Modernism And New Criticism Essay

3204 words - 13 pages

Modernism and New Criticism

The ways in which we define the importance of texts is constantly changing. We can look back and see critical theories used, such as Historical Criticism, Reader-Response Criticism and Psychoanalytic Criticism. Each of these theories offers a different way to interpret a text. However, when looking back over the texts of a specific era, shouldn’t the type of criticism we used for a book be based on that time period?

Defining the Modernist Era of literature seems almost impossible, since the definition of modernism often seems to constitute anything from being “new and common” to “new and uncommon” (Barzun). This term seems to be able to stretch from the 1500’s to present; but for the sake of this essay the Modernist Era in question is that from the early twentieth century (circa 1910-1940’s). Out of, and during, this era the critical theory named New Criticism came into play. Although, nowadays, the use of New Criticism is unpopular, it is essential to use when defining the Modernist Era.

Even though New Criticism isn’t used anymore, many of its basic constructs are. For example, the idea of close reading and using textual evidence (as will be done in this essay) are characteristics that were important to New Criticism. Now it is practically impossible to be in an English class, be it high school or college, and not have to use these skills when talking about a text. New Criticism basically theorized that the text itself was the most important aspect of writing; therefore, to understand the meaning of a piece of literature one must look to, and in, the text, rather than trying to define it by outside components, such as those used in Historical and Biographical Criticism (Tyson 117-120). It should be noted that prior to the use of New Criticism, Historical/Biographical Criticism were widely used in defining the meaning of a literary text. Thus, New Criticism was a reaction against Historical Criticism, which tended to focus on the outside forces, such as those that influenced a writer or even a reader, and not the text itself.

Despite the New Critics separating the text from its author and the time period, often the historical and sociological aspects inside the text were still made relevant. These aspects could not be completely ignored by New Critics, but since they were inside the text they could still be used to understand the texts meaning. These aspects pertained to the text themselves and shouldn’t be confused by the use of literary criticism, which may use these influences and how they were outside of the text.

Oddly enough, what I’m about to say almost seems to deconstruct the whole idea of New Criticism, as I use Historical Criticism to talk about the relationship of New Criticism and Modernism. The Modernist Era was a time when traditions began to fail. A lack of faith in the security of old traditions, mostly a result of WWI, made many people...

Find Another Essay On Modernism and New Criticism

Modernism vs Neo-Traditionalism Essay

1052 words - 4 pages Modernism vs Neo-Traditionalism: A debate on the merits and failures of two major competing paradigms in architecture and urban planning.      Beyond the term modernism underlies one of the greatest ideas in architectural development. Modernism was meant to provide more green areas, cheaper housing and more efficient use of space. This was to be accomplished by creating vertically dense spaces with the use of the new

Architecture Should be Technologically Rational Essay

2200 words - 9 pages 1890s and lasted until around 1945. Postmodernism then started at 1968 right after the Second World War. Modernism began as a rejection of the idea of cultural baggage of it pass. It is more about new ideas and also new ideas all of the time. Modernism is also based on using rational and logical most of the time. In architecture modernism played a role of bringing in new buildings after the two World Wars such as exploring new form, materials

Is Postmodernism a continuation or critique of Mod

3824 words - 15 pages 'to a new point of view which sees them simply as 'texts' which can be studied for their world-view and then dropped in favour of an alternative picture.'(10) Modernist writers were much revered, they were taken as the ultimate basis of reality , where there work could be absorbed and learned. Then came the crisis of modernism says Jameson. 'When it suddenly became clear that D.H Lawrence was not an absolute after all, not the final achieved

Mohan Rakesh, Modernism, And The Postcolonial Present

9589 words - 38 pages MOHAN RAKESH, MODERNISM, AND THE POSTCOLONIAL PRESENTAbstractMohan Rakesh, Modernism, and the Postcolonial Present": The fin-de-siécle critical project of redefining the spatio-temporal boundaries of modernism has lately gathered new momentum by taking up the question of modernism's relation to colonialism and postcolonialism. Appearing at the intersection of modernist studies and postcolonial studies, important recent essays by Simon

Russian Modernism Before 1917

928 words - 4 pages As the twilight of Russian Realism was approaching, Russian modernism was on the way to its awakening. Due to the modernism movement, many different styles of art, and not to mention poetry, came to be. So, what exactly is modernism, one might ask. Modernism is described as breaking up with the past and promoting innovation along with creation; coming up with the next new thing. It is looking for new forms or ways to express one’s self. Modern

Modernism, Modernists in American Literature, Robert Frost, Wallace Stevens, Ezra Pound, and T.S Eliot.

1313 words - 5 pages literature. Ezra Pound created Imagism he gave some rules about literature after he had gave this rules many poets went to London be able to talk wilt Pound about this rules. T.S Eliot added new thing to literature too he also criticize society he wrote a close reading from the text. Wallace Stevens was against to war he see poetry as a way of understanding reality. Robert Frost had a different style he mixed Realism with Modernism in his poetry. When we look all this poets we can see they create Modernism as a response of war, social troubles and culture and they wrote and criticize about this theme.

German and Sonderweg. Was Germany's development prior to WWII normal or abnormal.

1310 words - 5 pages equality, merged in the motto of the French Revolution, and then later on split up and expressed in the two ideologies of liberalism and socialism. It is here that the ideas were corrupted and eventually lead to the complete domination of Germany by Nazism. Modernism was the vogue in Germany before World War I and was leading societal changes. Many of the new views and concepts were coming out of Germany during that time, the Bauhaus School being a

modernism in latin america

1024 words - 5 pages , shaping Modernism. This movement is similar to and overlaps in part with European Modernism, yet it also diverges from its European counterpart in ways that are characteristic of Latin America (""). Modernism added neologisms and aimed to renovate and supplement their prominent international Spanish and Portuguese language. The humanities became new, novel, independent, and cosmopolitan which meant it did not stay local but moderately


650 words - 3 pages Postmodernism The 20th Century, in many ways, can be remembered as a time of scientific and technological revolution. The innovations and rapid growth in many areas of technology have cast doubt upon words such as ignorance and impossibility. This revolution also instigated new and/or radical ideas in the world of academia. The growth of post-modernism and its adherers in historical circles have caused quite a stir in dealing with the

Modern and Post-Modernism Architecture

1070 words - 4 pages terminology and style and finally giving an example of both style. Post-modernism is a new way of thinking includes new architectural issues and more sophisticated than modern architecture. Moreover, post-modernism architecture has tended to avoid designs problems and designs difficulties. Furthermore, post-modernist architects have also tended towards an attempt to humanise design ideas. In other words, they interact with design problems and accept

Modernism 1920's, great look over ethnic and genders.

1055 words - 4 pages modernism in society. Modernism affected numerous cultural aspects such as music, art, literature, gender, social, and cultural rights. Modernism was the ultimate trend of the 1920's era. However there are multiple aspects of it to be examined, along with why so many Americans were opposed to it at the time. Setting the scene for modernism, New York city was the background for major development of a modernist society and became the &quot

Similar Essays

Towards A New And Integrated Language: A Rejection Of Post Modernism

1284 words - 5 pages The term post-modernism has gradually become popular with music commentaries since the phrase was first coined in the early mid 1960's. It was adopted as a way of explaning the rise of so called 'populist' music in the era of the avant garde. The history of the term can be traced to the upsurge in parodying the past in art and architecture and was thought to be a new aesthetic which would eventually replace modernism. In music, this apparently

New Historicist Criticism: Macbeth And Power

1166 words - 5 pages of a feudal monarch is the power-hungry politician, the cult leader, or the ruthless business tycoon. But the new historicist conception of power is different; rather than being a top-down affair that originates from a specific place or individual, power comes from all around us, it permeates us, and it influences us in many subtle and different ways. This idea of decentralized power, heavily indebted to post-structuralist philosophy (see Derrida

Genealogy Of Postmodernism Essay

1237 words - 5 pages Genealogy of Postmodernism INTRODUCTION Genealogy of Postmodernism CONCLUSION The first half of the twentieth century was full of political and social changes, which affected the lives of people, but also it has a great influence in the field of art. Many intellectuals wanted to express their ideas differently. They criticized this society and felt needs to express their discontent. These new tendencies were highly experimental and innovative

Analysis Of Still Life With Apples And Oranges By Paul Cezanne

2224 words - 9 pages -garde:2014). In the purpose of this study, Cezanné was part of early 20th-century art world’s avant-garde known as Impressionism. Clement Greenberg (1909: 755), identifies Kant as the first philosopher to describe Modernism as a self-critical tendency as he was the first to criticize criticism in itself. A modernist is said to be seen as a kind of critic, who criticizes according to a specific set of values and ideas about the development of art