This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Modern Human Origins: The Multiregional Theory

1566 words - 7 pages

Multiregional Evolution: a theory that suggests modern humans evolved from individual populations of Homo erectus throughout Europe, Asia, and Africa during the middle of the Pleistocene epoch. Its supporters claim that premodern humans, Homo erectus, migrated from Africa to Europe and Asia and that gene flow amongst these population is responsible for the evolution of modern Homo sapiens (Jurmain, Kilgore, Trevathan, and Ciochon, 2013). This theory was developed by Wolpoff and his colleagues in the 1980s and is a topic they continue to explore today (2000). There are many who discredit this theory though. They believe that the multiregional model does not prove how all of these separate populations remained genetically similar to one another if they all evolved separately. The works of Pearson (2004) and Stringer and Andrews (1988) explore this opposing view to the multiregional model.
Wolpoff, the founder of the multiregional theory, spends the majority of his essay discrediting those who oppose this theory. He expresses the idea in his article, “Multiregional, Not Multiple Origins,” that those who discredit the multiregional theory do not truly understand it. This is explained when he writes,
“For whatever reason, there has been a continued pattern of misinterpreting or incorrectly describing multiregional evolution.” (Wolpoff et al. 2000)
He discusses the work of Chu et al. and how they determined the multiregional theory to be false after studying ancient Chinese populations. When confronted about the lack of genetic evidence to support the multiregional theory, Wolpoff responded that there is a lack of genetic evidence to oppose the theory. He writes,
“No time has been found at which every genetic locus resides in a single African population.” (Wolpoff et al. 2000)
By saying this, Wolpoff means that one cannot prove that all of the uniquely human genes evolved directly in Africa. While this doesn’t disprove anyone’s opposing views on the multiregional theory, it does give someone reason to support this model. This evidence shows that because of a lack of genetic evidence, it is completely plausible that modern humans could have evolved simultaneously in Africa, Asia, and Europe.
Pearson opposes the multiregional theory in his article, “Has the Combination of Genetic and Fossil Evidence Solved the Riddle of Modern Human Origins?” He argues that because there was small population of Homo erectus at the time modern humans were beginning to evolve, there wasn’t enough gene flow to support uniform evolution outside of Africa. He writes,
“The effective population size of modern humans is about 10,000 breeding individuals, [Templeton’s study] implies that fewer than 1,000 of those individuals might have lived outside of Africa across the entire expanse of Eurasia…a population density that low would not have allowed a non-African population to survive and would effectively prove the Out-of-Africa model.” (Pearson, 2004)
Pearson’s main idea...

Find Another Essay On Modern Human Origins: The Multiregional Theory

Stakeholder theory of the modern corporation

840 words - 4 pages , both theories have a lot in common and they cannot be divided. According to Hawke both theories “used to justify differing views on: whistle- blowing, tax avoidance, risk to auditor independence, deception and exploitation in business transactions”. (Hawke, 2010) Both theories have the same practical implementations and the same consequences, which mean that if stakeholder theory is true, then shareholders theory is trues. In the modern

The Origins of Totalitarian Democracy, Political Theory and Practice during the French Revolution and beyond

1577 words - 6 pages There are different attitudes towards politics The Origins of Totalitarian Democracy, Political Theory and Practice during the French Revolution and beyond J.L Talmon The author, Talmon, states that there are different democracy attitudes towards politics. The liberal approach assumes politics to reach through a matter of trial and error a state of ideal harmony, and the totalitarian

The Theme of Eveline: The Aspect of Modern Human Existence

1138 words - 5 pages with Frank, which seems to be the only solution of all.Eveline lived a hard life, arduous, boring and hopeless. But she still thinks that she has the right to happiness. Maybe that is what the modern human existence like in Author's eyes. The outside world is a cage, with invisible bars, whereas the inner self longs for freedom. The conflict between this two are intense and central to the human survival. Frank's exoticism fascinates Eveline and

The Polygenesis Theory and its Effect on Human Ethnic Relations

1106 words - 5 pages As we know, polygenism is a theory that believes that human origins came from different lineages. Co-adamism is one of the branches of Polygenism. Co-adamism is a theory about God created other human besides Adam and Eve at the same time. Co-adamism or often called double-adamism is a theory developed by Henry Home, Lord Kames from Scotland. He began with the languages and the origins of man and then he theorized that the new world was emerged

Liberalism vs the Hobbesian Theory of Human Nature

6765 words - 27 pages -creation.  I intend to show that Rorty's liberalism is incoherent.  In light of this failure of ironist liberalism I will provide a new basis for a moral guideline for self-creation that arises from the philosophy of Thomas Hobbes.  Before I present an alternate "moral guideline" I will lay out Rorty's concept of self-creation and liberalism. Rorty rejects traditional moral theory because of its reliance on a common human nature or essence.  He

Analyzing the human characteristics of the aged by using Maslow's theory of human needs

1087 words - 4 pages The Human Characteristics of the AgedTalking or thinking of the aged people, quite often people assume somewhat a biased attitude. To become old, it seems to be of a different species, socially, culturally, physically, sexually and financially. Many young people think that it is hard for them to understand the strange behaviors of the old. But if you learn something about Maslow's theory of human needs, you will have a better understanding about

Psychology / the use and definition of psychology and its advantages to modern medical theory

1345 words - 5 pages " (Toni Blake). Locke's and Plato's theories were known as nature verses nurture. Plato siding with the nature side, and Locke with the nurture part. Immanuel Kant gave the modern belief saying, "The form of thought and action is provided by nature, but the content is provided by experience (Compton's CD). His theory has become widely accepted in the psychology field. Today psychologists think our experiences are what shape the way we believe or what

Are Modern Humans Still Evolving? A research paper on the relevancy of Darwin's age-old theory

1751 words - 7 pages population is causing the human genome to play catch up.Are Modern Humans Still Evolving?In the year eighteen fifty-nine, Charles Darwin published a book which he called "The Origin of Species". In this book Darwin theorized that populations evolve over the years through a process called natural selection. Darwin realized that in a population, more individuals were born than could possibly survive, he also recognized that the individuals that

Surviving Post-Modern Life: The Necessity of Human Relationships and the Written Word

2352 words - 9 pages , which make them feel more a part of the human race, and through the companionship that they find with each other. Coupland proves that belonging in a post-modern society is possible, particularly if one is willing to take the utilitarianism route, and adjust their personal beliefs to please that of the greater good. Douglas Coupland uses Hey Nostradamus! to clearly illustrate how essential human relationships and the written word are for

Twentieth Century Aesop’s Fables: How Ted Hughes Presents Modern Man through the Non-Human

1729 words - 7 pages Twentieth Century Aesop’s Fables: How Ted Hughes Presents Modern Man through the Non-Human. Ted Hughes’ poems mostly explore the world of nature. He uses ordinary animals like crow, pike, and skylark, but adding mythical quality to them. Animals in his world are superior to human and he seems to adore their brutality and instinct. He does not rationalize animal, which is unlike D.H Lawrence. Some criticize him for praising animals’ brutality

"Human resources are the most important assets a modern organization has."

1087 words - 4 pages words also means that knowledge has become the key factor of productivity and competitive power. As Peter F. Drucker (1994) has observed, '...an economic order in which knowledge, not labor or raw material or capital, is the key resource.' That is to say human resources are the most important assets a modern organization has, because only human beings can make, transfer and exercise knowledge. Moreover, different resources have different functions

Similar Essays

Thoughts On Human Origins. Assignment: Describe Your Personal Views On How Modern Humans Came Into Existence. Provide Justification For Your Beliefs

1222 words - 5 pages Thoughts on Human OriginsWhen considering the origins of human life on this planet, I must rely on the observations of others to draw my conclusions. I was not there when the world began, when humans appeared, or when religious texts were written. Furthermore, I have not conducted my own scientific research on the subject, nor have I studied in great detail the research that has been done. Yet, I have come to believe in what I know as "evolution

The Modern Dream Theory Essay

2746 words - 11 pages and Modern Conflict Theory." Routledge Taylor & Francis Group, 1 Apr. 2008. Web. 21 Oct. 2013.Curci, Antoniettia, and Bernard Rime. "Dreams, Emotions, and Social Sharing of Dreams." Psychology Press, 1 Jan. 2008. Web. 17 Nov. 2013.D'Amato, Barbara. "Aggression in Dreams-intersecting Theories: Freud, Modern Psychoanalysis, Threat Simulation Theory." N.p., 1 July 2010. Web. 21 Oct. 2013.Freud, Sigmund. The Interpretation of Dreams. New York

The Origins Of The Universal Declaration Of Human Rights

1766 words - 7 pages According to Xiaorong Li, there is no debate as to the Western origins of The Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) (2001 81; 86). However, while this may be true, as is demonstrated by the similarities between the UDHR and the French Declarations, such intellectual origins should not lead us to mistake the UDHR as a product of Western cultural imperialism (Stephen Marks 1998, 511). This is important to note, for with regards to the

The Out Of Africa Model Of Human Origins

657 words - 3 pages One of the most hotly debated issues in Anthropology focuses on the origins of modern humans. There are two theories about the origin of modern human, one being that modern humans originated in Africa and the second being that pre-modern humans migrated from Africa to become modern humans in other parts of the world. While both theories originate in Africa, most evidence points to the first theory, the Out of Africa Model. The amount of fossils