Montaigne,Shakespeare, And Columbus; The Argument Of Savagery

1282 words - 6 pages

Both Montaigne and Columbus have the opportunity of observing outside cultures immune to the modern society they live in. Both make judgements relating to the preconceptions they have about civilization and modern society. However, each author has a completely different outlook on the civilizations and so called barbarians they observe. Christopher Columbus views himself as superior to the Natives of the lands based off of his preconceptions. Columbus mentions in his writings how great his land, king, and government are and how beneficial they have been. Columbus goes on to say “All these islands are densely populated with the best people under the sun; they have neither ill-will nor ...view middle of the document...

Later, Montaigne goes on to talk about how the Cannibals are no where near as barbarous as modern civilization by comparing the act of war and what is important to society. The Cannibals view war as an act of valor whereas modern society views war as an act of self prospering. Montaigne sees the simplicity of the Cannibals as being the closest thing to perfection. Montaigne’s views on the Cannibals seem somewhat Utopian as if they live the closest life to perfection because of their ignorance to modern society and their simplicity as a civilization. In The Tempest by Shakespeare many of the characters can be compared to Montaigne and Christopher Columbus’s attitudes towards outside civilizations. A great example is Shakespeare’s characters Prospero, Caliban, and Ariel. The Greatest playwright of all time uses his characters to convey his opinion towards Montaignes thoughts on the cannibals.
After reading The Tempest by Shakespeare it is apparent that many of the Characters represent something more than a simple character. Three characters that standout include Prospero, Caliban and Ariel. Montaigne and Columbus’s attitudes are each conveyed through these characters. Shakespeare does a great job of concealing the true meaning of the characters. A great example is Shakespeares character Prospero who seems to represent modern civilization. Prosperos two servants can be said to represent people who embrace modern civilization and those who don’t. Caliban is a representation of the society that does not embrace modern civilization, but is held captive by it and cannot live without the help of the civilization. Ariel on the other hand is a representation of the society which tries to distance itself from modern civilization. Caliban and Ariel both represent the different views that Columbus and Montaigne have. Caliban is an ethnocentric character just like Columbus is in his Letter of Discovery. Ariel is more of a modest character like that of Montaigne and sees himself on the same level as others and is a more accepting character that takes everything into account before he judges.
Caliban is easily seen as Shakespeares representation of a savage. Prospero views caliban as a slave that is inferior to him because of the things he used to practice with the witch. Throughout the story Caliban can bee seen as a blunt and Vulgar character which is easily represented every time he converses with Prospero. Caliban greets Prospero with a curse showing his anger that i built up towards him. Shakespeare wrote the story during the time period where his country was the strongest and most powerful to him which made him naturally deny any outside civilization and give them no credit. Shakespeare believed that anything contrary to his countries customs were savagery. Shakespeare and Columbus both seem to be ethnocentric beings who strongly believe in their own customs. In the text...

Find Another Essay On Montaigne,Shakespeare, and Columbus; The argument of savagery

Purity and Civility in The Praise of Folly by Desiderius Erasmus and Of Cannibals by Michel de Montaigne

1521 words - 6 pages Purity and Civility in The Praise of Folly by Desiderius Erasmus and Of Cannibals by Michel de Montaigne Both in “The Praise of Folly” by Desiderius Erasmus and “Of Cannibals” by Michel de Montaigne-relating to the common point to which attention is tried to be drawn-inquiry of true civility with regards to the Nature and its necessity according to certain circumstances are substantiated. First of all,Erasmus stating

The Navigation of Christopher Columbus and the Age of Discovery

5022 words - 20 pages Before beginning the research for this work, I had planned on producing a paper and presentation which detailed the history of open sea navigation and the difficulties and dangers which would have faced sailors and seamen during the Age of Discovery. My premise was that we, living in the twentifirst century, had lost touch with the reality of just how hazardous a voyage such as that undertaken by Columbus was. I had hoped to be

The Savagery in The Life of Pi

1177 words - 5 pages In the book Life of Pi, written by Yann Martel, the idea of the boundaries between savagery and humanity are tossed around quite a bit. In Pi’s life or death situation, the idea of savagery becomes a little obscured by the desperation to survive. There are several acts within the story that people who are not in Pi’s situation would possibly see as being savage. As I read the text, I see most of Pi’s actions as a need to survive. Pi creates

"Lord of the Flies": Dissolution of Civility and the Domination of Savagery

1089 words - 4 pages In "Lord of the Flies" by William Golding, the two main characters, Ralph and Jack, represent weaknesses of succumbing to darkness in order to emphasize man's inevitable fall into savagery. Golding demonstrates how man's innate savage nature unavoidably dominates all forms of civility and society, by exemplifying the faults of man in a concentrated setting such as the island. The novel is considered a fable or a parable because it includes an

Lord of the Flies: Civilization vs Savagery

947 words - 4 pages transformation from civilization to savagery in the conflict between two of the main characters: Ralph who represents law and order and Jack who represents savagery and violence. Lord of the Flies has remained a very controversial novel to this day with its startling, brutal, and truthful picture of the human nature. In the beginning, human influence was starting to affect this uninhabited “Garden of Eden”. Ralph, the charismatic and newly elected

Savagery of Man: A Comparison of Lord of the Flies and a Separate Peace

841 words - 4 pages There is evidence in both Lord of the Flies and A Separate Peace that display the savagery of man. In Lord of the Flies there is savagery found when the choir boys and most of the bigguns separate from Ralph’s authority and form their own tribe. In A Separate Peace, savagery is found in unnamed characters during Leper’s war experience - he feels such a need to escape from evil and savagery in the war that he takes the risk and actually does. In

The Reputation of Christopher Columbus

2360 words - 9 pages The Reputation of Christopher Columbus When judging a person's importance in history it becomes hard not to judge that person without characterizing their achievements as either negative or positive. It becomes even harder when all of the facts are not known and when a reputation has already been established. Christopher Columbus is such a person. Through history, from the time he sailed to the present, debate as to whether


758 words - 3 pages In the movie "The Lord of the Flies" a group of civilized boys is marooned on a remote island, without any adults or supplies. The boys start out with a civilized democratic society. It slowly turns into a savage chaotic society.At the begging of the movie we were introduced to Ralph and Jack. At first Ralph and Jack agree that there should be rules to help govern themselves until they are rescued. This led me to believe that at the beginning of

The Challenge Between Civilization and Savagery in Lord of the Flies by William Golding

1501 words - 6 pages In the novel Lord of the Flies by William Golding, symbolism and allegories were used to show how the children who are stranded on an island have a huge struggle with civilization and savagery. Ralph, Piggy, Jack, and Simon are the ones in the novel that struggle with this the most. Golding wrote this story because he was horrified of Stalinism in Russia. His experience in World War II effected his view on humanity and evils that are capable

Perceptiveness on civilization and savagery of human nature reflected from william golding's lord of the flies

10966 words - 44 pages Perceptiveness on Civilization and Savagery of Human'sNature Reflected from William Golding's Lord of the FliesIntroductionLord of the Flies, one of William Golding's many novels, is a well written, well thought out writing that depicts the savagery of human nature. William Golding the man himself is qualified enough to write about such topics because he was involved heavily in W.W.II. This caused Golding's views on life to change to his current

The Voyage Of Christopher Columbus

1513 words - 6 pages American History I Christopher Columbus' Voyage to North America Spanish exploration first began with a series of revolutions. First, the Commercial Revolution generated economic stability. Second, the Intellectual Revolution generated interest in the Earth's composition and the pursuit of exploration. Europe then called for a political revolution to end the disorganized and disorderly rule of its government. This revolution returned

Similar Essays

The Ideas Of Machiavelli, Locke, Shakespeare, Montaigne, And Achebe

1427 words - 6 pages ). Montaigne believes society can stay together without any strong and organized government controlling them. Such a notion is a total contrary to the idea of Achebe.While keeping in mind his own ideas about independence from colonial influences, Chinua Achebe's thoughts parallel the thoughts and writings of Machiavelli, Shakespeare, and Locke, as well as their premises about human nature. Okonkwo becomes an exemplar of the ideas of all three figures with

Dante And Montaigne: The Epitomes Of Their Time Periods

1271 words - 5 pages During the middle Ages and the Renaissance there were two magnificent writers who demonstrated epitomic belief and thought of their eras. One brilliant writer, Dante Alighieri, wrote the Divine Comedy during the Medieval Ages. During the Renaissance period Michel de Montaigne wrote the Essays. Montaigne is thought to have made the modern day essay. Although, these two different writes wrote in two completely different time periods, their pieces

In Defense Of The Indians By Las Casas And On The Cannibals By Montaigne

1707 words - 7 pages the Europeans during the 1513 conquest. The Spanish Conquest of Central and South America and the voyage to the New World by Christopher Columbus in 1492 brought the Spanish crown a great amount of wealth. The native inhabitants which resided in the Americas prior to the discovery, saw what was once their home being taken away from them and being completely devoured by the Conquistas. In Defense of the Indians by Bartolome de Las Casas and On

Columbus And The Indies Essay

620 words - 3 pages their lifestyle, selflessness, and kindness to strangers. Colon in this letter also ascertains a degree of innocence in the Indians while drawing a distinction amongst the Europeans advantageous actions in the exchanges for broken objects for pieces of valuable gold. Throughout the letter, Columbus describes his prohibition in the colonist to trade unfairly with the people that worshiped them as if they had been sky fallen. Columbus ulterior