This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Modeling A Process Assessment Framework In Archi Mate

1653 words - 7 pages

In order to evaluate the concept mappings from TIPA to ArchiMate, we will perform a BWW (Wand and Weber 1993) analysis according to two criteria: completeness and clarity. The Bunge-Wand-Weber Model provides an ontological evaluation of grammars method, where we compare two sets of concepts to identify four ontological deficiencies:

1. Incompleteness: can each element from the first set be mapped on an element from the second? – The mapping is incomplete if it is not total.
2. Redundancy: are the first set elements mapped to more than a second set element? – The mapping is redundant if it is ambiguous.
3. Excess: is every first set element mapped on a second set one? – The mapping is excessive if there are first set elements without a relationship.
4. Overload: is every first set element mapped to exactly one second set element? – The mapping is overloaded if any second set element has more than one mapping to a first set one.

The amount of TIPA concepts that have no representation in ArchiMate defines the lack of completeness. Clarity is a combination of redundancy, overload and excess of concepts. Lack of completeness can be a serious issue while lack of clarity can make the mapping unidirectional and hard to reverse.
Considering all the above, we can say our mapping is complete, because every TIPA concept has an ArchiMate representation of itself. Furthermore, ArchiMate concepts can be so generic in a way that can accommodate some TIPA concepts, meaning sometimes the mapping does not reflect exactly the actual element meaning, but its generic meaning. We take advantage of this, through a set of assumptions, in order to achieve completeness. However, an extension to specialize and accurately represent these concepts would be much welcomed.
As for redundancy, there is sometimes more than one ArchiMate element to represent a TIPA concept. This happens in Generic Work Product and Specific Work Product, because TIPA describes these concepts as a set of artifacts that result from performing each process. These artifacts are the ITIL elements of each process which were already mapped by Vicente and each one represents a different ArchiMate element. The problem with redundancy is that the “correct” ArchiMate concept has to be chosen according to context and experience, and although this choice is rather easy for human architects, it can be a serious problem for automated model transformations. So we conclude that our mapping is redundant.
We also find excess, as ArchiMate has concepts that are not defined on TIPA as stakeholder or principle. One could argue that implicitly they actually exist with their ArchiMate definitions, where stakeholder is “the role of an individual, team, or organization (or classes thereof) that represents their interests in, or concerns relative to, the outcome of the architecture” and principle “a normative property of all systems in a given context, or the way in which they are realized” or even gap “an outcome of a...

Find Another Essay On Modeling a Process Assessment Framework in ArchiMate

Bottlenecks in a Process Essay

507 words - 2 pages Bottlenecks in a Process PAGE 1 Bottlenecks in a ProcessBy definition, a bottleneck is any resource whose capacity is insufficient to satisfy the demand upon it. For example, in a computer network a server could become a bottleneck if it can't send the required data to all computers that request it. Bottlenecks can be not just machines or specialized equipment; skilled workers also can be bottlenecks in a process (Schwab J. & Gerard F

A Framework For Barriers Of Telemedicine Implementation In Iran

1849 words - 8 pages telemedicine and this phenomenon is more prominent in smaller cities. In the process of doing this research, we became familiar with doctors who did telemedicine with a low quality and without having licensure, and these things cause people to become pessimistic to telemedicine. According to findings and interviews with doctors, they introduced some other barriers that this model does not include them. Those barriers were as bellow: Not being efficient and

the importance of research in a social work framework

1065 words - 5 pages The importance of research in a social work framework Social work, often considered a relatively modern profession, has developed through advances in knowledge, social reforms, democratic ideas and increasing body of research and literature (Doel, 2012). The Social work profession is lead by theories from social sciences, indigenous and humanities knowledge, which comes with a respect for human rights and diversity and is often thought of as a


712 words - 3 pages HOSPITALITY ASSESSMENT - Work in a socially diverse environment.1. Describe TWO advantages of working with colleagues who come from culturally diverse backgrounds.The hospitality industry is an example of multiculturalism at work, the Cultural Characteristics of Australia (2000) show that of the 800,000 small businesses in Australia, 21% are owned and operated by people with a non English speaking background and 17% of the population speak a

A Critical Assessment of Race Talking in Private

1949 words - 8 pages " (Schuman, Steeh, and Bobo, and Krysan [1985] 1997). The government helped this process by passing equal rights laws, and the public seemed to be willing to move towards a classless society. However, in later decades, through inaction, there still seems to be little or no public support aimed to help disadvantaged African Americans (Schuman et al. [1985] 1997). This inaction can be explained with a term that Joel Kovel (1970) calls "aversive

Assess whether the Weberian approach offers a more sophisticated framework than the functionalist perspective in understanding social stratification

1422 words - 6 pages . In other words, by considering combinations of factors, including wealth, power and prestige, the Weberian approach offers a more sophisticated framework in understanding social stratification.ReferencesMacionis, J.J. (1997), Sociology, Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall International.Lawson, T. and Garrod, J. (1996), The Complete A-Z Sociology Handbook, London: Hodder & Stoughton.Bilton, T., el. at. (1989), Introductory Sociology, London: Macmillan Education Ltd.

Human vs. Computer: Comparison of How the Truth of a Statement is Determined in the Framework of WVO Quine’s Holism

969 words - 4 pages placed in context of Quine’s beliefs about language and the steps to acquire it in our early years, which he summarizes in “The Nature of Natural Knowledge” (henceforth, NNK). According to NNK, we learn to establish links between sense data and statements when we learn our first language. Therefore, the process of establishing the truth of a statement from the sense data is determined by the process by which we acquire language, specifically

Human vs. Computer: Comparison of How the Truth of a Statement is Determined in the Framework of WVO Quine’s Holism

1531 words - 6 pages prescribes more than one action for a given situation (if B, then (B’ or B’’)). The truth of a computer statement is fixed deterministically because the program relates the discrete “all-or-nothing” elements of the code and input (“1”s and “0”s) to the “1”s and “0”s of the output in a single possible way. It seems that a fitting analogy to a deterministic digital computer is an hour glass. There is always a one-to-one correspondence between the

Culture as a Process in Levine's Highbrow, Lowbrow

725 words - 3 pages Culture as a Process in Levine's Highbrow, Lowbrow In Highbrow, Lowbrow, Levine argues that a distinction between high and low culture that did not exist in the first half of the 19th century emerged by the turn of the century and solidified during the 20th century, and that despite a move in the last few decades toward a more ecumenical interpretation of “culture,” the distinction between high art and popular entertainment and the revering

With Reference to at least three companies of your choice, critically evaluate Dunning's Eclectic Paradigm as a framework explaining the reasons why companies engage in Foreign Direct Investment

3043 words - 12 pages Eclectic Paradigm (EP) proposes a multifaceted framework for incorporating a number of context specific and operationally testable theories seeking to explain a particular component of the internationalisation process of FDI. The approach specifies three sets of explanatory factors to explain the nature and direction of FDI: Ownership factors, Location factors and Internalisation.As the three principles are derived from a variety of theoretical

A Re-Vision of Teaching: Portrait of a Teacher in Process

4427 words - 18 pages A Re-Vision of Teaching: Portrait of a Teacher in Process In Adrienne Rich's essay, When We Dead Awaken: Writing As Re-Vision, Rich writes about re-vision as the act of seeing with fresh eyes, of entertaining an old text from a new critical direction (629). RichƒÎs idea of looking at a subject with fresh eyes is a strategy that I decided to employ to reflect on my own teaching practices. In using re-vision to examine one

Similar Essays

Modeling A Process Assessment Framework In Archi Mate

1395 words - 6 pages these domains and their relations, providing the architect with instruments that support and improve the architecture process (Lankhorst 2004). In a short time, ArchiMate has become the open standard for architecture modeling in the Netherlands; it is now also becoming well known in the international EA community, being today a TOG standard (Jonkers H., Proper E. 2009). The domains of business, application and infrastructure are connected by a

Gis Analysis In Flood Assessment And Modeling

2233 words - 9 pages . (2004). GIS spatial modeling of river flow and precipitation in the Oak Ridges Moraine area, Ontario. Computers & geosciences, 30(4), 379-389. 17. Kulkarni, A. T., Mohanty, J., Eldho, T. I., Rao, E. P., & Mohan, B. K. (2014). A web GIS based integrated flood assessment modeling tool for coastal urban watersheds. Computers & Geosciences, 64, 7-14. 18. Liu, Y. B., & De Smedt, F. (2005). Flood modeling for complex terrain using GIS and remote sensed

Process Modeling In System Analysis And Design

1080 words - 4 pages both systems. Often times the project requires a tight schedule that is not conducive for creating multiple logical and physical models. It is important to use process modeling when developing a system in order to prevent errors in logic later on in the project. These models also help to ensure that all requirements have been met by the system and the users are satisfied with how the system is being implemented. Further, the modeling helps that

An Assessment Of & A Framework For Successful Offshore Outsourcing

4533 words - 18 pages outsourcing is essential. The cost benefit ratios always demonstrate a bias towards offshore outsourcing. Lower costs to product development and high quality of products, easier access to higher technological capabilities and talent, advancements in telecommunication technologies, positive tax incentives in the supplier's country are often the factors that influence offshore outsourcing.Offshore outsourcing is the process of externalizing a