This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Modernization: Afghanistan Vs India Essay

2107 words - 8 pages

Department of Political Science and Humanities
The Final Research Paper
December 4th, 2013
State Building and Political Development
Kohistani ID# 8709
Professor: Isaqzadeh
State Building (POL-335)-Sections One

The 2013 Fall Semester

Modernization in Afghanistan vs. India
The political scientists, economists, philosophers, and other scientists have different views and ideas about development and modernization such as, Adam Smith, Karl Marx, Lenin, Baron, and Frank are the different scientist that introduced development theory. Similarly, this paper offers a discussion of modernization theory between two Asian countries; which is Afghanistan modern era during king Amanullah khan and India in the colonial power by British. I want to elaborate their reform toward modernization, that how they completed their reforms, what were the advantages and dis advantages of these reforms. How the reforms did were benefit for the people and both countries transformed modernization politically, economically, socially, and technologically. However, according to the modernization theory in these two countries was not happened by same factors, both have deferent ideology, deferent views, and deferent strategies.
Afghanistan is a mountain country which is located in central Asia and established in 1747 by Ahmad Shad Baba. He mostly interested to form an empire and a macro society from different ethnic tribes, but he did not established legal institutions and strong government with strong army he use his personalized skill and he mainly rely on the resources and booties of India because he did not collect taxes from the people. After his death Temur Shah and his sons came to power but the internal conflict, polygamy and external aggregation began in Afghanistan which it lead to the end of Durani Empire and every provinces become autonomous. Since Ahmad Shah Durany Afghanistan had an empire and provincial kingdom until King Abdur Rahman Khan Era; he created a strong central state and wanted to monopolize the state power over afghan people. But during King Abdur Rahman Khan Afghanistan become a renter state that also, modernization emerged as a result of conflict between two major power British and Russia which they used Afghanistan as buffer zone. According to the Charles Tilly’s theory of War Making and State Making as Organized crime which modernization was not occurred in Afghanistan same as European countries by using four phases of state making toward development and modernization which are war making, state making, protection, and extraction (Tilly, 1985). Additionally, there are two major elements for modern state to determine its sovereignty and bureaucracy which was not in Afghanistan because, did not have fully independence also, with a weak economy and Afghanistan was using as Swiss chess model government that the state...

Find Another Essay On Modernization: Afghanistan vs India

Modernization Essay

2466 words - 10 pages praised for his Jihad against British but latter his social reforms gave him bad image in society. (Thomas, 2010) As Semlser said that culture was the main obstacle to his reforms that stimulated people. His foreign policy was the other barrier that prevents his reforms from execution because he was supporting Muslims in India and Russia who used to support his father. As Afghanistan is land locked country it economy is dependent on its neighbors

Globalization Process in Afghanistan Essay

2558 words - 10 pages European style modernization of the country but was stopped by ultra-conservatives. After 1947 when British withdrew from the neighboring India, United States and Soviet Union began spreading influences in Afghanistan. A brief venture into democracy ended in a 1973 coup and a 1978 Communist counter-coup. The Soviet Union invaded in 1979 to support the weak Afghan Communist regime, sparking a long and destructive war. This war took lives of millions

Foreign Aid

1557 words - 6 pages lead nationalist forces to democracy. Examples of countries not completely under the communist worldview were India and Egypt. These countries leaders were politically influential however they were on the borderline between capitalism and communism. They welcomed the American modernization ideas however they didn’t want to be dictated by the United States. They did want socioeconomic growth and development for their countries.(Ofori) The foreign

British and Ottoman Empire Imperialism

2423 words - 10 pages imperialize states as Far East as Iran, Afghanistan, and India. During this transition period between 1520-1566s, it was Suleiman’s goal to have the Ottoman Empire be the most powerful empire of all and presenting power through physical appearance was the way to show that power. Suleiman I wore an extra large turban, fur vest, and had a masculine face. Below is a portrait of Suleiman I (Carnagie, Saari, World History in Contex). (Portrait of

The Death of Indian Culture Exposed in The Jewel In the Crown

1342 words - 5 pages British rape of Indian land and culture. British colonial sentiment became a primary influence in India, when the revolt of 1857 led to the reorganization of British influence. The British felt that India could not rule itself, that they (the British) would govern India as its benefactor, bringing modernization to an inferior culture. The Indian economy was transformed into a colonial economy, whose nature and structure was determined primarily by

The Rise to the Top: Why the United States is in Complacency

1267 words - 6 pages to disagree. Even India reported strong Q3 numbers and they operate solely on Democracy. “The provisional estimates of National Income for 2012-13 also revised the third quarter GDP number to 4.7 per cent” I do believe that Democracy is wonderful but the BBC video does bring up a great point. “Democracy, the need to persuade people to move out and accept modernization is holding India back.”3 It’s not only holding India back its also holding

Child Labour and in Impoverished Society

1469 words - 6 pages child labour prevails in the countries, which are poor or underdeveloped. Nearly 70% of world's poor live in Asia alone and major contribution made by China, India, Pakistan, Nepal, Afghanistan and Bangladesh. Where 70% of populations live in rural areas have main employment in agriculture and small and cottage industries. Major percentage is illiterate or semi literate. In India alone around 45% of total thick population of one billion is

Air/Aviation Law an Expanding Field of Study in India

3596 words - 14 pages /legis1223889647_The_Airports_Economic_Regulatory_Authority_of_India_Bill__2007.pdf. Ibid. Supra note 18. Object and Purpose, Carriage by Air Act, 1972; See generally the scope of liability regime under Carriage by Air Act, 1972 in Air Carrying Corporation vs Shibendra Nath Bhattacharya, AIR 1964 Cal 396. Carriage by Air (Amendment) Bill, 2008 Passed by Lok Sabha Today, Press Release, Ministry of Civil Aviation, Government of India (10 Sept

Exploring International Psychology

959 words - 4 pages to human strengths and weakness, which was later challenged (King, Viney and Wood). Greek philosophers were progressive and influential. Greeks developed many theories rooted in psychology such as: healing treatments, dreams, rationalism vs empiricism, being vs becoming, atomic, illness, basic elements, relativism and many more. I was surprised to learn from King, Viney and Woody the following; The decay was illustrated by a new emphasis on

History of India Essay

6566 words - 26 pages to unite European humanistic and democratic ideas with Indian concepts of an interdependent, responsible community to create a unique political philosophy complete with action plan. In the last years before his assassination in 1948, Gandhi's idiosyncratic program fell out of step with the modernization paradigm of Nehru and the leadership of an independent India, and his ideas became a background theme within Indian political economy. On a

The Importance of Women Yesterday, Today, and Tomorrow

1462 words - 6 pages . "Before the Women's Suffrage Movement - Women's Suffrage Movement vs. Women's Rights Movement in the 1800s." Women's Suffrage Movement vs. Women's Rights Movement in the 1800s. N.p., n.d. Web. 25 Feb. 2014. "Importance of Women." Ancestry.com. N.p., n.d. Web. 27 Mar. 2014 "The Long Road to Suffrage." About.com Women's History. N.p., n.d. Web. 24 Feb. 2014. "The Women of Afghanistan." The New York Times. The New York Times, 15 Aug. 2012. Web. 6 Mar. 2014. Udas, Sumnima. “Challenges of Being a Woman in India.” CNN. Cable News Network, 12 Jan. 2013. Web. 03 Apr. 2014

Similar Essays

Modernization: Afghanistan Vs. Turkey Essay

2462 words - 10 pages ). Amanullah Khan instantaneously jumped on to the well intentioned, nonetheless hasty, path to the reform and modernization of Afghanistan. Amanullah was very much influenced by European modernism and particularly by Mustafa Kemal Ataturk of turkey and the process of modernization that he had undertaken. Nevertheless, Mahmud Tarzi can also be credited for the persuasion. He launches the first newspaper, Seraj ul-akhbar in Afghanistan in year

Modernization In Afghanistan And Iran Essay

2174 words - 9 pages The process of Modernization in Afghanistan under King Amanullah Khan and Iran under Shah Reza Pahlavi The modernization process has been experienced in different ways by different countries that some of them succeeded and some of them failed. Theoretically it has been defined as “a concept in the sphere of social science that refers to the process in which society goes through industrialization, urbanization and other social changes” (Zapf

Importance Of Afghanistan In Inner Asian Geopolitics

3336 words - 14 pages they cannot ignore Afghanistan and cannot think to realize their dreams of regional stability and peace without collaborating with Kabul. Similarly, for other countries, including Pakistan, India, and neighboring regional powers, Afghanistan has remained as cause of disagreement. The Great Game of superpowers in Asia that had dynamics much larger than its regional platform was played on the grounds of Afghanistan. Therefore, to study Central Asian

Afghanistan Under The Rule Of The Musahiban Family

2297 words - 10 pages After the fall of Amanullah Khan, Habibullah Khan Kalakani ruled for a short term and then the Musahiban family ruled over Afghanistan from 1929-1978. The Musahiban family halted the social changes that Amanullah Khan wanted to make which moved it away from developing the economy, state building and modernization. The economy was the same as it was at the turn of the century. The Musahiban family followed the policy of encapsulated modernization