Modernization And Dependency Theory Essay

2603 words - 10 pages

Modernization and Dependency Theory
A clear and advanced look at the two theories leaves one with the assumption that they are related and therefore they can be discussed together. This is attributed to the fact that they both argue from the same point of development and that development of a nation can only be reached at by ensuring the acquisition of new techniques. In addition a country on its own cannot acquire the advanced techniques but through the interaction process with other countries. In terms of modernity, Anthony Giddens compares it to riding on a board a huge juggernaut (Potter 2002, p. 63). This brings with it consequences in the sense that those who resist the juggernaut are crushed. However, this maybe steady for a given period of time and later on it takes a steady path and moves on to a path where the initiators cannot foresee. This makes it clear to the innovators that as long as the institution of modernity is still in existence, we can never be able to control the pace at which it moves.
Modernity has brought with it a major phase of social change and this is mostly in the direction of globalization. Giddens is convinced that the global modernity being experienced by most of the countries is as a result of the frequent interactional processes that are going on. This leaves it a responsibility to every citizen in the country to adapt to the system of social change. It can therefore be agreed that the changes that appear in the traditional setting of the societies are in itself as aspect of modernization. The global modernity has become a form of social life and those who resist it are regarded as social deviants. It has discontinued the previous forms of modernity and brought in more advanced forms.

Modernity can be viewed as one that not only takes in new stages of post modernity but also brings in a style of modernity that is embedded in modern life. Those eager to try out new methods of modernity should not assume the fact that it is always safe to try out new skills but should be prepared to accept the risks that come with it. It is all about trust, risk, opportunity and the dangers that accompany every sphere of modern life. We can only manage the stages of modernity but can never fully control them. Whenever we try to reduce the risks, new risks come up. An example is the daily studies that are undertaken on the ill health yet we still have high mortality rates being experienced in the world (Armstrong & Zegher 2006, p. 17). Modernity can therefore be well understood from a view of several institutions. One of them is capitalism where there is commodity production that involves competitive productive markets, labour power and private ownership of property.
Industrialism involves use of inanimate power sources and machinery to produce goods. This affects several sectors including transport, communication and everyday life. As a result there is creation of new employment and growth of several...


Modernization Essay

1892 words - 8 pages Ferdinand Tönnies (1855-1937) formed the theory of Gemeinschaft and Gesellschaft. Ferdinand Tönnies saw modernization as the progressive loss of human community (Gemeinschaft). He also believed that modernization caused people in modern societies to drift apart and personal relationships became more impersonal as people became more self-absorbed (Gesellschaft). Ferdinand Tönnies theory suggests that … modernity turns society inside

Theories about Development and Modernization Essay

1569 words - 7 pages building and social modernization such as fostering entrepreneurship and achievement orientation” (Pieterse, 2010, p. 6). As a whore, there are three theories that can be used to explain about development which is Modernization Theory, Dependency Theory, and World System Theory (refer to Figure 1 in Appendix 1). Modernization Theory The first theory to explain about development Theory of Modernization introduced by Walt Whitman Rostow that

Modernization and civilizational clash

632 words - 3 pages : modernization, civilization, world-system, and globalization theory. Although there are four perspectives that signify the world’s system, I will only be comparing the theories of modernization and civilizational clash and their nature. Modernization is defined as the conversion from the former civilizations in society to contemporary society; as it is establish today in the West. It models a perspective of economic, social, and cultural progress that

Future of Modernization

1331 words - 5 pages "the process of social change begun by industrialization" (Macionis, 2006). Ferdinand Tönnies (1855-1937) was a German sociologist that produced the theory of Gemeinschaft and Gesellschaft. The term Gemeinschaft refers or human community and Gesellschaft means "...essentially united in spite of all separating factors" (Macionis, 2006). Tönnies suggested that modernization turns society inside out so "essentially separated in spite of

Comparative Analysis of Modernization

2523 words - 10 pages bullets, producing goods, balancing import and exports, employments opportunities for all people, and becoming economically independent from west. Although Amanullah khan’s reforms did not match the stages given by Smelser,but he took ideal approaches toward modernization and looked at the modern society an example of its counterparts (Smelser, 1988). Also considering underdevelopment theory and world system theory has crucial roles in

Dependency theory

929 words - 4 pages Dependency theory appeared in the 20th century 50`s. The main topics that are included in dependency theory are historical materialism connected with other critical traditions, a partnership between developed countries and developing countries, interaction between a core and a periphery. Dependency theory mainly is used to talk about Western societies and Third World countries. Foundation of the dependency theory is Marxism, also it prefigures

This article argues that modernity is the second form of colonization.

2229 words - 9 pages superior status of the hegemonic superpower. Along with that the theory and frameworks arisen in the ongoing status will be considered. The term "modernity" and "modernization" is used here interchangeably, although the former suggests the status more than the process, yet its nature provides the appeal for me to think of modernity as an end as well as a mean in itself.Being the end the United States want so many countries to reach, modernity's

"Critically analyse one theory to explain the global political economy" I examined the Dependency Theory.

2562 words - 10 pages ABSTRACTThere are no universal truths in political theory. This essay is about Dependency Theory and its use to explain the global political economy. Dependency Theory is a political interpretation of the way economic systems impact on the Less Economically Developed Countries. . As a theory it is an activist for change but also a means of understanding the world order and it is for these reasons I chose it above other theories I examined. I

The Effects of Globalization, Democracy and Change on Somalia

2123 words - 8 pages changes through the increase of globalization. In contrast to the modernization theory Marxist would attribute the fall and continuous retrogression of Somalia to the theory of dependency. This theory takes into account historical and sociological aspects of a country and how the economy of one country becomes developed at the expense of another (Allahar 1994). One cannot accumulate a whole lot of capital without a whole lot of people

Modernization in Afghanistan and Iran

2174 words - 9 pages , 2004).Even there is no single approach toward this process, evolutionism, diffusionism, structural functionalism, systems theory and interactionism as well as other disciplines such as political science, economics, anthropology, psychology and others are combined to be known as modernization theory. This paper discuses the process of modernization and its challenges in Afghanistan and Iran. It talks about the actions which have been taken by these

modernization as a concept of social change

6079 words - 24 pages ' and 'progressive' can be highly misleading from the Systems Theory perspective. tem variants in a competitive situation. Selection processes are therefore intrinsic to modernization. But another use of 'modernization' is as a synonym for 'ratio- nalization'. Rationalization usually entails the reform of a social system by central government, along the lines of making it more of a 'rational bureaucracy' involving standardization of explicit

Similar Essays

Development In El Salvador 1980 2000 Essay

4829 words - 19 pages antithesis of Modernization, known as Dependency Perspective.The Dependency PerspectiveThe Dependency Perspective emerged in the 1960s, and is very much and extension of the previous economic designs of Vladimir Lenin and Karl Marx. What is unique about dependency theory is that it is the first theory of development to emerge from the non-developed world. Dependency theory was largely a product of Latin American scholars and very much reflects

Future Of Modernization Essay

1937 words - 8 pages industrial revolution, urbanization and other social changes that alters people's lives. Modernization promotes individualism over the unity of traditional communities and encourages rationality over traditional philosophies. Modernization can have both positive and negative effects on society and can often bring about controversy.The German sociologist Ferdinand Tönnies (1855-1937) formed the theory of Gemeinschaft and Gesellschaft. Ferdinand

Government And Politics Crisis Of Development Discourse

1664 words - 7 pages The Crisis of Development Discourse     The rise of development theory has been an interesting phenomenon.  In the latter half of the 20th century, many theorists have tried to explain the origins of "under-development."  The debate over the idea of development has been intense, and has led to the emergence of two contending paradigms:  Modernization theory and dependency theory.  Upon close investigation, one realizes that both theories

Modernization Essay

1882 words - 8 pages Ferdinand Tönnies (1855-1937) formed the theory of Gemeinschaft and Gesellschaft. Ferdinand Tönnies saw modernization as the progressive loss of human community (Gemeinschaft). He also believed that modernization caused people in modern societies to drift apart and personal relationships became more impersonal as people became more self-absorbed (Gesellschaft). Ferdinand Tönnies theory suggests that … modernity turns society inside