer whose descent was of Alsatian Jewish. Alfred allegedly was guilty of spying for the German

California's Supreme Court Weighs in on Proposition 8

511 words - 2 pages to the state constitution must be approved by the state legislature before being put on the ballot. Proponents of the Prop 8 are arguing that the initiative was approved correctly and in a free election the voters choose to exercise their right to change the constitution. Arguing for Prop 8, Ken Starr stated "it would be a miscarriage of justice for the court to overturn the results…" (Sakuma, 2009, ¶ 4).The justices put forth a

When the Innocent Become Guilty: Who is to Blame For Wrongful Convictions?

979 words - 4 pages always be tied with the terms “wrongfully convicted” “miscarriage of justice” and “wrongly imprisoned” forever in our justice system’s history. These men along with other who are wrongly convicted lose time with their family and living their lives or even sometimes they are executed and lose their lives. Their families are affected by having to pay for appeals, missing time with their love one and also the social stigma of the public believing there

Evaluate the role of Juries in achieving just outcomes for VOS - Essay

999 words - 4 pages evidence presented in the courts. However the “difficulty for a jury to fully understand the legal significance of something presented in court…could lead to a miscarriage of justice” (Judge-Alone Trials: Minimising the Risk of Unfair Prejudice, NSW Courts, 2015). In 2008, BOSCAR, under a study entitled “Juror Understanding of Judicial Instructions in the Criminal Trials”, found that only 55.4% of jurors correctly comprehended the meaning of ‘beyond

Similar Essays

The Hurricane Miscarriage Of Justice Law Assignment

1213 words - 5 pages The Hurricane Miscarriage of Justice Wrongful convictions occur due to the mentality of individuals with authority mixed with the bad science. The four cases I reviewed (Walchuk, Carter, Waudby and Truscott) all had something in common. They were all convicted quickly, the crown had the mentality they were correct and scientific evidence was faulty and inaccurate. Firstly, Leon Walchuk was wrongfully convicted for killing his wife (Corinne

Miscarriage Of Justice Essay

726 words - 3 pages To Kill A Mockingbird is a classic book by Harper Lee. Justice, being righteous and morally right, is a recurring theme in this book. Set during the Great Depression, the story takes place in a small town full of judgemental Southerners in Alabama. At the end of the tale, Boo Radley, who never left his house, saves two children from an attacker by fatally stabbing him. Boo was the gossip topic of children and adults. The townspeople thought he

Curtis Mc Ghee Case Exoneration Essay

1634 words - 7 pages man behind bars, and he was serving time for a crime that he never took in part of committing. This case of Curtis McGhee raises a question on our criminal justice system and it leads us to confirm that miscarriages of justice do occur, and there should be various reforms that should be made so these miscarriages can be prevented from occurring in the future. How did the miscarriage of justice occur? Curtis McGhee was charged for the murder of

Criminal Legal System And Ethics Essay

1308 words - 6 pages determination of the depth or scope of application of a particular law. Some laws may reflect a subjective will of the people. For instance, the media may sensationalize a case demanding severe penalties while the legal frameworks may have limitations to the sentencing. The other ethical issue is miscarriage of justice. Bribery, falsified testimonies, and fabricated evidence obscure true justice leading to miscarriage of justice. Policy makers